Lionel Messi

Status
Not open for further replies.
And Madrid, Atletico, Sevilla, Espanyol and the 5 in europe...
:lol: The 5 in Europe. 4 games against the likes of Shaktar, Lisbon and Basle. Which has made you wax lyrical about him and Barca since the season begun. You are only fooling yourself here..


Obvious yes but why couldn't comparisons be made between a prime Duff (he was really good in his first season at cheslea) and Ronaldo blowing hot and cold as a teenager?
Because it was dead obvious who was the better talent. A thing that has been proven beyond a shadow of a doubt now.

Not sure what you mean
Now you want to play dumb. :rolleyes: You know darn well what I mean. Barcelona is still the only big team that gives chance to youth it has produced consistently. Arsenal too.


I rate Hleb pretty highly, who knows how special Bojan is.
Everyone who watches him

Eto'o didnt get a chance at Madrid and Rooney and Messi were both superior to Ronaldo at 17.
Utter Bullshit. Eto'o at 17 was a far inferior player to Ronaldo aged 17. I know that for a fact. Eto'o was like Frazier Campbell by then.

Why not? He just won the argies the under 20s world cup aged 17 but still had months to wait for his citizenship. Rijkaard said he didn't care if a player was 16 or 32. If they are able to play they are able, Messi was able.
That's just silly logic. Messi got into the Barca side once he was ready. It's that simple. That is why he didn't play earlier. This should be obvious. To claim he was ready earlier is silly. He didn't come from another club but from their youth side.So if he was ready earlier, they'd have had no qualms using him.

I agree with you to a certain degree but why do good players fail at big teams then?
So many other factors. That accrue to then as individuals. That's why men like Veron flopped in England despite being classy players.

If it is so easy to fit into a world class team and due to the players around you you will automatically look better then why does anyone ever look below par for good teams?
First off, I said it is easier to look good amongst good players when you have no experience. I never said it was easy.

Secondly, a player can flop for many other factors that are not even connected to their ability. There is mentality..etc..

Yeah again Messi is lucky to be at Barca....
Of course he was. You seem to think its a bad thing to be lucky. Players like Ronaldo, Pato and Rooney were a richly talented as Messi at 17. But there were not as fortunate to be at as big a club. Due to circumstances beyond their control. It happens.

Sporting aren't known for producing players. They don't have good coaches and a good academy...
Now you are just being stupid. It is beyond obvious the large clubs like Barca or Manchester United would develop a young talent like Messi's or Ronaldo's far better than a Sporting could.

I guess if Ronaldo was at Barca he'd already have surpassed Pele and Maradona.
Come up with something more clever.

Didn't he get a virus in pre season disrupting him at a vital time? Which resulted in him struggling in his first few games?
Rooney hardly missed a league game. Which is what you were trying to claim. In another attempt to down play Ronaldo's importance

Maybe, it's not uncommon but i'm sure you are one of the people who point out that United are better off than they were at this point last season. So despite Ronaldo missing the start the team still picked up more points?
Wrong again. We have exactly the same points we had at this point last season. That still does not detract from the fact we missed Ronaldo badly before his return form injury.


Fine, he is a mature player and has been sinse he burst onto the scene. He can still improve and quite a bit in my opinion despite being mature.
In what ways ? That will make him so much better than he is now ?That has been the case for Ronaldo since he came out agec 17?


Yeah due to Ronaldo not being mature at a young age he can find that maturity as he grows older meaning that basically every season he will improve where as Messi wont because he is already mature. So while Ronaldo develops maturity and becomes the greatest player the world has ever seen Messi will be damning the fact he was a natural at a young age and couldn't go on the path of steady improvement like Ronaldo...
Stupid logic again. Learn to actually follow what people are saying. Rather than dreaming up dumb shit like this above.

It shouldn't be pointed out to you that Messi has less scope for improvement as player than Ronaldo. Especially since he is smaller and has been more close to full maturity since age 17.


