Paul Pogba | Undergoing Medical | Helping out the Laundry Ladies

Do you want Pogba for £100 million?


  • Total voters
    1,968
But it's the Spanish banks that give them the favourable terms. No other football clubs do this because no other clubs can leverage the preferential treatment that Real get from the Spanish banks. Even with our revenue we can't get the terms that they get.

But it doesn't mean that they can only have loans from Spanish banks, it just means that they will have normal deals with the others. I mean, it's simple to understand.

Edit: And Real Madrid can afford those normal deals.
 
This 'saga' is causing too many petty arguments. The levels of frustration and impatience on here atm are unreal.

It doesn't help when a good portion of posters say it's a done deal and it was wrapped up weeks ago when there are reports of Madrid coming in to it.

I think it's safe to say the caf is in a meltdown.
 
Cant believe this is still on going, i would wait to they confirm the Higuain deal and then say heres our final offer and you have 48 hours, dont believe they will be funding that deal without the Pogba sale, if they dont want the deal then lets move on and get someone else in.
They won't "confirm the Higuain deal" without the Pogba deal being signed!!! Why does no one else understand this!!??? :wenger:
 
They won't "confirm the Higuain deal" without the Pogba deal being signed!!! Why does no one else understand this!!??? :wenger:

why coz you have said so ?

considering its been reported hes had a medical and should be wrapped up within the next 24 hours i cant see the Pogba deal being done by then can you ?
 
.
This 'saga' is causing too many petty arguments. The levels of frustration and impatience on here atm are unreal.

It doesn't help when a good portion of posters say it's a done deal and it was wrapped up weeks ago when there are reports of Madrid coming in to it.

I think it's safe to say the caf is in a meltdown.

Feck I knew it!

its off isn't it :(
 
Ok. Pogba is a very good player. Is he worth this money? I don't think so. If Juv is dragging their feet over this deal, I would move on. With the price quoted, we can buy 2-3 player of similar level e.g. RW, CB and MF. Stop wasting time and get it done else move on.
 
They won't "confirm the Higuain deal" without the Pogba deal being signed!!! Why does no one else understand this!!??? :wenger:

That's most likely the reason why Higuain isn't expected at Juventus until next monday.
Can't imagine that it would take them that long to activate the release clause (considering that it is due to expire if i reckon correctly) and since the've already agreed personal terms with the player and performed his medical they're now just waiting for the end of Pogba negotiations.

May it be one way or another, Juve will have an interest in solving this situation as soon as possible in order to allow their team a valid pre-season.
 
But it doesn't mean that they can only have loans from Spanish banks, it just means that they will have normal deals with the others. I mean, it's simple to understand.

Edit: And Real Madrid can afford those normal deals.
I would disagree because it's all related to the club balance sheet understanding by the bank and those do not translate well in a financial statements for football clubs. This is why a local bank would be more inclined to deal with you. Right now, with all the capital and liquidity regulations, no bank would be interested in doing a deal to help a club, let's not fool ourselves here. Either you raise cash yourself or you have "bad" terms. And I simply believe Real is not ready to have those bad terms. Again I am waiting to see the next big transfer for Madrid, with no player sale before. It might not happen anytime soon.
 
Ok. Pogba is a very good player. Is he worth this money? I don't think so. If Juv is dragging their feet over this deal, I would move on. With the price quoted, we can buy 2-3 player of similar level e.g. RW, CB and MF. Stop wasting time and get it done else move on.

I am sure Woodward and Mourinho know if the Pogba deal is on or not. Just because they haven't informed us muppets yet doesn't mean we aren't getting him.
 
Why would Real need political support to get a loan?

They are a cash generating business, with multiple international recognised brands and growing revenues - they would get a loan quicker than you and I could borrow some cash from our best mates.

Moreover, I'm pretty sure they won't even need a loan to finance this Pogba deal. They just don't need/want to pay Juve this tremendous fee + pay Raiolas cut as they are not in need for Pogba. So they're playing hardball like they always do and hope that the player will force a move, thus, enhancing their negotiation power.


I'm not sure this is right. It's been reported, e.g. Swiss Ramble, that Barcelona relied on political intervention to guarantee their bank loans (effectively, Barca did not meet the terms of repayment on existing debt, however political influence has meant this issue has been overlooked by banks). So there is precedent that political intervention occurs in regards to Spanish football debt.

There have also been reports about political interventions to enable Real to take out loans to fund the Bale acquisition, e.g. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/fo...gated-for-illegal-state-backing-say-MEPs.html. I don't know what the outcome of the investigation mentioned in this report was, or whether it is even concluded, but the report suggests that Real lack sufficient assets, or even promises of future income (which have already been used to guarantee other loans, according to Swiss Ramble), against which to guarantee significant new debt.

