A dismal start that he got them to 4-2 with. One of which was a loss against a randomly super hot Vikings defence. He wasn't even 'bad', I'm not sure why it's something to be held against him. The mid season part where they were trying to figure it out with everyone breaking down was the dismal part, and even then he went 320ave 12-3 TD-INT, rushed for 160 yards with a pretty massive average, while the defence was allowing a whopping 37pts on average.....just to compare that, none of others even allowed 33 or more in a single game, yet alone a 4 game span averaging 37.
Mind you outside of those 4 losses, neither did he, but once that was shored up....it allowed him to flourish with only comeback king Jordy supporting him in a big way really.
I'd allow any of Ryan, Brady or Zeke to win though. It's nice to have a open MVP race really. Really is. But even as a Bears fan, I can't help but admire Rodgers, always have, since his Favre backup days, in terms of short term form that he's produced at times, theres no one better, but it's only longevity and durability that will cost him getting close to the mammoth stuff Brady and Manning put up over 20 years.