Joao Neves | signed for PSG
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have four new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting.
A new Odds or Evens competition is starting now. Click here to read the rules and message Damien to submit your eight players by 14th September 2024
A new Carabao Cup prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for round 3 which begins 17th September.
A new Champions League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 17th September.
A new Europa League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 25th September.
For Odds or Evens you have until the 14th September to submit your players. Submissions will be open for the next 6 days, 11 hours, 30 minutes, 13 seconds, and will close on Sep 14, 2024 at 12:30. -
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) get the depressing job of reviewing United's 3-0 loss at Old Trafford to Liverpool. They discuss what went wrong, Casemiro's day to forget, and the pressure now on Erik Ten Hag. They also take some time to give McTominay a proper farewell, and give their overall thoughts on the Summer Transfer Window.
- Status
I'd say, he's similar to a Xavi type i.e. high volume passer, always showing for the ball whereas Mainoo is more Inesta i.e able to jink past players and do the unexpected but still good in possession. Not a perfect comparison but still good I think. Where I'm going with this is that we'll need a "big" behind them that's decent on the ball but also physical and athletic enough. Don't ask me what we do with Bruno.
Am definitely warming to the idea of splashing Jim's cash for him.
This is how I see it. Get him in this summer, and hopefully have ourselves in a position where we can spend big on Wharton next summer if we don’t need much else (assuming he continues to improve next season).
Be interesting to see how Toby Collyer progresses?
Very frustrating knowing nothing can be properly negeotiated until after the Euros by which time he could have had a great tournament and interest from other clubs comes in + his price sky rockets.
There’s nothing other than Ten Hag talking to him on the pitch to suggest that he’s on the brink of the first team but you never know of course.
Too early to say obviously but that would be something to see.
Well finally see a United side who’s core strength apart from Counter attack can be possession football.
This would be some signing “if” it happens
His price won't be impacted. He's a "release clause or nothing" player, so it's 120m or you don't get him.
Spoiler, we won't get him.
Didn't it already come down? It started at 120M and down to 90M or something from last rumors.
The more I see of him, the more I think he looks like a player Pep would have at City.
I'm not getting my hopes up only to see them swoop in and sign him. I still haven't properly gotten over Chelsea gazumping us for Essien all those years ago.
I'm not getting my hopes up only to see them swoop in and sign him. I still haven't properly gotten over Chelsea gazumping us for Essien all those years ago.
Probably just a euro vs pound difference
Only if you're going to an absolute cowboy for an exchange rate.
That is a very interesting mix of players indeed
Regardless whether you think he can play in double pivot with Mainoo in 4231 or he can only play no 8 with Mainoo as no 8 in 433, investing money on him is still considered as investing in great future for the club and the long term objective.
I gets different vibes between him and Sancho. I feel like he’s not just talented but he also has top class professional attitude and character, which something Sancho lacks.
I gets different vibes between him and Sancho. I feel like he’s not just talented but he also has top class professional attitude and character, which something Sancho lacks.
Yeah so wish we could agree a deal with his agent during euros, however bet he won't be open to that because will want competition for his client
The no 8 in 433 is different to no 8 in diamond formation.
Mainoo isn’t mobile enough to play in the role of the no 8 in that diamond formation IMO. He’s more suited to no 6 or no 10 if we are switching diamond formation.
The amount of cover that mobile no 8 needs to do to help his full back and his midfield is a lot and I’m not sure Mainoo is the kind of player.
I’ve seen him live twice but I’m 100% in..
Build with midfielders that can create space for themselves and others whilst also keeping a shape.
Build with midfielders that can create space for themselves and others whilst also keeping a shape.
Frustrating we can't go all in for him due to the fact we have other issues in the first XI too
The fact that we have people who want to see him play in front of a DM, and others want to see him play at the base of midfield should tell us enough on how rounded he is.
I have been on this train for a while but every game I see, I become more impressed.
The only impact I can see the Euros having on his price would be the structure of his deal (if below the release clause), as you might have to make the incentives more achievable if he looks very good on an international stage, and his wages would be much higher too.
I have been on this train for a while but every game I see, I become more impressed.
The only impact I can see the Euros having on his price would be the structure of his deal (if below the release clause), as you might have to make the incentives more achievable if he looks very good on an international stage, and his wages would be much higher too.
Every other club that is after him would have as well then.
Doesn't get the attention unless our name is the one in the headline though.
Rather than comparing him to Rodri, he’s more like Roy Keane than Rodri IMO. Rodri is less aggressive than Neves.
Yes, then I think we agree. Your last line there sums it up for me. Wonderful as Neves might well be, we simply aren't in a position to spend that kind of money on any player this summer, let alone one who isn't the obvious uncomplicated 'right answer' to play in the same XI as Mainoo and Bruno.
That's a short term look at building a team. We already know we're not going to be amazing next year. Just getting him improves us though compared to our midfield options this past season. So even in the short term it's an improvement. However, you don't always have to solve every issue United have in a transfer window. As long as you have a plan that we will solve that in the following transfer windows, it should be fine.
There are also times you have to just strike. Which players are available is all up in the air. Different clubs have different needs depending on the window. If Neves is available now, with not much competition to win him over, then the time to get is now. Because you don't know which top clubs will want him later on. Similarly, the right player you (not you specifically) want could not be available this season (Wharton), but might be available next year.