There have also been recent reports about the state aid given to Real by way of land deals: http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-16-2401_en.htm. So not specifically about helping to support them to guarantee new loans, but it is another example of political support aiding Spanish clubs financially.


I would say that all football clubs seem to use smoke and mirrors to distort their financial positions, so it's very difficult to say one way or the other. But the evidence over the past few years, not all of which I have listed here, and I'm not also not including the specific story @Gasolin mentioned about a current investigation into political influence over banks with regards Real Madrid loans (I don't know anything about that), suggests that Real don't have much borrowing ability remaining, and already rely on political intervention to guarantee existing debt, never-mind future debt.
 
Ok. Pogba is a very good player. Is he worth this money? I don't think so. If Juv is dragging their feet over this deal, I would move on. With the price quoted, we can buy 2-3 player of similar level e.g. RW, CB and MF. Stop wasting time and get it done else move on.
Everybody has said this but which MF of similar quality/potential could we acquire, while still having money left over to spend on a quality cb and RW?
 
why coz you have said so ?

considering its been reported hes had a medical and should be wrapped up within the next 24 hours i cant see the Pogba deal being done by then can you ?
Because they are not stupid. They can't afford to buy Higuain without selling Pogba therefore if they buy Higuain first they lose all negotiating power on closing the Pogba deal, either to us or whoever. If the Higuain deal is confirmed then that means that the Pogba deal (to us or whoever) is also done, whether it's been announced or not. IMO.
 
Ok. Pogba is a very good player. Is he worth this money? I don't think so. If Juv is dragging their feet over this deal, I would move on. With the price quoted, we can buy 2-3 player of similar level e.g. RW, CB and MF. Stop wasting time and get it done else move on.
I put an article from a French magazine that explains why the valuation is still rationale.
 
Can people stop spouting the shite that he doesn't want to come back here and we are forcing him. If Pogba comes here then it's because he believes we are a huge club with a very enticing project spearheaded by the best manager in football. If he had the option to go to Madrid I think he might choose them but that option doesn't exist and he clearly would prefer to play for Utd over Juve which is a big statement in itself. In terms of him leaving down the line, if Utd get back to winning ways on the pitch in the next couple of years, players like Pogba won't be going anywhere.

I hear what you are saying.
But since the Di Maria affair, I think many on here have on their minds that we may get an absolute top class attacker (in FiFA XI) team, who joins us because Madrid don't want him.
Then a year later, he gets himself a transfer to another team.
Also, because Madrid have taken Ronaldo (previously) and attempted to take DDG (and failed because of a FAX machine error), many on here are scared of Madrid.

Pogba may well arrive this season, but what if he gets a better offer next season to go to another team?
 
I agree! Maybe I have to much time in the sun.

Regarding topic I hope Mourinho prefers a 433 formation with Pogg in the front of our midfield. I don't like this 4231 formation with Roo in the middle, makes me uncomfortable.

Rooney is playing in the middle, get used to it.
 
I would disagree because it's all related to the club balance sheet understanding by the bank and those do not translate well in a financial statements for football clubs. This is why a local bank would be more inclined to deal with you. Right now, with all the capital and liquidity regulations, no bank would be interested in doing a deal to help a club, let's not fool ourselves here. Either you raise cash yourself or you have "bad" terms. And I simply believe Real is not ready to have those bad terms. Again I am waiting to see the next big transfer for Madrid, with no player sale before. It might not happen anytime soon.

They are always going to sell players because they have a limited amount of players registrable, so you will wait forever.
 
"Pogba's worth"

"If it doesn't happen in X number of days it's off"

There is no point arguing about SUBJECTIVE BS. We have no control over the club.
 
"Pogba's worth"

"If it doesn't happen in X number of days it's off"

There is no point arguing about SUBJECTIVE BS. We have no control over the club.

That's the only purpose of a forum.
 
Would it be enough though? Obviously LVG was poor at getting much out of Schneiderlin, but that's no excuse for not being able to pass from A to B across the pitch. I don't think he'll ever be good enough for our starting 11.

Last season I felt that Morgan was invisible for most games.
The term "silent domination" was mentioned, but I don't particularly like players who barely touch the ball and who go through a 90 minute game, without putting themselves about.
At Southampton he was in a 6th place team (I think). And last season we finished 5th. So maybe Morgan's level is not at the very top. Maybe it is in a top 5/6 placed team.

He is tall and athletic, which is exactly how Jose likes his midfielders to be. We shall wait and see what Jose does with him.
On the subject of midfielders: Bastian, for me, was never invisible and is definitely good enough to play in a title/CL winning side. But, his problem is his poor injury record over the last few years.
 
On the subject of midfielders: Bastian, for me, was never invisible and is definitely good enough to play in a title/CL winning side. But, his problem is his poor injury record over the last few years.

