Jose Mourinho | 2017/18 Assessments | Poll Added

Your stance


  • Total voters
    1,563
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
He’s right though. United have a grand total of three European Cups.
Theres a difference in going out now and then when we're attacking and just not quite being good enough, to this. Theres a difference to having the right plan and just not finishing, to this. This was atrocious and the wrong attitude from the first minutes, yet it was clearly Mourinhos gameplan, and he just got it all wrong (which is big, because this is how he's always been. So not much reason for optimism).
 
Mou: "I've sat in this chair twice before, with Porto - Man Utd out, with Real Madrid - Man Utd out, so this is nothing new for this football club." #MUFC

Feck off Mourinho. Get out of my club.
What. The. Feck.
 
Yes he did and he's the first to acknowledge it, but he was Alex Ferguson, the greatest United manager of all time. Even by the time of our first major CL disappointment under him - getting knocked out by Monaco on away goals in 1998 - he had already won the league for us four times, the FA Cup three times, and been to the CL semis the previous season.

Mourinho is nothing to us in comparison (something Mourinho himself acknowledged when he became our manager), he has earned none of the credit with us that Fergie built up over the years, and he'll never earn any combining this type of football with results like tonight.

And the bolded is what the "...but, but but Fergie" weirdos will never seem to understand.
 
Also I'd just like to reiterate that to all of those who pointed at the Chelsea and Liverpool results as progress, both these sides are painfully average. Absolutely not the level we should be looking to aspire to. We didn't exactly dominate them either.
 
It was pathetic, no top side goes away from home to a team like Seville and plays for 0-0. We would have gone to likes of Basel or Porto and played for 0-0 as well, it is an outdated, negative approach.

Exactly. Liverpool or City would have won this tie by 4 or 5 goals.
 
I don't want to go through a new manager again. I still think Jose should get next season.

Tonight was so bad though, so inept, so cowardly.

I'm seriously thinking would it be so bad if he went in the Summer. He fecked this tie up in every possible way from mentality to tactics to lineup to substitutions. An absolute horror show from him.
 
Theres a difference in going out now and then when we're attacking and just not quite being good enough, to this. Theres a difference to having the right plan and just not finishing, to this. This was atrocious and the wrong attitude from the first minutes, yet it was clearly Mourinhos gameplan, and he just got it all wrong (which is big, because this is how he's always been. So not much reason for optimism).

Nah, going out is going out. Same result.
 
Mourinho in his right state of mind would never say that. He has taken the loss very badly.
 
We didn't play chicken shit football against Chelsea or Liverpool, or in a whole range of Premier League games that brought us to 2nd place.

As I already said, today we were terrible and he shoulders a big part of that with the tactics and selection. I do not want to defend him on tonight's performance but it's certainly laughable to suddenly want him out and ignore everything else he's done.

We did play chicken shit football against Liverpool in the second half - and if the referee had done his job, it could have cost us. If we had played like we did in the first half, we wouldn't be having this discussion. But we hardly ever do. That is the problem. Why did we win against Liverpool ? Because Mourinho tactically was better than Klopp. How about winning a game because we are a good football side, or because we play good football!

And it's not like I suddenly want him out - I have wanted him out for a long time. I don't look forward to United-games anymore, thats how far it has got. We are a disgrace to look at - and if after 18 months, Mourinho can't make us play proper football - when do you think it will happen ?
 
@VP89, while I agree these things happen and it's not the end of the world what I don't like is the way we were playing. Like it didn't matter, like it wasn't last 16 of CL, never out of 1st gear, no ambition or anything. Who's to say we won't look like that next year in a CL knock out game.
He's improving us but I think we should get the league next year or he should leave.
And that's coming from his fan.
Feel the same.

My problem is that i don't necessarily see a proper alternative.

But that isn't for us to decide.
 
People saying the 1st leg was "pathetic" etc are being over emotional. Nothing wrong with playing like that for the away leg knowing you've got the second leg at home and 0-0 is a good result.

However if you want to call tonight pathetic, I don't see how anyone can really argue with that. The whole point of a 0-0 away result is that you come out attacking/aggressive at home, which we just weren't, regardless of what Mourinho thinks.

0-0 is not a good result away from home, the lack of away goals is damning - as it was today. It always gives the other team huge hope, even if they let in a goal after 1 minute. No away goal, no progress. I’m pretty sure the stats are hugely against teams that play away in the first game and don’t score. Phychologically, even losing 2-1 away can be a better result than drawing 0-0. At 2-1 you know you have to play and win, at 0-0 you are never out if the other team doesn’t score in the second game - something I think United players had on their minds tonight.
 
I dont see hypocrisy in calling out Mourinho yet not wanting to have him sacked (yet). Sitting back and pinging the ball up front while having clearly superior players is cowardice. Thats what it is and calling it out is normal. I was hoping we see the crazy counter attacking football Mourinho brought to Madrid a few years back but i've lost hope on that so he must deliver on the one thing he is known for which is success on the pitch. If he doesnt bring success then why should we stick by him for the long term? Next season is his chance to keep his place at this club by winning the PL, nothing less should be acceptable.
 
Like everyone else is saying. You're wrong here. It's not about going out. Mourinho isn't a manager who comes into a team and builds for the future. He doesn't excite any fan. He doesn't play positively. He was always about winning - here and now. That was why we got him. In 2 seasons here, he's shown he can't do that anymore, he can't get the results and so it's time to cut him and get a manager that respects our traditions. If we lose, we lose, but you have to go down fighting and with the right game plan. It is one game, Yeah, but one game is all you need sometimes to make a decision (and let's not kid ourselves, Mourinho has been walking on eggshells for ages because we play like shit every week because of his playstyle despite unlimited spending and have had plenty of embarrassing results).

christ. He has 2 cups, is in the running for another this year, sits 2nd behind a ridiculously great side in City and its not enough. I'm not even going to bother anymore.
 
