Yes, but some posters have formed an opinion and narrative that they have to stick to for reasons unknown...
Wan-Bissaka for sale
- Thread starter Bastian
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) is joined by CEO Duncan Drasdo and Financial Director Andy Green from the Manchester United Supporters Trust for a special episode on all things behind the scenes at Old Trafford including a brief history of MUST and their aims today, views on INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe so far, and the Old Trafford regeneration.
Absolute nonsense.
I still think we should keep him.
He's not an elite right back and there's room to upgrade, but with him and Dalot, both of whom had good seasons, I'd argue right back is the one position in the team that isn't a problem.
We have too many other positions requiring attention.
He's not an elite right back and there's room to upgrade, but with him and Dalot, both of whom had good seasons, I'd argue right back is the one position in the team that isn't a problem.
We have too many other positions requiring attention.
Given the small fee being offered along with the full back issues we had last year; I would rather keep him unless we have someone ready to come in with a higher potential.
Left back is where we should be focusing more and Dalot with AWB as cover for RB is fine, even if we lose him for nothing or offer him a 1 year extension (which he may not take).
£25M+ and them yes, move him on.
Left back is where we should be focusing more and Dalot with AWB as cover for RB is fine, even if we lose him for nothing or offer him a 1 year extension (which he may not take).
£25M+ and them yes, move him on.
Yeah, you're right, 50m for a guy who can basically only do slide tackles.
Great business.
He makes goal line clearences, blocks shots & makes good short passing and dribbling. His crossing is crap aswell as his tracking back. His heading has significantly improved from getting outdone nearly every game to only 1-3 times a season max that will lead to a goal.
You just don't rate him.
I can count so many world class performances wan bissaka has put for us against the best players in the world.
Literally shits on a player like Herrera or even Rafael. Apart from Dalot this season he has been our best RB post SAF.
Underrated player because he looks clumsy even when he protrudes his skills & can get caught playing someone offside.
His LB positioning really made him look worse than he is.
Frimpong is not leaving Leverkusen so i will have AWB all day.
He's not been horrendous, but we will improve that right hand side when we see the back of him. He just doesn't play on the front foot, but he is good at engaging wingers and sitting in. I have problems with his concentration and decision making, but plenty of full backs have those problems, they just usually come with the bonus of being good going forward.
He's clearly not worth anywhere near what people think, otherwise people would be queuing up for him at £15m. I'd be happy to get £15m and find someone better going forward.
I'm with you. Very good 1v1 defender. Aside from that, doesn't give us anywhere near enough.
What is there to rate?
He has no anticipation, can't read the game so he has zero awareness of danger, doesn't track runners, can't defend the back post, has the positional sense of a baby in a ball pit at left back and right back. Technically his first touch, dribbling and passing are poor for the level he's supposed to be at, and he offers next to nothing in the attacking third. Either by making runs or being able to cross the ball.
Honestly, he's just a dreadful footballer, Paul Parker was 10 times the player.
Not a very successful signing but clearly not one of the worst signing we ever made. He had some good games, limited player but you can't see him not trying.
Show me him not defending the back post in the last two seasons?
More than one or two goals max that has happened & people still calling out his weaknesses under Ole than the progress he made under Ten Hag.
His passing, his first touch and dribbling is actually crazy good and he is very press resistant
I guess everyone has different eyes.
Jesus fecking Christ, what an absolutely putrid take that is.
Not really. I've seen plenty of teams who would force the press to his side when Utd tried to play out from the back with him, because he was seen as the weak link. And there are lots and lots of examples of his poor positioning and awareness costing goals.Show me him not defending the back post in the last two seasons?
More than one or two goals max that has happened & people still calling out his weaknesses under Ole than the progress he made under Ten Hag.
His passing, his first touch and dribbling is actually crazy good and he is very press resistant
I guess everyone has different eyes.
Honestly, he's technically a terrible footballer and nowhere near good enough for Utd. Never was and the sooner he's gone the better, he will not be missed.
I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle, he's been okay in most games, pretty good in games against the top 6 where he locks up the best wingers, but he's not the type of RB you want if you want to dominate the ball on the opponents half. I also think calling his passing, first touch and dribbling "crazy good" is a massive overreaction. I don't see anything special there.Show me him not defending the back post in the last two seasons?
More than one or two goals max that has happened & people still calling out his weaknesses under Ole than the progress he made under Ten Hag.
His passing, his first touch and dribbling is actually crazy good and he is very press resistant
I guess everyone has different eyes.
Yeah like forcing the pressure by Doku to Wan Bissaka's side vs City
The guy gets out of presses great like a winger.
Rafael is shit. Benefited from playing under SAF and soon as he went the guy is invisible
A Championship teams dream defender then?
Is it dark down in that hole you're digging?Rafael is shit. Benefited from playing under SAF and soon as he went the guy is invisible
He's an awful player. 15m tops is what he’s going to fetch and at best he'll end up out in Turkey or the Championship.Yeah like forcing the pressure by Doku to Wan Bissaka's side vs City
The guy gets out of presses great like a winger.
Rafael is shit. Benefited from playing under SAF and soon as he went the guy is invisible
What the feck does that even mean?Rafael is shit. Benefited from playing under SAF and soon as he went the guy is invisible
Horrible opinion on Rafael, you should be ashamed of yourself.
