Transfer Tweets - 2019/20 | Check the OP for blacklisted sources before posting

Status
Not open for further replies.
25M for Rojo is actually a great piece of business by us. It isn't another signing like we all want, but at least we've managed to find a taker for some of our deadwood that people have been moaning about us not selling this summer, and for a decent fee at that.
 
diarm said:
I've spent 6 years thinking that but have seen little to know inclination from any of them to put the measures in place to build a better structure to the footballing side of the club.

We literally had Woodward come out last year and say the financial success of the club was not reliant on what happened on the pitch. I have come around to the conclusion that they genuinely believe the club is too big to fall - it wouldn't be the first time that supposedly competent businessmen allowed complacency and arrogance to be their downfall.

As for the idea that nobody could have known the managerial appointments would be a disaster - I disagree. Without a clear and cohesive structure and strategy no manager will come in and be successful in modern football.

Our entire club was built around one man. It was always fantasy to think you can build your club on every manager being a Ferguson or a Busby - the type of talent that comes around once every couple of generations and the likes of which may never be seen again in the modern game.

We had examples of well run, 21st century clubs to look to. The Moyes mistake could have been forgiven as sentiment and inexperience on the part of the club, but after that the leaders in our boardroom had to take stock, look outside their own experience and egos and acknowledge what was working elsewhere.

Barcelona, Bayern, City - clubs who are structured in such a way that a change of manager doesn't instantly result in an entire upheaval of every aspect of the club.

Pep Guardiola, seen as the new messiah and competition for Fergie's legacy, didn't come to City until Begiristain had been there to lay the ground work behind the scenes for a few years.

Klopp who has worked miracles at Liverpool, met with Woodward and walked away because he couldn't get on board with Ed's vision (or lack thereof) for the club. He clearly didn't have the same reaction to his meeting with Liverpool's owners and the last two years have shown he made the right decision.

It's not as simple as picking the right manager from a hat and everything will sort itself out. Rather than blaming all the managers who have failed, we should be pointing out fingers at the people setting them up to fail from above.
Click to expand...

Some good points here and a refreshing take on the situation over the usual 'feck Ed, he's useless' rhetoric.

Really well put mate
 
Berbaclass said:
That doesn’t really correlate with our summer business though, we’ve made 3 seemingly very well thought out and sensible signings.
Click to expand...

We have made 3 well thought out signings. The Maguire one took too long when we all suspect he could have been signed and bedded in during the pre season tour. He could have been signed for less money last summer. The idea that Leicester wanted to be thrashing about trying to replace him in the last few days of the window is absurd.

We also needed to sign a right winger and having lost Herrera, a midfielder. Yes it is difficult to sign five players in a window but for a club with our resources and in the position we find ourselves, it was important we fixed the blatant issues.

Three summers ago, City signed a keeper, two right backs, a centre back, a left back, a central midfielder and a right winger - all for their first team squad. They went on to win immediate back to back titles.
 
Barnslig said:
Thank feck for that, do not want. Better playing with 10 men next year, or giving every single minute Mandzukic would've got to a youngster, way too old.
Click to expand...
Yeah its great putting all of our hopes go youngsters. Not.
 
Kearnkoff69 said:
25M for Rojo is actually a great piece of business by us. It isn't another signing like we all want, but at least we've managed to find a taker for some of our deadwood that people have been moaning about us not selling this summer, and for a decent fee at that.
Click to expand...
It also means our net spend is like £50m or something if it goes through.
 
Majima said:
Could you blame him though? It's all on his shoulders again. If I was him I would be livid.
Click to expand...

I would be too,he's being set up as the scapegoat by fans once the season starts while the club have shown less ambition than most midtable sides this window

If the fans are sick of this shit,I can't imagine how the players in the squad with any ambition must feel
 
Rojo isn’t a bad CB but an awful left back yet we played him there most of the time. Crazy but 25m is a good price
 
Majima said:
Could you blame him though? It's all on his shoulders again. If I was him I would be livid.
Click to expand...
Considering the pittance spent yet again, I’d write him a check for 5M to just be quiet this season until he gets his move next summer.
 
Berbaclass said:
I'd be happy to continue this discussion but it's not the right thread. Agree to disagree for now.
Click to expand...

Yeah fair enough. Had already sent a last post before reading this but you're right - it's a conversation for another thread.
 
Brownie85 said:
I've not got a problem with youngsters getting a chance, but when they struggle, lose confidence and form, then what?
Click to expand...

We carry on playing them and ruin their confidence further seems to be the plan.
 
When a youngster with, what, 8 first team games, is being quoted at £50 million, £25 million for an Argentine international who can play in 2 positions is a bargain.
 
Rolaholic said:
I would be too,he's being set up as the scapegoat by fans once the season starts while the club have shown less ambition than most midtable sides this window

If the fans are sick of this shit,I can't imagine how the players in the squad with any ambition must feel
Click to expand...
One big joke is what it is, whilst Woody & the Glazers are laughing all the way to the bank.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.