[.Rossi]

Exactly. You haven't seen him play and go by what your "mate" has been telling you. Again with the "he only played upfront" myth. Go back and watch some of his games in midfield. He played box to box against arsenal and did pretty good - much better than the likes of Clevs, Valencia or Young do now a days.

You haven't followed his career. You don't know how he plays so I'd suggest not to make stupid comments such as "all he has is use his elbows, his hair and bully boy tactics". It's evident you're just basing him on his performances on last season.

Well it's hardly a stupid comment on my behalf when I'm basing it from when I watched him play, last season, for MY team now is it?!?!?! Don't be so patronising!!
My mate is a hardcore Everton fan. I don't follow them so, I'm going by his word! And anytime I watched him play for Everton, he wasn't exactly the stand out player

Box to box against Arsenal?!?! You are joking right?!?! The same Arsenal we bossed in midfield with Park Ji Sung?!?!

Oh, and let's not forget Fellaini's interview some weeks back...Which was very telling

 

[Smoke On the Water]

You haven't followed his career. You don't know how he plays so I'd suggest not to make stupid comments such as "all he has is use his elbows, his hair and bully boy tactics". It's evident you're just basing him on his performances on last season.

Well said, 90% of this thread in a nutshell.

 

[.Rossi]

Well said, 90% of this thread in a nutshell.

Oh Ok.....Drop RVP, Rooney and Falcao for him then.
Better yet, play him in midfield, protecting the back four, where he wants to be the new "Roy Keane" ....He wasn't very good there was he?!

 

[Devil may care]

Nice thing he did for charity, still needs selling at the earliest possible opportunity.

 

[shamans]

Oh Ok.....Drop RVP, Rooney and Falcao for him then.
Better yet, play him in midfield, protecting the back four, where he wants to be the new "Roy Keane" ....He wasn't very good there was he?!

Please read what others are saying. No one has suggested that. He has the potential to be a very valuable squad player and gives us a different option for some matches. If you haven't followed his career there's no need to comment about his playing ability.

Well it's hardly a stupid comment on my behalf when I'm basing it from when I watched him play, last season, for MY team now is it?!?!?! Don't be so patronising!!
My mate is a hardcore Everton fan. I don't follow them so, I'm going by his word! And anytime I watched him play for Everton, he wasn't exactly the stand out player

Box to box against Arsenal?!?! You are joking right?!?! The same Arsenal we bossed in midfield with Park Ji Sung?!?!

Oh, and let's not forget Fellaini's interview some weeks back...Which was very telling

Exactly my point. The guy single-handedly won games for Everton against top opposition but he never stood out as the stand out player to you. It's ironic because he had a pretty decent outing once against YOUR team on an opening day of Sir Alex Ferguson's last season.

Yeah so playing well against Arsenal counts for nothing. Unless he has bossed Chelsea in midfield he is not eligible to be a squad player for Man United. And tell your mate and every other Everton fan you see that it's nice to see where their club are right now. I thought they were finally "relieved" with Moyes gone and Martinez was the guy they needed? I can assure you that 90 percent of Everton fans would not want to see Fellaini leave. Now that he's had a terrible season their just trying to "prove" that they knew this all along.

 

[.Rossi]

Please read what others are saying. No one has suggested that. He has the potential to be a very valuable squad player and gives us a different option for some matches. If you haven't followed his career there's no need to comment about his playing ability.





Exactly my point. The guy single-handedly won games for Everton against top opposition but he never stood out as the stand out player to you. It's ironic because he had a pretty decent outing once against YOUR team on an opening day of Sir Alex Ferguson's last season.

Yeah so playing well against Arsenal counts for nothing. Unless he has bossed Chelsea in midfield he is not eligible to be a squad player for Man United. And tell your mate and every other Everton fan you see that it's nice to see where their club are right now. I thought they were finally "relieved" with Moyes gone and Martinez was the guy they needed? I can assure you that 90 percent of Everton fans would not want to see Fellaini leave. Now that he's had a terrible season their just trying to "prove" that they knew this all along.

Oh Ok.....I must buy the boxset, "Fellaini, the golden years! U12s - U18s" before I can make a good judgement. Good Jesus......I don't follow Barcelona so, I best not make a judgement on Messi....He could be shit for all I know

Single handedly.....Good Jesus. No one wins a match on their own!

