Browniee
New Member
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2011
- Messages
- 11,045
So a shit load of money to buy a couple of world class forwards?At the moment it is 0.
Oh that's right, there's no time left.
So a shit load of money to buy a couple of world class forwards?At the moment it is 0.
Define "good deal"? It's very late in the window and regardless of what fee we end up getting, it will be hard to bring in replacement without paying a significant chunk of what we get for De Gea.
You don't really expect us to replace him for peanuts? We will spend a lot, unless we are after one of the german goalkeepers or Cillessen.
And there is plenty of time left, if we stay away from Bilbao.
But he will be. We'll have a 25 man squad and someone else will get the chances he had. I don't believe his contribution was that great that we needed to go out and spend another £60m on somebody. He didn't add that much. Half his assists were corners, set pieces and the odd hit and hope ball into the box. Not like we don't have another corner taker or somebody capable of producing similar flukey moments. I don't look at last year and see him as vital to how we played or as some sort of unbelievable gamechanger. An average player can provide what he provided last year.
We won't be left with Romero as our number 1.I wouldnt be surprised if we didnt get a replacement this window.. see how it goes with Romero.
We'll end up with Cillessen
Or there could be something in the Leno and Oblak early rumors.
I think you're missing the point. By spending that much money in the first place the club identified we needed a player of that calibre to progress, the fact he didn't work out just means we now need a different player of the top calibre to progress.
I'm suprised to see so may proclaiming a higher fee as excellent news. We're not a midtable club we don't need the money to progress it's about quality players and we're losing one. The club has learnt the lesson of what it means to have a brilliant trusted keeper in between the posts.
Sorry I just can't get worked up about losing ADM. We didn't have him or a galactico, if you like, before and he didn't make the slightest bit of difference last season so I can't cry about it. Depay is more like the signings we've had down the years and I wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if he makes more of an impact.
In terms of progressing, we were doing pretty fine in general (obviously Moyes rather than players were the problem before), so don't agree we needed one like him to progress. Woodward wants one because he is clearly obsessed with landing a big name on his watch regardless of whether they are needed but that's another argument.
Not fussed about DDG either. He's going. Doesn't want to be here so let's make the best of a bad situation and get as much money as possible. It's not really about needing the money. We /LVG messed up which is why we're in this situation but it's about making a stand and getting Madrid to pay up. £29m is paying up.
£29m for DDG would be excellent business, jeez what's our net spend if that's the case?
Leno would be great. I'd be ok with Oblak too.Or there could be something in the Leno and Oblak early rumors.
Yeah. Seems once you get LvG's confidence you have it. Blind at central defense, not getting a winger and now possibly selling Chicha and DdG. I personally don't agree with it. I'd rather we strengthen all 4 these positions (if the two mentioned leave). Too late in the window to get 4 deals done, surely.. Positive is Januzaj won't be sent out on loan and can continue his development at Utd, getting more games than last season. Wilson should get more chances to. Fellaini will be used as a striker on multiple occassions. Oh well, it's hypothetical until the window closes but it's looking plausible.
Leno would be great. I'd be ok with Oblak too.
So Romero as nr. 1 this season?
If that's the war you want us to win then it was never even going to be one and the club always knew that, for the simple reason that were talking about English and Spanish clubs and two Spanish players.Because it once again shows that they will take a player from us when they choose whereas by all accounts we've failed to sign Ramos and possibly Bale from them this summer.
Selling him this late in the window with no real replacement for him and still very obvious weaknesses in our squad which won't be addressed will leave a lot of people unhappy.
We need to replace him, doesn't have to be with a galactico, but he definitely needs replacing.
We have. Memphis.
Don't doubt another body was needed but we've already got him.
We have. Memphis.
Don't doubt another body was needed but we've already got him.
£29m for DDG would be excellent business, jeez what's our net spend if that's the case?
Memphis wasnt brought to replace him, he was in addition. And if anyone thinks we only need one winger who can score and assist goals regularly in the whole team, then they are lost
I'd be happy with that to be fair, with a tighter midfield and a protected defence, the form and class of our keeper 'hopefully' won't be called upon as it has the last couple of seasonsSo Romero as nr. 1 this season?
That's true. With protected defense and defense and midfield working together defensively Romero won't have so much to do and if he will have he'll react as vs Brugge.I'd be happy with that to be fair, with a tighter midfield and a protected defence, the form and class of our keeper 'hopefully' won't be called upon as it has the last couple of seasons
This, although a fully fit United XI could beat anyone in their day we are an injury away from 'oh feck' again. We can't rely on Rooney, we just can'tWe need someone else, Memphis can't be our only difference maker.
Some fans are prepared to go into the season with risks/doubts.
Selling DDG is fine when we don't have a like for like keeper as a replacement.
not replacing RVP and Di maria is fine because they were pants (which is partially true but doesn't justify them not being replaced with better alternatives)
We don't need a No.9 IF rooney finds form
Yes it's been a good window but there is a real danger of MUFC solving one problem and creating another this transfer window.
This, although a fully fit United XI could beat anyone in their day we are an injury away from 'oh feck' again. We can't rely on Rooney, we just can't
Memphis wasnt brought to replace him, he was in addition. And if anyone thinks we only need one winger who can score and assist goals regularly in the whole team, then they are lost
'On the wings it's Nani and Di Maria out and Depay in. He looks amazing but ADM, despite one very bad season, is still considered a world-class player.'
Ok, discussion is heading away from main point which was above.
I disagree that we are weaker than last season based on the above changes.
ADM did next to nothing and Nani wasn't here.
We maybe the same but we are not weaker.
Who says he wasn't brought to replace him? I don't know one way or the other but given ADMs unhappiness was well known can you say that as fact?
No purpose in selling DDG now, especially after we held out the whole transfer window. And overpaying for Cilessen would be silly as you say.
£29m for DDG would be excellent business, jeez what's our net spend if that's the case?
I love DDG I really do and I'm gutted he's leaving but the only reason he's in the 'world class' category is because he was called upon so much by the lack of protection by his defence in front of him. The amount of shots and chances the opposition had over the last 2 seasons was ridiculous,That's true. With protected defense and defense and midfield working together defensively Romero won't have so much to do and if he will have he'll react as vs Brugge.![]()
'On the wings it's Nani and Di Maria out and Depay in. He looks amazing but ADM, despite one very bad season, is still considered a world-class player.'
Ok, discussion is heading away from main point which was above.
I disagree that we are weaker than last season based on the above changes.
ADM did next to nothing and Nani wasn't here.
We maybe the same but we are not weaker.
Yeah but can we get anyone this late in the window. I don't know if we're in for Cilessen.Yeah much better keeping an unhappy player, who isn't in the right frame of mind to play. Keep him in the stands for the season as it'd be silly to get £29 million for him & buy a replacement who can be our long term keeper.
Also how do you know we're going for Cilessen?
-£29 million value![]()
No one said that we were weaker, at the moment we are as good as when Di Maria was useful and that's not enough, we need to strengthen our offensive line.