Next permanent manager | Poll updated

Who should be the next permanent manager?

  • Luis Enrique

    Votes: 113 7.4%
  • Erik ten Hag

    Votes: 1,300 84.7%
  • Julen Lopetegui

    Votes: 10 0.7%
  • Mauricio Pochettino

    Votes: 79 5.1%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 32 2.1%

  • Total voters
    1,534
Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you a United supporter?

I am. But I support no one blindly. The club is acting like a bunch of amateurs.

When you're a manager with Conte's pedigree you're either wanted or you're not. You don't sit and wait while someone decides if you're got enough for him.
 
We quite clearly tried desperately to land Conte but he turned us down. He was likely holding out for the Spurs job knowing Nuno was on his way out.
 
Why is this thread necessary? Exactly the same as countless other threads.
No it’s not, try reading it again.

….but thank you for your well constructed thoughtful contribution.
 
Then most likely Ole will get fired? Is Conte the only manager in the world or something?
He is the undisputedly the best manager available at the moment. Zidane is also available but wouldnt consider us and doesnt have a record of delivering trophies at different teams
 
Revan are you really using Chelsea as an example on how a clubs transfer policy is run. They have how many players on loan every year? They always sell well because they have had a system set up for a long time and we have only just started with a DoF. They buy well and they sell well, of course not every transfer works out but a lot more of those have than ours have post Fergie.

Well, yeah. Your point was that he hasn't been backed as much as Chelsea managers, which I think was a false point, considering the money he has spent.

Here is a list of first teamers bought or loaned under Lampard/Tuchel

Mendy
Werner
Havertz
Ziyech
Niguez
Silva
Pulisic
Lukaku
Chilwell.

And here is one of Ole: Maguire, AWB, James, Bruno, DVB, Telles, Ronaldo, Cavani, Varane, Sancho, and a few expensive teenagers he does not play.

That was added to a squad already containing

Kante,
Kovacic
Jorginho
Kepa
Azpilecueta
Alonso
Mount

while Ole had a squad that had finished above Chelsea the season he took it. Containing back then the best GK in the world, Pogba, promising talents like Rashford and Martial to name a few.

They had a proper base to build on. Ole didnt have that. The amount spent by united or the net spend is a bad argument to use
because the club always gets fleeced for players with the odd exception. Chelsea have had a system in place for years and years
that allows them to perform better in the market. Liverpool have it too and City well they can spend what they want.

Even without taking into account the net spent (cause Chelsea sell one million players per year), Ole still spent more than Chelsea managers in his time, as I mentioned in my other post. It was not significantly more, like it is the case with the net spent, but it was still more.

My original point was more about the players bought in rather than the money spent. We have wasted so much money on shite
and finished players that its been a running joke. All of you who criticise Ole can surely at least admit he is attracting better players.,
My issue has been he doesnt get the players he needs in quicker to catch up with everyone else.

Ole is far from blameless but people do not want to give him any credit for the team building he is doing until the control of the Glazers.

I do not think that Ole has bough well. 450m euros spent, I would expect much more than this. 80m for Magure or 55m for AWB, are hardly money spent well. Where are the Robinsons, Salahs or Fabinhos under Ole, players who were not yet mainstream and who performed very well. That is what I think is spent well, what Klopp did, build a top squad under a very constraint budget. What Ole did, was going for the most obvious choices, and overpaying for them. And in case of Sancho, then not playing him.

At best, he has been OK/decent in the transfer market. Which is still better than his predecessors, to be fair.
 
I’m pretty surprised Rodgers is viewed so negatively around this forum. Liverpool connection apart, of course.

I think he’d be a very clever appointment for you guys at the end of the season. His teams always play very nice football and he seems to maximize the qualities of all his players. Also a very good eye in the transfer market and doesn’t need superstars to do well.

If in an alternative universe Tuchel had to step down tomorrow I’d have no problem taking Rodgers at Chelsea.
They’ve been pretty shite this season, and he’s bottled top 4 two seasons running before that. He’s an alright to good level manager, yeah, but he’s so far from what our competitors have managing them.
 
For me Ten Hag is the obvious candidate but I would still sack Ole in the international break regardless if we can get him immediately or at the end of the season.

Rodgers I don't really understand, bottled it at Liverpool, bottles it each season now on missing top 4 from strong positions and has started this season poorly.

