Romelu Lukaku image 9

Romelu Lukaku Belgium flag

2017-18 Performances


View full 2017-18 profile

6.1 Season Average Rating
Appearances
51
Goals
27
Assists
10
Yellow cards
3
Status
Not open for further replies.
His hold up play just simply isn’t good enough. Cannot understand why we have signed him to play as a lone striker.
it like last year when we tried to play Zlatan up front against a teams who famously play a high line, or at the end of te season when we left Rashford isolated.

You have to play tactics that make the most of the players you have, thats what Conte did today that Mourinho didn't.
 
We knew what we were getting with him.

Very good goalscorer, but his all-around game leaves a lot to be desired. I thought he was showing some good signs at the start of the season, but that's gone off the boil lately.

We don't do him any favors either by just hoofing it to him.
 
He's had zero through balls or crosses to feed on.

He's a striker not a creator.
I feel sorry for him.

When the chances were created he scored.
 
Again no problem in him passing through a drought out, it happens to the best strikers in the world. The problem is in his overall play. He just seems to get contained easily with defenders when no one is creating for him. I don't expect him to create for himself, but he should his build up to bully defenders and provide nuisance to them, to hold up the ball and bring the rest of his teammates up to the pitch. You can't be of that size and lose challenges that easily it's ridiculous.

If he wants to become an elite striker he must learn to play on his strength. Use your physicality ffs.

So you want him to run around smacking lads ?

What the actual f**feck is a striker meant to do when he gets no service ?

The man has proved he can score goals when he gets service.
 
So you want him to run around smacking lads ?

What the actual f**feck is a striker meant to do when he gets no service ?

The man has proved he can score goals when he gets service.

If this the only thing you understood from what my post then it can't be helped.
 
I said it from the beginning, he's not a great footballer and has poor movement. Most of the time it looks like he's marking the opposition CB.
 
As you can tell from my username, Mark Hughes was my idol.

The touch of a God, didn't get the goals but added so much more. Right now , whilst ROM will score 15 per year more than Sparky did...... He's not even half the player
 
Your post didn't make sense.

It makes every sense.

A striker of this size should be winning challenges and aerial deals and holding up the ball under pressure with not much problem. On the reality it looks the opposite. He loses possession of the ball very easily under pressure. That's unacceptable for such kind of strikers.

He doesn't get enough service thus doesn't score much, that's normal and all but all the other things I want from my team's striker are done very poorly from him since Liverpool game.

If he doesn't play on his strength and use his physicality to impose himself on the defenders he won't become an elite striker.
 
He's not being utilized accordingly. He's pacey but not mobile, he turns rather slow. He should be on the end of accurate crosses/through balls running into space.
 
He looks weird without a beard too.
He is the type of person who is better looking by being hairy. Why did he have to be bald?
He's not being utilized accordingly. He's pacey but not mobile, he turns rather slow. He should be on the end of accurate crosses/through balls running into space.
Agree.

Still his use of his gifted physicality is much to be desired. Not winning enough aerial battle. Can't fault his effort though. He is not lazy as he used to be back when he's newer to the league. He just needs to improve and we as a team needs to improve our service for him.
 
Yet again another match where I think he will get a lot of criticism when it's the 9 men behind him that are letting him down.
Sure he may not be the most technically gifted, but we don't give him anything to work with
 
He got a big chance vs. Liverpool and missed, he got a nice chance vs. Stoke and missed and he could have done better with his one chance today. Not writing him off, but when you are so limited at everything else - you absolutely need to burry those chances you get. Right now he is playing poorly and could/should be benched for someone with a deeper register than him.

Can’t pass, can’t dribble, can’t link-up, and now he can’t score for shit. Would have liked Morata here instead of Lukaku, that’s just how it is - he is a much more polished and he is even a better header of the ball. Not that he did so much today, other than scoring a great goal, but in most games this season he has been instrumental in the build-up as well as scoring goals.
 
He is living off scraps. He had a few poor touches today but he was barely given the ball.
 
