I don't understand the hostility on this board toward advanced metrics and their deep analysis. It's bizarre. If "goals and assists" were enough to gage a fraction of a player's contributions, than why count passes, runs, tackles, duels, dribbles, etc.?
Step out of the dark ages and join the enlightened.
MAJESTIC
I can't stop repeating myself about his ease of executing skills to beat players. So easy for him.
Who the feck makes a video like this and decides to cut all the clips short so you can't see whether the pass actually finds its man? Disgusting.
That's true, but it's sort of similar to tripping yourself up on the finish line.I know right..but hey, still a good effort from him to watch the whole 90 minutes, cut it, put music, escape copy rights and upload it on youtube just hours after the game.
I thought he would have walked into our midfield in '16, right after the final in Milan why asking me? I might be the only madridista in the world who genuinely wanted us to sign him and was pissed off to see us give up without a fightSome still think he wouldn't get into Madrid's midfield @giorno ?
Powerful but with flair, and an eye for final pass. He's like DDG, which I feel very honored to watch them playing for United.
How about thinking this way instead: if let's say Stephen Ireland, and not say Martial, would have received "the pass" from Pogba, would he have scored?
ToureThere's simply not another player like him in world football. It's rare to find someone with his level of technique, vision and athleticism rolled into one.
So the problem with xG and xA is that people don't understand them.
Take Martial's goal tonight for example. It's a very low xG chance, because xG is taking the success rate of every shot from that position. How many of those shots do you think were as good a chance Pogba put on for Martial?
Pogba is a bit of a unique player, he gets into unusual positions and plays passes that totally catch the opposition off guard. For a player who just fires in crosses from the win (which isn't what KdB does fwiw) they will stick one up for a close range header that will be 0.7 xG, Pogba will play 2 weird passes to set up players for chances that by position alone are xG 0.3, but because of the timing and quality of the pass are effectively 0.5xG chances. The xG will say 0.7 vs 0.6 when in actuality it's probably closer to 0.7 vs 1.0.
Pogba is probably over-performing in terms of assists right now, but expected stats are not good at such in depth analysis of extreme players.
The media will underrate him because he hasn't put in consistently good performances against big teams, a lot of the times he's denied of space and pressed, he looks half the player.
The media will underrate him because he hasn't put in consistently good performances against big teams, a lot of the times he's denied of space and pressed, he looks half the player.
Maybe 15 years ago. There are trawlers who turn quicker than Yaya does these days.Toure
The main problem with xG and xA is that they’re a load of bollox. Massively open to misinterpretation (as you’ve illustrated nicely above) but come with a sheen of quasi-scientific quackery that makes people read far too much into them. Almost all stats in football are fundamentally flawed and these add nothing useful to the party.
I love this fact!Pogba is top of the league in assists right?
Its not. Scholes was named the satellite and Ronaldo said Scholes could hit trees from 70 yards on the training ground.I don't know about controlling a game. But his long range passing is a touch above Scholes. I really believe that and I know that's some praise.
difficult to say really. to be better, he'll need to be one of the best ever which is a stretch.He's as talented as Zidane was. And one day he'll be better player.
yes it certainly is. For me its the strongest part of his game. much better than his long range shootingHis passing is unbelievable at times.
Its neither. Cesc Fabregas has been the best long passer for 10 years.There aren't many better long range passers than him at the moment. It's between him and De Bruyne in the Premier League, I can't think of any other that come close.
got a big shoutHe’s going to be the best midlfielder in the world. Just hope we can keep hold of him.
I have to disagree. Zidane's dribbling skills were also dazzling from his youth days. When his manager saw him as a kid, he said how he was just dribbling past all the opposition. Also as strong as Pogba is, I remember Zidane being a powerhouse. The likes of Scholes and Keane even could not get him off the ball as he was a real physical specimen with big thighs. the final difference was that aggression. Pogba is the atypical modern day player compared to the 90's and 80's lot. Zidane grew up experiencing racism due to his Algerian heritage and it made him carry a feeling of resentment which translated into aggression on the pitch. He has been sent off over a dozen times in his career, sometimes due to violent stamps and that brutality shows he is unlikely to get bullied by rough opponents. Again, when we played Real, I recall Figo and Zidane shrugging off our players and being unphased by their aggression. Ad that to their technical prowess and we just had no answers. Its a good feature to have especially if you play in England.In terms of god-given abilities, he is perhaps, probably, likely ahead of Zidane, nevermind midfielders from this generation.
His problem so far is that he has not played in a team that's able to fully showcase said abilitiew.
Its neither. Cesc Fabregas has been the best long passer for 10 years.
It's not nonsense, but it only shows a broad picture. It's good to highlight some tendencies, but obviously not ideal in, say, player to player comparisonxG and xA, what a load of nonsense
Can't be bothered when people say this. Just take solace in knowing if he's as good as we say he is, he will prove the doubters wrong in time. There was also a solid period when people believed Ronaldo couldn't perform in big gamesThe media will underrate him because he hasn't put in consistently good performances against big teams, a lot of the times he's denied of space and pressed, he looks half the player.
Yeah we were getting frustrated by this as well. He will pull off a fabulous pass, and rather than surge forward in support he’ll jog around looking pleased with himself.Absolute class against a crap away side last night.
However he seems to be the 1st to take his foot off the pedal and start showboating. It then seems to Cath in to the rest of the team and as Maureen said...it all gets slow.
I disagree. Pogba has that Scholes-esque zip on his long passes that Fabregas doesn't have.
I think you have a good point in that Martial's goal should have a higher xG. Because the attack is a fast transition. But it's not enough to explain the xA-difference between De Bruyne and Pogba.So the problem with xG and xA is that people don't understand them.
Take Martial's goal tonight for example. It's a very low xG chance, because xG is taking the success rate of every shot from that position. How many of those shots do you think were as good a chance Pogba put on for Martial?
Pogba is a bit of a unique player, he gets into unusual positions and plays passes that totally catch the opposition off guard. For a player who just fires in crosses from the win (which isn't what KdB does fwiw) they will stick one up for a close range header that will be 0.7 xG, Pogba will play 2 weird passes to set up players for chances that by position alone are xG 0.3, but because of the timing and quality of the pass are effectively 0.5xG chances. The xG will say 0.7 vs 0.6 when in actuality it's probably closer to 0.7 vs 1.0.
Pogba is probably over-performing in terms of assists right now, but expected stats are not good at such in depth analysis of extreme players.
Agree to disagree then.I disagree, Fabregas has the panashe on his long passes.....this could go on a while.
@Rockets Redglare
@Rossa
I have already mentioned that Sterling have a high G/xG ratio and that this have helped De Bruyne getting a "free" assist. I did that in the post in which I introduced the statistics.
I disagree, Fabregas has the panashe on his long passes.....this could go on a while.
Pogba's long range passing is more Gerrardesque mixed with say Xabi Alonso in terms of style.. its very flat, but spectacular.. his accuracy however isn't as 100% as a Pirlo/Scholes but he has a greater range/types of pass than possibly anyone in the game and the fact he's ambidextrous.. he's a special special talent.
Through ball wise, he's not on KDB level IMO.. not as precise, decision-making not as good. Cesc is better in terms of decision making too, and through balls short and long - he is superior. Switching the play, Pogba is the best in the world IMO.. hits them out to either flank and with zip.
Has it in his locker to be best overall passer in the game but he'd need to up his consistency and accuracy. Short game would also have to come on alot. For me KDB is best all-round passer in the game at the moment (outside of Messi).