Luis Nani | 2011/12 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
feck me, so we're not allowed to be critical of any of our players on this forum (unless it's Berbatov/Carrick/Evans)?

On his day, Nani can be devasting. But he doesn't have those days as often as we'd like to see. He even admits that himself. Yesterday, I thought he was decent, nothing special apart from his cross for the 1st goal. He struggled to beat the left back on numerous occasions, in the sense that his cross just bounced of the defenders legs for a corner/throw in. The resulting corners were dog piss.

I also think he holds on to the ball longer than he needs to - thus saying his decision making still needs working on.

I have no qualms about his defensive work/tracking back because he does that really well. He's just one of those players that frustrates the shite out of me. But hey ho, that doesn't sit well with the caf. I guess i'll just have to deal with that. Somehow

I feel your pain.

Now please provide the several occasions of bad decision making.
 
I think I've noticed a bit more of a change in Nani's game this season in comparison to last. He's been less about beating his man and whipping in a cross and more about linking up superbly with our forwards and midfield using his close control and one touch passing. He's not as productive so far this season but he's probably more involved in the build up than he ever has been.

He's not hit the form of last season just yet but he's getting back into his groove. Once he starts beating players easily again thats when we will know he's back.

Agree completely with your assessment of this change in his style. It's a good change given we as a team have started relying more on our intricate link up play. At the same time, if he can combine it with his usual explosiveness he'll be something else.
 
I thought he was poor yesterday. The decision making around when to cross or take the man on was poor. It stymied our attacking options.
 
Can't believe there isn't a MJ inspired song for Nani yet
 
So how exactly did he played yesterday?
Didn't watched the match, some contradiction opinions here. He looked good on the MoTD Highlights btw.
 
He's on the up. Put in some nice crosses. Was consistent in his passing. Lost the balls a few times early in the game. I'm sure he was happy with his performance.
 
So how exactly did he played yesterday?
Didn't watched the match, some contradiction opinions here. He looked good on the MoTD Highlights btw.

For me, he had a great first 20 minutes, our biggest attacking threat, stunning cross for the goal and some excellent link up play around the box. After that Norwich took control and he saw much less of the ball and because of that he couldn't get a hold of things as well. A few poor touches here and there. Admittedly I was so immersed in the Spurs-Arse game that I didn't pay a lot of attention to our 2nd half, but he was average in it.

Overall he was by no means "poor" and there was nothing wrong with his decisions.
 
So how exactly did he played yesterday?
Didn't watched the match, some contradiction opinions here. He looked good on the MoTD Highlights btw.

First 20mins, we were all over norwich and they struggled to deal with us. Nani was our biggest outlet then and norwich couldnt handle him. he was linking up beautifully with welbeck and hernandez.

After that we stopped playing and he saw very little of the ball.

Once we conceded, we stepped up again and he was instrumental in that making penetrative runs towards the end and linking up with the strikers and with jones bombing forward.

Had a very good game imo whenever he got the ball. Wasnt wasteful, was direct and a consistent threat. how anybody could class his performance yesterday as poor is beyond me.
 
He was actually great in the last 10 minutes as well when we needed some inspiration. He put in one lovely cross that was cleared by a defender very close to the keeper. He also played a very good pass to Giggs which lead to Welbeck's headed chance.

Overall, very good performance from Nani. In addition to those moments in the last 10 he barely gave the ball away (as provided by the stats above somewhere) and created the first goal and generally linked up very well with Welbeck.
 
I've somehow got a reputation of being persistently harsh on Nani and I thought he did very well against Norwich, especially in the opening and closing stages. Brilliant assist and some really creative, incisive short passing.

So if that's how I saw the game he must have been fecking fantastic!
 
I've somehow got a reputation of being persistently harsh on Nani and I thought he did very well against Norwich, especially in the opening and closing stages. Brilliant assist and some really creative, incisive short passing.

So if that's how I saw the game he must have been fecking fantastic!

:lol:
 
I've somehow got a reputation of being persistently harsh on Nani and I thought he did very well against Norwich, especially in the opening and closing stages. Brilliant assist and some really creative, incisive short passing.

So if that's how I saw the game he must have been fecking fantastic!

No, apparently he made the wrong decision everytime he got into attacking areas and was frustrating in general :wenger:
 
I've somehow got a reputation of being persistently harsh on Nani and I thought he did very well against Norwich, especially in the opening and closing stages. Brilliant assist and some really creative, incisive short passing.

