MEN: Inside the worst Man Utd season in decades

Apologies if this has been covered already, but does anyone have context to this part:

He (Maguire) became such an easy target one teammate flagrantly leaked a story where the reporter's byline effectively gave away the source.

My guess would be the Bailly story. If I remember correctly the first article about Maguire selection upsetting teammates didn't openly mention Bailly but mentioned that it was a senior player that was fit, iirc Bailly was the only left.
 
My guess would be the Bailly story. If I remember correctly the first article about Maguire selection upsetting teammates didn't openly mention Bailly but mentioned that it was a senior player that was fit, iirc Bailly was the only left.

fecker literally goes AWOL at AFCON, no one can find him, comes back injured and then has the gall to say "why is Maguire getting selected'

That should amount to breach of contract and the fecker doesn't get a dime.
 
Very true.
While we were all laughing at the KDB "let me talk" clip last week. I did notice something. David Silva's authority was obvious. Simply said, no he couldn't. I don't think we have that. The problem.
I think the problem of leadership has been exacerbated by making a player from a lower placed team captain when he had barely kicked a ball for us. Leaders in a dressing room earn their place through periods of consistent performance. That's why David Silva and Fernandinho could tell Kevin De Bruyne to shut it. I think that's a problem we will have for a fairly long time.

It's not about level or reputation but character/temperament. Take PSG between 2012 and 2015, one of the main leaders and captains was Zoumana Camara, I bet that most of you have no idea who is but he was liked and respected by the likes of Ibrahimovic, Maxwell, Thiago Motta or Thiago Silva.
 
There has been some revisionism: two top-three finishes, four semi-finals and a final in under three years. Solskjaer's rose-tinted defenders fail to consider almost all of those feats came in the soulless and misleading behind-closed-doors era. United's runners-up status last season was false.

That's a bizarre point and irrelevant to the larger content of the article, every team was playing behind closed doors.

If United's 2nd place finish was false then by that logic I suppose Liverpool and City's titles wins over the last 2 years have been false as well. I can get on board with that.
 
Post ole, whatever disaster befell United this year, is all on Rangnick. He encouraged the divisiveness in the dressing room, and made no attempt to unite the players.
Is this irony? It is all on players. Behaviour on and off the pitch.
 
Hard to read that was,perhaps if some players worked as hard on their game as they do running to journalists,they might improve,its scary that so many of our players are always looking to pass the blame elsewhere and not take responsibility.
We need ETH to take charge of the dressing room and get rid of some of the entitled prima donnas.
There is a desperate need for players with hunger and fight,players who put the team first,I was around for the relegation and that time had nowhere the talent this lot have but at least they fought for the team and cared for the team,they just weren't very good
 
These stories are all so convenient. Not past the realm of possibility, of course, but just so convenient
 
The Elanga comment suggest that the leaker is a senior player who plays in his role. I doubt its mata (if he wanted to kick a fuss he would have done it ages ago) or sancho (he was getting games) which suggest Lingard or Rashy. Rashy is the one who refused to celebrate a goal.

I'd say we should do what SAF did with McGrath and we should get rid of both. In that way we would drive the message through that no one is bigger then the club. At that point everyone would learn that no one is safe
 
The Elanga comment suggest that the leaker is a senior player who plays in his role. I doubt its mata (if he wanted to kick a fuss he would have done it ages ago) or sancho (he was getting games) which suggest Lingard or Rashy. Rashy is the one who refused to celebrate a goal.

I'd say we should do what SAF did with McGrath and we should get rid of both. In that way we would drive the message through that no one is bigger then the club. At that point everyone would learn that no one is safe

It doesn't. It could easily be a CB or CM who thinks that Elanga isn't the best option if the team wants to win. It's not different to when you play Football, you don't just care about where you play, you also care about who you are playing with.
 
On another note, I can’t really be mad at players for being unhappy with Maguire being constantly selected despite the number of disasterclasses he has served up. That’s a managerial failure.

Pogba apologising to Ragnick after the senior players “ambushed” Ragnick without the captain seems like something he’d do. He’s always come across as a polite guy. I wonder who was the player trying to “hijack” it though
 
It's pretty damning reading. Ragnick may not have delivered on the pitch but he has hit a home run in terms of weeding out the poisonous characters in the club. We know exactly who needs to go and can finally start the process of rebuilding under a manager who has actually been appointed properly.
 
