Suedesi
Full Member
A true American obsessed with money
Makes the world go around
A true American obsessed with money
Makes the world go around
We have some, but I don't think we're sharing!This week, the challenge was not to raise the game but to manage a positive result following the 1st leg.
You're right in the sense that the team never suffers at the domestic level: the team never will never "We would be happy to defend and get a draw. Or we are happy with the draw". The spirit is always to score 3 goals per game at least.
It's not by accident if after beating 4-0 Barcelona, we lost there 1-6 two years ago.
PSG has to recruit world-class psychologists
I like your contributions and involvement on RedCafe but - I'm sorry to say that - this post is total bullshit from A to Z.
If we replay the 2nd leg 100 times with the same 22 players, you lose it 95 times. The 3 goals you scored are just a joke and you struggled to make some consecutive passes. Kehrer made a stupid mistake because he is young and inexperienced, not because he thinks he is the new Thuram... Buffon made a mistake because he is unprofessional?
That said, it's obvious the mindset of some players is not adequate when it comes to handle pressure and manage a positive result in Champions League... nothing to do with "professionalism". The team is not used to maintain/preserve a result because we have no opposition, no domestic challengers. While the humility of the whole team was bad during the 2nd leg against Barcelona, it was not the case this week.
Our squad is fantastic at all levels and - like Chelsea - we will make it at the European level: no doubts about it. We have the perfect coach and we just need some adjustments in the defensive section. I think we need to introduce more grinta in our team: 1-2 players with the mindset of players like Godin, Materrazzi, Paolo Montero, Di Livio...
Congrats once again but the storytelling you propose - generally developed by journalists who have to sell their paper or expertise - is ridiculous and is also a great display of arrogance, ignorance and imagination.
I like your contributions and involvement on RedCafe but - I'm sorry to say that - this post is total bullshit from A to Z.
If we replay the 2nd leg 100 times with the same 22 players, you lose it 95 times. The 3 goals you scored are just a joke and you struggled to make some consecutive passes. Kehrer made a stupid mistake because he is young and inexperienced, not because he thinks he is the new Thuram... Buffon made a mistake because he is unprofessional?
I think you're misinterpreting something: PSG are being laughed at because of the entitlement and arrogance backfiring in a spectacular way against a Manchester United xi who we wouldn't ever field if at full strength. If your side had the focus and professionalism, they would probably have taken us to the cleaners, what I feel you need to look at is why you don't have those traits and from there, you gather a clear picture of why people are saying what they are about the club/team.Very good point and I'm aware of that. And the fact that the club is owned by Arabs doesn't help.
From an historical perspective, PSG reached 5 consecutive times the semi-final of a European competition in the 1990s.
In the last 7 years, PSG reached the QF 3 times: kicked out by Barcelona 3 times, Real Madrid 1 time, City/United/Chelsea 1 time each.
2013
QF: 2-2 at home against Barcelona and 1-1 there >>> we were leading 1-0 at Nou Camp...not far away from a great performance
2014
QF: we won 3-1 at home against Chelsea and lost 0-2 there >>> the team unable to manage a positive result
2015
Last 16: destroyed by Barcelona, but Neymar/Suarez/Messi was unplayable. >>> Barcelona stronger
2016
QF: 2-2 at home against a weak City and we lost there 1-0: the team lacked freshness, inspiration for several reasons.>>> Depressing
2017
Last 16: PSG wins 4-0 at home against Barcelona but lost 6-1 away >>> the team unable to manage a positive result
2018
Last 16: I blame the coach for the starting 11 in the 1st leg against Real Madrid, Neymar injured between the 1st and 2nd leg >>> bad preparation (Lo Celso playing as a #6 for the 1st time of the season at Santiago Bernabeu)
Everybody can laugh at PSG but the club will be rewarded sooner or later.