When DDG was kicking the ball long towards Lukaku, I saw he'd chest the ball down and a smaller defender would then take the ball off of him.
He had one thing to do all game (head/chest down long balls and pass it to a team-mate, then run towards goal) and he couldn't do that.
I think today he simply had a bad day at the office. His worst game in a MUFC shirt, today.
 
All that strength is a joke, he's not man enough to handle the big games, you can see it on his face. He scores against small teams while Utd are in control anyway.

He's feeble, just trash
 
All that strength is a joke, he's not man enough to handle the big games, you can see it on his face. He scores against small teams while Utd are in control anyway.

He's feeble, just trash
Total BS. He's getting absolutely no service. So of course he's going to be miserable and frustrated
 
Rashford doesnt stop running and he didnt get any service.
Rashford is playing as a winger. It's his bloody job to run. If Lukaku runs around like a headless chicken, then who's going to maintain the shape needed to keep the opposition defense honest and play as target man. Some of you people are so clueless about the tactical aspect of the game its laughable
 
It makes every sense.

A striker of this size should be winning challenges and aerial deals and holding up the ball under pressure with not much problem. On the reality it looks the opposite. He loses possession of the ball very easily under pressure. That's unacceptable for such kind of strikers.

He doesn't get enough service thus doesn't score much, that's normal and all but all the other things I want from my team's striker are done very poorly from him since Liverpool game.

If he doesn't play on his strength and use his physicality to impose himself on the defenders he won't become an elite striker.

You're talking out of your asss mate
 
Total BS. He's getting absolutely no service. So of he's going to be miserable and frustrated
This wasn't about service, he can't even handle basic football control. You just knew that nothing good would come from him today, he's so damn easy to defend against.

This argument about "service" not being good enough is weak. You expect a £75M striker to be independently good enough to stand out, like Morata did a couple of times today when he made nice, productive plays with his team-mates.

Lukaku's got nothing like that, nothing. Elite striker? What a joke
 
Can't really fault him, he's gotten virtually zero service for quite some time. We have zero width or penetrative passer from the middle since Pogba has been out.
 
He's an isolated #9 in a team losing the midfield battle. Do people not understand how football works?

All the wanking over Morata in the match thread and saying we bought the wrong striker is so dumb. Morata would be having the exact same problem right now in this side.
Yes, this.
 
He's an isolated #9 in a team losing the midfield battle. Do people not understand how football works?

All the wanking over Morata in the match thread and saying we bought the wrong striker is so dumb. Morata would be having the exact same problem right now in this side.
Not the exact same problem though. Morata is actually decent at linking up and holding on to the ball, at least winning FKs.
 

I like Rom, but stuff like this shouldn't be happening to a top level striker.
 
OK. Sure Lukaku could do better but lets look at a few things.

1. - We have useless fullbacks who offer nothing:
2. - We can't take a set piece or corner - Just hit the first man
3. - We keep playing pathetic 'Tony Pulis' Long balls to Lukaku. - These are just ugly hoofs up the pitch
4. - Herrera has been rubbish for weeks. Has no understanding of his role with Matic.
5. - Mkhitaryan has been terrible all season can't keep the ball, hardly passes the ball forward, bottles most through balls. No service going forward.

For Lukaku to do well we have to play to his strengths, if we keep playing ugly passes over his head, have him feeding of scrapes forcing him to run into wide positions he will never score.

People suggesting he is at fault should look at what he does for Belgium when he is playing for them he has players crossing accurately giving him proper service.

Mourinho tactics and style of play are not in line with Lukaku's ability. He should've invested in proper full backs and better players who can cross a ball.
 
I was never enamoured with his signing to be honest, and my fears about his overall ability are coming to the fore. He has too many glaring weaknesses as a footballer. His first and often second touch are truly erratic, as is his movement and intelligence off the ball. You have to be able to control a football consistently at the highest level. He simply doesn’t stack up well to the worlds finest centre forwards.

What disappoints me most about today was his body language, his attitude. He didn’t work hard enough to involve himself. Morata has been off form but he busted a gut to get on the ball and make things happen. He never stopped trying to create space and work our centre backs.

