Liverpool - 2017/18

I’m not quoting any specific posts as I’d be here all day. I’m not surprised by a lot of biased on a Man United forum about Liverpool as I’m sure you’d see a lot the other way round on a Liverpool forum but a lot of stuff said on here feels quite ignorant to very clear and obvious things.

Firstly teams parking the bus against Liverpool. One of the two major advantages City have over Liverpool against these sorts of teams are very good full backs who can stretch the oppositions back line to open up space for the attackers in the middle. The other major advantage they have is the quality of their midfielders and the passing range of those midfielders. One of the massive problems we had against Swansea was our full backs not pushing high enough up the pitch to stretch their back line meaning there was never any room through the middle for Salah/Firmino. City are extremely good at stretching the play on the wings, which is exactly why Sane plays so much on the left while Mendy is out as they need someone to stretch play on the left and Sane does that and then of course Walker does it on the right. They have the quality in that midfield to make pin point passes which is something Liverpool lack massively. None of our current midfielders have the passing ability to pick out a sharp run from Mane or Salah which is exactly why we’re desperate for a deep lying playmaker next year, like a Xabi Alonso or even Mousa Dembele type midfielder. I honestly think we have a better front 3 than City, it’s their midfield that is light years ahead of ours which allows their forwards to nearly a season prolific as ours. But yeah there’s nothing wrong with Klopp’s system, it can work against any team, it’s some of the personnel that are still the issue in my opinion. His pressing style obviously works better against teams who want to take the ball but it still works fine against parking the bus teams and if anything this season our results against those sorts of sides have actually been better than last season. We’ve only lost to one non top 6 team in the league this season and that was the Swansea game.

Next is this mentality of we’re making progress so we’re happy. I have this mentality as do a lot of Liverpool fans because what you have to remember is it’s been 6 years since we last won a trophy and excluding the two finals in Klopp’s “first” season we’ve not been anywhere near any since. We’d all love a trophy of course but honestly right now in mine and most Liverpool fans heads what we want is to become a top European team again. For United for the 5 seasons post SAF, 3 of them you’ve been in the UCL, 1 in Europa which you won so you’re still a top European team and attract quality players regardless of UCL, it’s not the same for us. We’ve been in the UCL twice in the last 8 seasons and not been in the knockout stage since 2009. Reality is we’ve not been a big club for a long time and what we want is to become one again. Most Liverpool fans seeing as this is Klopp’s second full season are content with top 4 again and a decent enough run in the UCL. However (assuming we get top 4) a lot of us are now expecting we push for a trophy next year and have a proper title challenge. We fell pretty far as a club and a lot of us realise that it takes time to get back to the top. That’s why we’re content as long as we can stay in the UCL and attract top players so that we are able to progress to a title challenging and trophy challenging team. Klopp is 100% the right man for the job, the question is in my mind whether FSG will give him the money he needs for the imo the 4 new starters he needs this summer. Also what you have to consider is, would a player rather win the FA Cup and come 6th or play UCL and come 3rd in the league. If it was me I’d rather play in the Champions League. Top top players want both and if we want to keep our top players we will need to start doing both but for now I’m content with consistently being in the UCL.

I really don’t understand the insults on spending £75m on Van Dijk. I get he was in the Swansea and West Brom games but goodness me they were his 2nd and 3rd games for the club and he’s obviously going to take time to adjust. It’s like me insulting Sanchez for his performance against Tottenham. Just seems ignorant and idiotic. There’s no denying Van Dijk’s quality just like there’s isn’t Sanchez’s. The last 2 games Van Dijk has played for us I can honestly say we’re probably 2 of the most assured defensive performances I’ve seen for quite a while from Liverpool. He reads the game like no other Liverpool defender I’ve seen in recent times, he wins like 80% of his aerial duels and his passing ability was astounding at Porto. He’s took control of that back 4 and everyone is looking more assured and in control around him as well including Lovren and Karius. I know it’s all banter and what not but I get a bit of bored of it. I actually respect Man United massively as a club even as a Liverpool fan, I often just find it’s the fans that are the issue. However then again that’s the same at every club, but because of the rivalry United fans are incredibly biased and often straight up lie in an attempt to make a point. It is quite infuriating however I do realise Liverpool fans also do the same.

I believe if Liverpool invest the Coutinho money + summer sales on a deep lying playmaker like Torreira or Rabiot, a CAM/Winger like Pulisic or Fekir, another CB like Upamecano or Koulibaly and then if Karius doesn’t come good a goalkeeper like Alisson they can challenge for trophies and the league next season. But I also believe that so can United with the right investments (CM, CB, LB) and the correct tactics to get the best out of Pogba. I’m just enjoying seeing the Premiership getting stronger as it just makes for better viewing football (in most cases!).
 
Erm... whose gonna tell him?
Feel like his statement is a bit strong (aka wrong) but I understand his point. I think he’s saying players would rather play in the UCL than win the FA Cup which I do think is probably true. However, top players want both and if they don’t get both they’ll probably move on pretty quickly as their football careers are contextually pretty short.
 
Erm... whose gonna tell him?

If you actually read the thread, you'd see I was talking about the cups.