Right, on the one hand we have a small argentinian player with brilliant dribbling skills and a great left foot. He does many things like Maradona and even scores goals almost identical to Maradona, one with his hand and one from the half way line. He is seen as the man to deliver Argentina the world cup the same as Maradona was.
On the other hand we have Ronaldo, he speaks portuguese, so does pele. They both are good in the air and good with both feet. But while you make your points about maturity you seem to forget that Pele was complete at 17, comparison ends.
For sure. Pele retired aged 17 He didn't reach age 23 as the best player in the world and the most complete one. Setting records no one else has. Which Ronaldo is doing right now.


That is the future and so far this season he doesn't look like setting any records.
For sure. When he is not on top form and still in touch with thoae scoring goals for fun who are at peak form like your Messi. In a team that isn't near peak form. Like Messi's is.

Based on winning the champions league, winning many la ligas, winning more than one world cup, winning the copa america. These are achievments that he could achieve? Wouldn't winning two world cups be better than one? or Winning the copa america something Maradona was bitterly dissapointed not to do?
First off Messi is unlikely to win the world cup. Because Argentina aren't that good and he isn't good enough to inspire them the way Maradona did either.

Furthermore, Maradona won titles in Europe at Napoli. I'd like to see Messi do that at a similar club. Before you say he can out achieve Maradona.
 
Argentina have as good a chance of winning a world cup over the next decade as anyone.
 
Argentina have as good a chance of winning a world cup over the next decade as anyone.

That's a bit much; very strong they are, but always seems to be outshined by Brazil in the big tournaments. Messi could put them over the top, but as good as Messi, I for one am not gonna crown him king of anything until he DOES lead Argentina to the World Cup and is by far their best player.
 
Brazil are rubbish.

Argentina have been very poor recently though to be fair.
 
doesn't matter. no european team has ever won a world cup that was contested outside of europe.

None of the South American teams are playing well.

Spain have as good a chance as any.

So do a lot of teams though, there aren't any standout national teams right now.

A lot can change in two years though.
 
doesn't matter. no european team has ever won a world cup that was contested outside of europe.
Suits the Europeans since it's in the same time zone. Brazil are favs, then Argentina with Spain just ahead of............... England.
 
doesn't matter. no european team has ever won a world cup that was contested outside of europe.

So what ? History is made to be broken ,look at Spain , they were always bottlers but now they have won the Euro ,things can actually.
I'm not saying they will do so 100 % positive ,they have as much chance as anyone maybe more since they seem so strong now
 
I think this current Brazil crop are duds. Robinho is a shitty footballer who just does dumd tricks randomly all match and occaisionally scores a screamer against weak sides. Fabiano is a tidy striker but shouldn't be Brazil's best striker either, they've just not the quality of a true Brazil side even with Kaka. They desperately need Neves, Anderson, Jo and the likes to become world beaters by WC2010 or they'll be humbled worse than they were in 06.
 
There is no point in arguing Messi V Ronaldo on a United forum. On the one hand you have Ronaldo, a player who can do no wrong in the eyes of most united fans, a player who is basically the modern Pele in the eyes of some United fans. A claim i can't help but find baffling, extrodinarily baffling to be frank.

On the other hand you have Messi, the luckiest boy the worlds ever seen, he basically cant improve, he wont inspire anyone and the only reason he is even playing football is because he is at Barcelona.

Basically i don't see Ronaldo as a modern Pele or Messi as a modern Maradona. However Messi has the talent that you need to be that good and for me Ronaldo isn't as talented as Messi. People watch Messi and they are inspired, he is a player everyone would pay to watch and unless something miraculous happens he'll go down as the greatest player of his generation.

People will talk about Ronaldos 42 goal season for the rest of his career and beyond as justification for him being the best in the world. This season at least he hasn't been anywhere near the best player in the world, i wouldn't put him in the top 5 based on this season.
 
doesn't matter. no european team has ever won a world cup that was contested outside of europe.

Spain are unbeaten in something like 31 games. They are an exceptional international team and should rightly be considered favourites for South Africa.
 
