Kylian Mbappé joins PSG on one year loan with option to buy

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've never seen him score a genuinely good goal. I'm sure he has, but I've somehow just managed to see a lot of tap-ins and rebounds. There's more to the hype than that, right?
Scored a good goal against City and a very well placed high finish in the away game against Dortmund.
 
I still say this will be a pointless signing and I hope we don't spend all summer pursuing it.

Jose will not play with two strikers IMO, so he'd end up shunting Mbappe out wide to accomdate his typical big CF (whether Zlatan or Zlatan's replacement).

Jose just doesn't strike me as the manager to play with two speedy, smaller strikers especially when we don't have the current personnel to play a flat 4 behind them with two quality wingers.
 
I want us to sign him even more after reading this.

Is that

A) because he makes girls cry
B) because his nickname is Justin Bieber
C) because he plays a lot of Football Manager
or
D) because he lives with his mates

?
 
I still say this will be a pointless signing and I hope we don't spend all summer pursuing it.

Jose will not play with two strikers IMO, so he'd end up shunting Mbappe out wide to accomdate his typical big CF (whether Zlatan or Zlatan's replacement).

Jose just doesn't strike me as the manager to play with two speedy, smaller strikers especially when we don't have the current personnel to play a flat 4 behind them with two quality wingers.

Might be a replacement for Martial....
 
I've never seen him score a genuinely good goal. I'm sure he has, but I've somehow just managed to see a lot of tap-ins and rebounds. There's more to the hype than that, right?
You have be there to score all those tap-ins and rebounds. If it were that simple, every great striker would be putting up Cristiano's numbers otherwise...

He seems to be very good all around tho
 
I've never seen him score a genuinely good goal. I'm sure he has, but I've somehow just managed to see a lot of tap-ins and rebounds. There's more to the hype than that, right?

That's a sign of a good striker. A player who actually manages to get into the right places to stick the ball into the net.
 
Bet a "dorm" in Monaco is nicer than my place.

Looks like he's got his head screwed on, would love to have both him and Rashford playing for us.
 
I still say this will be a pointless signing and I hope we don't spend all summer pursuing it.

Jose will not play with two strikers IMO, so he'd end up shunting Mbappe out wide to accomdate his typical big CF (whether Zlatan or Zlatan's replacement).

Jose just doesn't strike me as the manager to play with two speedy, smaller strikers especially when we don't have the current personnel to play a flat 4 behind them with two quality wingers.
Completely agree! Great player but we have Rashford, which I think would have done just as well or even better if they swap places. I'd rather we sign someone like Icardi who Rashford can play off of.
 
I think Mbappe is a special case as a player. He really could be a Messi/Ronaldo level talent, and while there are parallels with both Rashford and Martial, the indications are he could be another order of player potentially.

If Zlatan remains, it probably would be something to look at the following summer, but if not, it wouldn't be unreasonable to bring him in and let him make the left side of the front three his own, then make another signing for the right side, whether Griezmann, Dembele, James or whoever. This would leave Rashford and Martial to fight it out for the central striking role in a mobile and dynamic attacking line-up.
 
I think Mbappe is a special case as a player. He really could be a Messi/Ronaldo level talent, and while there are parallels with both Rashford and Martial, the indications are he could be another order of player potentially.

I'd agree with this. If we can bring in Mbappe we should bring him in regardless of who we have. I'd have no worries about him and Rashford. There're plenty of ways that they can play together and consider both will still be very young next season they won't play every match anyway.
 
This kid will be the best striker in the world. He's the closest thing to R9 I have ever seen.

Strong on both feet, clinical finisher and so fast and direct.

I hope we do everything possible to sign him, he really is that special.
 
This kid will be the best striker in the world. He's the closest thing to R9 I have ever seen.

Strong on both feet, clinical finisher and so fast and direct.

I hope we do everything possible to sign him, he really is that special.

Absolutely agree! I hope we sign him! Even more so now it seems we'll have to sign a striker after the Ibra injury.
 
If it takes £100m to bring him to Old Trafford, so be it. This guy is top class.
 
This kid will be the best striker in the world. He's the closest thing to R9 I have ever seen.

Strong on both feet, clinical finisher and so fast and direct.

I hope we do everything possible to sign him, he really is that special.

Agree, he reminds me of R9 and also of Henry, I this kid has a higher ceiling than Rashford
 
Agree, he reminds me of R9 and also of Henry, I this kid has a higher ceiling than Rashford
It's hard to predict just how good Rashford will become, but my god if we had those 2 upfront together for the next 10 years then it'll be damn exciting.
 
I'm in the camp that is 'bewitched' by a potential trio of him, Martial and Rashford.

If we could pull it off, I'd try and bring in Llorente too, who wouldn't cost much. Llorente can score goals at this level, and would provide an alternative type of threat as a squad player.
 
Even though I'm not convinced he's the right signing, Griezmann seems like the player this summer who will cost Pogba money to bring here. This lad isn't like the Martial signing which went below the radar and if most are honest, didn't really know him, this lad is probably the most talk about in world football and therefore will be on everyone's radar. I know there's lots of stuff written that he won't go to PSG, but I think they need to make a statement and this lad would be it....
 
I'm in the camp that is 'bewitched' by a potential trio of him, Martial and Rashford.

If we could pull it off, I'd try and bring in Llorente too, who wouldn't cost much. Llorente can score goals at this level, and would provide an alternative type of threat as a squad player.
Hold me!
:drool:
 
------Pogba---Herrera------
Mkhi------------------Martial
------Rashford-Mbappe-----

:drool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.