Again, you are ignoring that Fellaini came out and said he's not part of the first team plan at all, at the moment in a recent interview. He said he's going to have to fight and train his balls off to get a look in.....Yet, we have a guy, coming back from a career threatening illness, who is part of the plan....Does that not seem at all off to you no?!

Listen, I admire your persistent defense of the guy...It's endearing if nowt else...But, sooner or later, you'll concede defeat

It's like saying "Oh this is Anderson's year" in 2013.....Which btw, I must check again to see who said that

 

[Bwuk]

To be fair, Fellaini did dominate against us most of the time when we played Everton. We didn't have anyone who could deal with his size.

 

[Smoke On the Water]

@.Rossi You sound like a bit of a tool here to be honest. There is no need to get so snarky over your ignorance being called out. You keep repeating the same type of things over and over that make it obvious you haven't watched him, or know where his strengths lie.

I'm off to check on those comments as well. I am not sure he said he had no chance - I thought he just said there was competition and he aspired to be the best person for the first XI in the managers eyes. Not really sure what is wrong with that at all, if anything. Placating a bunch of toddler fans who are desperate to see the player leave would be very low on his priority list. I would think, anyway.

 

[Empire]

I love how people use the Bayern match to say he has no heading ability, it is ridiculous. Yes, he lost a few headers in that game. But I can think of countless matches where his aerial ability was strong and he won headers, but sure let's focus on that one game and pretend like it is the norm.

Offensively I think he is good at heading (attacking the ball to head on goal) but defensively I'm not so sure, I haven't seen enough to judge in all fairness but I don't want to because I have seen too many times when the ref is not looking he just throws his arms in someone's face.

Last thing we need is him getting sent off.

 

[JPRouve]

Please read what others are saying. No one has suggested that. He has the potential to be a very valuable squad player and gives us a different option for some matches. If you haven't followed his career there's no need to comment about his playing ability.





Exactly my point. The guy single-handedly won games for Everton against top opposition but he never stood out as the stand out player to you. It's ironic because he had a pretty decent outing once against YOUR team on an opening day of Sir Alex Ferguson's last season.

Yeah so playing well against Arsenal counts for nothing. Unless he has bossed Chelsea in midfield he is not eligible to be a squad player for Man United. And tell your mate and every other Everton fan you see that it's nice to see where their club are right now. I thought they were finally "relieved" with Moyes gone and Martinez was the guy they needed? I can assure you that 90 percent of Everton fans would not want to see Fellaini leave. Now that he's had a terrible season their just trying to "prove" that they knew this all along.

That's not true, i'm not trying to say bad thing against Fellaini but even in his best period he was at best, the 5th best player in Everton's team behind at least Baines, Jagielka, Distin and Howard.
Fellaini has been very good for Everton but never their best player.

 

[Siorac]

To be fair, Fellaini did dominate against us most of the time when we played Everton. We didn't have anyone who could deal with his size.

He dominated against us once, in that famous 2012/13 opening game. Where he bullied Carrick, playing at CB, in the air.

Vardy also dominated us at the weekend but I certainly wouldn't want him at United.

 

[Ekeke]

Going back to the Blind comparisons, it isn't laughable to suggest that Fellaini is a better player. I know people are blinded by their hate but he did actually play CM for Everton and put in some good performances. Blind has had one good performance for us and did relatively well in the Dutch league. Blind will probably be the better player but I don't think it is as one sided as everyone here thinks.

Blind obviously has a lot to prove in England, but hes also a completely different type of player. What hes better at, hes far better at than Fellaini. But hes not going to play as a forward and score goals

 

[MoskvaRed]

If, based on his Everton performances, he was a United level player, it's strange no one activated his buyout clause until his manager at Everton was (over) promoted to the United job. If you are still playing for a top 10 team into your mid-20s, then, in the absence of a Le Tissier-like sense of loyalty, it means you have probably found your level.

 

[Cheesy]

If, based on his Everton performances, he was a United level player, it's strange no one activated his buyout clause until his manager at Everton was (over) promoted to the United job. If you are still playing for a top 10 team into your mid-20s, then, in the absence of a Le Tissier-like sense of loyalty, it means you have probably found your level.

Yeah, while he was very good for Everton most of the time, I don't think I can really remember a lot of transfer windows where it seemed as if Everton were really struggling to hold onto him. Ironically, of course, in the season he left he ended up dropping down the table, compared to where he would have been with his old club.

