Moyes So Far!

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet, still, toughest early schedule we've had in how long? Things are obviously not going well but there's quite a bit of overreacting happening here. It was always going to be a rough ride.

No reason to compare him to Hodgson. Hodgson had a shit squad and was immediately set upon by the Liverpool faithful who thought the team should win the league. He was also still on target to keep the team in 7th when he was dismissed. It's apples and oranges.

Moyes has made positive changes. Dropping Young, Valencia and Rio and bringing in better players.

The problem remains what it has been for three years. We have one capable CM. Should be better when Cleverly gets back but he attempted to remove Felliani and push Jones up into that position. It didn't work. Jones ended up being responsible for the goal and Felliani, if anything, is good at defending set pieces. Most worrying is that Felliani fell apart when pressured. So, his poor form could get worse as other teams see this. Rooney and Felliani lost the ball in dangerous places way to often.

I hope we won't see Giggs anymore. There is no reason. I hope he's in the Young Rio category for Moyes now. He is taking note and he is making changes. If people can't see this game wasn't a step up, I don't know what they will see. We hit the post twice. Could have easily been a blowout.

But we are now in a place where teams will no longer fear us. Particularly at the end of the game. We are Mike Tyson after he was beaten. It's a different situation for the players.

All we need now is for Moyes to bite some fecker's ear off.
 
And yet, still, toughest early schedule we've had in how long? Things are obviously not going well but there's quite a bit of overreacting happening here. It was always going to be a rough ride.

No reason to compare him to Hodgson. Hodgson had a shit squad and was immediately set upon by the Liverpool faithful who thought the team should win the league. He was also still on target to keep the team in 7th when he was dismissed. It's apples and oranges.

Moyes has made positive changes. Dropping Young, Valencia and Rio and bringing in better players.

The problem remains what it has been for three years. We have one capable CM. Should be better when Cleverly gets back but he attempted to remove Felliani and push Jones up into that position. It didn't work. Jones ended up being responsible for the goal and Felliani, if anything, is good at defending set pieces. Most worrying is that Felliani fell apart when pressured. So, his poor form could get worse as other teams see this. Rooney and Felliani lost the ball in dangerous places way to often.

I hope we won't see Giggs anymore. There is no reason. I hope he's in the Young Rio category for Moyes now. He is taking note and he is making changes. If people can't see this game wasn't a step up, I don't know what they will see. We hit the post twice. Could have easily been a blowout.

But we are now in a place where teams will no longer fear us. Particularly at the end of the game. We are Mike Tyson after he was beaten. It's a different situation for the players.

:lol: It doesn't matter how many threads you say that in, it's still not true.

But generally, you're right. It's unfair to compare him to Hodgson at this stage. The two situations aren't remotely similar.
 
Jesus Christ. Let's all celebrate for hitting the post twice against the mighty Southampton. How can't these simpletons see how good we are?


Yeah, way to stay calm.

I watched a team that was better than they were against West Brom. Improvement game to game is okay with me. People here have gone from screaming about the starting line up to screaming about substitutions. That's improvement.

We were never going to come storming out of the gates with a new coach and a glaring hole in the midfield.
 
It was a joke. I thought they were trying to take the piss out of Barca with that low of a bid.

The biggest joke was that they kept on going back as if increasing the bids by £2-3 million a time was clever or going to work. For the serious powers of European football it must've looked like some kind of comedy.

And yet, still, toughest early schedule we've had in how long? Things are obviously not going well but there's quite a bit of overreacting happening here. It was always going to be a rough ride.

No reason to compare him to Hodgson. Hodgson had a shit squad and was immediately set upon by the Liverpool faithful who thought the team should win the league. He was also still on target to keep the team in 7th when he was dismissed. It's apples and oranges.

Moyes has made positive changes. Dropping Young, Valencia and Rio and bringing in better players.

