Paul Pogba | Undergoing Medical | Helping out the Laundry Ladies

Do you want Pogba for £100 million?


  • Total voters
    1,968
Why are we acting like this is a done deal, I haven't read or heard anything concrete in the media.

Am I missing something?

Not a done deal, but the Di Marzio tweet has taken muppet sentiment to extremely bullish levels.
 
Ye, he'll perform like shit and Real will want to sign him, sure.
Who said Real would sign him? He may flatter to deceive, we may get impatient and get rid. Not inconceivable. Wouldn't be any shortage of takers for him after a couple of seasons underperforming and a cut price deal stop being a clown.
 
Mkhitaryan will be wide right or 10 I think can't see him playing any where else tbh also what do you have to do round here to get more than 3 posts a day on here ? the Caf is oppressing my muppetry and it's just not right :D
Put your shift in newbie!
 
There isnt a journalist more reliable than him today. And everyone does get it wrong from time to time but he doesnt make mistakes as often as the other journalists do.

You are thinking about someone else (Tancredi maybe?), Di Marzio has been very accurate with his transfer info from the past two seasons.

Ahh I think it was Tancredi, remember it being an Italian journo.

So you're saying my cock should be well and truly out?
 
I dont think he meant the CDM position behind Pogba when he meant do we have the personnel "behind" Pogba.

Why can't Carrick or Schneiderlin be partner with Pogba? We had Carrick - Schools partnership and it worked brilliant. Kroos - Schweinsteiger against Italy worked fine. Pogba is also considered to be a player with a good work rate and willing to do defensive contribution.
Jose's team in Madrid didn't have a type of Makelele. Neither Busquest and Rakitic are type of Makelele style.
 
Why can't Carrick or Schneiderlin be partner with Pogba? We had Carrick - Schools partnership and it worked brilliant. Kroos - Schweinsteiger against Italy worked fine. Pogba is also considered to be a player with a good work rate and willing to do defensive contribution.
Jose's team in Madrid didn't have a type of Makelele. Neither Busquest and Realistic are type of Makelele style.
I never said they cant play behind Pogba.
 
Mkhitaryan will be wide right or 10 I think can't see him playing any where else tbh also what do you have to do round here to get more than 3 posts a day on here ? the Caf is oppressing my muppetry and it's just not right :D
Yes, you are right about Mkhitaryan. But if there is an utmost need & the push comes to shove, he has the skill set to play there & has already done so for Dortmund.

Well, you have to make quality posts to earn some likes from the Mods/Scouts & that would increase you posting power in the mains. You can earn likes in the Newbie forum too, so if you run out of posts in mains, keep trying in the Newbie section and write some informational posts & you would earn the likes in no time.
 
Di Marzio is fairly reliable as compared to other journalists. However these things happen very fast and are unpredictable. I still remember SAF telling us fans in my local supporters club that Gazza was basically a done deal and he would sign him up once he returns to Manchester. We're talking of SAF here and not journalists.

If Real decides to match our fee then we're back to square one.
 
genuine quistion, does ManUtd of now have the right personnel who can stay behind Pogba for him to shine?

Right now NO, But that's something Jose is trying to put right, and we only have to look at the quality he has added this Summer. What we have right now plus Pogba would make us an instant challenger for the league IMO.
 
I can understand the concerns about the cost. It IS a bonkers amount of money.

Baffled by the people who think he is overrated and not what we need though. He would easily be the best midfielder in the league.
 
You are not joking, are you? I am thinking hardman kind like Makelele is those needed behind him.

Why can't Carrick or Schneiderlin be partner with Pogba? We had Carrick - Schools partnership and it worked brilliant. Kroos - Schweinsteiger against Italy worked fine. Pogba is also considered to be a player with a good work rate and willing to do defensive contribution.
Jose's Real Madrid didn't have a type of Makelele. Neither Busquest and Rakitic are type of Makelele style.
 
