The Guardian - Manchester United to sack Erik ten Hag after the FA Cup Final

Status
Not open for further replies.
If this is true, I have some fairly conflicted thoughts.

On one hand I understand the decision, I expected that the new footballing structure would want to bring their own man in, and our season has been poor, even with mitigating circumstances. The names we're being linked with fill me with dread (RDZ, McKenna, Southgate, etc), but I'm sure there are some decent managers out that hopefully we're looking at instead.

On the other hand though, it's absolutely classless that this has leaked before the final, and it points to something frankly rotten in the club that it's gotten out again. The way we handled LVG left a really bad taste in my mouth, even though I didn't doubt for a second that it was the right decision, and this feels worse given the timing and that I'd hoped the lack of class was a one off rather than endemic.

There's a lot of folks in here effectively dancing on the grave of Ten Hag's United career in this thread, which I find a bit sad. I get thinking it's the right decision, even feeling happy he's gone for the ones that really can't stand him, but I honestly can't see how any United can be happy with the way the club has handled it. Not only is the leaking unprofessional, it's undermining our preparations for the cup final.

That wasn't us. The Mourinho camped leaked that.
 
There will not be another like Fergie. We have not won a league title for 11 years and counting. From top dogs to also-rans: our new reality. Sacking managers every 2 years won’t change anything. Deal with it.
In an ideal world longevity is best. But if they are all going the wrong way as all of ours post Fergie have done after varying time limits, you don’t hang around hoping that they will come good. Big clubs don’t accept it. I thought we envisioned ourselves as a big club?
 
Tuchel has won the German league, the French league and the champions league. He’s managed Dortmund, PSG, Chelsea and Bayern Munich.
I don’t understand how that’s failure.

You want to honestly back a manager that has ONLY managed Ipswich?

I meant a failure in the PL.
Although finishing 3rd with Bayern is just as bad a finishing 8th with us.
 
You've rated Onana all season, of course you wouldn't care about standards
No, I used common sense and context around him so I am patient to give him another season after he is used to the league. This isn't FIFA.

Standards my arse, you can hide behind "standards" all you want, truth is another thing.
 
Why are so many people pissed at the club when it's pretty obvious the leaks came from elsewhere?
People have gone all in on this guy, therefore it's the club that's the root of all evil. Pretty bizarre , but that's the social media these days.
 
yes, for another season under a proper footballing structure. Sacking manager after 2 season is not a solution
Keeping a failing manager who has had us playing awful football for over a year isn't a solution either. Any manager needs to earn his time, not be given anything. 2 years is the average manager tenure.
 
Can you guys point to any previous examples of a manager announcing their leaving, voluntarily or otherwise, and it being a good thing for the team? All the evidence I've seen points to the opposite; the manager loses authority and the players lose at least a few %, which is enough to be the difference between success and failure. There's evidence as early as this season with Klopp, and even the greatest motivator of all time in Fergie has admitted that the players put their tools down when he announced his retirement the first time around.

How does that evidence line up with our situation? We only have 1 game left, that's tomorrow and it's a final. What "loses authority" are you talking about? There's nothing left in the season mate, there's no more coaching sessions even.
 
Can you guys point to any previous examples of a manager announcing their leaving, voluntarily or otherwise, and it being a good thing for the team? All the evidence I've seen points to the opposite; the manager loses authority and the players lose at least a few %, which is enough to be the difference between success and failure. There's evidence as early as this season with Klopp, and even the greatest motivator of all time in Fergie has admitted that the players put their tools down when he announced his retirement the first time around.
A one off game (especially a cup final) is a fair bit different than announcing it months in advance.

I remember us starting to play better in 18/19 when it looked almost certain that Mourinho was about to be fired. So much so that we ended up actually keeping him for another two months.
 
In an ideal world longevity is best. But if they are all going the wrong way as all of ours post Fergie have done after varying time limits, you don’t hang around hoping that they will come good. Big clubs don’t accept it. I thought we envisioned ourselves as a big club?

