Next Draft - Ideas and Discussions

@The Stain A suggestion. Rather than having the usual 3 rounds per turn, cut it down to two. Get a Sheep in R1, you just have one more turn to get it right. Far quicker and potentially lot more sheep :devil:

:lol: i'll keep that in mind.

3 rounds also mean more players blocked, which is also a good thing in the long run.

2 rounds could be frustrating because it could lead to 4/5 sheeps per team.
 
P-Nut0712
2. Moby
3. Enigma_87
4. Raees
5. Chesterlestreet
6. Downcast
7. Skizzo/Annah
8. Joga Bontio
9. Sjor
10. Invictus
11. Gio
12. harms
13. EAP
14. DavidG
15. Tuppet
16. Oneniltothearse

Interested:
1. Mazhar
2. Boris
 
You can take my place
Thanks for the offer, but I honestly don't want to take someone's spot if they are more interested than I am. If you are not to keen on playing this draft, then I'm okay with taking your spot.
 
Thanks for the offer, but I honestly don't want to take someone's spot if they are more interested than I am. If you are not to keen on playing this draft, then I'm okay with taking your spot.
Yeah, take it - I'm not disinterested but I lack certain enthusiasm at the moment, especially towards the games themselves
 
The pace of this draft is so slow.

Yeah, take it - I'm not disinterested but I lack certain enthusiasm at the moment, especially towards the games themselves

No longer interested in the games in which we can demonstrate that 11 x > 11 y because (x1 + x2 + x5) > (y1+y2 +y6) and x4 scored more goals that (y8 + y9)? :devil:
 
Oh... missed it, I thought you guys were going for those ultra complicated drafts. :(
 
Just a thought. If more guys want to play it would be possible if instead of normal matches you just get a voting card to determine the winner. Basically send in your top 5 and i'll count it up. Quick, easy and you can move on to the next draft quickly.
 
Just a thought. If more guys want to play it would be possible if instead of normal matches you just get a voting card to determine the winner. Basically send in your top 5 and i'll count it up. Quick, easy and you can move on to the next draft quickly.
thumbup.gif
 
Just a thought. If more guys want to play it would be possible if instead of normal matches you just get a voting card to determine the winner. Basically send in your top 5 and i'll count it up. Quick, easy and you can move on to the next draft quickly.

Matches.

I'd propose to have all R1 matches in a single thread. Just 8 posts with teamsheets only. No discussions, no debates. People can just vote in a standard Format

Match 1 - Manager A vs Manager B - Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 2 - Manager C vs Manager D - Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 3 - Manager E vs Manager F - Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
.
.
.

Maybe we can have discussions from Semi's onwards!
 
Last edited:
Matches.

I'd propose to have all matches in a single thread. Just 8 posts with teamsheets only. No discussions, no debates. People can just vote in a standard Format

Match 1 - Manager A vs Manager B: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager C vs Manager D: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager E vs Manager F: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
.
.
.

Maybe we can have discussions from Semi's onwards!

I like that idea. Some sort of interaction/match up while keeping it simple and new.
 
Matches.

I'd propose to have all R1 matches in a single thread. Just 8 posts with teamsheets only. No discussions, no debates. People can just vote in a standard Format

Match 1 - Manager A vs Manager B: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager C vs Manager D: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager E vs Manager F: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
.
.
.

Maybe we can have discussions from Semi's onwards!
Was going to suggest that. One thread for all R1 games.
 
Matches.

I'd propose to have all R1 matches in a single thread. Just 8 posts with teamsheets only. No discussions, no debates. People can just vote in a standard Format

Match 1 - Manager A vs Manager B: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager C vs Manager D: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
Match 1 - Manager E vs Manager F: Winner Vote: <Insert Manager Name>
.
.
.

Maybe we can have discussions from Semi's onwards!
With 32 managers it would be 16 games of course. Could repeat the concept until the semi's. Standard format as in just sending all your winners to us?
 
With 32 managers it would be 16 games of course. Could repeat the concept until the semi's. Standard format as in just sending all your winners to us?

I doubt you'd get 32 managers. You'll get stuck around early 20s max imo. Keep it to 16.

Voters will use the standard format (something like the one I posted above, draft mod can refine and finalize) to post in the thread. You can total up after maybe 12 hrs (instead of 24) and announce all R1 results in one go.
 
sheep draft with 32 managers would be epic:lol: lets try it!
 
Very easy to get 32 managers IMO

If we have less than 32 players, always possible to find a way to select the best 16 teams.
 
Very easy to get 32 managers IMO

If we have less than 32 players, always possible to find a way to select the best 16 teams.

yeah id reckon we could easily get to the 30 mark....18 of us now, separate the usual partnerships and you are close to the 25, shadow wankers step out of the shadow and few older regulars in @Cal? , @Balu etc. join the party train and are we are there :drool:
 
A sheep draft would be an absolute mare with 32 managers. You'd be lucky to squeak Djemba Djemba through at that rate, let alone a great.
 
I can easily see us going to 32 if all of the AM's/scouts actually become managers.the simple first few rounds with just straight matchups should also help bring in newer faces.

Why not try it out? @The Stain
 
A sheep draft would be an absolute mare with 32 managers. You'd be lucky to squeak Djemba Djemba through at that rate, let alone a great.

One free round and then let the massacre begin :D Maybe add one more round as well so we have 4 picks per round...
 
A sheep draft would be an absolute mare with 32 managers. You'd be lucky to squeak Djemba Djemba through at that rate, let alone a great.
So we can call the next draft a "Mare Draft" and award "mares" instead...

I'll get my coat
 
One free round and then let the massacre begin :D Maybe add one more round as well so we have 4 picks per round...

I don't mind expanding the number of managers to 32 but I don't think a sheep draft would be the ideal format to implement it but am open to anything.
 
Let's just cut it off at 20 teams. Me and Antohan will remove the worst teams for R1 or if you prefer we'll do byes.

Definitely using EAP's suggestion at least for R1, maybe for the quarters too if you're game for that.
 
Let's just cut it off at 20 teams. Me and Antohan will remove the worst teams for R1 or if you prefer we'll do byes.

Definitely using EAP's suggestion at least for R1, maybe for the quarters too if you're game for that.

What's the first criterion?
 
It'd not be fair to the teams if it's just based on your or anto's vote. If you allow them to draft, you need to permit them a match.

Indeed, it could raise discontent...

For the round 1, if we have 24 managers, we can imagine 8 games: 3 teams per game and a poll to select the worst team :devil:

Up to The Stain/Anto to choose the rules.
 
Last edited: