Messi v Ronaldo | Contains double your daily salt allowance

Messi or Ronaldo

  • Messi

  • Ronaldo


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Spain managed to win everything those same years and are essentially Barca minus Messi.

Have you forgotten the all time CL scoring record he broke last season? Messi's 2nd goal against us in 2009 wasn't that "vital". Ronaldo's goal against Chelsea however, was definitely vital.
UCL is far more competitive than World Cup. Spain won the World Cup by scoring only one goal in each of the games in KO. Holland reached the final despite having a defense which would have made current's United defense look grand. Their CB were Heitinga and Mathijsen.

There were a few teams on Europe who would have stopped that Spain team. FFS, Croatia almost managed to stop them. Portugal who were pretty shit send them to penalties.
 
Why do you choose to argue with Cal? I suggest everyone ignoring him when it comes to anything related to Ronaldo/Messi.

It would probably make him go mental though.
 
I don't think that we are disagreeing. Ronaldo was poor on the final (he was poor on 2009 final too) while Messi was excellent on both finals.

What I was saying there is that Barca wouldn't have been as succesful as they were without Messi. He saved them many times. He destroyed us on 2011. Contrary to what many people think, Barca's road to the trophies (UCL) was very difficult and in many games they barely managed to win. Messi was always there, scoring, assisting or creating space for the others.
Messi scoring the 2nd goal in a 2-0 win = excellent

Ronaldo scores the 1st goal in a 1-1 = poor

Right...
 
If you always state the obvious, you're always right.

Spain are as close to Barca-Messi as it gets and they basically managed to win everything those few years, in a much more boring way...

And again, don't you realise that you can't compare achievements of international and club sides?

You'd have a point if Spain were a club side with the same players, but they're not, so it's utterly irrelevant.
 
Messi scoring the 2nd goal in a 2-0 win = excellent

Ronaldo scores the 1st goal in a 1-1 = poor

Right...

He said he was poor in 2009 final, he didn't score a goal in that and was in fact pretty poor. He was decent in 2008 but still missed important penalty in the shoot-outs, wouldn't blame it on him though.
 
Messi scoring the 2nd goal in a 2-0 win = excellent

Ronaldo scores the 1st goal in a 1-1 = poor

Right...

What? Messi was superb in the 2009 (and 2011) final for that matter, presuming it's what you're referring to.
 
Messi scoring the 2nd goal in a 2-0 win = excellent

Ronaldo scores the 1st goal in a 1-1 = poor

Right...
Ronaldo didn't score in 2009 and had a poor match, shooting from 40m every time the ball came near him. On 2008 he scored and played great (although almost lost the game with his pen).

Messi was excellent on 2009 and he did much more than just score the goal (although, I think thay Xavi was MOTM). On 2011 he was easily the best player on the pitch and completely destroyed us.
 
Yep, poor in big games and when you come up with Messi's two CL final goals he just disregards them completely.
I never said he's poor in big games, stop making things up. I just disagree with someone who said Messi is better in big games.
nope, he was still a good player, in fact he was second in the ballon d'or polls
And yet Ronaldo was easily the better player over those 2 years.
 
Ronaldo didn't score in 2009 and had a poor match, shooting from 40m every time the ball came near him. On 2008 he scored and played great (although almost lost the game with his pen).

Messi was excellent on 2009 and he did much more than just score the goal (although, I think thay Xavi was MOTM). On 2011 he was easily the best player on the pitch and completely destroyed us.
My mistake, I thought you are saying Ronaldo has always been poor in CL finals.
 
Honestly, I literally don't have a clue what you're on about. How have you decided from my post saying that Cristiano hasn't outperformed Messi in the 14/15 season that I am arguing about who deserves the 2014 calendar year Ballon d'Or?

I am beyond confused. Are you drunk?

You're fecking confusing me I'll tell you that.

Let's lay it all out, i posted a picture of Ronaldo holding the Ballon d'Or basically saying how the hell did he win this if:-

1) Messi was better 1st half the season Aug-Dec (something you said)
2) Messi won the best player at the world cup during the other half the year Jan-May where the Ballon' d'or 2014 is judged.

Then you replied "because Ronaldo won the Champions League and people just focus on goals"

It's all there. You said Ronaldo won the Ballon d'ore because "people just focus on goals"

You can apologise now.
 
@Cal? it's time for you to face the facts and admit that you're simply wrong.​
The fact is Ronaldo is the reigning Balon D'Or winner.

It's your opinion (shared by many it seems) that Messi is a better player, try to learn the difference between the 2.
 
The fact is Ronaldo is the reigning Balon D'Or winner.

It's your opinion (shared by many it seems) that Messi is a better player, try to learn the difference between the 2.

