Oranges038
Full Member
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2020
- Messages
- 14,457
Took me one second to see he was clearly onside. I know they have to, but that definitely didn’t require lines being drawn.
Just looking for an excuse to disallow it.
Took me one second to see he was clearly onside. I know they have to, but that definitely didn’t require lines being drawn.
Yep long delay to confirm the obvious!Took me one second to see he was clearly onside. I know they have to, but that definitely didn’t require lines being drawn.
Think they were dotting the I’s and crossing the T’s after yesterdayTook me one second to see he was clearly onside. I know they have to, but that definitely didn’t require lines being drawn.
Took me one second to see he was clearly onside. I know they have to, but that definitely didn’t require lines being drawn.
Yep. Rash was well off there and they even drew the lines.Think they were dotting the I’s and crossing the T’s after yesterday
Yep. Exactly what I thoughtSurely that WW should stand? Maguire didn't touch it?
They didn't even give themselves enough time to check it? They just seen WW offsideYep. Exactly what I thought
Because decisions are subjective. Unless it’s an absolute blatant Maradona or Henry handball there’s no lint in it interfering with the game. And we’ve had a handful of those cheating circumstances in decades
Mentioned it in the match thread but they are consistently checking the wrong man on the offside calls. They missed the one for the Brentford goal yesterday, spent ages checking the Rashford goal despite clearly being played onside and then didn’t check the right man for disallowed Rashford goal when there’s a small chance he may have been on.
The way they kept zooming for the players near him for his first goal was ridiculous. I swear you would get from older people who are half blind.
I do wonder when the officials get given VAR duty they just seen it as a take your kids to work today and let them play with the computers when the time comes
The whole introduction of var has been a mess as has been the implementation. Most sports like cricket, tennis or American football the crowd get to see the process behind decisions.Referee’s seem to defer making any decision they feel may be contentious assuming VAR will correct them and VAR then seems to not to want to overrule the man on the field, so they consistently get decisions wrong.
I would copy The cricket system where captains get to send decisions to VAR and if they are incorrect they burn one of their 2 calls they’re allowed to use. I would also have referees using ‘soft signals’ that can be overturned if incorrect so they feel more confident making call themselves again
The VAR referee made an error so basic that the PGMOL decided to issue a public statement. It’s hardly Arsenal trying to shift the blame when the responsible party is holding their hands up and saying “We failed - that one is on us”.I’m surprised the amount of coverage the possible error in the buildup to Brentford goal got in comparison to a much more glaring mistake in Palace v Brighton game (at least here, as Arsenal fans are calling FA corrupt, Brentford cheats and demanding the victory to be awarded to them, among other nonsense I have seen since morning). Even with that line drawn in the picture I am still not entirely convinced Norgaard is offside, and he is it’s a matter of centimeters, or a fraction of second in which you decide to stop the frame to analyze their positioning. Arsenal seem to have focused on trying to explain why they conceded by looking frame by frame seeking referee’s error rather than pointing out their defensive naivety.
Shocking again, clear goal for Gundogan ruled out for nothing and then a clear yellow card for Grealish given as a pen.
What do you mean ? Grealish is very very very smart, very clever and Ramsey very very very naive. Are you saying they very very very cheated ?That penalty given is ridiculous. Ramsey makes no attempt to tackle Grealish.
I don’t there’s anything to suggest City would ever cheat.What do you mean ? Grealish is very very very smart, very clever and Ramsey very very very naive. Are you saying they very very very cheated ?
Would love this. But they are too protectedNeed to go the cricket route and have audio of the VAR officials talking through the process and explain how they’ve come to make their decision.
My son said straight away after seeing the replay that it didn’t even come off Maguire, but then we never got shown another replay and the game just went on.Has anyone seen a good replay of the Weghorst goal yet? There was one angle which seemed to suggest the ball came off the Leeds defender and not Maguire at all, but VAR just appeared to make their decision based on Weghorst being ahead of the play rather than how the ball came to him. Shoddy to say the least.
It definitely came off the Leeds players arm.Has anyone seen a good replay of the Weghorst goal yet? There was one angle which seemed to suggest the ball came off the Leeds defender and not Maguire at all, but VAR just appeared to make their decision based on Weghorst being ahead of the play rather than how the ball came to him. Shoddy to say the least.
yet again it seemed like they watched 1 replay, stopped it in slow motion at a convenient point that looked like it “might” have came off maguire, then dropped it and carried on.Has anyone seen a good replay of the Weghorst goal yet? There was one angle which seemed to suggest the ball came off the Leeds defender and not Maguire at all, but VAR just appeared to make their decision based on Weghorst being ahead of the play rather than how the ball came to him. Shoddy to say the least.
Tbf one of the refs is Australian. He sent off some poor bloke for "running aggressively towards the ref"
I'm sure they also have their own interpretation of the word AXE and will be sent to the Championship for 2 weeks instead of one before coming back like nothing happened.