In contrast to the Luckhurst player driven narrative about a clueless Rangnick, we get this from Whitwell

Ralf Initially wanted to come up with a strict system and pass on detailed instructions to players.


Players came from different backgrounds – some thought football was about freedom and some thought more intense tactical sessions in-formation were necessary.


Ralf thinks bad recruitment lead to this ("At Hoffenheim and RB Leipzig he had led clubs that made signings based on an overarching idea. Publicly he pointed out how Manchester City and Liverpool built squads subservient to a concept. At United this aspect seemed muddled", "In Rangnick’s opinion, United’s results were being affected by a fractured squad put together by five different managers")
 
The amount of snakes we have in the dressing room is more than I initially thought.
 
It doesn't. It could easily be a CB or CM who thinks that Elanga isn't the best option if the team wants to win. It's not different to when you play Football, you don't just care about where you play, you also care about who you are playing with.

I doubt it. Elanga is not Messi but was given games based on merit. Also this squad comes across as selfish. All they care about is not winning but who is keeping them out of the team
 
That reads like there's not one leaker anyway, seems like a culture of leaking when things aren't going your way. It's all very odd to be honest, I have no idea what happens from here. I hope people leaving relieves some of the fractures, but feck knows.
 
It doesn't. It could easily be a CB or CM who thinks that Elanga isn't the best option if the team wants to win. It's not different to when you play Football, you don't just care about where you play, you also care about who you are playing with.

It kind of does, a CM or CB wouldn't mind him playing because he protects the CM or CB alot more than some other forwards.

Also, the player also questioned why Maguire plays, so I doubt its a CB. It wouldn't be a CM because I don't think a McFred would care if Elanga plays.
 
That reads like there's not one leaker anyway, seems like a culture of leaking when things aren't going your way. It's all very odd to be honest, I have no idea what happens from here. I hope people leaving relieves some of the fractures, but feck knows.

Or it could be one leaker and Luckhurst is making it sound like its a culture.

We cannot be sure, he is just a mouth piece. It is clear that the player that is leaking this is upset that he didnt get game time.
 
It kind of does, a CM or CB wouldn't mind him playing because he protects the CM or CB alot more than some other forwards.

Also, the player also questioned why Maguire plays, so I doubt its a CB. It wouldn't be a CM because I don't think a McFred would care if Elanga plays.

They would mind it if they don't rate him which is what the article suggests. CM and CBs don't want to be "protected", they want to play in a winning team with a winning formula.
 
Post ole, whatever disaster befell United this year, is all on Rangnick. He encouraged the divisiveness in the dressing room, and made no attempt to unite the players.
Based on what? Laurie Whitwell's piece in The Athletic suggests the exact opposite in fact, saying that Rangnick actually spent too much time and effort on trying to keep players happy for much of his reign. It also says that he now regrets that, which was obvious anyway from his recent interviews.
 
They would mind it if they don't rate him which is what the article suggests. CM and CBs don't want to be "protected", they want to play in a winning team with a winning formula.

Are you sure? When you are playing in a team with Rashford Lingard and losing goals left right centre?

When you are not winning games, you need your forward players to protect you.

its clearly Rashford or Lingard.
 
I doubt it. Elanga is not Messi but was given games based on merit. Also this squad comes across as selfish. All they care about is not winning but who is keeping them out of the team

That's your perception from the outside, in truth you have no idea about whether it was on merit or not. For all you know players thought that an other player was performing better on the training pitch or didn't rate his performances.
 
Absolute nonsense!
Rangnick came in and did exactly what needed to be done - shone a spotlight directly where the blame lies. He wasn't brought in to unite the players and i'm glad he didn't because they would still be getting away with their crap if they'd somehow managed to scrape a top 4 finish.

He might not be a very good manager but he excels in building excellent clubs. Wholesale changes are needed, we've seen the amount of backroom changes that are happening, now its time to focus on the footballing side of the rot.

:( The bolded part!
 
It kind of does, a CM or CB wouldn't mind him playing because he protects the CM or CB alot more than some other forwards.

Also, the player also questioned why Maguire plays, so I doubt its a CB. It wouldn't be a CM because I don't think a McFred would care if Elanga plays.

The player that questioned Maguire is rumoured to be Bailly.
 
Deleted the last post because the links aren't clickable, so it's annoying to read. I'll just copy it here...credit to /u/9solskjaerhaswonit9 on Reddit.

The in-fighting actually went public when a player scored and barely celebrated. An enthusiastic teammate encouraged him to smile in front of a nearby camera, which only incensed the player after the game, irritated by his teammate's apparent obsequiousness. This happened with United winning in a game they won.