He slowed our play down too much, whether that was intentional on orders from LVG or whether its because he's not up to the cut and thrust pace of the PL is another debate
 
It's like Groundhog Day, it really is. We should have just signed a few Joe Allens for £60m, that would have kept our RedCafe accountants happy.

In the absence of any updates yesterday, in the Independent they published an article that was about the articles that journalists had written about this story :wenger:
 
I have a muppet feeling that we will have some news by tonight on Pogba. Ed's back. Mino's chilling. Marotta actually went to his office last night. Hoping he got Ed's fax.
 
I can't see Pogba being announced before Higuain is. Juve have been posturing for a while, so to appease their fans, they'd surely have to sign Higuain first.
 
Agreed.

Pogba left because he couldn't get in the team. He has a point to prove, has family in the area, friends who he played with from a young age, he's going to triple his wages alongside all of the other benefits of playing for one of the globes biggest clubs under arguably the best manager of his era with a project that's designed to make this club one of the most competitive in Europe again! Not only all of that but United backtracking proved him right all along and he will undoubtedly be the highest profile player in the team and possibly the face of United for years to come.

At Madrid he's just another galactico who isn't guaranteed a starting place who it has been widely reported don't rate him as highly as we do anyway.

I know what decision I would make, United fan or not.
This is great. Hope it's been sold to him like this!!!
 
The only media attempting to report that there's problems with negotiations are the Spanish press..which should tell you something.
The only thing paralysed about all this is the media coverage due to the delay of the announcement.
 
I can't see Pogba being announced before Higuain is. Juve have been posturing for a while, so to appease their fans, they'd surely have to sign Higuain first.

Or release the bombshell of Pogba leaving first, and then immediately calm the hysteria by announcing Higuain after. Not sure they want their last bit of business to be their star player leaving.
 
starting to piss me off , coming here, going to Madrid, if he wants to come here just sign already, if he really wants to go to Madrid , let him go.
If he is swayed by a phone call from ZZ, do we really want a player that wants to play for Madrid ?
Also Raiola's €25m commission, FFS wish I was a football agent , seems like money for old rope.

Having followed this thread for weeks without posting, my own view is that however fantastic a player is and however much he'd improve us, we should only pursue him if we're his number 1 choice. If there's any doubt about that, I'd rather the club didn't continue the chase.

Exactly.... If the reports about him waiting for Madrid are true, then we should just forget about him and move to our next targets. We shouldn't sign a player who's heart lies with another club. Even if we sign him this summer, what guarantee do we have that he won't be forcing for a move to Madrid next summer. I am not sure about him staying with us for more than 2-3 years, especially him having Raiola as his agent. He is 23 now and he is not even near world class at the moment. The reason why we are paying a crazy crazy amount of money for him is because he has the potential to develop into a world class player. But even if he does fulfill his potentials and become a world class player, it will take at least 2-3 years for him to reach his prime. And by then, he and his agent will be all over us forcing a move to Real. So, what is the point of buying him for such an absurd amount when we know that the players heart lies with another club and most probably will leave us sooner or later?

And what if he fails to fulfill his potentials and never reaches the heights we are expecting? Then we over paid a huge sum of 80 millions on an average/above average player. Yes, i know that every signings has it's own risks and nobody knows about the future. But when you are spending an absurd sum of 120-140 million on a single player, you better make sure that he really wants to join you and he will stay with you for a very long time. In case of Pogba, if we are signing him for the reported amount, we should get his service for at least 5-6 years.

In short, after going through all these reports, i won't be disappointed if we don't get Pogba. I would rather prefer us to sign Kroos (70m) and Matuidi (30m) OR James (60m) and Matuidi (30m) plus another CB (30-40m) and we are good to go.
 
Everybody has said this but which MF of similar quality/potential could we acquire, while still having money left over to spend on a quality cb and RW?

Just a quick example:

30-35m for Matuidi (CM - box-to-box)
20-25m for Fabinho (RB)
40-50m for Mahrez, Yannick Ferreira Carrasco (release clause at about €40m) etc. (Winger)
5-15m for a decent and experienced back-up CB (maybe Williams from the Swans?)

That's only a quick example but it clearly shows that there're possibilities to split the Pogba money on more signings, thus, enhancing our squad as a whole way more.
Nevertheless, I'd prefer signing Pogba and then selling a bunch of our deadwood (Rojo, Young, Basti, Fellaini, Jones) to fund the acquisition of a decent CB and maybe another back-up signing - I simply doubt that we will land Pogba though. Hopefully Woody and Mou prove me wrong...
 
For the millionth time, we don't need another 4 or 5 "decent" players to pad out the squad, we need a huge signing of a proper world class (or semi-world class) player to elevate the whole squad.

People seem to think signing about 8 players in a summer is a good idea to build a team with :wenger: We'll spend about 6 chaotic months trying to blend them together and just end up being too far behind anyway.