No but Giggs is a squad player not part of the first eleven and not typically in when everyone else is fit unless for a specific reason. Every winger doesn't need to be a Ronaldo but they need to be able to do something. As I said Young has had a lot of his goals/assists from set pieces and being pushed higher up the pitch, playing in a deeper role and not being the set piece taker certainly not a main one, for me seriously reduces what he naturally brings, as I said though he's still more than good enough to be a squad player. Valencia doesn't need to be a set piece taker nor player higher up the pitch to be very effective though.
In honesty though neither would be part of my first eleven.
Set pieces or not - he produces the goods. Fact remains if Young gets a good run of games, he is capable of delivering. Maybe most of his assists are from set-pieces but that's another route to get goals for the team. Frank Lampard would be Djemba-Djemba without set pieces. He's scored close to 50 penalty kicks for Chelsea. I just don't understand the criticism Young gets on these pages. He has not disappointed me yet in a red shirt. I can always count on him.