RedorDead21
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2013
- Messages
- 9,279
We need both but CB is definitely priority, who do we have after Varane, Martinez and Lindelof?
We have Shaw who can play there if we have a decent left back to bring in?
We need both but CB is definitely priority, who do we have after Varane, Martinez and Lindelof?
Mount , Onana , Hojlund and Pavard is a great transfer window if we can box this off. Makes us far stronger . RB and CB versatility, Keeper who can play out from the back , another player who is creative and can help our transition in the middle of the park and create opportunities, and an Actual striker ( albeit young and mostly potential at this stage ). Bring on the season . I'm excited by all of that
It quite literally does make sense. He can tackle but a defender's job involves a lot more involved than that. He's regularly caught out of position, gets sucked inside and loses his man or gets lost under the high ball.
My concern is that he's 25. Can he really improve his awareness and positioning that much? He's surely been told what he's doing wrong thousands of times by now.
The fact that ten Hag hasn't gotten rid of him yet means very little. You can only make so many changes in one window and he's not the main cause for concern but I highly doubt he's anywhere near the first team in 2/3 season's time.
Why not get an actual CB instead of worsening the LB position?We have Shaw who can play there if we have a decent left back to bring in?
You do realise that Amrabat hinges on selling Fred & Donny not those two or don't you see him as someone capable of covering
Amrabat coming in would be contingent on an outgoing and that may not necessarily be Fred as his place was taken by Mason Mount. United knew Mount was coming as far back as May, so were relaxed about Fred fraternising with Fulham manager Marco Silva outside Old Trafford on the final day of the league season.
The bolded part is a bit of a reach. Where else would he be? The reserves? He has been playing PL football since he was 19, about to start his 7th PL season. He is one of the world's best tacklers, very good when it comes to recovering, reads the game surprisingly well, and is a decent ball carrier.
His problem is concentration, and as you say, gets caught out of position too often for a right back. More often than not, he manages to save the situation, so it's not like a lot of the goals we concede are on him, but it's a bit of a risk when he loses focus.
His offensive contributions started off pretty decent, with 4 assists in his first PL season for us, and 2 goals + 4 assists in his second. Now that we haven't played with a striker, his contributions have gone noticably down, and he barely crosses anymore. When he does it, it's actually pretty good. They're often on the ground so the target can hit it instantly (like Mejbri against Bilbao).
At the very least, he will be a back-up, and hopefully ahead of Dalot.
He's 25. When is he going to develop this concentration?
Reserves, no,I expect him to be sold, along with Dalot (unless they improve significantly) if we want to be challenging for titles. One of them may be kept as a back-up but neither are really good enough.
He already has, in my opinion. Last season, he was much more positionally secure and had way fewer concentration lapses than in the previous seasons. Whether he further improves it remains to be seen this coming season. I just don't think he is someone we should sell, as I think he is definitely good enough to be part of a PL winning squad, at least as a rotational player.
The fact it is a planned transfer window with some logic behind it, rather than just random signings that just don't fit in.add a midfielder to that (probably Amrabat) and it's the best window in a very very long time
Including Salah and TAA as well, AI would have done a better job.A work experience student could've written this piece. 'Here are a list of players with a year left on their contracts next summer.'
That was a response to AWB not being good at heading balls away.Ok mate.
That's also gone into the transfer tweets feed btw.
I suppose that's the max we could get from a Turkish team.
That was a response to AWB not being good at heading balls away.
Shiit, does every tweet here automatically go in the transfer twitter feed? In that case I apologize.
Is Pavard the one who scored a worldie in the world cup?
Yep, the Premier League market is a giant bubble where nothing makes sense and it's separated from reality.The discrepancy between the English market and rest of Europe is mad.
YesIs Pavard the one who scored a worldie in the world cup?
And if the BBC is to be believed Amrabat wants to join Atletico Madrid not usYou do realise that Amrabat hinges on selling Fred & Donny not those two or don't you see him as someone capable of covering
That’s because for the last month, we haven’t made any bid. Of course he’d rather join someone who bids for himAnd if the BBC is to be believed Amrabat wants to join Atletico Madrid not us
And if the BBC is to be believed Amrabat wants to join Atletico Madrid not us
Tapsoba gives you what Todibo does but is better in the air imo. I think he is a more direct replacement for Varane and gives better balance next to Martinez. He loves a cheeky awkward looking dribble circa 2010-2012 Chris Smalling which is always fun.
Why not get an actual CB instead of worsening the LB position?
That won‘t happen. Fred or McT out is Amrabat in probably.If we sell McTominay, VDB and Fred and only have Mount as a midfield signing we are asking for trouble in the event of injuries.
If we sell McTominay, VDB and Fred and only have Mount as a midfield signing we are asking for trouble in the event of injuries.
Have you got the article
Not really. Mount replaces Fred, Mainoo replaces McTominay and quite frankly nobody needs to replace Donny, but we've got Hannibal for good measure. Besides, we absolutely will sign another midfielder should all of those three depart.If we sell McTominay, VDB and Fred and only have Mount as a midfield signing we are asking for trouble in the event of injuries.
Exactly - the BBC aggregate any old tat in that column, as opposed to their 'official' football news announcements (largely by Stone)..it's according to a Spanish paper I think. Spanish paper in 'player prefers to come to Spain' shocker
Mount is Fred's replacement. I think we will buy a dm/first phase midfielder to replace McTominay; probably Amrabat, hopefully Caicedo. Hannibal/Mainoo can replace vdB's non existent minutes. We would still have EtH's first choice trio from last season: Casemiro, Eriksen and Bruno.If we sell McTominay, VDB and Fred and only have Mount as a midfield signing we are asking for trouble in the event of injuries.
He's worth more imo. Would rather sell McTominay for over 30 million.
Were you impressed when he wins his 1 v 1 battles consistently up against the best left wingers in the league? Matoma at Brighton had right backs scrambling last year but AWB won his battles almost every time. That, to me, is very impressive.We shall see. There was an improvement but I didn't really see what everyone was so impressed by. Maybe, he can kick on.