The problem remains what it has been for three years. We have one capable CM. Should be better when Cleverly gets back but he attempted to remove Felliani and push Jones up into that position. It didn't work. Jones ended up being responsible for the goal and Felliani, if anything, is good at defending set pieces. Most worrying is that Felliani fell apart when pressured. So, his poor form could get worse as other teams see this. Rooney and Felliani lost the ball in dangerous places way to often.

I hope we won't see Giggs anymore. There is no reason. I hope he's in the Young Rio category for Moyes now. He is taking note and he is making changes. If people can't see this game wasn't a step up, I don't know what they will see. We hit the post twice. Could have easily been a blowout.

But we are now in a place where teams will no longer fear us. Particularly at the end of the game. We are Mike Tyson after he was beaten. It's a different situation for the players.

Please don't talk about the fixture list. A tough start just means an easy end. When Moyes was complaining about the computer it just smacked of desperation and it looks even worse now that we've got to the so-called 'easy' games and we're still not winning.

Moyes has made changes, but obvious changes, and long after they were overdue. It was plainly obvious after about 2 or 3 games that the likes of Young and Valencia were completely off form and that Rio and Vida's legs looked suspect but changes were not made because Moyes wanted 'experience'. Presumably because 'experience' of big games was lacking in a title winning squad.

Moyes still persists in being needlessly negative, he still has the team set up in lines that are far too far from one another leaving our players often isolated and unable to get moves going and he still makes baffling subs that seem to be based mostly on which players he trusts rather than form e.g. Giggs for Nani today, Fellaini for Welbeck. If centre midfield is an issue its his problem: Nobody told him to spend £27.5 million on a player who excels as a number 10 not a number 8.

Fixture list, world class players lacking, squad inherited...so many excuses, so few answers. Lets stop blaming everyone else and have someone take some responsibility, eh?
 
Well, Martinez, Pochetino, Rodgers and Laudrup managed to play attackijg football with limited teams. They didn't get results though, so here Moyes beats all of them. On the other side, I was always worried that it could be his mentality that is more defensive minded which will be destined to fail here. Still cannot be sure, but it seems so.

Now at-least he should do is make a Capello and while playing boring and defending, still to be able to win the games. Not that I want that, but better than this.

Dunno about that rumour, if that's true, then yep, we are in big trouble. Better to not thing about it.


Ferguson-Moyes.jpg
 
Yeah, way to stay calm.

I watched a team that was better than they were against West Brom. Improvement game to game is okay with me. People here have gone from screaming about the starting line up to screaming about substitutions. That's improvement.

We were never going to come storming out of the gates with a new coach and a glaring hole in the midfield.

fecking hell, it's not that hard to be better than the team who was against West Brown. Even if they are havily drugged they should be better than that team.

I am seeing the change of expectations from many people here tonight. 15 points from the next 5 games is a must Moyes supporters said. Now that we have only 4 points from three of those games, it's all good cause we played better than against West Brown when we made one of the biggest pathetic performances I have ever seen from us. If being better than the team who played against WBA is the expectation and what is acceptable, then we are truly and utterly fecked.
 

By rumours I meant, does really the club payed/asked the fans to bring this on the stadium? It is quite possible that fans who are happy as long as we play better than against WBA brought it there without instruction by the club.
 
I'd prefer us to lose/draw games because we've gone gung ho rather than sitting back and bitching out. I'd like to see Nani, van Persie and Rooney be a bit more individual at times. I'd like to see Fellaini and Carrick trying a few hollywood passes. It's all very bland and mish mashed. No 'style of play' and a serious identity crisis.

Makes you wonder how important Sir Alex and his carefully selected coaches were to this entire organisation.
 
Please don't talk about the fixture list.


Ridiculous not to.

Please don't talk about the fixture list. A tough start just means an easy end. When Moyes was complaining about the computer it just smacked of desperation and it looks even worse now that we've got to the so-called 'easy' games and we're still not winning.

As if SAF wouldn't have done the same thing. Please.