:lol:

Besides Leicester's miracle season, name one Premier League club that recently succeeded in challenging for the top competitions who weren't also taking cup competitions seriously? Apply that same question to any major league in Europe. To win the top things, requires a winning mentality throughout the team.

As someone who has seen first-hand players' response to winning domestic cups over the last few seasons, I can tell you that your claim they don't care is simply rubbish. As for the 24 months expiry date, that could happen irregardless of what a club may have won 2 years previously. 2 years can be a lifetime in football. Don't get me wrong, I love that some Liverpool fans are more than happy to prioritise finishing top 4 over actually winning something, and I agree there is a logic to it - particularly in the current football climate. But if you are seriously wanting to win stuff - you know, the aim of football - then you've surely got to get back in the habit of walking before you run? Seriously, if your squad got a taste for winning, I'd be worried about what you could achieve.

The way things are in the Premier League currently, any club other than City claiming to have established themselves as a shoe in for top 4 is unlikely to happen any time soon.

You have won one league cup in 12 seasons. Wigan have a better record than that having won a more prestigious cup. You held a open-top bus parade for the league cup win. If I was a Liverpool fan, I'd be fuming at that record. People laughed at Arsenal's baron period a few seasons back, but that record pails in contrast to your current streak.

Suggesting cups lead to greater success is all fantasy. Those 3 FA cups kept Sanchez at Arsenal didn't they?

The fact is that the cups are second rate trophies which really aren't important anymore. CL qualification is a greater achievement in today's game, like it or not.
 
Last edited:
Far from it. Spending huge money on players and hope it fixes is like shooting in the dark. Klopp had 5 tranfser window to address major problem and to say that the problem still exists, shows that he doesn't care enough or cannot fix it. I have no issues with Klopp's front line. However, even with good defenders, with they way they commit players on the offense, i don't know if they could hold onto say a 1 goal lead in a crucial tie. That's their problem with the cup competition.
You mean like Jose? Of course with a better defence Liverpool are going to be better
 
If you actually read the thread, you'd see I was talking about the cups.



Suggesting cups lead to greater success is all fantasy. Those 3 FA cups kept Sanchez at Arsenal didn't they?

The fact is that the cups are second rate trophies which really aren't important anymore. CL qualification is a greater achievement in today's game, like it or not.

I actually wouldn’t disagree with you on that point. My argument is that if you are serious about mounting challenges to the league and champions league, a winning mentality and experience is vital. Particularly when the core of your team has no experience of this.

It’s here that taking domestic cup success seriously plays an importance. Your point re Alexis is fair, but how much sooner would he have left without those FA cups?

I know you want to focus on cementing yourself as a top 4 regular, but other than city I can’t see anyone doing that soon. I think we could get there in a season or two given our wealth advantage, but I’m not totally convinced yet. With that being the case, immediate cup success is even more important.
 
Of course silverware is important and I'd gladly trade a year of attracting football for a year playing shite but winning the Premier League, don't get me wrong. It's just that I'm very happy we do play such attractive football even though it hasn't translated in trophies so far. I hardly miss any game while I can assure you it'd be a chore for me to sit through every United game the last four years if I see them play from time to time, so fecking dull and uninspiring.

Serious question.

How did you stick it through the last couple decades of being a Liverpool fan, assuming you’re older than about 12?

Even your best sides who actually won stuff weren’t even close to the current United side in terms of talent on display and attractive football.

You guys wrote every book on winning ugly. Liverpool can’t have played more than a handful of seasons of good football in your lifetime.

How much of a chore has it been for you?
 
They are major trophies, or at least they have been for the last decade or so as your lot have desperately tried to cling onto your "most successful club in England" medal.

Obviously we'd swap them for the Champions League and Premier League in a heartbeat, but considering we weren't even in the CL last season, and it became abundantly clear by around October that we weren't really in title-challenging condition, I'll gladly celebrate winning two of the three competitions we stood a realistic chance in. At the end of the day, our Europa League win booked us a place in the CL group stages and won us a trophy. Your fourth place saw you having to face a play-off and you had nothing to show for it.

It's all well and good you talking about how the PL and CL trophies are all that matter, but do you actually consider Liverpool to have a realistic chance of winning either? As I said in my previous response to you, the PL has the strongest Top 6 it has had for a number of years, and you are all but guaranteed to face one, if not two or more of Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, Barcelona, PSG, Juventus, and the other English sides en-route to any CL final.

If United can't win the PL or CL, which is looking likely to be the case this year, I want them to go for the cups. We're out of one, but have as good a chance as anyone else in the FA Cup. I would sacrifice second for fourth right now if it meant guaranteeing the FA Cup this season, even if that also meant Liverpool finishing second. However, I see no reason why we can't finish second, win the FA Cup, and get to at least the quarters, if not further, in the CL.

Arsenal spent the best part of a decade focusing on not competing for league titles or CL trophies OTE="Alex99, post: 22187867, member: 43985"]They are major trophies, or at least they have been for the last decade or so as your lot have desperately tried to cling onto your "most successful club in England" medal.