If we maximize our ceiling, the chances of winning the biggest trophies increase. Neves and Mainoo have the right mentality, great talent, and great profiles for a future midfield foundation when United should be hitting their peak window for trophy contention. And they're pretty good right now too.
We can spend that much so long as we're strict on balancing those types of signings with outgoings and incoming players. If there is a chance for Casemiro to leave, already that leaves you in great position. The combination of wages, and transfer fee from Saudi clubs gives us an out. Varane leaving frees up wages. Brandon Williams just left and he was getting paid a small amount compared to other top players, but too much for his contribution.
The balancing act can be done. I don't like thinking of it as impossible. The club management just has to be smart.
Last edited:
Have you actually watched Neves play?
I was trying to find player highlights for him from last night’s Ireland game because I always feel they’re a much more accurate representation of a player than the handpicked highlights packages.
There doesn’t seem to be one yet but I found this one from the Finland game last week (apologies if it has already been posted):
Very tidy player, press resistant with great touch and awareness. A much safer passer than I’d imagined him to be with the majority being bounce passes or backwards passes. A couple of nice switches peppered in there too.
There doesn’t seem to be one yet but I found this one from the Finland game last week (apologies if it has already been posted):
Very tidy player, press resistant with great touch and awareness. A much safer passer than I’d imagined him to be with the majority being bounce passes or backwards passes. A couple of nice switches peppered in there too.
I was watching a thing last night on best midfielders of the 90’s and it struck me who Neves reminds me of as well as Carrick and that’s Edgar Davids, Davids like Neves wasn’t the tallest but incredibly strong and a very good ball winner whilst also being a very good passer even if it did go unnoticed due to Davids playing with Zidane and Del Piero.
I don’t see any reason why Mainoo and Neves couldn’t play together with Fernandes ahead of them and there’s a lot of Seedorf in Mainoo, as pairings go Seedorf and Davids weren’t too bad were they ?
I don’t see any reason why Mainoo and Neves couldn’t play together with Fernandes ahead of them and there’s a lot of Seedorf in Mainoo, as pairings go Seedorf and Davids weren’t too bad were they ?
We're restricted once again by our inability to move players on, especially those on fat wages.
The management of our transfer outgoings has held us back on numerous occasions.
The management of our transfer outgoings has held us back on numerous occasions.
Much more combative against Sweden for those trying to ascertain his CDM credentials. Nice bit of tapping up by Bruno at the end:
He still looks raw getting disposessed a couple of times and losing a couple of battles but there’s definitely talent there.
He still looks raw getting disposessed a couple of times and losing a couple of battles but there’s definitely talent there.
Last edited:
Bruno's been in his ear from day one. 
It can be done but it's simply not necessary to take that risk when a more straightforward approach seeking to put square pegs into square holes is possible.
Every season there will be 'must get' players. We are never going to find ourselves in a position where we have £100m to spend and no 'generational, must-have' players to spend it on.
I am also not convinced by the 'buy this 19/20/21-year-old and their position is solved for the next ten years' mindset, enticing as it is. We hear it every summer, and sometimes we get that player. I think I have actually seen it work for us twice since I was a kid: Wayne Rooney, and David de Gea. That is not a good return on that approach to signings.
My other point still stands: whether it would be the right thing to do this or not, we simply can't afford him. He has a €120m (£101m) release clause. We don't have that much money to spend.
Last edited:
You can definitely see the pros and cons of Neves here. I think his height is still a big issue, as he goes for aerial duels but he doesn't win any because of his physique. On the other hand his football skills and determination is great. I think we should sign him if he doesn't cost more than 75m plus bonuses. He looks incredibly talented, but we gotta improve other areas, too.
Well got to see an entire game of his for the first time. Seemed a tad nervous at the start, but grew into the game and kept things ticking and simple.
Good work rate, decent technique, a couple of long passes from deep to show his range. All in all a strong performance for a promising 19y old.
Should improve with experience, but don't understand the 100mil valuation, and I am afraid it would weigh too much on him if he were signed for that amazing amount.
Same as Felix in that regard, basically.
Good work rate, decent technique, a couple of long passes from deep to show his range. All in all a strong performance for a promising 19y old.
Should improve with experience, but don't understand the 100mil valuation, and I am afraid it would weigh too much on him if he were signed for that amazing amount.
Same as Felix in that regard, basically.
So am I, both players have been deployed as DM in games this season at their respective ages, both players have also played in the 8 this season.
So, when you have 2 players that can play that, they will mature and understand, one goes forward, one sits. This would make us unpredictable.
Also, we have seen us play a 3-1-6 this season, we can adapt that to a 3-2-5 which will help us defensively and both these can keep the ball better, so going forward we should be able to play better too.
Looks like a 60M player at best, and a risky one at that. Very raw and lost the ball in dangerous areas of the pitch. I didn't see the aura great midfielders have. Kobbie has shown flickers of it. Only 1 match though - I'd love to see more of him in the Euros.
I cannot see a midfield trio of Kobbie, Neves and Bruno working defensively, though.
I cannot see a midfield trio of Kobbie, Neves and Bruno working defensively, though.
Hes better than Mainoo at the moment especially defensively too
To me he's got the weight and running style of Brian mcclair sign him up.
I would say aura is something he definitely has.
- Status