I mean, the fact they can even present that title says a lot; how many other clubs would generate that kind of headline with it actually being feasible?This from the the Beeb was interesting:
PSG: Football Club or Fashion Brand
https://www.bbc.com/sport/av/football/47462183
You've demonstrated almost everything he was saying. Just in these two lines you're entirely missing the point: you will never have the opportunity to play a game more than once. It doesn't matter if you think you are so much better than the opposition you would win the game 95 times out of 100. Your players had one chance, and they lost. They probably wouldn't have let Barca thrash them 6-1 95 times out of 100 either, but they did it on the night all the same.
String together consecutive passes? Who cares?! You strung together plenty of pointless consecutive passes and it didn't help you one bit. You created embarrassingly few chances and the ones you did create, you couldn't take. We ended up shooting on target exactly the same number of times that you did, in fact. And our strikers did a better job and so did our goalkeeper, hence the scoreline.
Of course Kehrer was not being unprofessional (unlike Dani Alves). But it does surprise me that you act like a team who have a world-class star in every position when Rashford spent the first half walking past your RB as if he wasn't there, over and over and over again. He hasn't had such an easy opposite number all season in the Premier League.
I don't know what your fans/ultras say when your team acts so assured and entitled for no good reason,
I think you're misinterpreting something: PSG are being laughed at because of the entitlement and arrogance backfiring in a spectacular way against a Manchester United xi who we wouldn't ever field if at full strength. If your side had the focus and professionalism, they would probably have taken us to the cleaners, what I feel you need to look at is why you don't have those traits and from there, you gather a clear picture of why people are saying what they are about the club/team.
I don't know what your fans/ultras say when your team acts so assured and entitled for no good reason, but I can only imagine the inquisition if that happened at the clubs who have history of winning the grandest trophy. With Madrid out, and Barcelona looking vulnerable as well as Bayern being a shadow of themselves, the trophy is more up for grabs than it has been in years - your side should have had a razor sharp focus on swooping in, destroying whoever they faced and snatching that trophy if at all possible. The way you came out at OT before the goals is the way you should always be playing in terms of drive and hunger, I can't see how that is refutable as it's the bare minimum all top clubs should demand, and if they then lose, well OK, they tried their hardest, better luck next term.
This is not the impression PSG give and until you have it, I don't see you progressing beyond the QF's unless you get a fortunate draw that doesn't pair you against quality sides that do have that drive.
If this humiliating KO doesn't change something at your club, and even within the team that's there for next season, I really don't know what will.
I mean, the fact they can even present that title says a lot; how many other clubs would generate that kind of headline with it actually being feasible?
First of all, welcome here.
I think there are several forms of respect.
1) Let's take the case of Neymar.
On the one hand, you could argue that he doesn't respect the club/fans by saying "Maybe I will leave, we never know. Everything is possible including joining Madrid...". On the other hand, he is very professional despite appearances and has the killer instinct on the pitch, always trying to make the team score whatever the opposing team. On the pitch or in the training sessions, he respects the club in this way. I do remember players like Okocha and Ronaldinho. I won't say they chose their games but I haven't see a consistent desire to have an impact on the pitch each week and during 90 minutes.
2) The case of Pauleta
I have a great respect for the player and the man. He was surrounded by weak/average players ans is a better player than Choupo-Moting. Pauleta was a top player but Zlatan and Cavani are beasts. Pauleta was much more reliant on his teammates. History will retain Cavani and Zlatan were better scorer but also better football players.
3) PSG before Qatar
Despite having top players and teams in the past, we only 2 times the French league (86/94) so the question is why? My answer is that the players were not ultimate professionals. And a ultimate professional is the greatest mark of respect. Maybe, I'm harsh with previous players but look at Chantôme who unfortunately plays for Red Star now
How is it possible we struggled so much in 07/08 not to be relegated?
4) Former players
We have some former players in the PSG's organization like Camara and Maxwell. Pauleta was a PSG embassador in the past in charge of the detection of Iberia talents in the early 2010s and we saw the result. Leonardo was so great, still gutted he is no longer part of the club.