Those close to one player referred to Rangnick as 'specs' behind his back. One player complained Rangnick 'talked to him like a child' and 'did not give a s---e' about Rangnick's advice.

O1q2urC.jpg


One senior player spoke disparagingly of any competitor for his position. One player found Anthony Elanga's playing time mind-boggling.

The representatives of one player attempted to scapegoat a United great

cvKYByR.jpg
 
Also, I think there are some strong indications that Carrick and McKenna provided more than they are being credited for; witness Rangnick's troubles without them.

Yes, that sounds about right.

Ole seems to have fancied himself a SAF style manager, leaving certain details to his coaches (both in terms of general training and match preparation).

I also agree that it's far too simple to just dismiss our results in '21 and '20 as Covid-related coincidence. We clearly weren't the 2nd best team in the country in '21 and perhaps not the 3rd best team in '20 either - but it wasn't pure luck either. They did something right - but it obviously wasn't sustainable. And the long-term "cultural" change seems to have been as illusory or flimsy as Ole's alleged plan to make us the most hard working team in the league, etc.
 
Apologies if this has been covered already, but does anyone have context to this part:

He (Maguire) became such an easy target one teammate flagrantly leaked a story where the reporter's byline effectively gave away the source.
The Draper aticle from the mail gives context to this episode. There was a story that broke befire the City game about Maguire. The words used in the story gave away the source. Apparently, everyone knows who went to the papers with it
 
It's not about level or reputation but character/temperament. Take PSG between 2012 and 2015, one of the main leaders and captains was Zoumana Camara, I bet that most of you have no idea who is but he was liked and respected by the likes of Ibrahimovic, Maxwell, Thiago Motta or Thiago Silva.
I would guess those players met Camara there. Bringing in a new player from a lesser team and making him captain before he has established himself looks like a bad move to me
 
Are you sure? When you are playing in a team with Rashford Lingard and losing goals left right centre?

When you are not winning games, you need your forward players to protect you.

its clearly Rashford or Lingard.

Yes, I'm sure. We finished with the 8th defense and the 8th offense, we needed to score and create goals as much as not concede. So you can bet that more than one person at United is upset about the way we attacked and failed to score.
 
In contrast to the Luckhurst player driven narrative about a clueless Rangnick, we get this from Whitwell
In Rangnick’s opinion, United’s results were being affected by a fractured squad put together by five different managers")
This is the genesis of our problem.
 
Yes, I'm sure. We finished with the 8th defense and the 8th offense, we needed to score and create goals as much as not concede. So you can bet that more than one person at United is upset about the way we attacked and failed to score.

Exactly. The defence who keep conceding goals would not be saying you need to score more goals whilst conceding loads of goals.

Regarding a defender asking, you do realise that Lingard and Rashford who were backup have had a terrible season too? Worse than Elanga.
 
I would guess those players met Camara there. Bringing in a new player from a lesser team and making him captain before he has established himself looks like a bad move to me

I don't think that the move changes much when it comes to genuine leadership. You wouldn't respect someone authority/leadership just because they were there and you wouldn't do for years, your opinion would change with deeper mutual experience.If anything the angle that you are using is problematic because it's superficial coming from Leciester doesn't mean that you are not a respectable leader, the issue for Maguire is that he seemingly isn't a leader at all and wasn't seen as a leader at Leicester. I wouldn't be surprised if one of the reason Maguire ended up with the armband is his transfer fee and the presumed idea that "star" players are supposed to be the leaders in a group.
 
Exactly. The defence who keep conceding goals would not be saying you need to score more goals whilst conceding loads of goals.

Regarding a defender asking, you do realise that Lingard and Rashford who were backup have had a terrible season too? Worse than Elanga.

Of course the defense would say that you need to score more goals, I really hope that you don't think footballers only think about their own position when it comes to winning or losing. And I used CM and CB as an example, in a post where I said that it could be anyone, I didn't and I'm not telling you that it is a CB.
 
But we coped better with it, clearly. Why, otherwise, were we better away than at home?

11 teams were better away than at home in 20/21 - and we werent' even the best one. City had more away points than we did (and more points than they had at home), and Everton had a better away/home differential than we did. Also, it's not that unusual - there were 5 teams this season too who had more points away than at home.

Premier League - home and away tables - historical 2021 (soccerstats.com)
Premier League - home and away tables (soccerstats.com)