Just watched Alien again for the 1000th time yesterday. It was my partner's first time. Now we're set for an Alien binge
We just finished ours!
Alien is pretty much perfect. The atmosphere, the slow build until the first chest burst, the omnipresent menace of the xenomorph, the use of the space on the ship, the final showdown between the alien and Ripley... It's all quite wonderful and suspenseful from start to finish.
I'm actually not a massive fan of
Aliens which is a little bit too much 80s Reagan cliché action, with particularly one unsufferable character, but in terms of action films, it's very good. I just don't think action is the best mix with Alien, but I know it's a few people's favourite.
I have a lot of fondness for
Alien 3 in its "assembly cut" version - it's imperfect, sure, but I love the vibe of the film and while it's quite clear from the edit it's a film that suffered from production issues, it's closer to the atmosphere I enjoy. The cast is quite good in it and it has a grittiness I love.
I didn't enjoy
Alien Resurrection at all. I've always found JP Jeunet to be overrated, and beyond the amazement of seeing Dominique Pinon in a sci-fi action film, it really doesn't offer much. I also find the aliens in this one a lot less menacing than in the other films, and the characters are cliché cardboard cut-outs. The whole premise is a bit stupid and it never really kicks into full gear.
So, then comes
Prometheus, or its unofficial title "stupid people doing stupid things". In general I'm not one to nitpick
too much about script realism, and I'm a big believer in suspension of disbelief, but this one really goes beyond any acceptable tolerance in that regard. It starts off nicely, the film looks great, and while early on you realise the characters aren't going to be deep and interesting, there was still a way to achieve what the film set out to do without the levels of idiocy displayed onscreen. It's an aesthetically pleasing object, with very little beneath the surface.
We finished the binge with
Alien Covenant which I stomehow am not sure whether I'd seen it before. I felt it was somewhat better than Prometheus, but it suffered the same issue of having characters ignoring the most basic common sense. The whole sequence when they're back at the place David set up camp is particularly stupid. Oh, and Danny McBride is pretty bad in it, unsurprisingly.
Overall, characters seem to have gotten more and more stupid with passing films, and some of the writing basics such as finding a way to have things happen somewhat organically, or the usage of space (in the last 3 films, you don't really understand where things or people are, it's messy), are completely disregarded. Real shame.