Don't really see why the board love Poch either, another manager who hasn't won anything meaningful. I also don't think his football is that good to watch but may be on my own there.
 
Are people thinking we’ll go after him during the international break if these next 2 games go tits up or wait till the end of the season and then try?

I think as long as Ole doesn't get battered by City he is safe. A draw in Italy and losing by fewer than 2 goals to City and I think he will have the season.

Completely disagree, he should be well out the door but I just don't think the club have the will to do it. I also see how strongly GNev, promotes him getting the season and I'm convinced he has inside info.
 
I think as long as Ole doesn't get battered by City he is safe. A draw in Italy and losing by fewer than 2 goals to City and I think he will have the season.

Completely disagree, he should be well out the door but I just don't think the club have the will to do it. I also see how strongly GNev, promotes him getting the season and I'm convinced he has inside info.

I think that he is already safe and had always been
 
I do not think that Ole has bough well. 450m euros spent, I would expect much more than this. 80m for Magure or 55m for AWB, are hardly money spent well. Where are the Robinsons, Salahs or Fabinhos under Ole,
Ronaldo, Cavani and Varane aint bad.
 
I support Manchester United not this or that manager. I suspect you would talk differently if Ole wasn't a fellow Norwegian

But your title is literally "used to support", so you're saying that you don't anymore. Which is it?
 
It's too late. If the board wanted Conte, they should have sacked Ole last week. There was zero reason to wait. It's not like Ole has only been here a short time. He's had plenty and we've seen what his team looks like. I wouldn't blame Conte for signing for Spurs and not waiting for us to do what needs to be done.

We're screwed now. There is nobody else available that we can get. The names people talk about already have jobs, and highly likely won't leave them. We may as well stick with Ole until the end of the season and get rid then.
 
Why does it bother you what I say? I'm allowed to express my opinion and if we already have a thread discussing something, why do we need another one.
Dude chill. Just ignore the threads that make no sense to you. No use bellyaching about something you can't control. As a fellow supporter of this frustrating club that should be something we're used to by now. ;)
 
Because there's a good chance we won't make top 4 under Ole... and we can't afford to waste an entire season that will set us back years missing out on CL football.
You really can't think that Conte's appointment or somebodies either is going to guarantee Top 4.
 
You really can't think that Conte's appointment or somebodies either is going to guarantee Top 4.
Nothing is garaunteed. All you can do is give yourself the best chance possible.

If we had a competent manager to start the season, it would be absolutely unthinkable that we'd finish outside the top 4 with the players we have.
 
Nothing is garaunteed. All you can do is give yourself the best chance possible.

If we had a competent manager to start the season, it would be absolutely unthinkable that we'd finish outside the top 4 with the players we have.
Maybe you are right but both City, Chelsea and the Dippers are pretty strong so we can certainly say that all those teams predict a top 4 finish for themselves. If we are to assume that our season is going to be that bad because of Ole it is safe to assume that we just need to be better than Arsenal, West Ham or Spurs. And we don't have City's or Chelsea's squad just the first 11
 
It's one of Rodgers Potter Poch and Ten Hag. But if we sack Ole mid season it's only between Potter and Rodgers since Poch and Ten Hag won't be available till end of the season.
I'd go with Potter ahead of Rodgers if we sack Ole soon. Rodgers Is currently underperforming and appointing a Liverpool reject while they have arguably the best manager in the world just doesn't sit well with me. With Potter at least he's still an unknown entity at top level and hes got potential. If he fails we can sack him end of the season and go for Ten Hag or Poch
 
It's one of Rodgers Potter Poch and Ten Hag. But if we sack Ole mid season it's only between Potter and Rodgers since Poch and Ten Hag won't be available till end of the season.
I'd go with Potter ahead of Rodgers if we sack Ole soon. Rodgers Is currently underperforming and appointing a Liverpool reject while they have arguably the best manager in the world just doesn't sit well with me. With Potter at least he's still an unknown entity at top level and hes got potential. If he fails we can sack him end of the season and go for Ten Hag or Poch
We will get a caretaker if Ole leaves before the end of the season

Conte was the only one I think we’d have considered as a permanent appointment before May
 
Spurs fans are happy now but in 18 months they will again be looking for a manager. While we'll still have Ole.