 

[Manucho the boss]

If he starts against West Ham and wins a few headers we might be lucky enough to have fat Sam bid for him in January. I'd take £10m for him, prob cost us another few million to supplement his wages over the next few years though.

 

[Cheesy]

If he starts against West Ham and wins a few headers we might be lucky enough to have fat Sam bid for him in January. I'd take £10m for him, prob cost us another few million to supplement his wages over the next few years though.

Wouldn't surprise me actually, he'd be perfect for a side like West Ham. Considering how he's been here, £10m would be a good deal for us as well. No club is going to pay a lot more for someone who obviously doesn't have much of a future here, and it'd be great to get his wages off the bill.

 

[.Rossi]

@Smoke On the Water
You call me an ignorant tool, so do expect me to reply in a serious tone? Purely on the basis I haven't "followed his career" btw
For what its worth, I would be saying the same things if he was at Everton. . In fact, I did

 

[shamans]

That's not true, i'm not trying to say bad thing against Fellaini but even in his best period he was at best, the 5th best player in Everton's team behind at least Baines, Jagielka, Distin and Howard.
Fellaini has been very good for Everton but never their best player.

In terms of "best" player in skill and talent I don't know but there have been numerous matches that he was the "best player on the pitch" for them. BTW, Distin doesn't really belong on that list.

 

[Roboc7]

If, based on his Everton performances, he was a United level player, it's strange no one activated his buyout clause until his manager at Everton was (over) promoted to the United job. If you are still playing for a top 10 team into your mid-20s, then, in the absence of a Le Tissier-like sense of loyalty, it means you have probably found your level.

If we had appointed any manager other than Moyes he wouldn’t be here, if he was regarded by other managers as highly as a lot of people like to make out £23.5m was a bargain. However other managers knew that to get the best out of him you have to give him freedom and make sure you hit lots of long balls into his chest and head. He is a wrecking ball you send out to rough people up, bully players in the air and cause problems by simply getting any player in your back 4 to lump balls up to him. That is what he did at Everton, that’s what he is good at, it doesn’t matter how many times we play him or where we play him if we don’t play to his strengths he is a waste of space, as a box to box or defensive midfielder he is only an average do a job type player but use him as moyes did at Everton and he is effective enough to cause problems for anyone.

Writing is on the wall for him, he will go in one of the next two windows, not because he is a bad player but because he doesn’t fit in and we don’t need him.

 

[kouroux]

Why is he being criticized for doing charity work ? Wtf is wrong with some of you ?

 

[Kostur]

Why is he being criticized for doing charity work ? Wtf is wrong with some of you ?

Welcome to Fellaini thread, sanity and common sense do not apply here.

 

[.Rossi]

Why is he being criticized for doing charity work ? Wtf is wrong with some of you ?

Aye, that is harsh

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

Be nice to see the big man at some part of the game tomorrow. Had a very good game against West Ham last season, and has looked bright in the very few minutes he's had so far this season.

EDIT:

I'd like to see him come on for Di Maria if we've got like a two goal lead, having a midfield three of:

Fellaini - Herrera
Blind​

 

[OnlyTwoDaSilvas]

I'm not his biggest fan, but I want him to be given a proper chance under a better manager than Moyes. Regardless, I think he could come in use tomorrow, if he's fit. I think Blind could get bullied at DM if West Ham play a physical game, and the centre back pairing we field is likely to be a very inexperienced one. Fellaini could be usefull dropping back and getting under a few lofted balls and crosses. Just as long as he doesn't assault anyone, he could do well there. Just sit tight, and don't maraud forward. Leave that to Di Maria and Herrera.

 

[saivet]

Just stumbled across this, must be the first time I've seen this goal, pretty decent.

The lad get a hell of a lot unwarranted criticism.

 

[Gannicus]

I'm not a Fellaini fan at all, just to make that clear. Has he been cleared to play tomorrow? If so, we could probably use his menacing demeanor to cope with West Ham tomorrow after we take a two goal lead on them.

 

[OnlyTwoDaSilvas]

Just stumbled across this, must be the first time I've seen this goal, pretty decent.

The lad get a hell of a lot unwarranted criticism.