Longevity is only best if you have the absolute best in class in the role already. Then you don't need or want to change because everything else is a downgrade. We were in that position when we had Ferguson. Man City are in that position today with Guardiola.

Those managers came along once a generation.

If you don't have one of them, you need to cycle through the best of the rest and try and get the most out of the resources at hand, and constantly look for someone else who might get more out of the resources you have.
 
Not sure why everyone is blaming INEOS since I don't believe for one second they would leak this at this time.

Its someone with an agenda against United.
 
People have gone all in on this guy, therefore it's the club that's the root of all evil. Pretty bizarre , but that's the social media these days.
A lot of people these days are incapable of even basic critical thinking skills.

Therefore "it's been leaked, it's the club's fault" is the narrative. It's depressing.
 
I support every United manager. This leak the day before the cup final is disgraceful. I feel sorry for Ten Hag. Carrying the can for a club that is rotten to the core.

Bang on. It's absolutely disgusting.

Club could redeem itself by either issuing a statement denying it or a leak to a favoured journalist saying it's nonsense.

Our manager and players completely undermined the night before a final, wankers.
 
Why are so many people pissed at the club when it's pretty obvious the leaks came from elsewhere?
A lot of people these days are incapable of even basic critical thinking skills.

Therefore "it's been leaked, it's the club's fault" is the narrative. It's depressing.

The leaks will still have started at the club. There's no way this gets out without the club being, at best, careless with the information. It's possible to agree with (and seemingly celebrate) the decision while also holding the club to account for handling it badly.

People have gone all in on this guy, therefore it's the club that's the root of all evil. Pretty bizarre , but that's the social media these days.

This is beyond childish. Being annoyed at the club for handling it horribly is entirely unrelated to backing the manager. Look at when LVG left for example, fans were fairly unanimous in agreeing it was time for him to go, but still really disappointed in the club for the lack of respect demonstrated in how it was handled.
 
Even if that's true, it's still on the club. Allowing that information to get out was classless, just like it is now.

Hiring that prick was the problem - and that's on the club. Unfortunately, he proved he was one before he'd even jumped into the role.
 
Not sure why everyone is blaming INEOS since I don't believe for one second they would leak this at this time.

Its someone with an agenda against United.
Why would you meet with agent when FA cup final is less than week away? Thats where it got leaked from
 
Imagine ETH walks before the final if they don't give him assurances they havent made up their mind.
What manager wants to go to a cup final after almost concrete rumors he's being sacked, only to lose to a vastly better City side.
 
The leaks will still have started at the club. There's no way this gets out without the club being, at best, careless with the information. It's possible to agree with (and seemingly celebrate) the decision while also holding the club to account for handling it badly.
How? The club is speaking to multiple other parties when trying to sound out a new manager. These parties all have contacts in the media. Word inevitably gets out, and there's only so much the club can do about it.

Besides, it sounds like ETH has been well aware of his fate since before the Arsenal game anyway (not that it should've been much of a surprise regardless).
 
Don’t worry we will be here wondering who our new manager would be in 2 years after getting our hopes up the first season and then crumble the season after.

So what should the club do then? Not sack a failing manager?
 
The leaks will still have started at the club. There's no way this gets out without the club being, at best, careless with the information. It's possible to agree with (and seemingly celebrate) the decision while also holding the club to account for handling it badly.



This is beyond childish. Being annoyed at the club for handling it horribly is entirely unrelated to backing the manager. Look at when LVG left for example, fans were fairly unanimous in agreeing it was time for him to go, but still really disappointed in the club for the lack of respect demonstrated in how it was handled.
It's not the bloody club that leaked it.
 
The leaks will still have started at the club. There's no way this gets out without the club being, at best, careless with the information. It's possible to agree with (and seemingly celebrate) the decision while also holding the club to account for handling it badly.



