Did as well as you can expect a 36 year old to do on his own at this level.
35
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 30
- Clean sheets
- 8
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 1
- Yellow cards
- 2
- Status
Casemiro made the first and more important mistake, but bad defending for the goal
Casemiro, Evans, Wan Bissaka all did bad there I think.
Still, if both Varane and Lindelof are leaving this summer, I'd keep Evans for another year. Martinez, Maguire, new CB, Kambwala + Evans (hopefully featuring less than this season). That would be enough as we won't play Europe most probably.
No way. Much prefer to see Kambwala or another young player playing if thats the level of performance thats put in
Thought he was great considering everything? Like how good he is on the ball.
36 year old, hadnt played for most of last season with injury, had to play his second game in the space of a week and its only 1-0 against the team who have scored the most goals. He's literally doing as good as he possibly can. There's no way he'd have thought he'd have to play this much when we brought him in. Everyone else should be ashamed they arent putting the graft in that he has.
Well as 5th CB and (most probably) no Europe he wouldn't play often. More of an option to have, like a 3rd GK. And he's had a solid season taking everything into account.
He hasn't played 'extremely well', but I'd say he's been good for most of the season. The odd bad game, but the good has definitely outweighed it.
Thought he played well today
He's been as good as our poorly performing CBs in a team that finishes 8th in the league. Maguire has been better but sure, he's been as good as the rest. But I would rather see youngsters given those few precious games if this is the standard of performance we get from the senior players. Its not good enough for a team hoping to finish higher than we are.
He's done better than expected and that might be because I never thought he would be starting for united v arsenal in 2024.
Decent today, but if we end up keeping him an extra year it'll be ridiculous scenes.
He was ok, clearly he wasn’t fit, as per getting subbed.
i still can’t believe he came to United for training help so that he could stay fit and find a new club. Instead here he is playing lots of games for United
i still can’t believe he came to United for training help so that he could stay fit and find a new club. Instead here he is playing lots of games for United
Man Utd 3:2 Newcastle
Another solid if unspectacular display.
Doubt if even he thought he'd play as much as he has this season. Been a good signing.
Doubt if even he thought he'd play as much as he has this season. Been a good signing.
Honestly wouldn't think anything of him signing on for another year, helps the HG quota and all things being well, shouldn't see half as much football as he has done this year, will be useful alongside a young 4th CB in Europa Conference if we get in and as a captain for that side in general if we go young.
Him potentially outlasting varane is a funny thought to me.
Last edited:
Would be Uttar madness
And to think that he just came back to the club to stay fit whilst he was without a club.
We should keep him for another year.
We know Varane will leave and probably one of Lindelof/Maguire as well so keep Evans for another season would be good decision. Hopefully he'll play less minutes next season if he stays though.
Been alright having a CB with PL medals under his name
I think he's been one of our best players this season to be fair. We shouldn't be relying on him but he's done a great job.
I can't imagining us signing two centre backs this summer, so with Varane leaving and one or both of Maguire or Lindelof on the way out, he'd be worth another year as 4th or 5th choice.
I can't imagining us signing two centre backs this summer, so with Varane leaving and one or both of Maguire or Lindelof on the way out, he'd be worth another year as 4th or 5th choice.
Definitely worth an extra season. He was good last night, and he brings real experience to the squad and a winning mentality. Would love him to stay on as back up
Man City 1:2 Man Utd
Massive, the experience was vital today
Best value signing we made since SAF retired.
Calm and cool. Smart signing, would be fine if he is around next season.
delighted for this man.
Good for him.
Having him around for another year wouldn't hurt us.
Having him around for another year wouldn't hurt us.
Happy for him. Didn't expect he would play as much as he did or even at all in 2024 
But a fa cup winners medal, not bad
But a fa cup winners medal, not bad
Who would've expected him to come back, have a good season (from an individual POV), and earn an FA Cup winners medal after beating City a few years ago? Even just a year ago!
If he's off, what a way to end your career.
If he's off, what a way to end your career.
Abd they say you can't live your dreams. Chuffed for him.
Unexpectedly, he completed his United domestic quadruple today. Well done Jonny. Would like to see you stay at the club next season.
Slotted in seamlessly. Oh yes.
Only PL winner in our side so great to see him win a trophy with us after all these years. Keep him for another year. Varane and probably another CB are leaving anyway.
I guess he's won every domestic trophy with us now ?
Had we made conference league would've kept him just for those games to be surrounded by youth. Europe might be a bit much to ask since I'd want to go hard in that.
Fantastic, absolutely fantastic. Must be a dream for him.
Anyway... Anyone knows what's Rafael up to these days? He might cover the full backs too
Anyway... Anyone knows what's Rafael up to these days? He might cover the full backs too
Delighted for him, what a send off.
Completed the trophy set on the way out the door as well.
Completed the trophy set on the way out the door as well.
Have him replace Huddlestone as the player-coach. Let him stay as long as he likes. Legend.
Delighted for him. Would love to see him get Huddlestone’s old role
- Status