He's got some excellent highlights whilst at Everton. His touch and passing was often excellent. He had some great games against us too, and for more than just being a a physical clogger. It hasn't worked for him here yet, but I don't doubt his ability. He's a good player, and I still believe Van Gaal could get something out of him. If Fellaini can follow instruction, then I see him doing a decent job.

 

[C'est Moi Cantona]

I'm not a Fellaini fan at all, just to make that clear. Has he been cleared to play tomorrow? If so, we could probably use his menacing demeanor to cope with West Ham tomorrow after we take a two goal lead on them.

I thought he was miles off been ready, could be useful from the bench if he is fit.

At least the guy isn't spitting his dummy out about his situation like a few have, and wants to stay and fight for his place, may not be enough but nice to see.

 

[Van Piorsing]

Fellaini's good for Manchester United in Fifa 14 and 15. So far that's all I can say positive about his input in the new club.

Time for him to step up and just play the goddamn quality football.... in Manchester United. Please !?

 

[ZDwyr]

Just stumbled across this, must be the first time I've seen this goal, pretty decent.

The lad get a hell of a lot unwarranted criticism.

But but but I've been told by everyone here that he doesn't have a first touch

 

[AllezLesDiables]

Marouane is a good niche player that can look excellent with certain types of styles. The downside is that in the wrong style of play he's can look mediocre. The bigger issue is that he's being scapegoated for Moyes despite the fact that United offered him the money and transfer. What was he supposed to say? No, I don't think I'll take a pay raise or be part of the biggest club in England.

He's got value for United but given that the team hasn't figured itself out yet it's a bit harsh to run him off without seeing what he can bring to the table. Maybe it won't work out, but it's not like he has zero pedigree. He's capable of influencing games.

 

[NoWinNoFee]

I'd rather see Fellaini on the pitch than Darren Fletcher that's for sure.

 

[KiD MoYeS]

He can do a job in the midfield diamond, it'll help him to have competent midfield teammates like di Maria and Herrera.

 

[izec]

he played behind the striker for the goal, he would never be in this position for us. There is a big differnece in delivering for Everton and delivering for United. He would never score that goal for us. He has a lot of pressure now to save his career here, but in the end will be sold.

 

[.Rossi]

he played behind the striker for the goal, he would never be in this position for us. There is a big differnece in delivering for Everton and delivering for United. He would never score that goal for us. He has a lot of pressure now to save his career here, but in the end will be sold.

Sense!

Not to mention when he was giving a certain role, he continuously lost his man and that cost us before

 

[Lawman]

Well it's hardly a stupid comment on my behalf when I'm basing it from when I watched him play, last season, for MY team now is it?!?!?! Don't be so patronising!!
My mate is a hardcore Everton fan. I don't follow them so, I'm going by his word! And anytime I watched him play for Everton, he wasn't exactly the stand out player

Box to box against Arsenal?!?! You are joking right?!?! The same Arsenal we bossed in midfield with Park Ji Sung?!?!

Oh, and let's not forget Fellaini's interview some weeks back...Which was very telling

The same Park that never gave Pirlo a kick of the ball also buddy!

 

[Lawman]

Marouane is a good niche player that can look excellent with certain types of styles. The downside is that in the wrong style of play he's can look mediocre. The bigger issue is that he's being scapegoated for Moyes despite the fact that United offered him the money and transfer. What was he supposed to say? No, I don't think I'll take a pay raise or be part of the biggest club in England.

He's got value for United but given that the team hasn't figured itself out yet it's a bit harsh to run him off without seeing what he can bring to the table. Maybe it won't work out, but it's not like he has zero pedigree. He's capable of influencing games.

I hope he gets a chance as he has quality no doubt. Last year it was his first season (he had injury problems with operations) plus the team and club were in disarray hardly a great environment to settle in.

 

[LR7]

I don't see what 'job' he could do for us. He's hardly the steel we need in midfield. He doesn't rough people up a bit and make his presence felt or intimidate the opposition, he just incessantly gives away niggly, pathetic fouls. As for every other footballing quality, he's inferior to the three we currently have in midfield positionally and technically.

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

He's back! If we play the diamond against Everton, with Herrera currently out, I'd replace him with Fellaini. I feel he's much more suited to the box to box role than Fletcher, as he's more of a threat going forward and has the stamina to get back.

I would play a midfield diamond of:

Blind
Fellaini - Di Maria
Mata
​

 

[Sam]

He should be as far away from the team as physically possible.