Moyes has made changes, but obvious changes, and long after they were overdue. It was plainly obvious after about 2 or 3 games that the likes of Young and Valencia were completely off form and that Rio and Vida's legs looked suspect but changes were not made because Moyes wanted 'experience'. Presumably because 'experience' of big games was lacking in a title winning squad.

Imagine if he had come in and made a large swath of changes. That's how you lose the locker room. See: AVB at Chelsea.

f Lets stop blaming everyone else and have someone take some responsibility, eh?

And maybe have an understanding that there are many things at play. One being an incredibly tough fixture list. To ignore that is to have an agenda.
 
fecking hell, it's not that hard to be better than the team who was against West Brown. Even if they are havily drugged they should be better than that team.


Yes, so an improvement.

I am seeing the change of expectations from many people here tonight. 15 points from the next 5 games is a must Moyes supporters said.

Maybe. You're also seeing what you want to see because you've been against him from the beginning, so that's how that works out. What you've said here is about the most RAWKish post I've seen yet. Pretty clear.

I do support Moyes. I support the team. I'd like the team to do well and I'm looking for the positives, of which there are some. Obviously. I guess that makes me someone who supports the manager of the club I support. What a shithead I am.

I look forward to the next couple of month's in which guys like you start calling people like me "Moyes supporters" as a negative term. Good stuff
 
Fergie said he wanted coaches to challenge him. Rene clearly did as discussed in champions league final. I felt Querioz, McClaren and Kidd did that too.

I don't get that with Round and the old man. Thing is there not many standout coaches available. We'd have to wait four years for Pep. A lot of the good coaches like Van Gaal, Hiddink and Capelli are approaching the end of their careers. Even Heynekes.

Two standout candidates are though Klopp and for me Simeone. Simeone has achieved more in his short spell than Moyes has in 14 years as Manager. Could say that about AVB. Pretty sure Moyes was linked with Spurs job and they chose AVB last season .
 
Ridiculous not to.



As if SAF wouldn't have done the same thing. Please.



Imagine if he had come in and made a large swath of changes. That's how you lose the locker room. See: AVB at Chelsea.



And maybe have an understanding that there are many things at play. One being an incredibly tough fixture list. To ignore that is to have an agenda.

Agenda? Yeah. Obvs...
 
Yes, so an improvement.

An insignificant one. We were shit that day, we were shit today (especially in the last 25-30 minutes)

Maybe. You're also seeing what you want to see because you've been against him from the beginning, so that's how that works out. What you've said here is about the most RAWKish post I've seen yet. Pretty clear.

I do support Moyes. I support the team. I'd like the team to do well and I'm looking for the positives, of which there are some. Obviously. I guess that makes me someone who supports the manager of the club I support. What a shithead I am.

I look forward to the next couple of month's in which guys like you start calling people like me "Moyes supporters" as a negative term. Good stuff

I wasn't against Moyes that much compared to others. On the other side, I don't want to blind my eyes and to not see what is obvious (or claim that Moyes is better than Mourinho or that no other manager would have done better). 'Moyes supporter' wasn't a good choice of words, I agree, but I meant people who are not blaming him for his faults. Moyes fanboys would have been a better term, probably.

I also like the team to do well. Team is not doing well though. In fact, team is doing very bad. And there is a single main reason for that. I haven't ever asked for him to be sacked, but it is lunacity to claim that things aren't bad or that is happening any improvement. What improvement? In first three games we got 4 points against Swansea, LFC and Chelsea? In last 3 games we got 4 points against WBA, Sunderland and Southampton. Improvements my arse. Things are continually getting worse.
 
Let's be honest. Tough fixture list. Two of them away.

But I guarantee we would have won all the other games under Fergie. Chelsea came here and parked the bus. Under Fergie, we would have got a goal. Where as you never had that feeling when we played Chelsea under Moyes. Fact is he needs to start making his subs a bit more attacking.
 
And who would you be getting in? Do you want to be setting the precedent that if the manager doesn't hit the ground running in filling the current biggest club job in the world football will be sacked before a single season?