Back when Messi was winning three in a row you somehow didn't put much attention to who holds Ballon D'Or. :lol:
 
You're fecking confusing me I'll tell you that.

Let's lay it all out, i posted a picture of Ronaldo holding the Ballon d'Or basically saying how the hell did he win this if:-

1) Messi was better 1st half the season Aug-Dec (something you said)
2) Messi won the best player at the world cup Jan-May the other half the year where the Ballon' d'or 2014 is judged.

Then you replied "because Ronaldo won the Champions League and people just focus on goals"

It's all there. You said Ronaldo won the Ballon d'ore because "people just focus on goals"

You can apologise now.

How do you manage to operate a phone/computer?
 
@Cal? address the world cup question please, it's pathetic the way you're glossing over it. Why is Ronaldo's 2006 WC better than Messi's 2014? Answer the damn question.

Also while you're banging on about Ronaldo's CL final Chelsea goal, why don't you say a little piece on his fluffed penalty in the shootout? Better yet his fluffed penalty at the Camp Nou in the semi final which denied Utd an away goal and probably a much more comfortable second leg?

Let's face it, you simply ignore everything and anything that doesn't suit your agenda. Genuinely never seen this level of fanboyism anywhere.
 
Back when Messi was winning three in a row you somehow didn't put much attention to who holds Ballon D'Or. :lol:

I always said it was my opinion that Ronaldo is better, the last I checked none of us live in North Korea and we're allowed to have our own thoughts?
 
I always said it was my opinion that Ronaldo is better, the last I checked none of us live in North Korea and we're allowed to have our own thoughts?

:lol:

So now it's a fact that Ronaldo is the best, was it a fact back then that Messi was the best? You had no issue saying Ronaldo was better despite every single thing pointing to the contrary, now you have issues when people tell you Messi has been better even these past two seasons and it's somehow not debatable. Sweet.
 
@Cal? address the world cup question please, it's pathetic the way you're glossing over it. Why is Ronaldo's 2006 WC better than Messi's 2014? Answer the damn question.

He won't. It doesn't suit his point so he will just pretend he hasn't seen it. He's been doing it for the best part of the last two days.
 
Back when Messi was winning three in a row you somehow didn't put much attention to who holds Ballon D'Or. :lol:

I think he's dug his way to China by now. Let's start a new hashtag:

#admitit@Cal?
 
@Cal? address the world cup question please, it's pathetic the way you're glossing over it. Why is Ronaldo's 2006 WC better than Messi's 2014? Answer the damn question.

Also while you're banging on about Ronaldo's CL final Chelsea goal, why don't you say a little piece on his fluffed penalty in the shootout? Better yet his fluffed penalty at the Camp Nou in the semi final which denied Utd an away goal and probably a much more comfortable second leg?

Let's face it, you simply ignore everything and anything that doesn't suit your agenda. Genuinely never seen this level of fanboyism anywhere.

@Marcosdeto , is this okay, or just the one ending in "i" that is not allowed?

Ronaldo played a bigger part in Portugal progressing to the SF with a weaker side than Messi managed in the knockout stage in 2014.

As for penalties, those 2 Ronaldo missed didn't cost United. Shall I remind you of the one Messi missed against Chelsea? :lol:

This game: http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/17817584
 
BTW is this a fact that Casillas is a superior goalkeeper to De Gea? Because I seem to remember he got more votes for team of the year.
 
He said he was poor in 2009 final, he didn't score a goal in that and was in fact pretty poor. He was decent in 2008 but still missed important penalty in the shoot-outs, wouldn't blame it on him though.
He was much better than decent and he had a great first half. Essien could not get to grips with him at all in that game. He dominated Essien in that game both physically in the air and several times in one on ones. Like I said, his first half in particular was great beating Essien many times in the air and on the ground, scoring a goal as well as providing a great cross to Tevez which if he scored would have made the score 2-0. Essien required assistance from Joe Cole and Ballack in the second half due to the torrid time Ronaldo gave him in the first half but it still didn't stop Ronaldo from beating him one-on-one on a few occasions and from providing some dangerous crosses and he also took advantage of the amount of attention Chelsea were giving him by drawing players in and then releasing Evra down the left in space. His link-up play with Evra was great in that game, finding him in space quite a few times so that he could provide a cross or cutback.
 
If you always state the obvious, you're always right.

Spain are as close to Barca-Messi as it gets and they basically managed to win everything those few years, in a much more boring way...

Terrible argument. Spain don't play teams anywhere near as good as Barcelona do in the CL and in the league if you look at Real.
 