Obviously we'd swap them for the Champions League and Premier League in a heartbeat, but considering we weren't even in the CL last season, and it became abundantly clear by around October that we weren't really in title-challenging condition, I'll gladly celebrate winning two of the three competitions we stood a realistic chance in. At the end of the day, our Europa League win booked us a place in the CL group stages and won us a trophy. Your fourth place saw you having to face a play-off and you had nothing to show for it.

It's all well and good you talking about how the PL and CL trophies are all that matter, but do you actually consider Liverpool to have a realistic chance of winning either? As I said in my previous response to you, the PL has the strongest Top 6 it has had for a number of years, and you are all but guaranteed to face one, if not two or more of Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, Barcelona, PSG, Juventus, and the other English sides en-route to any CL final.

If United can't win the PL or CL, which is looking likely to be the case this year, I want them to go for the cups. We're out of one, but have as good a chance as anyone else in the FA Cup. I would sacrifice second for fourth right now if it meant guaranteeing the FA Cup this season, even if that also meant Liverpool finishing second. However, I see no reason why we can't finish second, win the FA Cup, and get to at least the quarters, if not further, in the CL.

Arsenal spent the best part of a decade focusing on not competing for league titles or CL trophies at expense of the domestic cups, and they became nothing other than a joke. If you can't win the best thing, you've got to try and win the next best thing, not feck it off as early as possible under the guise of not caring. Football is a game about winning, and I'm always completely baffled by football fans who don't care about their team winning because they're "entertaining".
You keep saying, that we don't care about winning. Are you not reading the responses? Winning is important. But winning the major trophies is the most important. Of course the small cups matters, but not very much compared to PL and CL. They are not major trophies imo. The important numbers here are 18-5, and 20-3.

You talk about Arsenal like they were a joke, when they always finished fourth.. So tell me, what are they now, with their recent succes in the domestic cups? Their fans sure don't look happy despite 3 FA Cups in four years..

There is a reason, why Liverpool and Tottenham fans overall are happy for the time being, despite no silverware. They feel, that their clubs are moving in the right direction, they get decent results, and they play some good football quite often..

Neither Arsenal, or you guys, seem to enjoy it very much, despite your recent silverware.
 
Last edited:
Serious question.

How did you stick it through the last couple decades of being a Liverpool fan, assuming you’re older than about 12?

Even your best sides who actually won stuff weren’t even close to the current United side in terms of talent on display and attractive football.

You guys wrote every book on winning ugly. Liverpool can’t have played more than a handful of seasons of good football in your lifetime.

How much of a chore has it been for you?
I was born in ‘93 and started following them after the mini treble season, and more actively since the ‘09 season, so not that long ago actually although I was already a fan when we won the CL and FA Cup in ‘05 and ‘06 (both great finals). The only time it well and truly hurt was the 13/14 season, that really sucked. The lost EL final against Sevilla wasn’t nice either but apart from that, it’s all been good to me. An early FA Cup exit like the last few season sucks for a few days but you’re not gonna sulk about it for the rest of the season, are you? Likewise with the title, I’ve accepted for several months that we aren’t going to win it so I’ll be happy when we achieve the next best thing which is a second consecutive top 4 finish - small steps and all that. It would be great to win something and maybe it will hurt more after experiencing 25 years of winning nothing at all but right now I still enjoy watching us play and cheering us on, and it’s not like I can have any impact on it or switch allegiance, so I’ll just have to live with it if it stays like this.
 
You keep saying, that we don't care about winning. Are you not reading the responses? Winning is important. But winning the major trophies is the most important. Of course the small cups matters, but not very much compared to PL and CL. They are not major trophies imo. The important numbers here are 18-5, and 20-3.

You talk about Arsenal like they were a joke, when they always finished fourth.. So tell me, what are they now, with their recent succes in the domestic cups? Their fans sure don't look happy despite 3 FA Cups in four years..

You keep saying, that we don't care about winning. Are you not reading the responses? Winning is important. But winning the major trophies is the most important. Of course the small cups matters, but not very much compared to PL and CL. They are not major trophies imo. The important numbers here are 18-5, and 20-3.

You talk about Arsenal like they were a joke, when they always finished fourth.. So tell me, what are they now, with their recent succes in the domestic cups? Their fans sure don't look happy despite 3 FA Cups in four years..

There is a reason, why Liverpool and Tottenham fans overall are happy for the time being, despite no silverware. They feel, that their clubs are moving in the right direction, they get decent results, and they play some good football quite often..

Neither Arsenal, or you guys, seem to enjoy it very much, despite your recent silverware.

Some of your fans may lack ambition, but your players certainly don’t (at least the better ones anyway). Which is why you keep losing them. And why you’ll continue to lose them. Top 4 medals won’t cut it when they’re telling the grandkids about their playing days.

Sure some medals are bigger achievements than others. But the major domestic cup medal or a European medal of any kind aren’t to be sniffed at.

It also gives purpose to the season and a culmination of the work the team have put in. Seeing players, particularly young ones, giddy after a Cup final with medals and taking their turn getting a photo with the trophy. That’s something. What does 4th get you? A few fist pumps and back slaps after some of the wins along the way I guess. No big celebration. Nothing for the fans. Nothing to show off in future years. Nothing added to the club’s cabinets.

