francobaresi
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2006
- Messages
- 5,614
It's intended to invite debate, that's the whole point of the thread.
Shit, that's three albums I've commented on already today. I'm staying out of this thread from now on* or I'll waste all my time arguing about music.
* I will examine every single list posted and pass comment
Interesting list franco, supprised at your lack of Floyd, Beatles, Zepp etc, I was expecting them in your list, but fair enough if you haven't heard them enough.
I do take exception at OK being at 47 though
My favourte Zeppelin song is Stairway to Heaven, brilliant song.
feckin hell, you're really stickin yer neck out there pal
RedNome, have you listened to New Order? The band Joy Division became after the singer topped himself. Their work from about 1982-1989 was class and some of the stuff in the 90s and 00s is quite good too. A bit less dark and more poppy than Joy Division, but some very good albums and singles in their back catalogue. Would recommend, they very much influenced the indie scene.
RedNome, have you listened to New Order? The band Joy Division became after the singer topped himself. Their work from about 1982-1989 was class and some of the stuff in the 90s and 00s is quite good too. A bit less dark and more poppy than Joy Division, but some very good albums and singles in their back catalogue. Would recommend, a lot of the bands on your list I think were influenced by them.
do 'im Nomes!!
nothin, sorry, i'm bein a twat
Ah ok, carry on.
Yeah, I'm guilty as charged on the old classics. I owe it to myself to listen to that stuff but never seem to get the chance. I'll add it to my list of NY resolutions (starting with Led Zep and Hendrix). I really can't get into the Floyd though, lord knows I've tried. And I find the Beatles over-rated (sorry... )
And OK Computer?
Yeah....?
I fear for Radioheads overall position in the final list (may have to fudge the results )
Hopefully Spammy will come through for me.
To be honest, I never really listened to it that much, maybe that's why it's so low. I know all the singles so well, and love them, but for whatever reason, I never got into the rest of the album as much.
I'll re-visit it, you have my word. I have over 4 hours a day iPod time at work, so I'll put in some study
There's a lot of Radiohead haters out there tbh mate, that's why I predicted Nirvana would fare better
Moby?
Moby?
The last 3-4 in the list were kinda fillers.
I want to put Superunknown in my list but can't decide what goes.
Have to say I have never liked New Order, Love Joy Division though. I think if I'm honest Ian Curtis was the big draw for me, his vocal sound for me was right up my street, reminded me a bit of Jim Morisson. As you have referenced, I found New Order to Poppy for my liking, have always been attracted more to the darker side of music.
Edit: I should probably give them more of a try than I have if I'm honest, Blue Monday was of course class.
You're not the first person to make that argument. They wrote a bit quite a bit of 'dark' stuff in the early 80s but they did go quite poppy later, lost them a few fans I think.
At the very least you should check out Ceremony and In A Lonely Place, the first songs New Order recorded, which were actually the last songs JD wrote but never recorded. Dark, but brilliant. If you haven't heard them I'll upload them for you when I get in.
Def Leppard goes mate. Get that shit outta there!!
Glad to help
No fecking way, the Lepps stay, that was my favorite band in my early days, and the first gig I went to as well, there's no way that I couldn't have it on my list, it would be dishonest of me.