Crustanoid
New Member
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2008
- Messages
- 18,511
Please go, Anthony
While I agree that having a 250k/week player planted on the bench is good management, I don't believe there is an issue with the club being unable to afford new wages for Pogba, I think it's a matter of in the even that Pogba decides to stay, do we want to pay him what he will demand given the impact his wages will have on other players' wage demands? While I know that CR7 has taken a Sanchez-sized sledge hammer to our wage structure, CR7 is an exception that others at the club simply cannot not reference when making their own wage demands. Paying Pogba 400-500k/week would have significant inflationary impact on Bruno, Rashford and (hopefully) Haaland.
i'm just baffled how Martial and Jesse made it thru this window without being sold or at least sent out on loan. I'd rather give the young players the opportunity to train and play wiht the first team instead of those two houseplants
Down to the manager. Anyone with a vision would have sold at least one of them. Both may be overkill but there's simply too many players in attack right now and they won't get gametime (without even factoring in youth products who should see cup games).
That’s just not true. You just need to see the Mourinho era to find out why it’s not true. Is he lazy? Is he not always putting the best effort? Absolutely. But does he have no fight in him? You don’t come at 19 years old being ridiculed as a waste of money before your very first game at one of the biggest clubs in the world and have a season like he did or his comeback from Mou’s management.My biggest issue with him is the complete lack of fight in him. Any time everything isnt just right, either at the club or at home he becomes a passenger.
I could see the case for not giving up on him as main striker quite yet, given his strong 19-20 campaign (although I wouldn't agree with it, I think. And if that spot was open, which it clearly no longer is). But what I struggle with is why we should keep him if he's our 3rd or 4th choice as striker, and need to be slotted in as second choice at left wing, despite the fact that we have lots of other options there (at least two of whom are better than him). I just can't make that make sense.
I don’t know if this is Ole’s sole call but I agree with the implication of your statement - that Ole is kind of insecure that way - likes to hoard players I guess for that “rainy day”. With James gone I guess there’s a case for Martial staying but his value is sinking especially in this state where clubs just can’t pay the transfer fees and wages of someone like Martial. We are probably stuck with him for this year. It certainly doesn’t look like Jadon coming in and Rashford being hurt is driving him to make a claim for a starting spot.
Why are people thinking it's Ole fault Martial and Lingard still here? If no one comes in with an offer then they can't fecking leave
Some sound like they'd be happy with a squad of 20Why are people thinking it's Ole fault Martial and Lingard still here? If no one comes in with an offer then they can't fecking leave
A club the size of United has to hedge some players in case this & that, fully understandable. But then they also say we will buy only of we sell. Most would agree if that's the case, we desperately need a DM. No real point having players rot on a bench if we can swap for a useful one, per above.Some sound like they'd be happy with a squad of 20
Selling this guy has to be a priority now. His wages are substantial and moving him on does actually move the needle a little in terms of lower our wage bill. In a strange way, if he does well and recover some of his goal scoring form, that may make it easier to move him on.
I think he could do well in a different team where the presume may be lower.
@Esquire @justsomebloke we've been hoarding players for long before Ole got here and we'll be doing it long into the future. We've basically ended up giving away Andreas, we ended up giving away Marcos Rojo, Alexis, we'll end up giving away others. We renew contracts of broken down players 'to protect value.' Its the club's policy to hold onto players in the hope of some fantasy fee payer appearing. Look what we did with Darmian. Years after publicly expressing we would let him go we were still holding on hoping someone would come in and pay us big bucks.
The people who run this club will hold on to Martial into the final year of his deal, then renew it like they did with Bailly, hoping for a sale fee. Just look at Lingard. One year left on his deal. He'll get a new one, just like Matic, just like Mata. Because the guys who run United always think some sap will come in and meet their valuation. They're happy to just clog up the wage bill with people who virtually never play, just in the hope of a transfer fee. Phil Jones, who is almost always injured, got a new four year deal out of our senior management.
Martial will be here for years to come unless he decides to push for the exit.
Good post and agreed. Just hope Murtaugh (sp?) and Fletcher will act as brakes to this insane “value protection” strategy. But even if you say this has gone on before OGS, I still say Ole has not been brave enough in this regard. Lingard definitely needs to go on loan or be sold. Why on earth Mata is still in the squad is beyond me.
If he's on a percentage of his wages, no reason to get him a move?Judging by the lack of interest Martial's agent is as lazy as his client.
Well he'd have to play every week so not surprising he turned it down.
"Non, merci. I'm 'appy sitting on the bench"
At this point, I don't even know how many clubs would provide him enough playing time and paying 125K/week for him. I'm not saying it's impossible, but it's definitely not going to be easy, and he'd have to agree to it as well. Just get this feeling he's going to be very difficult to move but he would probably be better off considering it.At 250k/w and with his attitude, hell yeah. We'll probably keep him as any type of move will have us paying half his salary and he's still good enough to be a fringe player that we keep around for squad depth.
Our mistake for giving him that contract after 1 goodish season in his 4th year here, not his.
Well I don’t blame him for the club being stupid enough to pay him insane wages. But what I do blame him for is that once he got his new contract he completely flopped. It’s clear this guy is not motivated by footballing success. People say well Berbatov was not a hard runner and appeared lackadaisical. That is the worse comparison ever as Berba clearly cared and was way more consistent. It’s sad really Martial’s talent really could have translated into a top 10 player in Europe. Don’t think he will get there now.Absolutely ridiculous he’s still here. Picking up a huge wage to be 4th choice winger and 4th choice striker.