And don’t tell me success doesn’t breed success. The greatest predictor of future trophies is current and past trophies.
 
Some of your fans may lack ambition, but your players certainly don’t (at least the better ones anyway). Which is why you keep losing them. And why you’ll continue to lose them. Top 4 medals won’t cut it when they’re telling the grandkids about their playing days.

Sure some medals are bigger achievements than others. But the major domestic cup medal or a European medal of any kind aren’t to be sniffed at.

It also gives purpose to the season and a culmination of the work the team have put in. Seeing players, particularly young ones, giddy after a Cup final with medals and taking their turn getting a photo with the trophy. That’s something. What does 4th get you? A few fist pumps and back slaps after some of the wins along the way I guess. No big celebration. Nothing for the fans. Nothing to show off in future years. Nothing added to the club’s cabinets.

And don’t tell me success doesn’t breed success. The greatest predictor of future trophies is current and past trophies.
You want to learn me about ambitions, and then you talk about how important minor cups are.. Actually, I find that to be unambitious. United fans in Fergusons time would have laughed at the thought of valuing Leage cups and Europa Leagues.

We don't lose players because of not winning minor cups.. We lose players, because we're not challenging or even participating in the major ones.

Do you really think a League Cup or a Europa League will satisfy the best players?? Of course it won't.. They want to play in CL against the best.
 
I was born in ‘93 and started following them after the mini treble season, and more actively since the ‘09 season, so not that long ago actually although I was already a fan when we won the CL and FA Cup in ‘05 and ‘06 (both great finals). The only time it well and truly hurt was the 13/14 season, that really sucked. The lost EL final against Sevilla wasn’t nice either but apart from that, it’s all been good to me. An early FA Cup exit like the last few season sucks for a few days but you’re not gonna sulk about it for the rest of the season, are you? Likewise with the title, I’ve accepted for several months that we aren’t going to win it so I’ll be happy when we achieve the next best thing which is a second consecutive top 4 finish - small steps and all that. It would be great to win something and maybe it will hurt more after experiencing 25 years of winning nothing at all but right now I still enjoy watching us play and cheering us on, and it’s not like I can have any impact on it or switch allegiance, so I’ll just have to live with it if it stays like this.

What I’m talking about is that in those years you’ve largely played poor football. To paraphrase Bill Shankly - if Liverpool were playing at the bottom of your garden, you’d close the curtains.

How the hell would it be a chore for you to watch United as a fan when you chose to start supporting Liverpool under Gerard Houllier and solidified your fandom under Benitez, two managaers responsible some of the most negative styles of play ever bestowed on Liverpool sides.

You use attractive football as a crutch for failure and claim you couldn’t sit through United matches, yet have happily sat through much much worse for years. Startling lack of self-awareness? Or just a bullshitter?
 
You want to learn me about ambitions, and then you talk about how important minor cups are.. Actually, I find that to be unambitious. United fans in Fergusons time would have laughed at the thought of valuing Leage cups and Europa Leagues.

We don't lose players because of not winning minor cups.. We lose players, because we're not challenging or even participating in the major ones.

Do you really think a League Cup or a Europa League will satisfy the best players?? Of course it won't.. They want to play in CL against the best.

The league cup win post-keane was huge for us so you've ballsed that up fairly quickly
 
You want to learn me about ambitions, and then you talk about how important minor cups are.. Actually, I find that to be unambitious. United fans in Fergusons time would have laughed at the thought of valuing Leage cups and Europa Leagues.

We don't lose players because of not winning minor cups.. We lose players, because we're not challenging or even participating in the major ones.

Do you really think a League Cup or a Europa League will satisfy the best players?? Of course it won't.. They want to play in CL against the best.

It’s unambitious to want to win trophies. :lol:

Has your barren spell made you guys completely lose the plot?

There is no either/or here. You can win cups, and leagues, and CLs. You don’t choose just to win the FA Cup and then that precludes you from ever picking up a league or a CL. Success breeds success. There isn’t some invisible barrier which says if you get top 4, you can’t win trophies in the same season.

Liverpool are failing as a club for a decade now. Even Spurs most ardent and one-eyed fans (Glastonspur) accept that despite the good work the club has done they need to win trophies to self-actualise. Some of your fans seem to get it. There was a time Liverpool existed to win trophies and nothing else mattered. The nouveau LFC fan seems happy with twitter gifs of pretty passing moves and football without consequence.
 
It’s unambitious to want to win trophies. :lol:

Has your barren spell made you guys completely lose the plot?

There is no either/or here. You can win cups, and leagues, and CLs. You don’t choose just to win the FA Cup and then that precludes you from ever picking up a league or a CL. Success breeds success. There isn’t some invisible barrier which says if you get top 4, you can’t win trophies in the same season.

Liverpool are failing as a club for a decade now. Even Spurs most ardent and one-eyed fans (Glastonspur) accept that despite the good work the club has done they need to win trophies to self-actualise. Some of your fans seem to get it. There was a time Liverpool existed to win trophies and nothing else mattered. The nouveau LFC fan seems happy with twitter gifs of pretty passing moves and football without consequence.
Ok.. I get it.. The League Cup and Europa League last year are proof, that Manchester United had a great season and because of these two important trophies, you are succesful now, and will be in the future. But actually.. Wasn't it a treble for you last season? You won the Charity shield too, didn't you? What a glorious season you had!