So if that's how I saw the game he must have been fecking fantastic!

:lol: Well played Pogue.
 
Was only half-watching the game on the laptop but I thought he looked very good too. Loving the burgeoning understanding between Nani and Welbeck, it's sure to guarantee us some magical goals at some point down the line. Providing we don't swap him for Sneijder, of course.
 
Don't know if that's serious or not.

But Nani is worth more than a swap for Sneider. And he doesn't ask for crazy wages. Yet.
 
I've somehow got a reputation of being persistently harsh on Nani and I thought he did very well against Norwich, especially in the opening and closing stages. Brilliant assist and some really creative, incisive short passing.

So if that's how I saw the game he must have been fecking fantastic!

Didn't Jones cross for Scholesy's goal, and Young for Giggsy's? Where'd you get a Nani assist from?
 
Ah, ok... My bad.

I like the fact that we have so many capable crossers. Rafael, Giggs, Valencia, Nani, Young, Rooney. We lacked that for a while prior to our naughties resurgence.
 
I don't think its being too harsh on Nani to say that his use of the ball at times is the biggest reason that he isn't a genuine world class player.

There still aren't many players that I'd swap him with though.
 
I don't think its being too harsh on Nani to say that his use of the ball at times is the biggest reason that he isn't a genuine world class player.

There still aren't many players that I'd swap him with though.

He is a genuine world class player though. He's one of the 3/4 most important players for the biggest club in England and one of the top teams in Europe. He's World Class.
 
He is a genuine world class player though. He's one of the 3/4 most important players for the biggest club in England and one of the top teams in Europe. He's World Class.
He isn't. World Class should mean, if Earth picked a squad to play Mars tomorrow, who would be in it. Nani wouldn't.
 
He isn't. World Class should mean, if Earth picked a squad to play Mars tomorrow, who would be in it. Nani wouldn't.

Thats the worst definition i've come across.

Here's a list of some of the strikers.

Messi Ronaldo Rooney RVP Aguero Villa Eto'o

Only 1 or at the max 2 World class among them? Really?

One could do the same for midfielders and come up with this list

Xavi Iniesta Fabregas Busquets Alonso Schweinsteiger Yaya Toure

Same questions. Arent all of these World class players?

PS- I hate the term because everybody just mends it to suit their opinion but yours is a real strange one.
 
Thats the worst definition i've come across.

Here's a list of some of the strikers.

Messi Ronaldo Rooney RVP Aguero Villa Eto'o

Only 1 or at the max 2 World class among them? Really?

One could do the same for midfielders and come up with this list

Xavi Iniesta Fabregas Busquets Alonso Schweinsteiger Yaya Toure

Same questions. Arent all of these World class players?

PS- I hate the term because everybody just mends it to suit their opinion but yours is a real strange one.
Its a strange definition of world-class, sure. Its banded around too often these days though. Seems as good a way as any of defining it.
 
My mistake, who picks the squad for the game against Mars then? Is he the person who decides who is World Class and who isn't? God, that's a lot of responsibility on his shoulders.

the question is, If God is the creator of everything (which includes mars AND earth) why would he make the two planets play against each other? Everything about this is weird.
 
Its a strange definition of world-class, sure. Its banded around too often these days though. Seems as good a way as any of defining it.

I'd say it seems a pretty shit way to define World Class, in truth, but i'll play along.

So, who would be in the squad then, if Nani isn't in it? I assume it would be a 25 man "World Squad", with 4 wingers? Which 4 are better than Nani?
 
the question is, If God is the creator of everything (which includes mars AND earth) why would he make the two planets play against each other? Everything about this is weird.

Maybe this is where the future of football lies. While mere mortals like ourselves are wondering if there will ever be a European Super League, God, in conjunction with his agent on Earth, Bilbo, is planning an Inter-Planetary Super League.
 
I'd say it seems a pretty shit way to define World Class, in truth, but i'll play along.

So, who would be in the squad then, if Nani isn't in it? I assume it would be a 25 man "World Squad", with 4 wingers? Which 4 are better than Nani?
Christ knows. I can't say I've given it much though to be honest.

To get back on track though, its his distribution of the ball that would be stopping Nani from getting into the esteemed Earth squad.
 
Christ knows. I can't say I've given it much though to be honest.

To get back on track though, its his distribution of the ball that would be stopping Nani from getting into the esteemed Earth squad.

It wasn't obvious at first that you'd posted without thinking it through. Glad you've pointed it out now though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.