Why does this matter more for Utd than the other clubs? (I assume you meant fans by the way)
Our players seemed to play better. Other teams thrive of the fans.
Why does this matter more for Utd than the other clubs? (I assume you meant fans by the way)
Not really, it should be group decisions between the scouts, football directors and coaching staff.
Given how things have gone it just seems like it probably would have gone more smoothly if Ralf had some influence on the football director side.
If those players identified are not arnotovic and rabiot, then yes.
Every thread people say we need to forget about the 2nd 3rd stuff. The reason is because most of the nonsense arguments fall apart when you take it into account. Like when people say we can't expect to beat Brighton with mcfred, and I say they were the major midfielders in a 2nd and 3rd place finish .. the response is always 'lets ignore that
So when he fails to, who do you think could? Poch; Jose; Ole?
Just because he’s a good manager doesn’t mean he knows the football market. Ajax players were identified by Ajax. You think he picked out Antony himself? ETH was watching São Paulo regular?
Are you of the belief that no coach on the planet could get the majority or even half of these players playing well?
And I'm not sure I agree with your last sentence. We now have quite a few players who would be underperforming for their fourth manager, if that happens. In my opinion, if we hit the wall now, it's the players taking the rap this time.
People still harping on about that second place failing to see how not having fans in stadiums changed everything. We happened to benefit from it, others didn't. but the reality is football is watched by fans in the stadium and we seem to have become unable to adapt back to that. says pretty much all we need to know about the club at present. At the rate we are going, it could be another 26-year wait for the title... (partly joking)
Why does this matter more for Utd than the other clubs? (I assume you meant fans by the way)
Not sure how many more managers need to fail before the penny drops that these players are operating at around their level.
Having said that, I don't think loads needs to be done to give an instant bump.
A competent goalkeeper immediately makes the back 4 look better. A competent midfield immediately makes the team look better.
But instead, we've so far signed a sub left back, a CB and an attacking midfielder. That's not to say those weren't areas that needed improving, but they shouldn't have been priority in my opinion.
So you think it's possible that a top coach can't get a tune out of an entire squad full of internationals?
Even Solakjaer got the majority of this squad performing well for good stretches. So I find it hard to believe given a few months and maybe one or two more signings that Ten Hag wouldn't be able to improve the majority this team/squad compared to last season.
As a possible signing for Man Utd yes he did.
There's a reason this summer we are only going after players Erik is familiar with, basically right now we don't have a scouting department in place. At least not an experienced one that's had 6-12 months to work on targets that suits Ten Hag's football. And from all reports Erik and Ralf's ideas on recruitment didn't gel.
I get where you are going and agree.Not sure how many more managers need to fail before the penny drops that these players are operating at around their level.
Having said that, I don't think loads needs to be done to give an instant bump.
A competent goalkeeper immediately makes the back 4 look better. A competent midfield immediately makes the team look better.
But instead, we've so far signed a sub left back, a CB and an attacking midfielder. That's not to say those weren't areas that needed improving, but they shouldn't have been priority in my opinion.
Ole. Southgate maybe.Are you of the belief that no coach on the planet could get the majority or even half of these players playing well?
I would love to hear Rangnick speak about his time at United. What he thought his role was going in, how his role was communicated within the club and in particular to players and coaching/backroom staff. When it became clear that the job he wanted to do wasn't the job the club wanted him to do and what happened thereafter.
If he could be convinced to speak out, it would give us all a much clearer idea of who the biggest actors in the club are. Is it the Glazers themselves or just the fools they've put in place? What are the actual goals and objectives of the club?
He did plenty of football talks before taking the United job didn't he? I wonder how much he charges and could enough of us chip in to hire him to speak in front of a camera for an hour or two.
Yeah I clearly meant from São Paulo to Ajax which you conveniently overlooked.
From reports… Ralf has been doing this for years. I’m very sure if they had a conversation Ralf was smart enough to identify players that matched ETH’s profile. Right now we are bringing up names such as Arnautovic.
This will never happen.
Rangnick would have agreed to an NDA as part of his severance package. He has no incentive for breaking that NDA. He's now coach of Austria and Man Utd is a closed chapter for him. Just like Rangnick is a closed chapter for Man Utd.
He wasn't a good coach. But he's shown time and time again that he knows how to build a football club. His opinions on the players should have been listened to. He was fecking right about them. But that would have been proper expensive wouldn't it.
In the present, Rangnick is only relevant for us when assessing whether his consultancy could have been a value add.
We all know he failed as an interim head coach, the table doesn't lie. The continued point of discussing Rangnick is whether we think this summer would have gone differently with more input from him. Seeing how its panned out, I can't help but feel we'd have done better than we have with him helping us raid the Red Bull group for players.