You must be happy with the way things are going for you. And the players must be happy too, because they can tell their grandchildren, about the legendary runs to win these important trophies..

It must be a great feeling being a United fan in such a succesful era.. I guess Red Cafe must be loaded with positive vibes?

Or.. Is there something missing? Succes in major tournaments? A direction? Are you not entertained?
 
This whole line of discussion annoys me. There is this idea on here that every time one of the top 6 get eliminated from a domestic cup or the Europa League there is this idea that they did not want to win or they did not value the trophy. We were the League Cup winners last season but, we ended up being eliminated by a non PL side this season, Arsenal won the FA Cup 3 times recently but, lost in the third round this season. In cup competitions a lot of times you just get caught slipping.
 
You keep saying, that we don't care about winning. Are you not reading the responses? Winning is important. But winning the major trophies is the most important. Of course the small cups matters, but not very much compared to PL and CL. They are not major trophies imo. The important numbers here are 18-5, and 20-3.

You talk about Arsenal like they were a joke, when they always finished fourth.. So tell me, what are they now, with their recent succes in the domestic cups? Their fans sure don't look happy despite 3 FA Cups in four years..

There is a reason, why Liverpool and Tottenham fans overall are happy for the time being, despite no silverware. They feel, that their clubs are moving in the right direction, they get decent results, and they play some good football quite often..

Neither Arsenal, or you guys, seem to enjoy it very much, despite your recent silverware.


nonsense
 
This whole line of discussion annoys me. There is this idea on here that every time one of the top 6 get eliminated from a domestic cup or the Europa League there is this idea that they did not want to win or they did not value the trophy. We were the League Cup winners last season but, we ended up being eliminated by a non PL side this season, Arsenal won the FA Cup 3 times recently but, lost in the third round this season. In cup competitions a lot of times you just get caught slipping.

agreed. i was gutted to go out this year again. another chance of a trophy gone, regardless of it being the carling cup.
what it did show was some of our players are not up to task as even squad replacements.
Though a lot of them played in MK Dons game couple of years back so we already knew that.
 
What I’m talking about is that in those years you’ve largely played poor football. To paraphrase Bill Shankly - if Liverpool were playing at the bottom of your garden, you’d close the curtains.

Fake news. Shankly said that quote about Everton, not Liverpool.
 
This whole line of discussion annoys me. There is this idea on here that every time one of the top 6 get eliminated from a domestic cup or the Europa League there is this idea that they did not want to win or they did not value the trophy. We were the League Cup winners last season but, we ended up being eliminated by a non PL side this season, Arsenal won the FA Cup 3 times recently but, lost in the third round this season. In cup competitions a lot of times you just get caught slipping.

Liverpool have been knocked out the cup by shit teams for 3 years straight. It’s not about do they care about the cups, it’s about if the way they play can even win them cups. If the answer is no, the way they are playing is simply flawed.

It is clear their team is unbalanced. You cannot get away with being attacking if it sacrifices your defence and you win nothing.

No one said you couldn’t get top 4 and win trophies as well. The reason they haven’t won any trophies is because they cant, simple as.
 
Liverpool have been knocked out the cup by shit teams for 3 years straight. It’s not about do they care about the cups, it’s about if the way they play can even win them cups. If the answer is no, the way they are playing is simply flawed.

It is clear their team is unbalanced. You cannot get away with being attacking if it sacrifices your defence and you win nothing.

No one said you couldn’t get top 4 and win trophies as well. The reason they haven’t won any trophies is because they cant, simple as.

Were they playing the backup brigade or pretty much first team squads though? I think given priorities a club like Liverpool wants to attract the best international talent, to do that CL is a big plus and that means a top four finish. I don't think the next big foreign talent cares overly much about who won the League Cup, but probably does factor in whether a club has CL football or not if he has a lot of big clubs looking for his signature.
 
I’m not quoting any specific posts as I’d be here all day. I’m not surprised by a lot of biased on a Man United forum about Liverpool as I’m sure you’d see a lot the other way round on a Liverpool forum but a lot of stuff said on here feels quite ignorant to very clear and obvious things.

Firstly teams parking the bus against Liverpool. One of the two major advantages City have over Liverpool against these sorts of teams are very good full backs who can stretch the oppositions back line to open up space for the attackers in the middle. The other major advantage they have is the quality of their midfielders and the passing range of those midfielders. One of the massive problems we had against Swansea was our full backs not pushing high enough up the pitch to stretch their back line meaning there was never any room through the middle for Salah/Firmino. City are extremely good at stretching the play on the wings, which is exactly why Sane plays so much on the left while Mendy is out as they need someone to stretch play on the left and Sane does that and then of course Walker does it on the right. They have the quality in that midfield to make pin point passes which is something Liverpool lack massively. None of our current midfielders have the passing ability to pick out a sharp run from Mane or Salah which is exactly why we’re desperate for a deep lying playmaker next year, like a Xabi Alonso or even Mousa Dembele type midfielder. I honestly think we have a better front 3 than City, it’s their midfield that is light years ahead of ours which allows their forwards to nearly a season prolific as ours. But yeah there’s nothing wrong with Klopp’s system, it can work against any team, it’s some of the personnel that are still the issue in my opinion. His pressing style obviously works better against teams who want to take the ball but it still works fine against parking the bus teams and if anything this season our results against those sorts of sides have actually been better than last season. We’ve only lost to one non top 6 team in the league this season and that was the Swansea game.

