Did against Arsenal.
Is Fred the worst regular starter for United in living memory?
- Thread starter PeteManic
- Start date
He is probably the worst regular starter for United.
But he usually ends as the best at the end of the games though.
But he usually ends as the best at the end of the games though.
He's very good in the right set up
Motm, again.
Man of the match today.
Ah well then, must of been exceptional then
the only defence he gets is
A - he runs around
B - he’s better than the other midfielders
I see you opted for option B
still doesn’t make him a good player, he’s maybe above average and that’s it
His first half was as bad as I've seen. Excellent second but can't be motm with half of it like that
Enigma of a player. Some great touches and plays. Sets up our first goal and gets a pen for also making a good run. He also made some nice interceptions, and as always he played better in the second half. However, he is also sometimes very loose in possession and sometimes makes is unable to make the easiest passes. Overall an important contribution today, but weird.
Jesus wept
Yep. Mistakes don’t matter and he’s so difficult to escape - little Duracell fuelled pastor. I reckon RR’s short term plan will be 4222 with Bruno and Fred in the middle 2.
No and this thread should be locked.
I voted him man of the match and then immediately wondered if taking out your own goalkeeper from a corner, allowing the opposition an open goal, should automatically rule him out?
No.
He's a very good player from the half way line to the edge of the opposition box. A DM he isn't.
Change this to Scott
That's a fecking nightmare for any midfield. I'm really excited.
He’s the first midfielders name on the team sheet in this squad.
That says something about our midfield however he’s better than a lot give him credit for and has been involved in some key goals for us recently.
That says something about our midfield however he’s better than a lot give him credit for and has been involved in some key goals for us recently.
Not a DM, as we all knew. Carrick has given him freedom to operate and get up and down the pitch whilst denoting McTominay as the holding player. This plays to Fred's strengths and he has done well the last couple of games, although still prone to stupid mistakes and gifts to the opposition.
Fred pretty much won the match, so I don't see how it is absurd that he could be chosen for Man of the Match.
Aside from the assist and the penalty, he created some other great opportunities: pass through to Telles in the box; winning the ball before Ronaldo was too greedy; starting the counter attack with Sancho in the second half etc.
Aside from the assist and the penalty, he created some other great opportunities: pass through to Telles in the box; winning the ball before Ronaldo was too greedy; starting the counter attack with Sancho in the second half etc.
Thought he looked very nervous and wasnt great first half but he wasn't alone. That said contributed to the win with both goals. Tale of two Freds but we lose that game without him....
What are people drinking thinking he's motm? He isn't a bad player, and will always work hard and make a great block or tackle here and there, but no top club can tolerate the amount of mistakes he makes. He'd be a great midtable player, but if we want to challenge, there's no room for constant mistakes. Every pass he misplaces in midfield puts creates an instant opportunity for the opposition.
I've always rated him. He has some shocking moments which are comically bad and these stick in the mind but generally he's our best midfielder.
Fred will improve to be a top player under Rangnick.
I don't particularly rate him bit he isn't even the worst player in the McFred partnership.
If you’re looking for the worst, check your memories for Schneiderlin.
Whatever man. If you can't admit he was good against Chelsea, then we're way too far apart. The point I was making was a very narrow one, I don't want to get into the Fred is good or bad debate, you can write volumes about it and it still won't be resolved. My argument was a very narrow response to this post:
He does go up high to pressure and players do often beat his pressure which leaves a wide open gap in midfield they can attack into. I'm just saying you can plug that by playing a DM behind him and continuing to utilize him high up the pitch.
Yeah but the only one we have is Matic. And he can’t play every game. So it’s a hindrance more often than it’s a benefit.
Can only imagine what Ralf is thinking about this fella 
My issue is with the term “exceptional”
now I’m reading Fred, a ball winning mid needs another ball winning mid behind to cover for when he gets beaten
we need players with vision and ability on the ball man, we have enough foot soldiers
Agreed
Two wrongs don’t make a right though
I'd rather not, thank you.
Can only imagine what Ralf is thinking about this fella
My guess is he thinks he’ll make a very useful player out of him.
Or he’s an awful player who belongs at another club once he can be replaced
Feck me sideways, what does he have to do for people to cut him some slack? That's two assists tonight and ultimately the difference between winning or losing.
I’d bet good money he absolutely feels the opposite. Fred can seriously press, like no other in this squad. He’ll need polishing and tactical fouling will be extremely important but I’d be amazed if RR doesn’t see him as important. I can’t see him playing so far back as he did with Ole though.
Also played his part in both of Arsenal's goals.
No. Always gives his all.
If we go down a break down every player and judge him by the mistakes, it will be very difficult to praise any player really, because every palyer makae plenty of mistakes in the run of games and today, except for defenders bar Telles but in the end he stepped up in the second half and basically won us the game again by borderline MOTM contribution with two assists and a great block in between some great play in the second half and less impressive in the first. You can't really blame a player like that.
Imagine he didn't have to spend his last three years playing out of position and with Sunday league athlete Matic, headless chicken McTominay or constantly switching off Pogba but most importantly in a system with no system, where he's the only one player doing the defensive game properly but totally out of sync with the rest of the team.
Easily the most important and underrated player for us the last three years. He will absolutely thrive under Rangnick and the next manager, so I am happy for him, he we will finally gets his appreciation. Still has a lot of fuel left in his tank, best athlete and the most commited player in the team as well.
Imagine he didn't have to spend his last three years playing out of position and with Sunday league athlete Matic, headless chicken McTominay or constantly switching off Pogba but most importantly in a system with no system, where he's the only one player doing the defensive game properly but totally out of sync with the rest of the team.
Easily the most important and underrated player for us the last three years. He will absolutely thrive under Rangnick and the next manager, so I am happy for him, he we will finally gets his appreciation. Still has a lot of fuel left in his tank, best athlete and the most commited player in the team as well.
I find this opinion incredibly strange, given Fred literally partners a much more limited and far less active player in midfield in McTominay.
Another crucial performance by Fred. Loads of fans with big fat egg on their face when it comes to this guy, and I for one absolutely love it.