Nothing in what you said convinces me that we should expect ETH to be hammered at home by Brighton or come 7th in the league. You aren't going to win this argument since that is what it is about. You can win strawman arguments if you like. But try to convince me that we should be getting hammered at home by BrightonThat argument is invalid because it's incredible reductive.
17-18 finished 2nd with 81 points. First place was 100. 19 points behind.
18-19 finished 6th with 66 points. First place was 98. 32 point behind.
19-20 finished 3rd, but again with 66 points, meaning there was no improvement, but competition got worse. First place was 99. 33 points behind.
20-21 finished 2nd with 74 points. First place was 86. 12 points behind. Also, Liverpool significantly underperformed that season.
21-22 finished 6th with 58 points, the worst points tally in PL history.
The team was never in shout of a title and neither previous season points tally was enough to come even close to winning the title the next season. The improvement at best was 8 points over the previous season. Not mention that direct rivals Chelsea, City, and Liverpool have actually managed to win either the PL or the CL during that period. Meanwhile, all our squad managed was to lose the EL to Villareal.
You can jump through all the hoops and mental gymnastics, but reality is what it is - the players we have had and continue to have are low quality despite an occasional good performance.
The players in the stand argument is a nothing argument. Every clubwas in the same boat. It's just an emotional Gary Neville parrotThe reason people tell you to ignore it is because the teams around us where in much worse shape that season, and no players in the stands. Its a nothing argument.
You dont get top 4 with this team anymore. Its simple as that.
They haven't downed tools, they're just mentally shot and have zero belief anymore. That's why a complete overhaul was needed, but the penny pinchers at the top got delusions of grandeur that Ten Hag could somehow wave a magic wand over them. Reality has already hit home and now we're trying to panic buy.Ralf got them playing for half a game, ETH got them playing for a couple of friendlies, this lot have downed tools again, weak mentally and physically.
No he didn't. Our football under Ole was on the whole pretty dire and was never going to be sustainable and ETH is never getting anything out of this group because Rashford is finished, Bruno inexplicably has become a complete liability for us and you never know what youre going to get with De Gea and Shaw.These 4 played a massive part in getting us top 4 finishes. Football is a team game. When relying on individuals it's eventually going to fall apart and here we are today.So you think it's possible that a top coach can't get a tune out of an entire squad full of internationals?
Even Solakjaer got the majority of this squad performing well for good stretches. So I find it hard to believe given a few months and maybe one or two more signings that Ten Hag wouldn't be able to improve the majority this team/squad compared to last season.
United wasn't hammered. It ended 2:1 and United wasn't the worse team in the second half. The problem isn't that this type of performances can happen. Its that it happened at least 30-40 times during the last 4 seasons against teams that are midtable at best.. When things go well in the second half, the team can easily pick up a point or even three (not that this would have been deserved). Ole was the comeback king, because the team barely played for two halfs.Nothing in what you said convinces me that we should expect ETH to be hammered at home by Brighton or come 7th in the league. You aren't going to win this argument since that is what it is about. You can win strawman arguments if you like. But try to convince me that we should be getting hammered at home by Brighton
The reason people tell you to ignore it is because the teams around us where in much worse shape that season, and no players in the stands. Its a nothing argument.
You dont get top 4 with this team anymore. Its simple as that.
The players in the stand argument is a nothing argument. Every clubwas in the same boat. It's just an emotional Gary Neville parrot
I know what you are saying. But people are saying we should EXPECT to lose to Brighton because of mctominay Maguire etc. That is what I am saying is childish waffleUnited wasn't hammered. It ended 2:1 and United wasn't the worse team in the second half. The problem isn't that this type of performances can happen. Its that it happened at least 30-40 times during the last 4 seasons against teams that are midtable at best.. When things go well in the second half, the team can easily pick up a point or even three (not that this would have been deserved). Ole was the comeback king, because the team barely played for two halfs.
No he didn't. Our football under Ole was on the whole pretty dire and was never going to be sustainable and ETH is never getting anything out of this group because Rashford is finished, Bruno inexplicably has become a complete liability for us and you never know what youre going to get with De Gea and Shaw.These 4 played a massive part in getting us top 4 finishes. Football is a team game. When relying on individuals it's eventually going to fall apart and here we are today.
The most important cogs in the wheel are in midfield. Do you honestly think we have the players there to even push for top 4 when the parts i mentioned are falling apart? ETH may be one of the potentially best managers out there but he can't work miracles. Both Klopp and Pep ripped up their respective squads in a very short period of time because even they couldn't get blood out of a stone so what makes you think ETH is any different?