Next is this mentality of we’re making progress so we’re happy. I have this mentality as do a lot of Liverpool fans because what you have to remember is it’s been 6 years since we last won a trophy and excluding the two finals in Klopp’s “first” season we’ve not been anywhere near any since. We’d all love a trophy of course but honestly right now in mine and most Liverpool fans heads what we want is to become a top European team again. For United for the 5 seasons post SAF, 3 of them you’ve been in the UCL, 1 in Europa which you won so you’re still a top European team and attract quality players regardless of UCL, it’s not the same for us. We’ve been in the UCL twice in the last 8 seasons and not been in the knockout stage since 2009. Reality is we’ve not been a big club for a long time and what we want is to become one again. Most Liverpool fans seeing as this is Klopp’s second full season are content with top 4 again and a decent enough run in the UCL. However (assuming we get top 4) a lot of us are now expecting we push for a trophy next year and have a proper title challenge. We fell pretty far as a club and a lot of us realise that it takes time to get back to the top. That’s why we’re content as long as we can stay in the UCL and attract top players so that we are able to progress to a title challenging and trophy challenging team. Klopp is 100% the right man for the job, the question is in my mind whether FSG will give him the money he needs for the imo the 4 new starters he needs this summer. Also what you have to consider is, would a player rather win the FA Cup and come 6th or play UCL and come 3rd in the league. If it was me I’d rather play in the Champions League. Top top players want both and if we want to keep our top players we will need to start doing both but for now I’m content with consistently being in the UCL.

I really don’t understand the insults on spending £75m on Van Dijk. I get he was in the Swansea and West Brom games but goodness me they were his 2nd and 3rd games for the club and he’s obviously going to take time to adjust. It’s like me insulting Sanchez for his performance against Tottenham. Just seems ignorant and idiotic. There’s no denying Van Dijk’s quality just like there’s isn’t Sanchez’s. The last 2 games Van Dijk has played for us I can honestly say we’re probably 2 of the most assured defensive performances I’ve seen for quite a while from Liverpool. He reads the game like no other Liverpool defender I’ve seen in recent times, he wins like 80% of his aerial duels and his passing ability was astounding at Porto. He’s took control of that back 4 and everyone is looking more assured and in control around him as well including Lovren and Karius. I know it’s all banter and what not but I get a bit of bored of it. I actually respect Man United massively as a club even as a Liverpool fan, I often just find it’s the fans that are the issue. However then again that’s the same at every club, but because of the rivalry United fans are incredibly biased and often straight up lie in an attempt to make a point. It is quite infuriating however I do realise Liverpool fans also do the same.

I believe if Liverpool invest the Coutinho money + summer sales on a deep lying playmaker like Torreira or Rabiot, a CAM/Winger like Pulisic or Fekir, another CB like Upamecano or Koulibaly and then if Karius doesn’t come good a goalkeeper like Alisson they can challenge for trophies and the league next season. But I also believe that so can United with the right investments (CM, CB, LB) and the correct tactics to get the best out of Pogba. I’m just enjoying seeing the Premiership getting stronger as it just makes for better viewing football (in most cases!).

Good post, I respect this. We’ll see how Liverpool do this and next season. Genuinely haven’t seen someone explain some of this stuff, other Liverpool fans just start crying and talk about Mourinho.
 
Were they playing the backup brigade or pretty much first team squads though? I think given priorities a club like Liverpool wants to attract the best international talent, to do that CL is a big plus and that means a top four finish. I don't think the next big foreign talent cares overly much about who won the League Cup, but probably does factor in whether a club has CL football or not if he has a lot of big clubs looking for his signature.

They named a strong side against West Brom and conceded 3 goals in the first half. Back up brigade or not, there is enough to not struggle against teams like Exeter and Plymouth. One of the posters said last year they rested players because of the league cup games against Southampton. They got knocked out of that as well anyway.
 
Were they playing the backup brigade or pretty much first team squads though? I think given priorities a club like Liverpool wants to attract the best international talent, to do that CL is a big plus and that means a top four finish. I don't think the next big foreign talent cares overly much about who won the League Cup, but probably does factor in whether a club has CL football or not if he has a lot of big clubs looking for his signature.
The thing is if this is the kind of attraction a clubs try to build then they are aiming to become a big club in long run. Clearly these talents after using these CL teams to hone their skill, would eventually try to move to more ambitious ones once their potential being fulfilled.

The one who look for ambitious clubs wouldn't mind being out of CL for a season as long as the clubs are working toward to challenging in long term.
 