Lukaku drifts too often...he seems like he’s waiting for people to lay something on an plate for him, despite his often poor decision making. He has to shoulder a lot of the blame for his goal drought, he needs to contribute more to the build up. I expect so much more from our centre forward.
 

I like Rom, but stuff like this shouldn't be happening to a top level striker.

Morata has one of those as well. Is it up against Smalling and he turns the. Like kicks the ball out in front of him. Kinda agree tho, at this level you’ve kinda got to make these things stick.
 
Not a kneejerk comment after the Chelsea match evidenced by posts in previous threads where some of the lingering concerns with him were voiced: e.g. Ultimately, I think Lukaku is what he is - we knew what we were getting based on the totality of his career. He's probably going to to be a Mario Gómez type player for United as far as the best-case scenario is concerned in terms of his production.
Hoeneß: "We now have alternatives for Mario Gomez. This is a prerequisite for success. He is good - but not very good."
That isn't meant to disparage Lukaku either because Gómez scored 99 goals in his last 3 seasons at Bayern - which was an exceptional statistical target for any striker, particularly the 2012/12 and 2012/13 seasons:





In spite of the goals, Gómez faced criticism because he never quite had or developed the all-round play or compensatory workrate needed to be the leading center forward of an elite club. And it's unlikely that Lukaku is going to show great improvement in those departments at this stage of his career (24½ isn't exactly young - especially for someone who has played 330 club games and 60 national team games). Reckon over the next 2-4 years (timeline is dependent on the evolution of the team - particularly in the Champions League), it'll be a matter of either acquiring or developing (Rashford/Martial) better all-round fits and alternatives - like Bayern did with Mandzukić and Lewandowski in quick succession. Just hope that the decision-makers at United are proactive enough to make the admittedly harsh decision when the time is right because while he's good in terms of the production over the course of a season (especially when he goes on a purple patch) - he's not very good from a broader perspective, and doesn't have the skillset to become very good or a difference maker at the position.
 
Complete tripe today. Couldn’t hold up an old folks home with a machine gun. How is someone so strong, so easily ushered off the ball?!
 
He is not very good at holding the ball up and linking play or bringing others to the game, so if Jose is playing a game of attrition, Lukaku is useless.
 
Another average performance against decent team. He's still young though, and maybe can learn a thing or two when Ibra is back.

You were claiming after just a few games that he'd already improved his first touch, link up play etc. Definitely moved up from his Everton level you said.

Now you're back to criticising those parts of his game and wishing we'd signed Morata.

A perfect demonstration of why you shouldn't judge a player on a game by game basis.
 
Not a kneejerk comment after the Chelsea match evidenced by posts in previous threads where some of the lingering concerns with him were voiced: e.g. Ultimately, I think Lukaku is what he is - we knew what we were getting based on the totality of his career. He's probably going to to be a Mario Gómez type player for United as far as the best-case scenario is concerned in terms of his production.

That isn't meant to disparage Lukaku either because Gómez scored 99 goals in his last 3 seasons at Bayern - which was an exceptional statistical target for any striker, particularly the 2012/12 and 2012/13 seasons:





In spite of the goals, Gómez faced criticism because he never quite had or developed the all-round play or compensatory workrate needed to be the leading center forward of an elite club. And it's unlikely that Lukaku is going to show great improvement in those departments at this stage of his career (24½ isn't exactly young - especially for someone who has played 330 club games and 60 national team games). Reckon over the next 2-4 years (timeline is dependent on the evolution of the team - particularly in the Champions League), it'll be a matter of either acquiring or developing (Rashford/Martial) better all-round fits and alternatives - like Bayern did with Mandzukić and Lewandowski in quick succession. Just hope that the decision-makers at United are proactive enough to make the admittedly harsh decision when the time is right because while he's good in terms of the production over the course of a season (especially when he goes on a purple patch) - he's not very good from a broader perspective, and doesn't have the skillset to become very good or a difference maker at the position.

100% agree
 
Status
Not open for further replies.