I'd take the best offer we get for him. I dont know what that is.
He just wouldn't be in my plans for the future along with a lot of others. I'd take the breathing space the money brings in. Think were long over due to get more sensible with transfers. Casually throwing 15m away just seems really wasteful and something that most premier league teams wouldn't countenance. I guess theres a point about us undervaluing our players and we could try hold out for more. Seems to be a few teams considering him but i imagine theres a lot of alternatives at his level and the list of suitors wont be that long.
I'm not sure how much trust you can place in a player with 6 months left on his contract. Even with the best will in the world your not going to risk injury if you need to find a new job in a couple of months time. I wouldn't pay 15m to loan him for half a season is how i'd nearly think of it.
He just wouldn't be in my plans for the future along with a lot of others. I'd take the breathing space the money brings in. Think were long over due to get more sensible with transfers. Casually throwing 15m away just seems really wasteful and something that most premier league teams wouldn't countenance. I guess theres a point about us undervaluing our players and we could try hold out for more. Seems to be a few teams considering him but i imagine theres a lot of alternatives at his level and the list of suitors wont be that long.
I'm not sure how much trust you can place in a player with 6 months left on his contract. Even with the best will in the world your not going to risk injury if you need to find a new job in a couple of months time. I wouldn't pay 15m to loan him for half a season is how i'd nearly think of it.
Why do we have to post that about our own players? He’s PL class
He’s not going to the Championship
Well just because he's the weakest in the defence doesn't mean he's terrible overall. Someone has to be chosen.
I know this is probably a highly controversial view but Wan-Bissaka’s ability and contribution to United falls somewhere in the middle. He’s semi-decent but that’s it.
Calling him ‘dreadful’ or one of United’s worst ever signings is an utterly diabolical and exaggerated take. He’s not some unmitigated disaster.
He’s been most reliable, largely injury-free and has had some excellent games completely locking down the right side and shutting out some of the best wingers in the game. This is also interspersed with games where he’s made appealing mistakes positionally as well as a distinct lack of contribution in attack.
Ludicrous take I know.
Calling him ‘dreadful’ or one of United’s worst ever signings is an utterly diabolical and exaggerated take. He’s not some unmitigated disaster.
He’s been most reliable, largely injury-free and has had some excellent games completely locking down the right side and shutting out some of the best wingers in the game. This is also interspersed with games where he’s made appealing mistakes positionally as well as a distinct lack of contribution in attack.
Ludicrous take I know.
People are so fecking dramatic and lacking in any rationale.
He can obviously carve out a decent PL career even if he’s not at the standard United require. The two aren’t mutually exclusive…
Yeah it’s a bit much. Absolute nonsense
Always thought it a bit odd that he's never had a look in for England.
He's alright. He's not a good footballer. He's a good defender, suited to teams where defenders defend, and that's not many EPL clubs these days.
if you can get 15-20m for him, you make the sale
You can tell when posters are talking shite, or agenda posting.... Their posts are filled with exaggeration, false assertions and very little substance. Not worth engaging really, the lack of effort shows you that you aren't going to get anywhere. Some utter nonsense posted in here about our players over the last season, but usually from the same posters.....
15mil in today's market is nothing. Keep him for cover. I'm pretty sure we will need him. Dalot can cover LB too if Shaw is injured again. And we need AWB to play RB.
We have only 3 proper LB/RB in Shaw, Dalot and AWB. I'm not sure what to say about Malacia. Who else we can rely on?
We have only 3 proper LB/RB in Shaw, Dalot and AWB. I'm not sure what to say about Malacia. Who else we can rely on?
He's not without use as a squad option, but when all's said and done I think it's obvious by now that he's simply too limited to be an integral part of this team. As such, he is one of the more obvious players to replace and upgrade. And with one year left on his contract, this is the right time to do it.
If he's sold, he obviously needs to be replaced.
Dalot separated himself from AWB last season, so if one of them had to go, it should be AWB. A more attacking option at right back would be good. There’ll be games where that sort of outlet will be invaluable.
Walker, Trippier, James and Alexander-Arnold are all better on the ball. Maybe he'd get more of a look in 10 years ago.
If he's replaced by a better FB I doubt many would be upset about it. Somebody remind me how have we done replacing FBs again? Hopefully the new guys do a better job and don't rush to appease the muppets... as its not a priority, for me.
They are all in a completely different class to AWB, in my opinion. Legit top team RBs all.
I'm not in favour of letting him go on the cheap. We have no cover at right back! He's a decent professional and will be a valuable squad player. Similar to Scotty M. We need players like this that don't moan about being on the bench.
2 years left on his contract I believe, will we look at renewing next year? Is he worth renewing?
If not, we should shift him this window and look for an upgrade on Dalot in the next 2 windows. But am not sure if we have cover for Dalot in the meantime.
Same goes for Harry actually.
If not, we should shift him this window and look for an upgrade on Dalot in the next 2 windows. But am not sure if we have cover for Dalot in the meantime.
Same goes for Harry actually.
Agreed. This is far from a 'Gareth Barry getting selected over Carrick' type of situation.