Only 12 days until the window closes. Thank God.
Then the real pain starts.
Then the real pain starts.
Solskjaer target 5 signings; 6 players could leave [BBC, Telegraph, Guardian]
- Thread starter roonster09
- Start date
150m for Pogba is simply laughable in this market. Such an offer wouldn’t even be worth reverting an email
Really? so self identification is a thing where you live?
it's what's best for the parties involved I would say, if Savic and Bruno can be bought with less than Pogba money then that's good business.
This 100m budget all comes from one dumb Odgen article who has consistently been shit for half a decade. You don't bid 70 m for Maguire if you only have 100 m to spend ffs.
Haven't watched any of those players, but from what i've read, aren't those players both attacking midfielders? 8/10'ish?
Wouldn't Bruno or SMS plus Longstaff or other CDM/b2b make more sense?
It’s not a good business when there are currently only 2 players in world football that may definitely be sold for more than Pogba (well, Messi won’t leave so we disregard him - so only Mbappe and Neymar).
Certainly in this market Pogba is worth a triple digit amount in million pounds starting with “2” (i.e. at least 200m)
If this artucle is true and that Woodward did anounce we only have 100 to spend that we be a good move by him. The only reason we always buy overpriced compared to other teams is the constant bragging from Woodward that we have lots to spend.
You go in a used car dealership and say money is not a problem you will come out buying an overpriced used car.
You think pogba is worth more than 150m?
I'd happily get shot of him for Savic and Fernandes. No brainer.
Personally, I wouldn't even enter negotiations if we were talking figures below 200m pounds.
What has he done for Manchester Utd to more than double his value? Sweet feck all. They got Hazard(a far superior player) for far less. 130m would do fine imo.
The world record for a transfer went from 89m to 200m since he joined.
Hazard had one year left on his contract.
Hazard is not a better player, and he was in his last year of contract. Besides, Pogba is not only a player, but also a celebrity which has additional value for the club.
It's a bit like with Maguire: if Man Utd doesnt want to sell, we don't sell. If we are ready to sell, we have a right to put any price tag we consider comfortable. Certainly anything below 200m pounds is uncomfortable as you can't sign a better midfielder for any money (there are no better midfielders in the game)
Hazard only had a year left, Chelsea were forced to sell him. 200m is too much imo but 150-170m should be enough.
Hazard only had one year left on his contract though, I think.
True but they're buying a tangible asset not years left on contracts. Its widely reported they are willing to pay no more than 100m and I believe that. Plus Pogba has stated he wants to leave so the diminishes United's chances to get what they want. 130-150 seems the area but anyone thinking Madrid would pay 200m for a player who has flopped here and is 3 years older need their head examined. Take 130 and start rebuilding with players who want to play for Manchester United.
The last thing Man Utd needs to do is to operate in accordance with desire of others.
200m for Pogba too expensive? Perfect, negotiations are over, the player stays. It's better to offer him a new 6-year deal on good money (de Gea deal sets the mark, Pogba is likely to be paid better)
I read we were supposedly going to offer Pogba £500,000 per week but not sure how much substance there is to it.
Think you're forgetting that Pogba has stated, along with his dickhead agent, that he wants to leave.
He never firmly stated this. There were certain words about "new challenge", but he never explicitly announced in public that he wants to leave Man Utd. And yet again, we may offer him a 6-year contract he is unlikely to receive elsewhere.
Yes he did. "Maybe now is the right time for a new challenge." Then his agent totally confirmed it. There seems to be some collective amnesia about this. Pogba wants to leave, it's common knowledge.
I think people make a bit too much of the transfers at the top end. Neymar went for £198m but it was the mother of all sketchy deals, with much of the value tied into his brand ambassadorship for Qatar and the 2022 World Cup. Mbappe is the most talented attacking player to emerge in the last decade and he went for £116 plus another 30-40 in add ons. Joao Felix just sold for £114.1, but again another very sketchy looking deal with probably all sorts of other crazy shit agreed between clubs, agents, etc. Coutinho sold for £105 plus add ons but it was a terrible deal for Barcelona and I think everybody other than their board has acknowledged this from the day it was struck.
Looking at all that and thinking that Pogba - who realistically wouldn't be among the top 10 players you would select to build a team around - is worth £200m is hard to believe. A lot of it is simply because of the previous price he sold for. But to be brutally honest his trajectory looked higher at that point in his career than it does now, after three fairly seasons in which he has shown his talent but hasn't really gotten better at an age when you'd hope a player would be improving toward their peak performance.
Yeah how about win the PL with United? There’s a new challenge for him.
Wanting to leave doesn’t diminish anything. Neymar wanted to leave - world record. Pogba wanted to leave Juve - world record. Ronaldo - world record. Hazard wanted to leave AND had one year left - 130 mill. A player wanting to leave doesn’t do that much in this day and age. To use your argument against you ‘they’re buying tangible assets not’ a player’s desire to leave.
It affects Manchester United though as what manager worth his salt wants a player who doesn't want to be there, so of course it has an affect. Another year with this Pogba circus is the last thing the club needs. We are bigger than that. 130-150m is a fair price.
Less than two weeks to go...
True but you also have to factor in your own financial situation. It doesn't seem like the funds are there to replace Herera. If you can get 130 - 150 mill for Pogba you can bring in SMS + Bruno Fernandes and still have about 10 mil extra. That's a whole lot better than just having Pogba by himself. As much as I'd like to keep him, seems the only way to balance this squad might be to sell him and use his funds on 2 or 3 players. I don't think any team will buy him for 200 mill, 130 - 150 is a lot more attainable.
For Woody to do something amazing in the transfer window.
1) No, it’s not
2) why do we need to sell at a fair price? If we sell to RM, we need to squeeze them dry. If Zidane is desperate, let it be 150m + Varane, plus they take Alexis on. 2-year long loan
I couldn't see this happening but if it did it would make extremely happy
If RM would take all o f our dross off our hands would be happy to throw Pogba in for free, he is dross half of the time anyway
‘Plus Pogba has stated he wants to leave so the diminishes United's chances to get what they want.’
That was the point you made and the point you made was wrong. When someone calls you out on a point you can’t just ignore it and say something completely different.
It needs to be a world record for a mid/attacking mid.
That's Coutinho - 140m, so certainly needs to beat that
It just needs to be a world record. Full stop.
Or you may need to understand the word diminish.
They can pay up if they want Pogba. I’m sick of being fleeced by other clubs.
We let them have Beckham for £25 million, and Ruud for £11 million.
Is everyone forgetting how much they wanted for an unproven Morata?
We let them have Beckham for £25 million, and Ruud for £11 million.
Is everyone forgetting how much they wanted for an unproven Morata?
‘Diminish United’s chances in getting what they want’ I.e. lessens United’s chance at getting the transfer fee they want. Which I refuted as being unfounded based on the fact that pretty much every world record fee has been a player wanting out. In response you then went on a tangent saying how it will affect United because the Pogba circus will continue. An entirely different point.
Last edited:
Yes, precisely. But I would rather take Varane+Casemiro+cashWhat, 200m or so?
We can still dream...for 2 weeks.
Out - Lukaku 70 + Pogba 140 + other dross Rojo/Darmian etc = total - 240/250 ish
In
Maguire- 80
Fernandez- 60
Partey - 50
Pepe - 70
Total 260
Out - Lukaku 70 + Pogba 140 + other dross Rojo/Darmian etc = total - 240/250 ish
In
Maguire- 80
Fernandez- 60
Partey - 50
Pepe - 70
Total 260