:lol: The 5 in Europe. 4 games against the likes of Shaktar, Lsibon and Basle. Which has made you wax lyrical about him and Barca since the season begun. You are only fooling yourself here..



That's just silly logic. Messi got into the Barca side once he was ready. It's that simple. That is why he didn't play earlier. This should be obvious. To claim he was ready earlier is silly. He didnt come from another club but from their youth side.



Ofcourse he was. You seem to think its a bad thing to be lucky. Players like Ronaldo, Pato and Rooney were a richly talented as Messi at 17. But there were not as fortunate to be at as big a club. Due to circumstances beyond their control. It happens.

Now you are just being stupid. It is beyond obvious the large clubs like Barca or Manchester United would develope a young talent like Messi's or Ronaldo's far better than a Sporting could.

Rooney hardly missed a league game. Which is what you were trying to claim. In another atempt to down play Ronaldo's importance

Wrong again. We have exactly the same points we had at this point last season. That still does not detract from the fact we missed Ronaldo badly before his return form injury.


It shouldnt' be pointed out to you that Messi has less scope for improvement as player than Ronaldo. Especially since he is smaller and has been more close to full maturity since age 17.



For sure. Pele retired aged 17 He didn't reach age 23 as the best player in the world and the most complete one. Setting records no one else has. Which Ronaldo has doine right now


For sure. When he is not on top form and still in touch with thoae scoring goals for fun who are at peak form like your Messi. In a team that isn't near peak form. Like Messi's is.



First off Messi is unlikely to win the world cup. Because Argentina aren't that good and he isn't good enough to inspire them the way Maradona did either.

Furthermore, Maradona won titles in Europe at Napoli. I'd like to see Messi do that at a similar club.


Messi wont win the world cup, Ronaldo will become pele....

You are seriously deluded. I've never seen anything from ROnaldo (due to my Ronaldo blindness) that makes me think he is like Pele, not the creativity, not the ease of playing and not even the productivity. He has had one season of exeptional productivity once he hit the age of 23, try being that productive from 17 right until you are 30 odds and i'll begin comparing him to Pele. Until then (which can't happen anyway) you really shouldn't compare him to Pele, he isnt and never will be that good.

You laugh at Messi scoring 5 in the champions league, you laugh at him scoring 1.5 goals every 90mins in the champions league yet against Alborg, celtic and villareal Pele, i mean Ronaldo hasn't scored a goal?

But wait, he's been injured and he's only played about 15 games this season, he needs another 10 or 20 to hit top form...

As for Sporting Lisbon, widely regarded as one of the best youth developers in the world. Your logic is bizarre, in your eyes anyone not developed by a big club like Barca has much less of a chance of making it as a player?

What sort of shit is that? Players can develop anywhere if they are good enough. Messi played for his home club in argentina before moving to Barcelona. They saw his talent and took him in to help pay for treatment for him because they saw what he could do, they didn't just take him and make him the player he is. They saw him play for 2mins and signed him such was his talent.

Messi wont go to Napoli, why would he? I can't see him leaving Barca for a start because i think he has a little loyalty to them. Only if what happens with Ronaldinho happens with him will he go.

Your argument revolves around Messi being at Barcelona and this being the reason he is the player he is. The luxury of playing for Barca basically. The ease at which all the young players break into the side. The same side that Fabregas left, that Pique left, that many players have left of genuine quality because it is so easy to break into the team as a talented young player.
 
None of the South American teams are playing well.

Form goes out the window in such tournaments. Last time Brazil won it, nobody tipped them for much and nobody tipped Germany for much either. In the last WC, everybody was cacking themselves at all the superstar talent available to them and they stunk the place out.

I think Argentina have a core of extremely talented young players that should give them a very good chance of winning it over the next ten years.
 
There is no point in arguing Messi V Ronaldo on a United forum. On the one hand you have Ronaldo, a player who can do no wrong in the eyes of most united fans, a player who is basically the modern Pele in the eyes of some United fans. A claim i can't help but find baffling, extrodinarily baffling to be frank.

