We should remember that he was injured over the international break so probably wasn't anywhere close to sharp enough for this game in hindsight. Mourinho will know full well he made a mistake this time.
22
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 41
- Goals
- 11
- Assists
- 5
- Yellow cards
- 4
- Status
Not up to PL speed yet, long way to go in the season.
Should not have started - he should have come on in the second half.
A Vidic-esque start to his United career.
I can't remember watching a single player being dispossessed that many times in one half of football before.
The bright side is that it surely can't get worse than whatever that was today.
The bright side is that it surely can't get worse than whatever that was today.
Should not have started his first game of his Manchester United career against City. He had some good bits though and will come good.
Well... I told you guys so
What did you tell by the way? That he is Shit? If so not sure how he pulled of the season he just had.
Far too early for any i told you so.
Today he had a shocking game.
Shades of Evra. I'm not worried, he's clearly a very good player. But his management so far has been a little strange. He should have had more minutes under his belt prior to this match.
He needs to be thrown straight back in against Watford.
He needs to be thrown straight back in against Watford.
Looked off pace. I don't think he was match fit. Maybe LvG did have a point in not starting players fresh from an injury.
He'll come good. Combination of first start against a very good city side.
Almost as bad as Bravo.
We learnt nothing from Vidic and Evra, apparently. Micky looked like a lost little boy.
He's definitely not ready yet, I think that has been made blatantly obvious today. I think it was genuinely visible in his pre-season and the start of the season in his cameo's. I think the moaning in the Rooney thread about how amazing Mhki is and how he would tear it up in place of Rooney was exceptionally premature. I said before this fixture that I don't think he is ready and that I wouldn't have started him. I think it was a bit of a mistake from Jose but he had the bones in his hand and why not roll them? No?
Eye opener for him. No smooth sailing, get to work on Monday and keep bringing the intensity and transfer it to match day.
Eye opener for him. No smooth sailing, get to work on Monday and keep bringing the intensity and transfer it to match day.
He's incredibly talented and all but he's a bit soft. His strolling around and casual play wasn't good enough either.
I'd start him against Feyenoord and hope he can boost his confidence a bit and get used to how we do things.
I'd start him against Feyenoord and hope he can boost his confidence a bit and get used to how we do things.
Frustrating. Was looking forward to seeing him. Was pushed off the ball way too easily today. Needs to get used to some pressing from big boys.
I don't like the casual figure he portrays sometimes. I had him down as a Tevez like player who players like a bulldog who is possessed. Against Hull he showed that real desire to make a different, but sometimes he doesn't. It's probably a confidence thing. He will come good in the end I think.
That he's sensitive and that he will fail you guys.
Had a "What the feck is this?" look on his face at the tempo the game was played at, hopefully he'll get used to it.
Wasn't mentally ready for the game, but neither were players that I expected a lot more, like Ibrahimovic for example. Very bad game today but I am not losing hope for this guy, he is fast and dangerous player which will come handy once he gets some rhythm. What stinks is that game like this should be opportunity to show what you got so I am very disappointing that neither him or Lingard showed something more. We shall see what season brings. We will need this guy to shine in order to challenge for the title.
Completely different to his previous cameos. Couldn't work the ball at all. Are we sure it was his arm that was injured.
That period of play where he didn't chase down Kolarov? and which led to the first goal was utterly bizzare from him. He was just stood still till Rooney started going mental at him to press and even then he just half heartedly sauntererd over.
Hope the shocker he had was just lack of fitness , and debut nerves. If not and he's just mentally weak, we've got a liability on our hands.
Hope the shocker he had was just lack of fitness , and debut nerves. If not and he's just mentally weak, we've got a liability on our hands.
Looked very out of sorts. Shouldn't have started, but we all wanted him to so it is only with hindsight that we can say that. Probably should have held off for an easier opponent though
Kagawa no 2
Let's give him a chance. The PL is a different animal to the German Leauge and get looked troubled by the pace of the game. Unlike Memphis though, I think Mkhitaryan is more skilled, has a better first touch and more pace so I hope he can get used to it.
There was no excuse for his lack of pressing, however.
@An Irish Red
Agree with you on that, he needs to start in the EL, get some confidence.
He was fan-fecking tactic for Dortmund last season. Where did he go.
some people only know extremes. whas this a terrible half of football? yes, one of the worst performances ever.
but to say he will be shit for us and he is a flop is mindblowing. he didnt play one single game for 90 minutes yet. if he puts in performances like that in december you can call him a flop but not at this point of the season...
but to say he will be shit for us and he is a flop is mindblowing. he didnt play one single game for 90 minutes yet. if he puts in performances like that in december you can call him a flop but not at this point of the season...
Well half fit and half match fit getting thrwn in there with a high tempo game, being a player that has the tendency to have problems at the beginning and not having adapted so far, there it went.
Perhaps too big for him to debut in, added to the fact he has just come back from a minor injury. Rashford should have got the nod ahead of him. He'll come good though.
Very poor today. Hope this doesn't hurt his confidence.
He'll have more games similar to this one before he comes good. Those of you who expected him to hit the ground running are in for a surprise.
He is a pussy.
I hope Mourinho can make him a man. We need Miki.
However, I'm not holding my breath. SAF had failed with Kagawa.
I hope Mourinho can make him a man. We need Miki.
However, I'm not holding my breath. SAF had failed with Kagawa.
I wish him well in future but this will shut up all the moaning before every game when he doesn't start.
Just proves that some players need easing in into English football. Doesn't necessarily mean he is a poor player though.
Just proves that some players need easing in into English football. Doesn't necessarily mean he is a poor player though.
wow , what a nonsense post. Fergie had one year with Kagawa, and he played the best football under him in England. He would have probably dropped/sold Rooney the season after and played Kagawa at 10, unfortunately he retired. So i think Kagawa could have been very good for us with another season.
Mourinho has been preparing him for a month. He has been used three times as a sub. And in the biggest game, against our main opponents, instead of playing with heart and passion... he produced a turd. How much preparation does he need? He is not a kid, he is 27!
Abysmal performance. He kept giving the ball back to them.
He'll be fine. Had a poor half like everyone else for us, but you have to remember it's his first start in the league after he had an injury for Armenia mid week. Maybe not the reason for the bad performance, but just wasn't ready mentally it looked like.
Anyway, I'd have him either on the right or as the 10 in our starting 11.
Anyway, I'd have him either on the right or as the 10 in our starting 11.
was awful today, can see why he hasn't been playing, needs to adpat to the speed of the premier league
Jokes aside, I really hope that Miki is not a weak pussy like Kagawa or Mourinho will sell him in January.
Maybe today was a bit to early. Some players need at least 6 months to get to grips with this league.
I still have some faith in him.
Although I still have faith in Morgan too. So my faith in players might not be worth much.
didnt Kagawa start well? i have a vague memory of him winning player of the month in August in his first season, then Rooney got fit and kagawa became an occasional winger.
- Status