Reddy Rederson
New Member
Harry Kane just gave him a look of utter disgust
Harry Kane just gave him a look of utter disgust
He played alright and you have to feel sorry for him; hes been practicising that celebration for weeks and it was for nothing.
Given he's energetic and doesn't produce in the final third, that would the natural shift to make for him. However like many have alluded I don't think he has the defensive grit and physicality to produce in that role. You can get away with being an average passer in midfield these days if you make up for it either with physicality or dribbling ability. I don't think just stamina and movement will cut it.I have a genuine question about Lingard, shouldn't he play in center midfield in a trio? He may be small but he plays with energy, he respects instructions and has a decent technique. He isn't really an attacker and doesn't have attacker's tools. Could he become a poor's man Milner?
We should extend his contract just in case he is shit next season as well. Because season after next, or after next next he is surely gonna be great. Still young, local lad, it's just a matter of time.I think Lingard has not been as good last year but maybe with faster play he will be better next season.
I have a genuine question about Lingard, shouldn't he play in center midfield in a trio? He may be small but he plays with energy, he respects instructions and has a decent technique. He isn't really an attacker and doesn't have attacker's tools. Could he become a poor's man Milner?
Don't understand the hate tonight, he actually played quite well. Unlucky not to get the winner.
He always does play better for England strangely. I wonder if it's due to the slower tempo of International football.
Well he is arguably playing with better players yes, but he just looks more individually dangerous in an England shirt.Strangely? With the desperate attacking football United have been producing for most of the last few seasons, I would find it more strange if the likes of Lingard didn’t play better for their national teams.
Well he is arguably playing with better players yes, but he just looks more individually dangerous in an England shirt.
The run for his disallowed goal for example, he rarely ever makes those sort of runs with United. If he did he'd score a lot more!
Yeah that's a good point, England do have an identity under Southgate which is why we've actually been doing quite well recently.Not making excuses for the lad but England may not have WC players in every Diggle position - but they do play in a systematic and symmetrically imposing way.
At United players like Rashford, Martial, Sanchez, Lukaku, Lingard have been playing without a single RW who stretches out the defence. The defenders just sit at RB and the centre and our attack is easily handled by quantity even more so than just quality.
Im not rating him to any of our players - but I really don't see Mane doing so well at Liverpool if it was Mata who played on the RW for them because the defence can just load up on the LW to block Mane & the central areas.
Something so basic is going to effect a lot of our players & we still didn't play players like Sanchez much at RW even just for cover or use.
Yeah that's a good point, England do have an identity under Southgate which is why we've actually been doing quite well recently.
I think it's the clear reason why Rashford and Lingard look better under England.
They'd just ask for £30-40m outright for Brooks. I highly doubt they'd want Lingard and his wages on their books.Still don't want ! Hope some one like Bournemouth could swap him with one of their players like Brooks.
Over 5mil a year for below average squad player is just too much
What the hell are you talking about - Lingard IS the RW. He (and Mata) are the very reason we haven't "stretched out" defenses for the strikers. In every post, you make sure to tell us that you don't rate Lingard or he's just a squad player and then proceed to give a long treatise about how great he is or would be at something. All the fanboys want to be stealth fanboys now ("he's just a squad player" has become a code on the Caf for "I love Jesse but I'm afraid to say it publicly now") and the second he scores his next goal sometime in December, you'll all be creaming your jeans.Not making excuses for the lad but England may not have WC players in every Diggle position - but they do play in a systematic and symmetrically imposing way.
At United players like Rashford, Martial, Sanchez, Lukaku, Lingard have been playing without a single RW who stretches out the defence. The defenders just sit at RB and the centre and our attack is easily handled by quantity even more so than just quality.
Im not rating him to any of our players - but I really don't see Mane doing so well at Liverpool if it was Mata who played on the RW for them because the defence can just load up on the LW to block Mane & the central areas.
Something so basic is going to effect a lot of our players & we still didn't play players like Sanchez much at RW even just for cover or use.
What the hell are you talking about - Lingard IS the RW. He (and Mata) are the very reason we haven't "stretched out" defenses for the strikers. In every post, you make sure to tell us that you don't rate Lingard or he's just a squad player and then proceed to give a long treatise about how great he is or would be at something. All the fanboys want to be stealth fanboys now ("he's just a squad player" has become a code on the Caf for "I love Jesse but I'm afraid to say it publicly now") and the second he scores his next goal sometime in December, you'll all be creaming your jeans.
Although I agree with the idea that because we are so unbalanced as a team it causes issues and closes off space for others to exploit that doesn’t excuse how terrible Jesse is on the ball or making decisions on the ball. He’s a serial killer of moves because he doesn’t see the pass and you can see players on the pitch getting verbally frustrated with his general lack of awareness of what is around him. Not to mention his obsession of everything must go to Rashford.No. When the whole team is struggling I'm not going to suddenly point fingers out at a player an pin point one or two random players I don't like.
Pogba is rubbish.
Martial is rubbish.
Rashford is rubbish.
Lukaku is, Sanchez is, Lindelof is, Smalling is, Young is - why the hell would I blame Lingard for this.
I don't have supremely high expectations of him but I'm not willing to give up on him until I see the whole team is good enough and then he struggles. He plays a type of football that is more in line with some of the more important players in the club, he has won cups for us, every manager uses him, has decent performances for England etc. He does well when the rest of the team is doing well.
The moment we do well and Lingard sticks out like a sore thumb for being out of his depth like quentin fortune or Obertan then I'd tell him to leave but he doesn't right now because the whole squad is struggling.
As I said - Mane from Liverpool would struggle here due to the sheer imbalance of our squad and its positioning only.
I want to fix the balance of the squad and its tactics & then if Jesse isn't good enough then get him out.
This club's truly doomed.Talks opening over a new contract and pay rise upto 130 thousand a week.
This should make a lot of people happy
Talks opening over a new contract and pay rise upto 130 thousand a week.
This should make a lot of people happy
Talks opening over a new contract and pay rise upto 130 thousand a week.
This should make a lot of people happy
Worth it just to see people fume.
Ole sees him as the future of United and does not want to lose him .
If we are lucky enough that he accepts the 130 000 a week and does sign a new contract I hope he gets the no 7 shirt too
Wouldn't take it that far
Talks opening over a new contract and pay rise upto 130 thousand a week.
This should make a lot of people happy
This club's truly doomed.
??The only ManUnited player Barca should after.
His movement and style will fit Barca perfectly. He can cause havoc in opponents defence by dragging defenders out of place and it will let Messi do his things. He's adept at starting a false counter attack (countering really fast only to track back when He's a only few metres from the box and then He can pass to Messi).
He can also be a poacher, a false 10 (AM who always trackbacks to help RB), a false winger (a Right winger that never beats the fullback and cutting inside every time) and making false runs all over the pitch (He will run and work really hard to make the opponents think He's doing something important even though He isn't - catching them off guard).
And He is also very trendy. Definitely born to be a Barca player.
Talks opening over a new contract and pay rise upto 130 thousand a week.
This should make a lot of people happy
The only ManUnited player Barca should after.
His movement and style will fit Barca perfectly. He can cause havoc in opponents defence by dragging defenders out of place and it will let Messi do his things. He's adept at starting a false counter attack (countering really fast only to track back when He's a only few metres from the box and then He can pass to Messi).
He can also be a poacher, a false 10 (AM who always trackbacks to help RB), a false winger (a Right winger that never beats the fullback and cutting inside every time) and making false runs all over the pitch (He will run and work really hard to make the opponents think He's doing something important even though He isn't - catching them off guard).
And He is also very trendy. Definitely born to be a Barca player.