I think you can argue whatever you like here, tbh. Clubs's approach to our crappy domestic cups seems very flexible to me depending what the Top 4 prospects / league form / squad depth / soft draws is like - Arsenal needed their Cup wins because League form was poor, same for Utd & LVG - so bad he got sacked anyway. Liverpool haven't quite been in that position coming from where they have been & the aspiration for any Top 4 finish in any season.

I don't think you can say those 3 FA cup defeats represent a grouping as evidence for team incompetence. For me, the ones that would have hurt them is the LC semi vs. Southampton & obviously the Seville Final - they're quite big games, January FA Cup ties probably not quite so much.
 
Cups do matter. But at this point in time I'd rather finish in top four than win a domestic cup.
 
Cups do matter. But at this point in time I'd rather finish in top four than win a domestic cup.

The thing is, a club that is a regular PL/CL challenger can ignore the cups. But for a club like Liverpool trying to establish themselves as a top 4 club, it is necessary to win the smaller trophies in the meantime, while working up to that potential PL/CL challenger status. Otherwise, players won't buy into the project.

If we had not won the FA Cup, LC and EL during the past 4 years, we would not have been able to attract some of the stars we did, and we would have been seen as a club left in the dust. However, we still seemed relevant even during these past years only due to our trophies, and that made players think we were genuinely building up to something better.

It is also not enough to regularly finish in the Top 4. Only when you challenge for the title regularly, can you ignore the lesser cups.
 
Ok.. I get it.. The League Cup and Europa League last year are proof, that Manchester United had a great season and because of these two important trophies, you are succesful now, and will be in the future. But actually.. Wasn't it a treble for you last season? You won the Charity shield too, didn't you? What a glorious season you had!

You must be happy with the way things are going for you. And the players must be happy too, because they can tell their grandchildren, about the legendary runs to win these important trophies..

It must be a great feeling being a United fan in such a succesful era.. I guess Red Cafe must be loaded with positive vibes?

Or.. Is there something missing? Succes in major tournaments? A direction? Are you not entertained?

Yes I enjoyed winning trophies. Personally, being at the FA Cup semi-final watching Martial dance through Everton to score the winner then a few weeks later seeing a former academy player Lingard smash in a late winner against Palace are two of the best match-going memories I’ll probably ever have. Is it Fergie’s treble winners cleaning up or the 2008 side conquering Europe, no. Is it a fairly young team in transition years growing the club’s success despite not being the best team around? Absolutely.

But yeah I mean, it wasn’t exactly a handholding emotional 2-2 draw at home in the league to West Brom on the way to an ok league finish, or whatever it is you guys have had to celebrate over the last decade.

Obviously United fans are desperate to win the league and the CL would be just lovely. But when my team aren’t likely to win the league then I want to win everthing else going. When your team aren’t winning the league, you’ve tried to win other stuff, but failed. So I guess it’s easier to pretend you didn’t want it in the first place.

If you can only be happy about winning the league or CL, no wonder you come across as such a bitter miserable git. Your barren spell suddenly looks like a decades long famine.
 
The thing is, a club that is a regular PL/CL challenger can ignore the cups. But for a club like Liverpool trying to establish themselves as a top 4 club, it is necessary to win the smaller trophies in the meantime, while working up to that potential PL/CL challenger status. Otherwise, players won't buy into the project.

If we had not won the FA Cup, LC and EL during the past 4 years, we would not have been able to attract some of the stars we did, and we would have been seen as a club left in the dust. However, we still seemed relevant even during these past years only due to our trophies, and that made players think we were genuinely building up to something better.

It is also not enough to regularly finish in the Top 4. Only when you challenge for the title regularly, can you ignore the lesser cups.
Finishing top four says more about ability to contest for the big trophies than 6th and a cup.

You're kidding yourself if you think your cups had any effect on the players you've signed, other than Europa league qualifying you for the cl.
It's about the money, the fact that it is not that long ago you were winning major honors and that players know you will keep spending shitloads to get back to the top.

No player would look at arsenal and think "I think I'd rather sign for them over spurs because id rather win an fa cup than be in the champions league."

Cups matter if you are already solidified in the top four yet not challenging for the league. If top four is a battle, that absolutely takes priority over the cups.

Edit: at least if you are a team whose goal is to challenge for major honors. Not sure spurs or arsenal are that anymore really. The word coming out from on high at those clubs suggest they arent really taking those seriously.
 
Last edited:
Yes I enjoyed winning trophies. Personally, being at the FA Cup semi-final watching Martial dance through Everton to score the winner then a few weeks later seeing a former academy player Lingard smash in a late winner against Palace are two of the best match-going memories I’ll probably ever have. Is it Fergie’s treble winners cleaning up or the 2008 side, no. Is it a fairly young team in transition years growing the club’s success despite not being the best team around? Absolutely.

But yeah I mean, it wasn’t exactly a handholding emotional 2-2 draw at home in the league to West Brom on the way to an ok league finish, or whatever it is you guys have had to celebrate over the last decade.

Obviously United fans are desperate to win the league and the CL would be just lovely. But when my team aren’t likely to win the league then I want to win everthing else going. When your team aren’t winning the league, you’ve tried to win other stuff, but failed. So I guess it’s easier to pretend you didn’t want it in the first place.