Who said Real would sign him? He may flatter to deceive, we may get impatient and get rid. Not inconceivable. Wouldn't be any shortage of takers for him after a couple of seasons underperforming and a cut price deal stop being a clown.
Wum.
 
Why can't Carrick or Schneiderlin be partner with Pogba? We had Carrick - Schools partnership and it worked brilliant. Kroos - Schweinsteiger against Italy worked fine. Pogba is also considered to be a player with a good work rate and willing to do defensive contribution.
Jose's Real Madrid didn't have a type of Makelele. Neither Busquest and Rakitic are type of Makelele style.
Base on the "analysis" of the fans here on Pogba, his best attributes are his attacking. In order to release that, isn't it best to have someone supporting him doing all the dirty jobs?
 
I keep thinking of that amount of money - it's insane - and getting worried. What if he breaks his leg? What if he's shit?

Then I think, it's Paul fecking Pogba, and everything's okay again.
 
Best hope for tonight: France lose, he scores two own-goals and gets sent off. I don't even want to think about where this story goes if he Travellers his cruciate ligament during a slide tackle in the sending-off incident.
 
For sure it is a crazy fee but it depends how you value his worth.

As a player Pogba is not worth €120m, far from it. But he is at a very high level and he is exactly what our midfield is crying out for, the fee would in part reflect his potential to get even better considering he's only 23. Also it would have to factor in his marketability and lastly it's a statement of intent.

I agree

Was it anymore crazy on the money Moyes spent on mata and fellaini? if united have the money and they want that player, lets just get him
 
He had Suarez, Iniesta and Rakitic to play with.

Brazil are a shambles of a team. He is their star man but he is not carrying them to glory.

Yep - clearly you don't rate Neymar enough or don't watch regularly.

He also said that Juve don't want to sell, or are we just forgetting that part.

At a third of their revenues, id be shocked if Juve decided against the price.

Ronaldo, Bale and Neymar were young players who were bought as long term investments.

Pogba isn't going to stick around for more than about 3 years. You can't look at him as an investment. His playing timeframe is going to be like we're buying a 29 year old, albeit one who still lacks experience and discipline. We're also buying at the top of the market. I can only see prices going down from here, a bit like they did after the Zidane transfer fee a few years ago.

If Pogba wants to leave in 3 years time like you are assuming, would we not get at least half the price back? and if we do, isn't that the same as buying a midfielder in his late 20's who would have little resell value? Not to mention, there is literally no-one like Pogba around.

Pogba's price valuation is probably made up of the following factors;
  1. How much is he worth as a player with his current abilities?
  2. How much is he worth as a player when fully developed?
  3. How marketable is he?
  4. How important is he to Juves team?
  5. How important is he to Jose's plans, is there an alternative with similar skill set?
Stick numbers in those factors and see if you don't come close to a 100m valuation.
 
He also said that Juve don't want to sell, or are we just forgetting that part.

Of course they don't want to sell. Doesn't mean that they won't sell though does it?
If we have reached an agreement with Pogba & his agent they can demand he be sold.
 
Base on the "analysis" of the fans here on Pogba, his best attributes are his attacking. In order to release that, isn't it best to have someone supporting him doing all the dirty jobs?

I guess there is no point to talk this even further if you haven't watch Pogba with your own eyes.
 


Juventus are adamant that the 23-year-old Frenchman, who has a contract with the Turin club until 2019, is not for sale and will do everything in their power to keep him. They recently offered Pogba a new contract, which would extend his deal for a further two years and increase his wages from €5m to €7m a year.