We don't know if other former PSG players were in the stadium this week, the cameraman will focus on currently newsworthy football personalities.
There is a lot to say about PSG and how serious they are but I have two questions.
Why has Thiago Silva stayed there for so many years? He basically spent his entire prime at PSG.
What were they doing on Wednesday? I understand they wanted to kill the game off but they were going through for the entire 90 minutes until the penalty. All they had to do was sit back and keep the ball. United were the ones who needed the goal. Sit back, wait for United to come out and get the goal they need. Then hit them on the counter.
A Mourinho or Benitez led team would have gone through 99 times out of 100. Those two would have ensured that no one left their own half and stunk out the place to get a result.
Lots of money whilst living in Paris? I can't really think of many better ways to spend your career. Especially since PSG have a few Brazilian internationals who he's likely close with, I guess he's just happy there.
I guess he also genuinely does believe they could/can win a CL, I mean especially when the club is bringing in players like Mbappe and Neymar, why wouldn't he? It's not like the club haven't shown ambition.
Juventus are about to win an 8th straight league title. Yet they do well most times. Until they get to finals but that's another storyTheir league structure leaves them mentally unprepared for the hard graft of Europe.
1) You just point out what's wrong. How can a player say that in public ? Don't care if he puts 5 against Guimgamp or Reims that's just unbelievable.
2) When you have a midfield of Rothen, Cissé or others frankly it's very harsh to judge him that way. Peak Pauleta during the Qatari reign would have been a monster.
3) During the years before the takeover it was Colony Capital so it explains why PSG was so poor (bad presidency + comical recruitement year after year)
4) Regarding former players there was only Bernard Lama.
Regarding the match, you should have look the players, a lot of them were complacent (Mbappé smiling like it's done, Thiago Silva being caught at half time saying "we have nobody in front of us,...).
I think Nasser, despite being a nice guy, took the wrong way, he sould have :
1) Poach all the youth setup in Monaco or Lyon
2) Poach all the good youth players in France and specially in Paris and the suburban
3) Not sign all susperstar (FM style) or player that had a good match againt you (David Luiz)
If he did that it would have provided a great setup for the current team.
Right now it's like watching 11 men playing spanking other teams in L1 but with zero chemistry and fighting spirit when there is adversity.
Look at it this way, if it was Barcelona or Madrid playing, I don't think your players would have made those errors because they would be a lot more focused. However, since they felt they didn't have to be at 100% to go through the tie, they ended up making the costly errors. That's the unprofessional part because in the Champions League, you can't go 95% as though you're playing a Ligue 1 team. You have to be at full concentration when backpassing or making a save, otherwise you might end up getting punished for it.
That's why their league isn't helping, it rarely presents them with scenarios that will be helpful to them in Europe. That's the way i see it anyway
Juventus are about to win an 8th straight league title. Yet they do well most times. Until they get to finals but that's another story
I thinks there's more to this.
Yet you keep forgetting the luck PSG had to even have to play against a severely depleted United which gave you that overwhelming odd in the first place. You forgot to mention that luck in the first half with injuries to both Martial and Lingard which allowed you to set comfortably in the second half because no one could run in behind you defense then you went and won the game comfortably(first half both team were cagey).Luck is part of the game and you should face the truth.
Play the 2nd leg like that against any good teams (including clubs like Lyon) and you lose it easily.
Do you personally know Buffon, Neymar and Alves? No.
I admire your imagination or your super powers.
You mean the same Arsenal that were comfortably beating Renne until they got a man sent off?While Arsenal get schooled by a midtable team from the same league.
Farmers get a bad rap on here. They're good honest folk.
Farmers, donkeys, Mickey Mouse. All terms used for derogatory reasons yet they're all great!
Been reading through this thread. Not one person has claimed thatPSG lost the game because of two schoolboy error and a unfortunate penalty. United didn't really threaten much outside of those three occasions.