Rashford is much worse because Ole basically run him into the ground. Bruno is much worse because we're trying to move away from the Stoke style of play adopted by Ole which suited Brunos style of play and actually move us into the 21st century. Shaw and De Gea upped their game when Telles and Henderson were brought in but how long before they move back into their comfort zone?Yes he did. As you yourself appear to argue when you point to the players who were massive in getting us to the top 4. Under OGS. But who are much worse now.
Rashford is much worse because Ole basically run him into the ground. Bruno is much worse because we're trying to move away from the Stoke style of play adopted by Ole which suited Brunos style of play and actually move us into the 21st century. Shaw and De Gea upped their game when Telles and Henderson were brought in but how long before they move back into their comfort zone?
Ole basically let the players do what they wanted because they knew they'd never be called out and were almost guaranteed starting time however their form which is why when the players were actually forced to act like professionals the weak mentality that was instilled has came to the forefront and once again, here we are today.
I agree. We shouldn't expect to be beaten by Brighton at home thoughNot at all. Roy Keane was talking about the issue after the Brighton disaster. our players are extremely weak mentally. Hence why the pressure of the crowds actually damages our players, whereas other teams thrive of it. Our squad is, quite frankly, not a squad that will ever challenge for the title in a normal season.
I agree. We shouldn't expect to be beaten by Brighton at home though
No I agree we shouldnt. But I worry that without significant upgrades to several of the players this will keep happening, regardless of manager.
100%. Some of us need to take the red tinted shades off. Brighton would not swap players like Caicedo for players like Fred. They just wouldn't. West Ham wouldn't want Fred and McTominay to replace Rice and Soucek, Leicester wouldn't want them for Ndidi and Tielemans, Wolves wouldn't want them for Neves and Moutinho, Southampton wouldn't want them for Romeu and Ward-Prowse. The list goes on.
Its all well and good saying Man Utd should be able to beat Brighton. However, in key areas, teams that are solidly midtable are better than us. They have better options than us. That should set off alarm bells for our supporters.
I didn't go into yesterday's game expecting an easy win. I thought we might scrape it. However, the gap (if there is one) between us and most Premier League teams is the smallest its been since the Premier League was founded. So we can't just turn up like the big swinging proverbial and expect to beat Brighton.
We needed, this summer, to take a long hard look at where we are. Be humble about the mistakes that we have made. Then take steps to start fixing them. Rangnick was right, we did need up to 10 new players. When you see what Spurs have done, what PSG is doing, it wasn't beyond the pale to get them either. We did not need to buy 10 Neymars. Campos has fixed PSG's midfield for more or less what we spent on Martinez.
Had we spent smart not big we could've really set Ten Hag up for success. Instead we have ended up where Man Utd have so often ended up since Sir Alex retired: Scrambling around at the end of the window looking at who we could get. Rather than having identified who is best for us before the window even opens, having the deals lined up, and making sure our key areas were strengthened before preseason began.
We are lightyears behind the best clubs in how they're run and, the saddest part is, the people in the club don't even understand that. They brief journalists that its unfair about how our transfer window is being written about. They honestly don't understand why they're doing a bad job. Rangnick's consultancy may have filled that gap, given them someone independent who could hold up a mirror. However, when he started doing it, the truth hurt too much so they chucked him out.
Honest to God I'm scared for the Liverpool game. This could be another humiliation after seeing them put 9 past us last season. If, as I fear, the Scousers absolutely slaughter us. Murtough and everyone involved in ending Rangnick's consultancy should be out and we should get a new hierarchy in place that can support the manager ahead of the winter window.
We should be upgrading the squad, but the manager shouldn't have us mid table in the mean time with the players we have. The result yesterday is on the manager, because we have the players to not lose to a weakened Brighton at home. I think ETH would agree with this, he isn't a self serving character like Ralf was, he will take responsibility for the team and that will help over timeNo I agree we shouldnt. But I worry that without significant upgrades to several of the players this will keep happening, regardless of manager.
Yeah I clearly meant from São Paulo to Ajax which you conveniently overlooked.
From reports… Ralf has been doing this for years. I’m very sure if they had a conversation Ralf was smart enough to identify players that matched ETH’s profile. Right now we are bringing up names such as Arnautovic.
We should be upgrading the squad, but the manager shouldn't have us mid table in the mean time with the players we have. The result yesterday is on the manager, because we have the players to not lose to a weakened Brighton at home. I think ETH would agree with this, he isn't a self serving character like Ralf was, he will take responsibility for the team and that will help over time