You’ve seen tonight why it’s not. 1 goal and you’re in serious trouble. Criminal not to try and score. He’s a moron.

Sevilla were utter shite in this game...and United were even worse.

0-0 was a perfectly fine score to take to the 2nd leg, if we actually took control of the game. Sevilla were there for the taking, and we just walked around the pitch like it was a training session.
 
Mou: "I've sat in this chair twice before, with Porto - Man Utd out, with Real Madrid - Man Utd out, so this is nothing new for this football club." #MUFC

Feck off Mourinho. Get out of my club.
wow, I'm speechless. He's a dead man walking and he knows it
 
Wouldn't mind seeing the back of him. His brand of football coupled with his arrogance riles me up like no other. He's such a coward.
 
Nah, going out is going out. Same result.
If you seriously see it in the same light, then idk what to say. United has always been a club with traditions to entertain the supporters. Win or lose. Mourinho doesn't do that.
 
Yeah, he's had a lot of money. Spent 3rd highest in the Premier League and he sits 2nd, and it is also worth noting he took over a poor United squad. One needing a front to back revamp, lets be honest. The outlay he's spent and being 2 seasons in certainly means he should be dispatching Sevilla and I'm not really arguing that point.

I'm just seriously baffled at why people just want him out. It's just bizzare. He has obviously improved us since he's joined and he still needs to work on getting players in to fix the midfield and full back problem. I wouldn't sack him when he's mid way through his project with us. Who would you even get to replace him that is a guarunteed performer? Fecking no one.


Your tag line is well deserved. Think you need to read posts better, though.
It's simple tbh. People wanna enjoy watching matches. Mourinho's biggest supporters and himself makes you think that there is no way to play attacking football (specially in must win games) without increasing the chances of you losing games. Like it has to be one or the other, that is what annoys most fans.
If Man United loses to Sevilla tonight by having more shots on targets, more clear cut chances, I guarantee you the feeling isn't the same. The result would be the same but the fans would appreciate watching a team that lost by giving its best a million times more than this shower of shit we're being served.
A lot of fans watch football for the beauty of the game as well as the results their team can get, Man United surrendering any will to play football in order to maximize results is bullshit.
 
Personally, I don't think there's anything wrong with Mourinho's comments. I mean all he really said, essentially, is that Manchester United is a shithouse institution and that were all a bunch of losers who should be used to defeat by now. What's all the fuss about.
 
Nah, going out is going out. Same result.

For you maybe. Some people want to be entertained when they watch their team play and that shouldn’t be too much to ask of a club of United’s stature and resources. Mourinho will never deliver that.
 
If you seriously see it in the same light, then idk what to say. United has always been a club with traditions to entertain the supporters. Win or lose. Mourinho doesn't do that.

I’ve been very clear about this in the past: style doesn’t concern me. I just want to see United win. Tonight was bad, but feck, it’s football.
 
honestly, that embarrassing post match shite is pissing me off a lot more than the loss. Just an arrogant prick taking the piss.
 
Paid Sevilla way too much respect over two legs and has been rightly punished.

Totally deserves the sh!tstorm thats coming his way
Do you honestly think there is anything coming his way? We are second in the league, have improved since lately and can say it's merely a blip.
 
Mou: "I've sat in this chair twice before, with Porto - Man Utd out, with Real Madrid - Man Utd out, so this is nothing new for this football club." #MUFC

Feck off Mourinho. Get out of my club.

Obviously he's right that getting knocked out of the CL is nothing new for United, but what was the point of him bringing up Porto and Madrid? Weird :wenger:
 
Well, that was a debacle, but the truth is we were never going to win the UCL this year. Let’s just go all out and beat the shit out of Manchester City, that will at least make up for going out against Sevilla.
What the hell? The truth is we were never going to win the PL. CL and FA cup should be priority and our only hope to win trophy. Beating Manchester City won't win us the PL anyway, but winning against Sevilla would give us a equal chance to other seven teams to complete for CL.
 
With the FA Cup on Saturday he's clearly trying to say "it's not a big deal" so we can move on and focus on the next match.
Rightly or wrongly of course
 
He’s right though. United have a grand total of three European Cups.

This is such a strawman. No one was expecting him to win it this season, and the anger isn't because we've gone out – it's how we've played while going out.

I wouldn't have a problem with him saying "it's very disappointing but you can't win this tournament every year, so I don't want to make a huge drama out of it for my players"

What pisses me (and many overs) off is that he made it about him and his previous successes over us. Demeaning the club and its current players to talk about his own achievements.
 
Obviously he's right that getting knocked out of the CL is nothing new for United, but what was the point of him bringing up Porto and Madrid? Weird :wenger:
Crediting himself instead of protecting the club.
 
christ. He has 2 cups, is in the running for another this year, sits 2nd behind a ridiculously great side in City and its not enough. I'm not even going to bother anymore.
Oh you're right I'm so happy we won the most pointless English cup available and barely won a cup that you're only in because you failed previously. All while playing awful football and not even doing defensive football properly. It's not all about results. But for Mourinho, it Is, fair, whatever. He has failed to get the results here though. Simple as.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.