- Joined
- May 13, 2008
- Messages
- 16,820
Its Palestine and Israel nothing will change in our life times.
DrunkenYoda, firstly, I hope you and your loved ones are safe, nobody deserves to feel threatened in their home. However, the people who's homes are under questioned, shouldn't be there in the first place, it's not Israeli land, it stems back to 1881, you can't just come in, take peoples land and claim it as a God given right.
Hamas are a terrorist organisation, and an extremist one at that, but that's not why Israel have problems with them. The IDF are just as bad, the only difference is they're organised.
I will never have to go through what you are, so I won't understand it as well, but I have close family members who have gone through the same situation (being bombed) up North, and what they have gone through is similar to what the Palestinians, and to a lesser but no less important amount, the Israelis.
When people are persecuted, tortured and run out of their homes, extremism happens, think the IRA (a once respected organisation turned terrorist paramilitary organisation.) Think the rise of the far right in Greece. When bad things happen, these people think they have an excuse. I'm not saying I sympathize with extremism, Jihad or Hamas, but what I'm saying is, your Government is in no means innocent, it's worse.
DrunkenYoda said:if you can post it as a response to you and others
firstly, thank you for the care.
secondly, I don't want to say what my thought are about this situation in the west bank, but I served there and it's not as people are thinking. the arabs in the west bank work with and for Israelis in the same place. I know you might think we're at war and killing each other all day long, but no, Arabs from the west bank are building the houses for the Israelis there !! yes, I've seen it with my own eyes, and yet i guess no one would believe me. btw where do you think Israelis go in the west bank when their car breaks out? take a guess.
but the Hamas situation is something else, Hamas doesn't want those lands, Hamas wants Israel to die. simple as that. Me, my parents, their parents, grew up hoping one day there will be peace. I don't want those wars and no one in Israel wants it. no one wants to rise kids in this situation. but it is being forced upon us. every time the the arabs nations / arabs living in Israel (palastine is a name given by the brits 90 years ago to the land of Israel, which is was named Israel 3000 years ago.
the land wasn't theirs in 1881 or whatever year you think it is. it was never given to them, it was never theirs to take. the arabs called 'Palastine' are group of people from all arabs nations around this area that came to Israeli sattlements and tried to live here. they didn't do a good job and the land of Israel was named as a 'complete ussless dessert that isn't worthy living' (by a brit that came here 120 years ago). Untill we came and made something with this land.now for the sentance about the IDF, sadly and truly I'm outraged because you won't see someone from Hamas posting here to tell you his side, but from my side I can tell you that the IDF is the most moral army in the world. we take care of injured terrorists, we take them to our hospitals, I had many occasiouns when a Hamas member was sitting eye-wrapped next to me and while you would think I'd hurt him, Me and the others didn't put a finger aginst him.
now look at the one Israeli in the Hamas hands. 5 years in prison underground, being tourchered, no one could knew if he's alive or not, when Shalit came back to Israel his arm was injured. tell me how in 5 years it didn't healed ?
look at the Americans, the mighty brits in afganistan and Iraq, look at Russia in their late wars, look at Syria, Egypt, Jurden and evrery other army in the world and you would see the the IDF does his maximum to minimize civilians being hurt and tries as much as it can NOT to kill but to make the other side surrender .
they weren't prasacuted, you might need to look for the Israeli History .
when first Israelis sattlers started building big citys (btw, most of the land were bought from arabs living in Israel, and some of them are in Jorden/Syria hands ) then the arabs living in small camps in here started killing the Israelis.
then we started the Hagana which means Defense in Hebrew (look at the meanings of our forces next to theirs, "The Jihad etc ..") to protect the people. after we were given by the UN nation of our own, we were attacked by the same people, plus Jurden Syria Lebanon Eygpt and Iraq if I recall. since that we've been attacked many times by the same forces, always winning the wars and then declaring truce. we gave Sinai (which is bigger then Israel) just to make peace with Eygpt just so they'll cross us now and help the Hamas.
There's a saying in Israel
When the Arabs will lay down their weapons, there will be peace.
When we will lay down our weapons, we will die.
That's as simple as that
Its a simple matter really:
United Nations Security Council Resolution 242:
Those territories include the WB and East Jerusalem, which Israel are currently occupying. Their violations of this have been crystal to the point where follow-up resolutions were out through condemning settlement expansion within these territories (vetoed by the US). The legal standings for this aren't even debatable.
Hamas was democratically elected by the Gaza electorate. The Palestinians had no say on whether they approved Israeli's settling in their territories.
It basically seems to be saying, "we Israelis are lovely and have done nothing wrong, it's all the fault of those horrible aggressive Arabs who have no right to be here anyway".
What are the odds of fatah coming back into power?
From the RT Live Feed: http://rt.com/news/gaza-israel-hamas-attack-687/
Nov. 15, 20:40 GMT:
An Israeli strike killed a UN school teacher in Gaza. Marwan Abu El Qumsan, an Arabic teacher at a UN school, was killed as his car was hit by a bomb on Thursday, the UN Palestinian refugee agency, UNRWA, says on its website.
How would that happen? Are you expecting free election in Gaza? Any potential candidates are still alive?
the last election was widely declared to have been both free and fair, Fatah lost out narrowly in a Democratic Election.
http://www.eu-un.europa.eu/articles/fr/article_5621_fr.htm
I recall people on here claiming Hamas took power because of Fatah corruption and not because the Palestinian society sides with the movement extreme ideology.