True. We took the piss out of other clubs for doing that with new managers for years, now people are looking rid of Moyes after 8 games. 4th place would be an acceptable outcome for his first season, and as bad as we've been so far that's hardly unattainable at this stage.
 
An insignificant one. We were shit that day, we were shit today (especially in the last 25-30 minutes)



I wasn't against Moyes that much compared to others. On the other side, I don't want to blind my eyes and to not see what is obvious (or claim that Moyes is better than Mourinho or that no other manager would have done better). 'Moyes supporter' wasn't a good choice of words, I agree, but I meant people who are not blaming him for his faults. Moyes fanboys would have been a better term, probably.

I also like the team to do well. Team is not doing well though. In fact, team is doing very bad. And there is a single main reason for that. I haven't ever asked for him to be sacked, but it is lunacity to claim that things aren't bad or that is happening any improvement. What improvement? In first three games we got 4 points against Swansea, LFC and Chelsea? In last 3 games we got 4 points against WBA, Sunderland and Southampton. Improvements my arse. Things are continually getting worse.


I've been here for a while. Honestly, I've never seen you this active. You seem to have a cause suddenly
 
Let's be honest. Tough fixture list. Two of them away.

But I guarantee we would have won all the other games under Fergie. Chelsea came here and parked the bus. Under Fergie, we would have got a goal. Where as you never had that feeling when we played Chelsea under Moyes. Fact is he needs to start making his subs a bit more attacking.


Fergie didn't have a good record vs Jose.
 
True. We took the piss out of other clubs for doing that with new managers for years, now people are looking rid of Moyes after 8 games. 4th place would be an acceptable outcome for his first season, and as bad as we've been so far that's hardly unattainable at this stage.

We took the piss out of other clubs because let's see. Chelsea third last season and four points off top. Beaten Arsenal and Spurs away, yet still sack Di Matteo. That is laughable. Same with Big Phil, they were like fourth at the time. Moyes isn't even top four.

If we mid-table around Xmas, should we stand and slide? Let another team grab one of those champion league spots. If we don't get champions league, we can forget attracting the world class CMs we want.
 
If we mid-table around Xmas, should we stand and slide? Let another team grab one of those champion league spots. If we don't get champions league, we can forget attracting the world class CMs we want.


You mean the one we haven't signed for the past 3 years?
 
He didn't, but although we were good on that evening the final 10 mins we totally settled for a point. I don't think Fergie would have done the same.


Maybe. But I don't think Jose plays that way against Fergie because he knows Fergie well. Moyes, not nearly as much.
 
Fergie didn't have a good record vs Jose.

Debatable. We had two champions league matches with Porto and Madrid, where refs played a part. Let's not forget, when Jose was first at Chelsea, we were in transition.

Also I never seen Jose play like that at Old Trafford. If he did that against Fergie, we would have scored.
 
Let's be honest. Tough fixture list. Two of them away.

But I guarantee we would have won all the other games under Fergie. Chelsea came here and parked the bus. Under Fergie, we would have got a goal. Where as you never had that feeling when we played Chelsea under Moyes. Fact is he needs to start making his subs a bit more attacking.

What makes our start this season uniquely special, have we always been given easy games at the start of seasons or something? In 2008-09 we had Liverpool and Chelsea away in our first four games. In 2009-10 we had Spurs, Arsenal and City back to back in our 4th, 5th and 6th league games. In 2011-12 we had Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea in our first five games. Even last season our 5th and 6th games were against Liverpool and Spurs.

David Moyes has used the fixture list as some kind of excuse but in many ways its no worse than it has been in previous years. Plus, given that we're through the 'tough' bit and still aren't winning what does it matter? Would it have made anyone feel better if the fixtures had been reversed and we'd started with a draw at home with Southampton, followed by a win at Sunderland and losses against West Brom, City and Liverpool with only a drab victory against Palace between?

This whole thing about the fixture list seems to be a complete straw man. Everyone plays everyone else at some stage in the season. To be the best you have to beat the best. Doesn't matter when, doesn't matter how. You just do.
 
