Mario Mandzukic or Arnautovic

Who should United sign?


  • Total voters
    343
  • Poll closed .
I’m sure he’s a nice bloke off the pitch, but whenever I watch him he’s throwing his elbows around, rolling around or generally being a bit of a dick trying to get a rise out of the opposition. I’m sure it’s more enjoyable when he’s doing it for your team, but I’d rather not go there.
He's not that bad.
 
I'd definitely take Arnautovic as back up striker/wide forward. I think he's looked a lot better through the middle at West Ham. Great first touch as well, could definitely stick with him up top.
 
I’m sure he’s a nice bloke off the pitch, but whenever I watch him he’s throwing his elbows around, rolling around or generally being a bit of a dick trying to get a rise out of the opposition. I’m sure it’s more enjoyable when he’s doing it for your team, but I’d rather not go there.

you know, we do need a replacement for Fellaini in this area
 
He was good enough to be a target for Bayern and Juve, but not us apparently.
I think I'll need to leave this thread early. It will prove to be my Perišić thread from last year. Already so much crap written. :D
 
I think I'll need to leave this thread early. It will prove to be my Perišić thread from last year. Already so much crap written. :D

I was defending Perisic as well last summer :lol:. These are good players!
 
On another note, looks like hoofball is here to stay. :(
 
I really like Arnautovic. Every time I watched him this season he was absolutely brilliant.
 
He doesn't like using Martial or Rashford at striker, so this makes sense. I just hope he doesn't make whoever we sign a secondary option on the left wing as well.
 
Mandzukic is so much better player than Arnautovic in almost every aspect of the game, that people who claim otherwise should be thred banned, for crying out loud.


But being honest, neither Mandzukic nor Arnautovic should be at Utd: Mandzukic is 32 and has no future and Arnautovic is a decent player who sometimes shows glimpses of brilliancy.
 
Physical player to lead the line when Lukaku is out. Dzeko would probably be too pricey for a backup role. Mandzukic might not be a bad option. I'd expect this might spell the end for one of Rashford/Martial.
 
Let’s sign some fullbacks first.
 
Mandzukic is so much better player than Arnautovic in almost every aspect of the game, that people who claim otherwise should be thred banned, for crying out loud.


But being honest, neither Mandzukic nor Arnautovic should be at Utd: Mandzukic is 32 and has no future and Arnautovic is a decent player who sometimes shows glimpses of brilliancy.

Bit harsh, I'm sure the fella has some plans for his life. :lol:
 
I can't see us interested in them unless they are free agents.
 
Mandzukic would be a great signing. Experience, works hard, scores goals and is versatile. We need leaders and warriors in our team. He would be a great squad option.
 
Mandzukic would be a canny acquisition.

I also wouldn’t say no to Arnautovic, he seems to have matured and we need more x-factor in the team. Jose has worked him before so will know all about him.
 
32 years old .... :wenger:

We should target Buffon, Inzagi and Pirlo as well.
Or maybe Ibrahimovic? Or Henrik Larsson? Or Teddy Sheringham.

The guy would be a back-up. Hopefully. If we got him cheap, it would be a good signing.
 
With the Fred signing being very exciting and possibly being the missing link so that Pogba can be freed while having and extra DM who can also be a deep playmaker - I think Mandzukic makes a lot of sense as a Fellani replacement to come for last 15 mins in games to change the strategy in tight games.
 
Why, cause of this rumors?

Stay? We hardly ever play hoofball. I think you mean crossing
It was a joke, I have no problems with long balls (we do play lots of long balls).
I think Mourinho doesn't like the fact that he has no striker to play long balls to when Lukaku isn't playing. I just wish bringing in someone like Mandzukic doesn't stop us from vastly importing our transition play with the ball on the ground. Something we are nowhere near good enough at present.
That said, I rate Mandzukic highly.
 
We might as well go for Steve Mounie, who's excellent in the air.
 
It was a joke, I have no problems with long balls (we do play lots of long balls).
I think Mourinho doesn't like the fact that he has no striker to play long balls to when Lukaku isn't playing. I just wish bringing in someone like Mandzukic doesn't stop us from vastly importing our transition play with the ball on the ground. Something we are nowhere near good enough at present.
That said, I rate Mandzukic highly.
Fair enough. :) He's very good in the air but I'm with you on that, I hope too it wont mean just going for the long balls. Mandža's build up play is very good, not to mention he gives his all every game.
 
I like to get mario, if lukaku ankle problems linger into the season we are in trouble with rashford up top. We need a capable backup.
 
I wouldn't mind Arnautovic as backup to Lukaku, think he's a good player, and very underrated. Always gives his all.
Haven't seen Mandzukic alot, so don't know that much about him.