Ekeke
Full Member
Wrong..
Dunno how you can categorize the term brilliant defensively, Albeda was purely a defensive midfielder whilst Baraja a box to box player( I am sinned here?) good at defending but more renowned for his late runs in to the box. Benetiz at times stuck to a two man midfield with Aimar operating on either inside right or inside left with Baraja or Albeda in the middle and Vincente on the left. He was always switching between systems and many a time Aimar played in a two man midfield connecting attack between Baraja and Carew.
Valeron played in a three man midfield. At Juventus Lippi stuck to 4-3-1-2 with Zidane playing in the hole behind two strikers, with Davids on the side left and Tacchinardi in the middle if my memory serves right. At Real Madrid, Zidane was starting on the left when they had Cambiasso and Makelele in the middle and then he played in a free role behind the striker after they switched on to 4-2-3-1...I am bored here, read my posts in the previous page.
Veron was sucessful whenever he was played infront of two defensive midfielders 4-2-3-1 by Svens Lazio and 3-3-1-3...by Beilsa's Argentina. For a brief period at United, he had his fair run of success partnering Phil Neville from a deepish central midfield but not for long.
Getting back to this argument, Xavi like all other enganches, needs couple of ball winners to protect his backside whenever he attacks upfront, but all these footballers are worth to have the attack played around them.
I dont remember well enough on the other 3, other than I'm sure I remember Valeron playing in a two against us several times as Diego Tristan was always partnered up front.
But even today Alebelda is playing box to box. He shouldnt be because Valencia really need someone sitting on the edge of their own box, looking after their circus of a backline, but for some reason you'll still see Albelda getting to the edge of the opponents box and shooting - though never actually scoring. He covered Baraja's runs forward because Albelda is a great team player. Baraja's style should be compared to Ballack's - Ballack played deep for Leverkusen too and popped up late in the box to score often. Neither Ballack or Baraja have ever been very good defensively though. They've always needed someone next to them doing a lot of defensive work. Aimar was a south american attacking midfielder. From what I remember they'd play him anywhere they could fit him in, but in most matches playing him as a 2 in midfield would have been asking for trouble defensively.