I'm not a big fan of the fixture list argument either, besides Southampton and WBA at home were not not games that made it look difficult
 
What makes our start this season uniquely special, have we always been given easy games at the start of seasons or something? In 2008-09 we had Liverpool and Chelsea away in our first four games. In 2009-10 we had Spurs, Arsenal and City back to back in our 4th, 5th and 6th league games. In 2011-12 we had Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea in our first five games. Even last season our 5th and 6th games were against Liverpool and Spurs.

It is slightly more difficult this year, but we have had difficult starts in the past too.

Irrelevant anyway, there have been more than a month since the end of the tough start. Now we are in the easy games so we should win them regardless of how much the computer cheated us.
 
True. We took the piss out of other clubs for doing that with new managers for years, now people are looking rid of Moyes after 8 games. 4th place would be an acceptable outcome for his first season, and as bad as we've been so far that's hardly unattainable at this stage.

IMO the league standings the matter so much at the moment. The bigger problem is the way we've been playing. We've been shite, defensive, sitting deep against whoever we play, and it's not promising for the future at all. If we manage fourth place, what will change next season? Is there a guarantee that we'll all of a sudden start playing a better style of football to get better results? I'm not so sure. I said it before but Moyes' high energy style he had Everton play has limited potential compared to managers who favor their teams to play a more attacking, technical style of play. I don't think you'd ever see Everton, with the style they played, win the title, regardless of what players he had. Don't think that will change being at United unless he tries to change his own style to adapt to us, rather then changing us to adapt to him.
 
It's not a rumour. There's a photo of one on another site (Republik of Mancunia). http://therepublikofmancunia.com/

Tell you what is RAWK-ish; sticking posters around the ground telling the fans to get behind the new manager.

It's new signage that has been going up around the museum as part of the tour route. It's got quotes from all 26 and a bit years of SAF's reign in chronological order starting in the North Stand and working round. Nothing to get your knickers in a twist about.
 
Ok we have Stoke, Norwich & Fulham before playing the almighty Arse. What is the minimum Moyes has to get and your predictions?
It's hard to predict scores at at the moment, Stoke won't be easy and I don't care about Norwich. Beating Fulham will give us momentum for the week ahead.
 
I don't mind the quotes around the place. I mean when he said it, we were all praising it and talking about how important the message is and how well worded it was. It's a speech that will be a part of United's history, something that is important to United. Now a few people have it in for Moyes they want it ripped down. C'mon guys.
 
Ok we have Stoke, Norwich & Fulham before playing the almighty Arse. What is the minimum Moyes has to get and your predictions?

If we come away with only a handful of points and absolutely outclass all of the above having peppered their goals with shots and been undone by bad referring, a breakaway counter or two or a set piece I'll not crow too much. If we actually look like we not only could have won but should have won that will be massive progress. The big problem I have at the moment is that in none of the matches we've lost can you make a convincing argument that we should have won. Every time we've dropped points its been a fair reflection of how we've played. Positives have not been plentiful. I just want it to look like its gonna get better.
 
Moyes motivation?

After Man United dropped points against Southampton, Matt Stanger ponders how David Moyes' negativity is harming the champions' belief...

By Matt Stanger.
October 19, 2013


A day that started with Manchester United announcing a significant victory for David Moyes as Adnan Januzaj committed to a new five-year deal, ended with the manager again looking woefully out of his depth. Southampton thoroughly deserved their 1-1 draw at Old Trafford and should arguably have taken all three points after dominating the champions for large spells before and after Robin van Persie's opening goal.

Moyes reaction

Southampton are riding the crest of a wave as they enjoy an excellent start to the season, but United should be deeply concerned by the speed at which their unbeatable aura is evaporating. Clearly the champions possess enough quality to beat a team who finished 13 places below them in the Premier League last year, but they were slow in possession and again looked devoid of ideas in the final third. A repeat of the defeat by West Bromwich Albion would not have been a surprise.