But that's just blatant lies, which makes you sound stupid because you just made that up.
 
Form goes out the window in such tournaments. Last time Brazil won it, nobody tipped them for much and nobody tipped Germany for much either. In the last WC, everybody was cacking themselves at all the superstar talent available to them and they stunk the place out.

I think Argentina have a core of extremely talented young players that should give them a very good chance of winning it over the next ten years.

Indeed, which is why I made the point that the tournament is wide open and there aren't any favourites.

With Messi, Aguero and Tevez they have the talent to go forward, but they have relied on Riquelme too much recently and he's been poor.

Hopefully Maradona sets them right, I doubt he will though.
 
Messi wont win the world cup, Ronaldo will become pele....

You are seriously deluded. I've never seen anything from ROnaldo (due to my Ronaldo blindness) that makes me think he is like Pele, not the creativity, not the ease of playing and not even the productivity. He has had one season of exeptional productivity once he hit the age of 23, try being that productive from 17 right until you are 30 odds and i'll begin comparing him to Pele. Until then (which can't happen anyway) you really shouldn't compare him to Pele, he isnt and never will be that good.

You laugh at Messi scoring 5 in the champions league, you laugh at him scoring 1.5 goals every 90mins in the champions league yet against Alborg, celtic and villareal Pele, i mean Ronaldo hasn't scored a goal?

But wait, he's been injured and he's only played about 15 games this season, he needs another 10 or 20 to hit top form...

As for Sporting Lisbon, widely regarded as one of the best youth developers in the world. Your logic is bizarre, in your eyes anyone not developed by a big club like Barca has much less of a chance of making it as a player?

What sort of shit is that? Players can develop anywhere if they are good enough. Messi played for his home club in argentina before moving to Barcelona. They saw his talent and took him in to help pay for treatment for him because they saw what he could do, they didn't just take him and make him the player he is. They saw him play for 2mins and signed him such was his talent.

Messi wont go to Napoli, why would he? I can't see him leaving Barca for a start because i think he has a little loyalty to them. Only if what happens with Ronaldinho happens with him will he go.

Your argument revolves around Messi being at Barcelona and this being the reason he is the player he is. The luxury of playing for Barca basically. The ease at which all the young players break into the side. The same side that Fabregas left, that Pique left, that many players have left of genuine quality because it is so easy to break into the team as a talented young player.

When anyone starts multiquoting Kemo a gay fest was always on cards and it was a matter of time you've thrown your toys out of the pram. You both are retarded, the bigger retard has won.
 
I thought he would have a quiet game against Villareal this week. He was clearly rattled against Real Madrid after the kicking he got in the first 20 minutes, yet showed great temperament and finally had the last laugh. Hopefully he should recover when the league starts again.
 
I thought he was very good.

Had a quiet game actually, he was more involved in the classico....

Barca were again impressive and it'd be a major upset if they lose the title this season. Pique was clumsy and slow culminating in his 2 yellows, he needs to step up his game or he'll lose his place to Milito once he comes back. Rossi had a good game despite missing a good chance in the first half, beautiful nutmeg and pass for Cani to score. The yellow submarine had enough chances to at least get a point towards the end with both Franco and Nihat missing one on one's with the keeper.
 
That's the thing with great players like Messi and Ronaldo , sometimes when they have a "normal" compared to their high standards , some will always think they were rubbish. You can't always be amazing in every match
 
Messi wont win the world cup, Ronaldo will become pele....

You are seriously deluded. I've never seen anything from ROnaldo (due to my Ronaldo blindness) that makes me think he is like Pele, not the creativity, not the ease of playing and not even the productivity. He has had one season of exeptional productivity once he hit the age of 23, try being that productive from 17 right until you are 30 odds and i'll begin comparing him to Pele. Until then (which can't happen anyway) you really shouldn't compare him to Pele, he isnt and never will be that good.
You are the one who is deluded. No one else. Ronaldo has already proven in the last 3 years he is begining to emulate Pele. & if he keeps his current rate up he might get there. It's obvious to all except you.