This is true in more than one sense.
Hamas won a free, fair and democratic election in 2006...by 44% to 41% for Fatah. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_legislative_election,_2006
background to that was a lot of things, but primarily Palestinian attitudes were hardened after years of the illegal occupation and lack of support from people like the UN, they felt abandoned by the existing government and by the international community and voted for Hamas because they wanted to actually do something and defend them against Israel's illegal and ongoing occupation.
Hamas and Fatah have been in negotiations over the next election date, though obviously the current Israeli attack will delay this of course.
that included ethnically cleansing of 8000 Jewish settlers.
You got to be taking the piss with lack of UN support for the Palestinians. Tens of millions of people had to flee their homes in the 1940's around the globe, and the Palestinians were the only ones to get a UN aid agency of their own. Quite telling that the same bunch of people stand out with their "refugee" status 60-odd years on, suggesting UN support has done nothing but hinder a lasting solution to their plight.
I thought you said to RK that this wasn't the time for slogans? And then you come out with the term ethnic cleansing to describe a group of people removed by their own ethnic/religious group?
The UNSC. That is the only UN organisation that really matters. And as long as each country there has veto power and Palestine remains a non-state, the UN will always do nothing for the Palestinians.
This is exactly what I meant. This was an act which was in sharp contrast to the so-called expansionism often attributed to the Zionists on this board. The Zionist regime evacuated an "ultra-Zionist" population from their homes, handing Fatah full control of the Gaza Strip. Next came free democratic parliamentary election in the Palestinian territories, and the people had their say. What happened next in the Gaza Strip suggested that this democratic exercise was a one-off.
My point is that this is not the definition of ethnic cleaning, considering that it was Jews who evacuated Jews (their religious or political beliefs at this point become irrelevant) and I couldn't miss the irony considering your previous request of RK not to use slogans and the history of the situation and how there came to be Palestinian refugees in the first place.
Anyway HR, what is the general consensus in Israel about what will happen next? A few more salvoes between the IDF and Hamas before a ceasefire is mediated via Egypt? Or another Cast lead?
The official United Nations definition of ethnic cleansing is "rendering an area ethnically homogeneous by using force or intimidation to remove from a given area persons of another ethnic or religious group."
Though other people will remove the by another ethnic or religious group, I don't think it really makes sense to claim that a race is ethnically cleansing itself.
I wasn't here 7 years ago so cannot comment on those discussions but what is your opinion on why Hamas was voted in?
Hamas was democratically elected within a year of Israel's complete withdrawal from the Gaza Strip. that included ethnically cleansing of 8000 Jewish settlers.
You got to be taking the piss with lack of UN support for the Palestinians. Tens of millions of people had to flee their homes in the 1940's around the globe, and the Palestinians were the only ones to get a UN aid agency of their own. Quite telling that the same bunch of people stand out with their "refugee" status 60-odd years on, suggesting UN support has done nothing but hinder a lasting solution to their plight.
The general concensus is that a situation in which Hamas dictates the daily lives of a million Israelis could not continue any longer. Egypt's role in this is hard to predict, because Mursi finds himself in a tricky position here.
The nature of these cyclic escalations is unpredictable, and often dictated by chance. What we know for sure is that both Hamas and Israel will survive this round. We also know that Israel works within a limited window of time before international pressure to stop the operation mounts. Add to this the high likelihood that a stray bomb kills a large number of innocent civilians, much to the satisfaction of some sick individuals, further limiting this window. Then there is the will of both sides to have the upper hand, meaning for example that if Tel Aviv is hit or a school is bombed Israel could well have its plans revised.
The general concensus is that a situation in which Hamas dictates the daily lives of a million Israelis could not continue any longer.
withdrawal but not ending of the occupation or blockade or siege or assassinations of democratically elected politicians...you mean where you listened to international law for once and stopped occupying some land illegally? don't fecking insult people by calling that ethnic cleansing, it's nothing of the sort.
you mean the 1940's when the UK and other powers took the Palestinians land from them and gave it to you because of international pressure from Zionists? and then when the international community did nothing during your ACTUAL ethnic cleansing of Palestinians and other Arabs during your expansionary wars? 60 years on and Israel continues to expand by brute force and in violation of countless UN resolutions that the UN only can't enforce because of your American overseers...
but who cares about the fact the Palestinians can't get enough food or clean water or sustain themselves because of your blockade, thereby meaning almost every death in Gaza is on your hands...and the constant assassinations of their elected government not only in Gaza but in other nations as well, all of this utterly illegal under international law of course...but a few crude rockets that kill barely anyone are apparently justification for you nations latest attempt at further genocide of the Palestinian population.
your "stray bombs" seem to kill a lot of civilians a lot of the time...and schools? you mean like the UN one you dropped chemical weapons on?
Warm thanks to the American tax-payers too.
Current Death Toll
20 dead - 5 confirmed militants/terrorists/freedom fighters, 8 civilians on the Palestinian side
3 civilians killed on the Israeli side
*Can't find reliable information for the remaining 7 Palestinian dead, they could be members of Hamas or civilians.
-Israel hit 130 sites overnight
-Hamas fired 11 rockets at Israel from Gaza
Lull in bombing as promised by Israel with the visit of the Egyptian PM.
Think nothing of it