However, José Mourinho hopes United will meet the player’s demands of €15.6m a year in an attempt to move ahead of Real in the chase for the player. That may still not be enough to ensure Pogba returns to Old Trafford, unless United can find an agreement with Juventus.


feck talk about blowing an offer out of the water
 
Why can't Carrick or Schneiderlin be partner with Pogba? We had Carrick - Schools partnership and it worked brilliant. Kroos - Schweinsteiger against Italy worked fine. Pogba is also considered to be a player with a good work rate and willing to do defensive contribution.
Jose's Real Madrid didn't have a type of Makelele. Neither Busquest and Rakitic are type of Makelele style.
Base on the "analysis" of the fans here on Pogba, his best attributes are his attacking. In order to release that, isn't it best to have someone supporting him doing all the dirty jobs?
I think Schneiderlin can be that man. While Pogba is more of an "attacking" 8, and Schneiderlin is more of a "defensive" 8, I think that pair could be good for us.
 
The money doesn't bother me in the slightest. It's not my money and its all relative in football. 30 million, 50 million, 80 million is all a hell of a lot of money. The cost / benefit analysis of signing Pogba given he reaches his expectations, and even including his wages, is going to make it worthy.

My problem is the principle of the whole matter. TBH I thought more people be it United or ABU fans would be talking about how ridiculous it would be to release a player only to resign them a few years after for a world record fee. It truly does make us look silly as an institution.

Having said that, I will not be complaining if we do sign him. If he does produce the form he is capable of I honestly believe he can elevate us to one of the best teams in Europe.
 
Moneymaking scheme:

1) Become a football agent.
2) Sign up TFM, Rashford, CBJ and any other young United player at danger of not playing under Jose
3) Let them run out their contracts then broker deals to good European clubs
4) Take a cut
5) Watch them become worldies
6) Sell back to United for massive profit
7) Take another cut
8) Sell on to Real a few years later
9) Take another cut
10) Go back to United's youth team and plunder the next generation

Either that or take over Juventus and generate even bigger profits
 
I try my best to forget we should already have him for free (or whatever peanuts we paid him)

But I suppose you have to put that aside and realise what he's turned into while at Juventus.

If we buy him for 80-100m then he's either going to stay with us and have a fantastic career or we are going to sell him on for a fortune after hopefully winning a few trophies with us. I don't see him failing as a player is my point.
 
I know signing Pogba would be drool worthy and all... But how do "statements of intent" actually help us? Are they really what might turn other targets' heads toward Utd, or something that would get us another noodle sponsor?
 
Better make him sign a 7 year deal or something. Would be a pisstake if he walks out on a free in 5 years in his prime
The situation in which he left the club was perfectly justified, as a youngster not getting game time and has proven the correct decision too.

It's a tad melodramatic to suggest he'd do it again after paying a world record fee and building a team around him.
 
My problem is the principle of the whole matter. TBH I thought more people be it United or ABU fans would be talking about how ridiculous it would be to release a player only to resign them a few years after for a world record fee. It truly does make us look silly as an institution.
But why does this matter?
 
Moneymaking scheme:

1) Become a football agent.
2) Sign up TFM, Rashford, CBJ and any other young United player at danger of not playing under Jose
3) Let them run out their contracts then broker deals to good European clubs
4) Take a cut
5) Watch them become worldies
6) Sell back to United for massive profit
7) Take another cut
8) Sell on to Real a few years later
9) Take another cut
10) Go back to United's youth team and plunder the next generation

Either that or take over Juventus and generate even bigger profits

Annoyingly, you now have to be a licenced lawyer to be able to be a football agent. Quite a bit of effort.
 
I know signing Pogba would be drool worthy and all... But how do "statements of intent" actually help us? Are they really what might turn other targets' heads toward Utd, or something that would get us another noodle sponsor?

It's easier to keep your best players if you bring in top players who can help you be successful. There is no given, but you stand a better chance of success with better players. It's that simple.
 
It's easier to keep your best players if you bring in top players who can help you be successful.

And quality attracts quality. Take Mkhitaryan's "Mourinho is building an incredible team" comments upon signing for us. I expect it was the club that asked him to say that to send a message out to potential signings but it works all the same.