And it's obvious you don't get what begining or emulating is.

In additon your claim he he has had only one season of exceptional productivity is beyond stupid. Like his 2007 season and the one before that never happened. Typical of your anti Ronaldo stance.

Lastly, you dare to call me deluded, yet want to make everyone else believe Messi is capable of surpassing Maradona. A player capable of inspiring a mere Napoli to a Serie A title. In the toughest league on the planet at the time. Yet Messi couldn't inspire a club of Barcelona's stature to one title last year. Or the year before. Ever since the fall of Ronaldinho....

You really need to wake up from dream land pal.

You laugh at Messi scoring 5 in the champions league, you laugh at him scoring 1.5 goals every 90mins in the champions league yet against Alborg, celtic and villareal Pele, i mean Ronaldo hasn't scored a goal?
:lol: It's you I've been lauging at not Messi! That should have been obvious by now.

You waxing lyrical about Messi's MOTM exploits in this season's champions league against the likes of Fc Basle, Sporting Lisbon and Shatkar then at the same time dissing Ronaldo for having MOTM performances against sides like Villareal, Cetic and Stoke City. That's shamefull really. :lol:

But wait, he's been injured and he's only played about 15 games this season, he needs another 10 or 20 to hit top form...
Only you could come up with such a weak argument. That's for sure.


As for Sporting Lisbon, widely regarded as one of the best youth developers in the world. Your logic is bizarre, in your eyes anyone not developed by a big club like Barca has much less of a chance of making it as a player?
Rather in your deluded logic. It's not remotely debatable that a player would develop far better in a youth set up, with better coaches that a big club like Barca can provide, than at a Sporting Lisbon.

But in your mad mind it is. That is why you've invented the even crazier idea that anyone said that "anyone not developed by a big club like Barca has much less of a chance of making it as a player":wenger:

What sort of shit is that? Players can develop anywhere if they are good enough. Messi played for his home club in argentina before moving to Barcelona. They saw his talent and took him in to help pay for treatment for him because they saw what he could do, they didn't just take him and make him the player he is. They saw him play for 2mins and signed him such was his talent.
FFS. You really are clueless. They nutured his talents better than a smaller club like a Lisbon ever could have. Do you know what that means? Or are you so dumb as to think nuturing means turning someone with nothing into a walking bag of talent?


Messi wont go to Napoli, why would he? I can't see him leaving Barca for a start because i think he has a little loyalty to them. Only if what happens with Ronaldinho happens with him will he go.
Then it should begin to dawn on you why he is unlikely to ever greater than Maradona. But I'm not holding my breath for that..

Your argument revolves around Messi being at Barcelona and this being the reason he is the player he is. The luxury of playing for Barca basically The ease at which all the young players break into the side.that Pique left, that many players have left of genuine quality because it is so easy to break into the team as a talented young player.The same side that Fabregas left
It never has been and never will be. Only you could create such a dumbed down version of my arguments.

My argument was very clear and very simple:

Messi got a better start than Ronaldo. But Ronaldo is currently very much ahead of him and is still getting better. So assuming that Messi will suddenly overtake Ronaldo's rate of developement is a falacy. After all, Ronaldo never had as good a starting point as Messi did. Yet he has currently surpassed him.

To illustrate this point further, Ronaldo moved from a small club, for a large fee for a teenager, to a big club to replace a first team star while still a very raw and inexperienced player. Expected to both fight for his place with top proffesionals, while being expected to met the expectation of him replacing his preddcessor well. But once placed in a better coaching environment than what he had at Lisbon , he made rapid progression, and within the 3 years since, he is now oficially considered the world's best.

Messi on he other hand, was at Barcelona from age 12. Meaning from such a young age his talent had access to some of the best coaching possible for it. Reached age 17, having no tranfser fee attached to his back, handed a chance to stake claim for a first team place, at big club, a club with a consistent history and culture of given talented players from it's youth ranks genuine first team chances. Yet despite all this. He isn't officially recognised as the best player in the world.