:lol:

So now it's a fact that Ronaldo is the best, was it a fact back then that Messi was the best? You had no issue saying Ronaldo was better despite every single thing pointing to the contrary, now you have issues when people tell you Messi has been better even these past two seasons and it's somehow not debatable. Sweet.
Nope, it's a fact that Ronaldo is the reigning Balon D'Or winner, it's still my opinion that he's the better player, just that it seems more and more people share that opinion than a few years ago.
 
@Marcosdeto , is this okay, or just the one ending in "i" that is not allowed?

Ronaldo played a bigger part in Portugal progressing to the SF with a weaker side than Messi managed in the knockout stage in 2014.

As for penalties, those 2 Ronaldo missed didn't cost United. Shall I remind you of the one Messi missed against Chelsea? :lol:

This game: http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/17817584

That was just crap from you, expected better.

Messi scored 4 goals in the group stages and it was largely due to him that Argentina qualified.

Ronaldo scored 1 goal in the group stage (from the spot) and they'd have qualified even without that goal.

Neither scored a goal in the knockout stages and neither had an assist. Portugal scored 1 goal between group stage and third place game, Argentina scored 2, neither team impressed in the attack. I honestly don't see how Ronaldo contributed to Portugal making semis, nevermind they lost and didn't even get a medal. The difference was in the group stage where Messi carried Argentina while Ronaldo contributed a single penalty kick goal in a game that was already won.
 
He won't. It doesn't suit his point so he will just pretend he hasn't seen it. He's been doing it for the best part of the last two days.

Correction - the best part of the last 5/6 seasons. The great avoider.
 
Terrible argument. Spain don't play teams anywhere near as good as Barcelona do in the CL and in the league if you look at Real.
You can only beat what's in front of you. It's a matter of opinion if Spain could have won the CL if they played in it.
 
You can only beat what's in front of you. It's a matter of opinion if Spain could have won the CL if they played in it.
Yeah and my opinion is that Ronaldo-less Real Madrid would have won Champions League in 2010 and 2011 but he prevented them from having a chance.

It's just my opinion though so you shall not argue with that.
 
That was just crap from you, expected better.

Messi scored 4 goals in the group stages and it was largely due to him that Argentina qualified.

Ronaldo scored 1 goal in the group stage (from the spot) and they'd have qualified even without that goal.

Neither scored a goal in the knockout stages and neither had an assist. Portugal scored 1 goal between group stage and third place game, Argentina scored 2, neither team impressed in the attack. I honestly don't see how Ronaldo contributed to Portugal making semis, nevermind they lost and didn't even get a medal. The difference was in the group stage where Messi carried Argentina while Ronaldo contributed a single penalty kick goal in a game that was already won.
Ronaldo got Rooney sent off to win that game against England, much more direct impact on the result than Messi managed in the knockout stage. :)
 
Yeah and my opinion is that Ronaldo-less Real Madrid would have won Champions League in 2010 and 2011 but he prevented them from having a chance.

It's just my opinion though so you shall not argue with that.
Fine, you're entitled to an opinion.

If we didn't argue over opinions, it'd be a very boring forum.
 
BTW is this a fact that Casillas is a superior goalkeeper to De Gea? Because I seem to remember he got more votes for team of the year.

David Luiz is at least the second best CB in the world according to his logic.
 
David Luiz is at least the second best CB in the world according to his logic.
That's a fact as well. My opinion though is that Coloccini is the best center half in the universe. I don't really have anything to back that opinion but nevermind.
 
That was just crap from you, expected better.

Messi scored 4 goals in the group stages and it was largely due to him that Argentina qualified.

Ronaldo scored 1 goal in the group stage (from the spot) and they'd have qualified even without that goal.

Neither scored a goal in the knockout stages and neither had an assist. Portugal scored 1 goal between group stage and third place game, Argentina scored 2, neither team impressed in the attack. I honestly don't see how Ronaldo contributed to Portugal making semis, nevermind they lost and didn't even get a medal. The difference was in the group stage where Messi carried Argentina while Ronaldo contributed a single penalty kick goal in a game that was already won.

Messi set up the winning goal in the dying minutes of the last 16 game vs Switzerland, dribbling a couple of players before laying it on to Di Maria. More than CR7 did int he knock outs in 2006
 
That's a fact as well. My opinion though is that Coloccini is the best center half in the universe. I don't really have anything to back that opinion but nevermind.

Tim Cahill is better. Everyone calls him Gary Cahill, but it's my opinion that it's actually Tim.
 
Messi set up the winning goal in the dying minutes of the last 16 game vs Switzerland, dribbling a couple of players before laying it on to Di Maria. More than CR7 did int he knock outs in 2006
To be fair I didn't see Argentina v Switzerland, I only saw the result and scorer.
 
Messi fans struggle to understand the difference between "fact" and "opinion".

*gives up for the night*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.