Thiago Alcantara | Signed for Bayern Munich

Status
Not open for further replies.
So on the 19th we should expect to see him at the 'Aon' training centre being covered by a. White sheet?
 
So on the 19th we should expect to see him at the 'Aon' training centre being covered by a. White sheet?

"Cum" Mainaldo, we're all adults here you can call it by its proper name.
 
I am hoping we sign this guy, would a great signing and would piss off my Barca supporting friends. Apparently they'd rather lose Fabregas than Thiago which shows how highly he is rated.
 


50415_120134811342089_4001312_n.jpg
 
Slight problem caftards. He is now linked with Bayern. Pep is lurking but I think we will win out based on playing time. That's what I'm hoping for at least.
 
Bayern have Kroos and Götze. If he's leaving for playing time, it'd be unwise to go there. I also suspect the fact this isn't the first time we've expressed interest in him will count for something.
 
Bayern have Kroos and Götze. If he's leaving for playing time, it'd be unwise to go there. I also suspect the fact this isn't the first time we've expressed interest in him will count for something.

Yeah, for the positions he'd be able to play, he has Kroos, Gotze, Muller, and Schweinsteiger and Martinez for the deeper positions all ahead of him. He wouldn't be at all better with playing time there, even with Pep in charge.
 
Holy feck, I've the second highest post count in this thread. I've tried to play it cool here, my inner muppet is stronger than I imagined.


FCBarca gets a pass, seeing as it's his clubs player, which puts R2D2Ronaldo up into 5th place as things stand.
 
Pfff, I'm through the looking glass anyway. Lost all touch with reality. If we sign him, I'll probably slide into nirvana or something. If we don't, a ban might be my only decent shout for sanity.
 
I will have an affair with De Gea's missus if he doesnt convince Thiago to come here. Out of spite.
 
FCBarca gets a pass, seeing as it's his clubs player, which puts R2D2Ronaldo up into 5th place as things stand.
Im actually more active than Gambit in the transfer forum nowadays. But no one seems to notice. His reputation obviously precedes him.
 
May I be spared rotten tomatoes being thrown at me if I submitted a crazy idea?

Since it's really hard to imagine Barcelona selling us a potential superstar -- Thiago Alcantara -- would we even consider the idea of suggesting to Barca a loan spell for the Spaniard?

Unless, of course, we can come up with another equally outstanding central midfielder, a loan for Alcantara could serve both clubs' interests quite beautifully. Yes, there are other decent midfielders out there who are gettable, but are Fellaini or Cabaye (I really do like Cabaye, though) are nowhere near Alcanatara's quality. Fabregas is up there, but does anyone really believe we're going to land him? I don't see Gundogan going anywhere. We're not going to snatch Wilshere from Wenger. I don't see Real selling Modric to us -- but Modric would be an outstanding acquisition for us. We might pick up Strootman but if we do he wouldn't give us what Alcantara offers. There's been a lot of chatter about James McCarthy over the last week but I trust we all agree James McCarthy is no Thiago Alcantara.

Where I'm going with this if that we can't actually buy a proper midfielder, why not borrow him for a season? I'm not ready to give up on Tom Cleverley quite yet and who knows what the youth pipeline might produce. And what if Alcantara actually warms up to the idea of being a United man after a season? Maybe he'll survey the situation at Barcelona next summer and decide his long term future is at Manchester. And if he decides to go back, then how much worse off are we than where are right now?

If we can buy the boy, let's buy the boy. But unless we can land a mid of the quality of, say, Modric, why not a loan deal for Alcantara?
 
Because doing a loan deal does not suit us in the long run since we are providing him with games, improving him as a player and then giving him back to his team. If he 17 or 18 then that's a different story but not when he is 22. You want to get something out of this deal.

Edit: FFS it's Ruud. Why did I even bother replying!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.