And Keep to your self this bollocks that I'm allegedly reffering to "The ease at which all the young players break into the side". Because it has zero to do with ease. But everything to do with the culture of Barcelona. The culture of giving genuine first team chances to their talented youth products, Always. Valdes, Puyol, Xavi , Iniesta, Busquets, Bojan and Messi of the current Barcelona side are all proof of this. So are past players like Dos Santos , Giovanni, Oleguer (now at Hull) , Reina (now at Liverpool) and Simao back in the day etc. All breaking into the side between the ages of 17 and 21. Given a decent squad status or in some cases proper first team places. Which has had zilch to do with it being easy. Or even them being special talents like Messi. It's just the clubs culture. Plain and simple. Thus it is not a slight on Messi's talent what soever to say this aided him. But to bury your head in the sand and pretend it had no hand in Messi's current progression is utterly stupid. It just shows you are beyond biased when it comes to matters concerning him.

Heck I like Messi far more than I like Ronaldo as player. But my love for Messi will never blind me to the truth. Ronaldo is better than him. & still improving at an astounding rate. It won't be easy for Messi to ever surpass Ronaldo. & it's even possible it might never even occur. A manager like SAF is no fool when he tells you the boy is headed for the heights of Pele and Maradona. So you keep fooling your self and think Messi is the only one who will get there. You will be in for hell of a nasty surprise.
 
Lastly, you dare to call me deluded, yet want to make everyone else believe Messi is capable of surpassing Maradona. A player capable of inspiring a mere Napoli to a Serie A title. In the toughest league on the planet at the time. Yet Messi couldn't inspire a club of Barcelona's stature to one title last year. Or the year before. Ever since the fall of Ronaldinho....

You're slightly deluded as well Chief.

Ronaldo is beginning to emulate Pele as much as Messi is beginning to emulate Maradona.
 
That's the thing with great players like Messi and Ronaldo , sometimes when they have a "normal" compared to their high standards , some will always think they were rubbish. You can't always be amazing in every match
Spot on. Scholesy was right. He did all he had to with out too much effort. Which is very good. Quiet by his standards. But a class performance all the same for me.
 
When you talk about Ronaldo and messi you're talking about damn good players :) obviously....

Some people seriously doubt Ronaldo - which is beyond stupid.

Ronaldo can do it any league in the world and on the big stage. Could messi do it in the premiership? I think he's be a great player but at a quicker pace would he find the room. Would he be strong enough to take the kicks?

Would love to find out.

I would add the white pele. Wayne - on top form is right up there too. He's a very intelligent, hard working, powerful lad - who I reckons waiting to explode on the bigger stages

I was VERY happy about his performances - especially since he picked up a knock and missed most of the first game. Of late, he's resembling the player we know he can be and on form he's always up their

I think Messi is brilliant - make no mistake but me questioning messi is as daft as anyone questioning our Ronaldo

I should add I think Ronaldo plays within himself. You can always tell when he's up for it and yesterday (first half anyway) he seemed like his old running at people self which hasn't been the case at times because of the thugs who can't take being embarassed
 
I agree with everything that has been said against FranklyVulgar and his lovechild Messi. Messi's a twat, feck him
 
You're slightly deluded as well Chief.

Ronaldo is beginning to emulate Pele as much as Messi is beginning to emulate Maradona.
Maybe. But I think our wrong though. I'd infact agree with you if Vulgar's argument was Messi was emulating Maradona.

However for him though Messi is certain to be the greatest player of his generation and the next Maradona. Set to go on to even surpass the great one himself. Barring injury. Wow.
 
Maybe. But I think our wrong though. I'd infact agree with you if Vulgar's argument was Messi was emulating Maradona.

However for him though Messi is certain to be the greatest player of his generation and the next Maradona. Set to go on to even surpass the great one himself. Barring injury. Wow.

If that's the case then Frank's lost it, completely lost it.

I haven't been reading the past 100 or so posts because there's just too much to read, not sure how you do it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.