(Oh God! )
 
I am reading that the reason Ole is still here, is because Woodward does not want the end of his reign to be negative. If this is true, Ole will be here for the rest of the season, protected in cotton wool.

A team that is 2 points behind us, a manager that has just had 17 opportunities to prove himself, a club that has not won a trophey in years, has shown 100 times more ambition than United. Within a day they made a decision to sack him and are planning to hire Conte.

It's becoming pointless supporting this club with this board in charge. The question is not even about our manager, its about what our vision is. The sooner Ed goes, the better. Absolute shambles we are, another year written off.

Yeah I feel exactly the same way as you because there is no forward planning at this club, at least if we showed some guts and announced the new guy mid season like City did with Pep then could feel some sense of optimism. Sadly that won't be happening because this club are too worried about hurting an ex players feelings and will hold back.
 
I think it's about time for this. So, who do you want to take over from Solskjaer?

The bar isn't very high, to be honest. At this point, I would almost accept anyone who has made their team actually play as a team.

The managers who have actually impressed me the most in the Premier League are Potter, Hassenhutl, Ancelloti, and Rodgers. I think these managers have shown the correct ability that can transfer to a club like ours, creating excellent team play out of lesser players (more so for Hassenhutl and Potter). They have shown that their players can play incisive football with a quick interplay that we are sorely lacking.

There is the obvious choice of Pochettino (who probably will takeover if Solskjaer is sacked), but I am actually leaning towards Hassenhutl.

The obvious choice for the recovery is that just put out there by Harry Redknapp the other day. Add Roy Keane to the coaching staff. Not fire Ole and make him manager. Roy would never accept that. We have a poor situation in midfield, and we're not strong at the captain position. Forget Potter, whoever that is, forget Hassenhutl and all that lot above. In our greatest period, we had the best midfielder in the world, and the best captain in any sport on earth. He is still there, and it boggles the mind that it took this long for someone to see the answer right under our noses.

Roy may seem harsh and frightening to lesser players, but does anyone seriously think Ronaldo, and Fernandez and Varane wouldn't want him in the dressing room and in the technical area? What winner doesn't want a winner beside them? Roy Keane on the coaching staff is the answer. Ollie has said many times that if he had choices, Roy Keane would have been the first player every time on the team sheet. Now he has the choice. Make it.
 
Last edited:
Well now that Conte is gone, I do hope we try some exciting young managers .There isn't any world class managers available. Just go crazy and get some hipster.

Ten Hag, Hassenhuttl, Potter , Amorim, Gallardo, Rose, Rodgers.
 
I’m pretty surprised Rodgers is viewed so negatively around this forum. Liverpool connection apart, of course.

I think he’d be a very clever appointment for you guys at the end of the season. His teams always play very nice football and he seems to maximize the qualities of all his players. Also a very good eye in the transfer market and doesn’t need superstars to do well.

If in an alternative universe Tuchel had to step down tomorrow I’d have no problem taking Rodgers at Chelsea.
Forget his Liverpool connection. What exactly has he achieved to be considered? Genuine question? Has been bottling top 4 for sometime now. People would say that Leicester aren't a top 4 team but the other competitors were so bad those years and he could have actually sealed it. Won FA cup ? . Means nothing , Martinez also has one.
 
Well now that Conte is gone, I do hope we try some exciting young managers .There isn't any world class managers available. Just go crazy and get some hipster.

Ten Hag, Hassenhuttl, Potter , Amorim, Gallardo, Rose, Rodgers.

I am going to try and treat the rest of this season like the second half of that god awful 15/16 under LVG, maybe one day we will get a manager we can all get onside with but right now not feeling any optimism of that happening soon
 
I am going to try and treat the rest of this season like the second half of that god awful 15/16 under LVG, maybe one day we will get a manager we can all get onside with but right now not feeling any optimism of that happening soon
Very true. The weirdest feeling that you love your club more than anything and very well know that we will challenge all the teams in the league under a semi decent manager. Yet, having to witness the slow death over the course of season with false dawns every 5 matches.
 
Very true. The weirdest feeling that you love your club more than anything and very well know that we will challenge all the teams in the league under a semi decent manager. Yet, having to witness the slow death over the course of season with false dawns every 5 matches.

Yeah that's exactly how I feel and still to this day have no clue how LVG survived December 2015
 
Status
Not open for further replies.