It's not about having the same team in 1 specific match, you do have the same players from the squad last year, except Suarez. I'm not saying that it's not a huge thing to either replace a star like him or to involve 7-8 new players seemlesly into the squad.
I'm saying that if Rodgers had so much faith that you were fine last year with your setup without Suarez, he'd continue with that and let the new guys force their way in and being given the chance when others needed a rest. And i belive that if that was the case, he'd start Borini before Lambert up top who doesn't seem to be given a chance at all after he turned down the move to sunderland, despite being the more like-for-like replacement as compared to really both Lambert and Balotelli.
(though i'd also give Balotelli a go before Borini in case Balotelli shrugged off his mental problems)
Moreno is in every way an upgrade to Flanagan/Enrique/whoever CB you neded up playing on left-back last year in my opinion, and he has the potential to be the best of your signings of the last window i think. He fits your profile, gives you speed and just needs to settle inn, still brings what I'd expect for someone tactically in that role in Rodgers team.
Definitely on Moreno, though gutted Flanagan got injured as I definitely see him as a regular.
A road-stick is a defensively upgrade on Johnson is a common joke on the internet for a reason, as decent/good as he is going forward i don't think you guys can afford the tradeoff with your CB and CDM being so poor. So i'd say you got an upgrade in Manquillo as well.
Manquillo has real promise but also is very naive still - I agree on Johnson, however to contradict that now he is back from injury he did provide some extra composure on the ball when he came on for Manquillo against WBA.
Allen was pretty much a backup-waterboy last year, wasn't he? Rotated in just when you had to. For the most part Henderson and Gerrard was playing, with Lucas being prefered above Allen after he got healthy again (might be wrong on the last one, that's how i remember it), so saying him being out is a huge loss in your general play just doesn't sit right with my current knowledge of Liverpool and Rodgers philosophy, even if he did good at the start of the season or at the summer tour.
Allen has had terrible luck with injuries, so it's hard to gauge. But when he played at the beginning of the season he was one of our best players and does add a little extra mobility the likes of Gerrard and Lucas lack.
He still has a lot to prove but has shown some of the good form he showed at Swansea.
Sturridge is the clear miss indeed, i completely agree with that as I mentioned earlier. He's got that swift movement and eye for a goal that Balotelli doesn't seem to bother to have, Lambert don't seem good enough for and Borini doesn't seem to get a chance to show that he's gotte. But if the striker makes up so much for the clubs way of playing the question comes back, why isn't the more similar player with the obviously good atittude towards working hard being tried out at least in Borini before a failing Balotelli and Lambert who's quality is best as a backup to annoy already tired defenders. Borini stretches the opponents way more than Lambert and Balotelli does together.
I have been surprised by some of the selections, Lambert for instance on his own up front against WBA clearly didn't work, same with Balotelli - he needs someone up there with him.
Problem is Sturridge hasn't been fit to pair up with Mario yet.
I also agree and strongly doubt that Sakho is Brendans first choice, but i really think he should be.
Skrtel has showed before that he is willing to work hard and be a squad player, and i think they are of around equal quality - yet Sakho expects to start more often and needs it to progress to a level where you have another good/great centre back. Would you rather have Skrtel at his current level who won't suddenly become a better player, or develop Sakho more for the benefit of the club?
That is another thing I find hard to understand about Rodgers management of his team.
Sakho is totally left sided, which is where Lovren prefers to play, I honestly think it's Lovren OR Sakho at the moment.
Personally I would rather we played Skrtel and Lovren so that partnership can develop as that doesn't just happen overnight - that said, there is no evidence we have resolved the defensive problems we had last year.
I actually think Ilori (who is out on loan), could end up the best of the bunch.
If i'm not mistaken, you now play with one spot open in your presumed first X?
Mignolet
Manquillo - Lovren - Skrtel - Moreno
Gerrard(holding) - Henderson(box2box)
X - Sterling - Lallana
Sturridge
Wouldn't it be better for the team to put in another midfielder and not ever, ever use Gerrard as the one shielding the backline? Sure you guys need some mobility up top but it to work, but even with Sturridge out you'd still have a trio of Lallana, Sterling and one of Coutinho/Suso/Borini//Markovic to use and the rest to rotate. I think the biggest reason for Coutinho having a fail-start of a season so far is because of the lack of movement from the front-man. Sturridge gives that when he plays up top, but Balotelli and Lambert really doesn't offer that much movement.
(yes, i notice i don't mention Balotelli and Lambert, they simply don't have the movement to play like you guys did last year and will only be plan-b players in my book)
I think Manquillo might be rested for a bit and he will go with Johnson for a while. To be honest I would add Balotelli to that line up to see if he can develop a partnership with Sturridge.
You might be right about Coutinho, he relies on that movement which isn't really Mario's game at all.
Just by looking at
physioroom you can easily notice that Lucas Leiva should be free to take up that defensive midfielder spot, easing the defensive preassure you currently have on both Gerrard and your backline. But yet again, i can't say i've noticed Rodgers taking any sort of action towards that at all. Has Lucas recently been completely shite in training or or been injured and is planned to return to fitness now?
Lucas has no pace and is often found to be a bit pedestrian, I wouldn't have him in the squad once Allen and Can are fit.
I'm not sure if i'm the blind one or Rodgers. But i see a lot of managerial opportunities that he should have at least given a chance or have thought (and to put a joke in) and therefor talked about to the media instead of his "transition" talk.
(Let's face it, it's most likely me seeing as he's educated on managing and i'm some
random guy in Norway who sits in a couch in a rented appartment)
For a random guy you talk a lot of sense and know a lot about football mate!
To end it off, the whole post can look completely wrong, but it's based on the information I have on Liverpool which is mostly through media, a mate and a game every now and then.