He had 12 interceptions in 3.5 seasons and ~300 tackles.
Made the pro bowl in his 3rd season in the league and even in his last season (interrupted by injury) he was excellent.
He isn't simply a case of he died young...so absence makes him greater than he was....
And yes, he had some issues - but he didn't commit murder or beat his wife.
As for the punter - he decided to run with the football and it was a clean hit. A hit the punter and no one else had any issues with...seeing as he got back up, went looking for Taylor and congratulated him for the hit.