Taking this result as a proof that United is a better team than PSG and therefore the French league is shit is a bit much.
PSG lost the game because of two schoolboy error and a unfortunate penalty. United didn't really threaten much outside of those three occasions.
Taking this result as a proof that United B Team is a better team than PSG and therefore the French league is shit is a bit much.
He also hates the Jonas brothers!Mickey Mouse hate Jews.
Yet you keep forgetting the luck PSG had to even have to play against a severely depleted United which gave you that overwhelming odd in the first place. You forgot to mention that luck in the first half with injuries to both Martial and Lingard which allowed you to set comfortably in the second half because no one could run in behind you defense then you went and won the game comfortably(first half both team were cagey).
You forgot to mention the luck which had the referee not send off Kimpempe who went on to score you r first goal.
For some reasons you just erased all those from your memory and you keep harping on about our luck.
Juventus have largely won most of those league titles by significant margins bar one or two seasons.That isn't a straight comparison. Napoli and Roma have provided a challenge to Juventus in recent years. PSG only had Monaco. I also imagine the standard of the average Serie A team is higher than the average Ligue 1 team.
The last time I witnessed PSG as a ''team" was when they faced barca at home before that 6-1. They were up for it, played with passion and looked like they gave a damn about things. Nowadays I look at them they appear as a group of individuals simply made to play together. Billionaire players turning up for games just for the sake of it. This is of course what I feel about them whenever I watch them.Juventus have largely won most of those league titles by significant margins bar one or two seasons.
I think PSG thought they had this game won before they even played. I contrast this to 2014 when we played Bayern. We were an awful side coached by an incompetent buffoon but Bayern went into that tie and actually showed us respect.
Someone gave a great example of Chelsea. Both PSG and Chelsea are money clubs but they seem distinctly different.. Chelsea's struggle to win in Europe were largely bad luck at late stages of the tournament. Phantom Luis Garcia goals, John Terry slips and a 'disgrace' of a referee. This PSG side are worlds away from that Chelsea side.
It still feels like Juve isn't destroying or dismantling teams as easy PSG can in their respective leagues.Juventus have largely won most of those league titles by significant margins bar one or two seasons.
I think PSG thought they had this game won before they even played. I contrast this to 2014 when we played Bayern. We were an awful side coached by an incompetent buffoon but Bayern went into that tie and actually showed us respect.
Someone gave a great example of Chelsea. Both PSG and Chelsea are money clubs but they seem distinctly different.. Chelsea's struggle to win in Europe were largely bad luck at late stages of the tournament. Phantom Luis Garcia goals, John Terry slips and a 'disgrace' of a referee. This PSG side are worlds away from that Chelsea side.
This is true, but at the same time he's been at PSG for 7 years now. I guess I just expected him to get bored of playing in France by now.
My opinion tooEh?
It helps when you got competition.
It helped Bayern when Dortmund were a real force under Klopp. They reached two champions league finals. When Dortmund dropped off the league was over early and they didn’t really have much intensity in the final half of the season.
Without Wenger pushing us, I don’t think we win the treble in 1999. They pushed us to be better. Same with Chelsea in 08.
You need teams in your league to push you. Winning it by 20 or whatever points is not really great. I’m not knocking the other teams, but they simple can’t compete.
My opinion too
+
Bastian Schweinsteiger's brother Tobias (Co-Commentator on DAZN Germany + he was a youth coach at Bayern Munich) has said a few weeks ago that he knows from Bastian that one factor for Bayern Munich's CL elimations was that they didn't have the 100% tension in April/May because they weren't challenged in the Bundesliga since months......to have a important game every 3-4 days in the 2012-2013 season was important not just at the games but also in training.
Yeah and in 2008 we had this great title battle with Chelsea.It’s why I think we after 99 struggled to build on it.
99/00 and 00/01 the league was far too easy for us. By the time Arsenal started to wake up in 01/02 our team started to age a bit and we sold our best defender.