If you can only be happy about winning the league or CL, no wonder you come across as such a bitter miserable git. Your barren spell suddenly looks like a famine.
This is probably the most sensible post I've ever seen from you on this forum.
 
Oh.. You completely blew me away right there :boring:
Yes I enjoyed winning trophies. Personally, being at the FA Cup semi-final watching Martial dance through Everton to score the winner then a few weeks later seeing a former academy player Lingard smash in a late winner against Palace are two of the best match-going memories I’ll probably ever have. Is it Fergie’s treble winners cleaning up or the 2008 side conquering Europe, no. Is it a fairly young team in transition years growing the club’s success despite not being the best team around? Absolutely.

But yeah I mean, it wasn’t exactly a handholding emotional 2-2 draw at home in the league to West Brom on the way to an ok league finish, or whatever it is you guys have had to celebrate over the last decade.

Obviously United fans are desperate to win the league and the CL would be just lovely. But when my team aren’t likely to win the league then I want to win everthing else going. When your team aren’t winning the league, you’ve tried to win other stuff, but failed. So I guess it’s easier to pretend you didn’t want it in the first place.

If you can only be happy about winning the league or CL, no wonder you come across as such a bitter miserable git. Your barren spell suddenly looks like a decades long famine
.
What?! Of course I would like it. I said all along, that the small cups would be nice winning.

And.. I told you, that I am happy with our football.. I don't get miserable watching us play, like your team seems to affect Man United fans.. Actually, I am happy with our club, team and manager.

I am glad that the small cups make you happy.. Good for you.
 
Last edited:
Fwiw

As lovely as 00/01 was, I enjoyed 13/14 a whole lot more even though we won feck all. We had no right to be challenging that season and every game was a matter of 'lets see if we'll win this one too with unabashed positive football'. From week to week, it was just thoroughly enjoyable.
 
Finishing top four says more about ability to contest for the big trophies than 6th and a cup.

No player would look at arsenal and think "I think I'd rather sign for them over spurs because id rather win an fa cup than be in the champions league."

Cups matter if you are already solidified in the top four yet not challenging for the league. If top four is a battle, that absolutely takes priority over the cups.

Edit: at least if you are a team whose goal is to challenge for major honors. Not sure spurs or arsenal are that anymore really. The word coming out from on high at those clubs suggest they arent really taking those seriously.

This is what I was getting at in regards to the cups, sure if you are already a guaranteed top four club go for cups. If you are not, then it seems better for the club to go for top four rather than the cups. So play those second string sides, seen the Harry Kane team barely scraping through matches playing their B side in cups. Usually with Harry Kane coming off the bench to rescue them. This indicates to me they are more concerned with top four than the cups, and tbf they have been well up for the CL this time round. Unlike last year where they were woeful.
 
Fwiw

As lovely as 00/01 was, I enjoyed 13/14 a whole lot more even though we won feck all. We had no right to be challenging that season and every game was a matter of 'lets see if we'll win this one too with unabashed positive football'. From week to week, it was just thoroughly enjoyable.

Find that bizarre if I'm honest but whatever floats your boat.
 
This is a mentality of modern football in the EPL I don't really understand. Surely if you want to start competing for the big honours, you've got to start by competing for honours in general? Both Liverpool and Spurs seem to have given up on prioritising the domestic cups, but if you want to instil a real winners mentality, then you have to be prepared to go for everything. I don't think this means having to be as all or nothing as you suggest. You can still put out a weaker side, but you make demands that they are in this to win it. I don't think your performances, in particular, over the last few seasons in the cups would suggest Klopp is doing this.

Real Madrid have won the Spanish Cup just once in the past 23 years .. what does that say I wonder ;)
 
Real Madrid have won the Spanish Cup just once in the past 23 years .. what does that say I wonder ;)

That they dont have to bother with it because of the amount of European and League titles they've won during the same period?
 
Were they playing the backup brigade or pretty much first team squads though? I think given priorities a club like Liverpool wants to attract the best international talent, to do that CL is a big plus and that means a top four finish. I don't think the next big foreign talent cares overly much about who won the League Cup, but probably does factor in whether a club has CL football or not if he has a lot of big clubs looking for his signature.
Sssh. You'll confuse Haram. He has no idea that teams actually put out under strength teams in the LC or early rounds of the FAC, or rotate players in those competitions because participation in at the top end of the PL and the CL is actually what makes or breaks a Top 6 club nowadays. And that is indeed why Top 6 clubs sometimes get beaten in early rounds of those two domestic cups. Until the 1/4 finals I rarely see them putting out full strength teams.
 
That they dont have to bother with it because of the amount of European and League titles they've won during the same period?
Wonder if Barca have taken the same stance then ? Oh no they haven't. But well done anyway for allowing the whole point of my post to fly a 100 miles above your head.
 
That they dont have to bother with it because of the amount of European and League titles they've won during the same period?
Wonder if Barca have taken the same stance then ? Oh no they haven't. But well done anyway for allowing the whole point of my post to fly a 100 miles above your head.
 
Wonder if Barca have taken the same stance then ? Oh no they haven't. But well done anyway for allowing the whole point of my post to fly a 100 miles above your head.

Once again I'm well aware of the point you're trying to make