Not a great deal can be said of Moyes' team selection on Saturday - with Januzaj again repaying the manager's faith with a wonderful pass in the build-up to Van Persie's opener - but there is plenty of room for criticism in the way he responded to the Saints' fight-back. Courage could have killed off the visitors, but instead Moyes chose the cowardly option to try and shore-up a 1-0 lead at home to a team who have averaged just a goal a game this season. The complaints Liverpool fans held against Roy Hodgson now seem to apply at Old Trafford.

Moyes' judgement in the big job has thus far been clouded by fear, beginning with his over-reliance on Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic in United's shaky start to the campaign and continuing against Southampton with three crushingly negative substitutions that predictably spurred Saints to find an equaliser. Replacing Nani, who was having one of his better days, with Ryan Giggs exhibited weakness; bringing on Danny Welbeck for Marouane Fellaini was absurd; and to sub Wayne Rooney for Chris Smalling in the dying stages was needless.

Pochettino reaction

The effect of these changes saw United retreat under renewed Southampton pressure as the atmosphere inside Old Trafford swung from expectation of a routine victory to the sudden fright at further dropped points. Such negativity may have been shrewd at Everton to hold on to a result in the last half-hour but by now Moyes should know that it is United's nature to look for the jugular. His substitutions shackled the beast, and even as Saints opened up in search of an equaliser, the champions still could not pick them off on the counter-attack.

One wonders what Shinji Kagawa, Javier Hernandez and Wilfried Zaha made of Moyes' reluctance to put the game beyond Southampton as the trio's absence from match action continued. Van Persie must also have been frustrated as he was forced to drop deeper and deeper as the service dried up in the second half, while Rooney will rue that final eight minutes he spent on the bench as Smalling was required to join the quest for a late winning goal.

Perhaps, under Sir Alex Ferguson, United would have snatched a crucial strike at the death to save themselves from the embarrassment of winning only three of their first eight fixtures. But Moyes is rapidly imbuing a lack of belief at Old Trafford, vaporizing the drive and desire that the champions demonstrated so readily as they romped to the title last season.

While Ferguson's final United side possessed plenty of faults, at least they had heart and hunger. Moyes' team, on the other hand, is so depressingly ordinary. The players are neither performing for the manager, nor has he shown that he can get the best out of a group with far more quality than which he is used to. You can have the fastest racing car in Formula 1, but it will still drive like a Skoda if you put the wrong man behind the wheel.

http://www1.skysports.com/football/live/match/287361/analysis
 
We took the piss out of other clubs because let's see. Chelsea third last season and four points off top. Beaten Arsenal and Spurs away, yet still sack Di Matteo. That is laughable. Same with Big Phil, they were like fourth at the time. Moyes isn't even top four.

If we mid-table around Xmas, should we stand and slide? Let another team grab one of those champion league spots. If we don't get champions league, we can forget attracting the world class CMs we want.

Unless we're in danger of getting relegated, which we won't be, we should give him to the end of the season at least. The last thing the club needs is to get in the habit of ditching managers mid-season and making Hail Mary replacement appointments.
 
IMO the league standings the matter so much at the moment. The bigger problem is the way we've been playing. We've been shite, defensive, sitting deep against whoever we play, and it's not promising for the future at all. If we manage fourth place, what will change next season? Is there a guarantee that we'll all of a sudden start playing a better style of football to get better results? I'm not so sure. I said it before but Moyes' high energy style he had Everton play has limited potential compared to managers who favor their teams to play a more attacking, technical style of play. I don't think you'd ever see Everton, with the style they played, win the title, regardless of what players he had. Don't think that will change being at United unless he tries to change his own style to adapt to us, rather then changing us to adapt to him.

I do agree to an extent - I wasn't particularly enthusiastic about Moyes' appointment in the first place - but having appointed him it would be mental not to see it through to the end of the season at least. The early signs have been shite but there's still plenty of time for him to stamp some sort of tactical mark on the team.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.