Renegade
Full Member
- Joined
- Nov 11, 2009
- Messages
- 5,394
Unacceptable decision. I’m raging.
How so?Mediocrity being rewarded, another reason why we don't compete for the big trophies anymore, also points to another frugal summer ahead in the transfer window.
How so?
We're likely getting rid of Rojo, possibly Bailly too, that leaves 3 CB's. Plenty of room for a 4th.
Also people seem to be forgetting that Woodward was willing to shed out something like £100m on Varane last summer if Real played ball.
Maybe too long a deal but im still pro it. People forget a squad is needed. Jones isn't going to be number 1 or 2 but is a very competent sub, one of the best replacement centre halves in the league. Given his smalling and Bailly injury record we need 5 anyway
No he isn't though, a player who's injured half of his career at a club cannot be called a 'solid squad option' even if he's just a 'squad option'. Those two cannot go together. He's fecking injury prone beyond belief, nevermind his constant 'Jones moments'.
Yes that is indeed a better argument. The problem lies having too many squad options.That's a much better argument than saying because he's an EPL winner. From the club's pov, it's obviously sensible. But over the last years, he's even struggled to be a reliable squad option.
Meh it’s obvious that Rojo is the one who’ll be moved on this summer.
You don't think we've seen enough from Lindelof this season for him to be a top defender? I certainly have.Yes that is indeed a better argument. The problem lies having too many squad options.
Jones
Smalling
Bailly
Young
Dalot
Rojo
Lindelof
There's not one top class defender among those unless we see drastic upturn in fortunes for one of them before the end of the season. That's the issue. Too many options. We need either one or two to elevate their game or their replacement.
Thing with Jones is inuries used to be his problem. Nowadays even when he's fit he looks a bit of a mess.If rather give young the 4 year then Jones. The man left Harry frickin Kane wide open 4 times ! He's an idiot.
Top defender ? Nope. He's certainly started looking solid. But there's a difference between solid/dependable and brilliant. Hope he turns out to be the latter bit right now he's gone from average to good.You don't think we've seen enough from Lindelof this season for him to be a top defender? I certainly have.
Phil Jones is 26...how? I was sure he was nearing 30.
How so?
We're likely getting rid of Rojo, possibly Bailly too, that leaves 3 CB's. Plenty of room for a 4th.
Also people seem to be forgetting that Woodward was willing to shed out something like £100m on Varane last summer if Real played ball.
He is here for about 8 or 9 years now. Can his fans name at least one season where he was consinstently good throughout the season?
Fellaini signed a contract last year and was sold this january.
Maybe?
So is Bailly. Jones has put in more good performances for us than Bailly has.Bailly is a far better option then jones. Ffs hes all over the place
Fellaini signed a contract last year and was sold this january.
Maybe?
Jones
Pogba
Lukaku
Rashford
Smalling
Grant
Lingard
Pereira
Young
Shaw
Mensah
McTominay
Tuanzebe
Yeah me too.I was really hoping we'd be getting rid of him soon.
I think "good" is a bit harsh, he's been somewhere in the middle of good/really good for me. Still, he has shown a pretty remarkable improvement since his first season here, I do think he has the traits to be a very good, if not top class, CB. It would also help if he had a better partner than Jones or Bailly. Hell, even Smalling alongside him.Top defender ? Nope. He's certainly started looking solid. But there's a difference between solid/dependable and brilliant. Hope he turns out to be the latter bit right now he's gone from average to good.