This is beyond childish. Being annoyed at the club for handling it horribly is entirely unrelated to backing the manager. Look at when LVG left for example, fans were fairly unanimous in agreeing it was time for him to go, but still really disappointed in the club for the lack of respect demonstrated in how it was handled.
The only way the leaks for LVG and probably ETH don't happen is if we don't approach any managers until after we fire them. In which case, our first choice replacements end up going elsewhere and the fans (rightfully) complaining about the incompetence of the club not getting things done properly.
 
This has been covered repeatedly. Read the thread.

I'm not reading 17 pages to find out what you're talking about, but I'd welcome an explanation as to how the press found out we're sacking Ten Hag without anyone at the club saying anything if you have one. Short of telepathy I can't think of a way that happens.
 
Ah so we are a club that defines it's manager by one season now, regardless of a good first season. The great United way. Best fans in the world. Don't show your bias or anything. Fan community my hole. Thankfully this place is no more than an echo chamber of a section of Manchester United fans. As embarrassing as this whole circus show. 1 post left for today and thank god will be my last. May as well ban the account. I don't have enough clown makeup to keep posting here.
worse season of the epl era...
 
Ah so we are a club that defines it's manager by one season now, regardless of a good first season. The great United way. Best fans in the world. Don't show your bias or anything. Fan community my hole. Thankfully this place is no more than an echo chamber of a section of Manchester United fans. As embarrassing as this whole circus show. 1 post left for today and thank god will be my last. May as well ban the account. I don't have enough clown makeup to keep posting here.

I could be wrong, but I sense you might be upset?
 
I'm not reading 17 pages to find out what you're talking about, but I'd welcome an explanation as to how the press found out we're sacking Ten Hag without anyone at the club saying anything if you have one. Short of telepathy I can't think of a way that happens.
We've started looking for a new manager.
 
The only way the leaks for LVG and probably ETH don't happen is if we don't approach any managers until after we fire them. In which case, our first choice replacements end up going elsewhere and the fans (rightfully) complaining about the incompetence of the club not getting things done properly.

That doesn't have to be the case at all. Surely we should be making sure that targets we approach have enough professionalism not to leak it. Especially not at such a potentially damaging time.
 
I support every United manager. This leak the day before the cup final is disgraceful. I feel sorry for Ten Hag. Carrying the can for a club that is rotten to the core.

Yep

But you will have a bunch of idiot fans happy , regardless of how it impacts our chances tomorrow. If he’s gone on Sunday , then no United fan should be happy we find out a day hey for the cup final, it doesn’t help us.
 
How does that evidence line up with our situation? We only have 1 game left, that's tomorrow and it's a final. What "loses authority" are you talking about? There's nothing left in the season mate, there's no more coaching sessions even.

We have the biggest game of our season left, far more important than any coaching sessions, and the manager who's coming up with the game plan to win it has had his authority undermined the day before that match.

The examples I gave were of teams that suffered due to managers being undermined. Do you have any examples of the opposite? As at the moment all you've got is what you "reckon" which is really nothing more than fantasy booking based entirely on your dislike of the manager.
 
Ah so we are a club that defines it's manager by one season now, regardless of a good first season. The great United way. Best fans in the world. Don't show your bias or anything. Fan community my hole. Thankfully this place is no more than an echo chamber of a section of Manchester United fans. As embarrassing as this whole circus show. 1 post left for today and thank god will be my last. May as well ban the account. I don't have enough clown makeup to keep posting here.
:lol: :lol: he got his wish anyway!
 
Why would you meet with agent when FA cup final is less than week away? Thats where it got leaked from

Business has to be done behind the scenes all the time. Agents are supposed to be discreet.

I don't know if they can pinpoint whose agent it is, but if they know, we should not be hiring that manager.

Let's all hope it's Southgate's agent:lol:
 
I'm not reading 17 pages to find out what you're talking about, but I'd welcome an explanation as to how the press found out we're sacking Ten Hag without anyone at the club saying anything if you have one. Short of telepathy I can't think of a way that happens.
Look up the page then.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.