Frenkie de Jong | The last muppeting lap

Frenkie to United?


  • Total voters
    2,033
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
We learn nothing from the last few years.
We should only sign player that want to play for Man Utd especially a superstar with a massive contract for 5 to 6 years.

FDJ only want to come to us if he is forced to take significant paycut. Things could turn south very soon and we will be left with an unhappy superstar on massive contract which we can't offload.

What's more likely is De Jong will be sold at a small loss to a CL club in a year or two if things don't work out. I doubt he'll be hanging around on a big wage.
 
It's semantics, if his priority is to stay... how exactly does he want to join another club? It's the same sentiment worded differently.

The positivity posse want to do mental gymnastics to sign a player who doesn't want to be here but stay put, meanwhile slate Ronaldo for wanting out of the club (contradiction).

The point I have been making is its far from ideal to be chasing a player that doesn't want to leave their current club. It rarely if ever works out.

We're walking right into another ADM, Lukaku type scenario here and folks are blind to it.
Because Priority≠Only Option(which is what you're making it out to be) circumstances change anytime which is again where Utd come in if/when it's clear him and Barca have to part ways
Of course there is a risk it could be Di Maria 2.0 but it's still a rare opportunity to sign a world class CM in his prime that also happens to the manager's top target. Signing him first of all goes a long way in showing we're willing to back the manager with HIS players not the club's choices and Ronaldo wasn't Ole's choice for that matter. Getting another player may suit the narrative of signings but if he doesn't fit the system people will again moan about managers not getting top targets.
Tonnes of players like Robben, Alexis(Barca), Cesc, Sneijder, Pedro, Ozil etc didn't want to leave Barca or Madrid but still thrived at their new clubs after embracing new environments. At least in FDJ's case we have the best manager he's ever worked with and if he helps us improve overall as a team he'll be happy here either way even if Barca was his dream
 
We learn nothing from the last few years.
We should only sign player that want to play for Man Utd especially a superstar with a massive contract for 5 to 6 years.

FDJ only want to come to us if he is forced to take significant paycut. Things could turn south very soon and we will be left with an unhappy superstar on massive contract which we can't offload.

Exactly it would be easier to accept if you were joining a team that will challenge and win major trophies. United are a massive club and if your only option, you will go, but leaving for a team that look many years from being a CL or PL winner seems a bit disheartening to be honest, especially as the weather/area might not be to his fancy either.

Money and ETH relationship will soften the blow of course but yeah we may get to a stage where he can’t be sold even if unhappy and will eventually be loaned/leave on a free etc like Pogba.
 
I've explained my stance in detail why its a bad move for it.

The original comment I replied to above suggested because of Barca's financial woes it meant we had to at least try even if the player wanted to remain... How many other top clubs are chasing him and willing to have this circus?
Chelsea is monitoring the situation and I am sure they would like to Gazump if they get the chance.
 
Money can be withdrawn for Glazers every year. But financing a new manager's most important purchase is a problem. One can well understand that someone accuses United of lacking ambition.
 
Exactly it would be easier to accept if you were joining a team that will challenge and win major trophies. United are a massive club and if your only option, you will go, but leaving for a team that look many years from being a CL or PL winner seems a bit disheartening to be honest, especially as the weather/area might not be to his fancy either.

Money and ETH relationship will soften the blow of course but yeah we may get to a stage where he can’t be sold even if unhappy and will eventually be loaned/leave on a free etc like Pogba.
As opposed to staying at a team that is facing financial ruin and need to take absolute drastic action soon to sort stuff out... but still seem to want to cut everyones wages so they can sign other players on huge contracts?
 
How long can this go on. Fee Agreed and then nothing happens. Weird transfer this. Have always had a bad feeling about this one.
 
So you truly believe that Ten Hag will just chase a player that he knows has no intention of ever joining us? Not sure if you're just trying to convince yourself or truly believe it.

Wouldn't be the first manager to do this would he? You're attempting to portray it as exclusive to ETH. It's not.

Moyes chased Cesc all summer, hell Pep has countless instances chasing players... he chased Maguire and didn't get him.

It's just a bad, bad feckin move.

If folks took a step back, looked at the bigger picture and just said OK, I'll put blind tribalism aside and do my best to be honest here and judge the transfer saga fairly and weigh up the statements being put out for consumption to the supporters, it's a bad move.

There is no way he'd want us to push that hard if he was certain that de Jong wouldn't want to come!

Mate, Barca's president is at a point this weekend where he is telling the player to make his feckin mind up. He's been blunt and told FDJ to accept the pay cut or sod off. If anything it actually seems like he is attempting to force Barca's had to pay him so he can stay or.. possibly considering taking the pay cut!

Does that sound like a player chomping at the bit to join our club?

Look how quickly we can do a deal with Malacia and we've Martinez telling Ajax to lower their price as he wants to consider offers from Arsenal and ourselves.

Meanwhile I'm mocked for suggesting a player will never tell his current club he wants out... give your heads a wobble lads.


What would be the point in agreeing a fee, going through two months of negotiation just for de Jong to say "nah lads, feck off". Makes no sense! What do you expect de Jong to say? He's bigged up the fact that Barca are his dream club in the past, and he doesn't want to come across as money obsessed, so obviously he's going to say he wants to stay. Do you truly think he's going to come out and say "Feck Barca and their financial woes, i want out at the earliest opportunity!". Not a chance. Ronaldo on the other hand, it's all about him, he doesn't care. He's coming to the end of his career and has feck to lose.

This is you personally caught up in the emotion of the transfer, you want it to happen so freaking badly and buy into a new world of ETH and rebuilds etc that you aren't thinking clearly. That's my honest opinion.
 
Last edited:
Barca emotionally blackmailing their players into accepting a significant pay cut says everything about them as a club. Pathetic.
To be fair Barca have to make drastic changes to clean up the mess left by Bartomeu. They obviously aren't going to dissolve as a club but they are in some serious shit.
 
Its the proverbial rock and hard place situation. He's wanted where he is, he wants to stay. Barca can't force him to take a pay cut, nor can they force him to leave without financial hardship (last thing they need more of)... So the circus continues and will continue all summer long.

What part of that situation sounds enticing and would make any club want to sign the player? Only one as stupid as ours would consider it.

Like the majority of modern day supporters you can't see the woods for the trees.
For all your negative scenarios to happened, it hinges on the situation where de Jong has to accept salary reduction. A situation that from what we know he refused to enter.
He'll not going to drag this out as long as he can. Once United and Barca agrees on the structural payment, which they're currently still negotiating, he'll come to us.
He can either refused to come to United and risk to get benched all season by Xavi (in a World Cup year no less),
or he can choose to come to United where he'll get a chance to show what he can do in his natural position, coached by the person who knows him well and most likely show the world that he's one of the best midfielder in the world.
 
Chelsea is monitoring the situation and I am sure they would like to Gazump if they get the chance.

I'll believe it when I see.

I doubt they want the drama and they need a CF not FDJ. I reckon they'll consider Neymar, but who knows.
 
To me it is obvious this deal has collapsed and with this being our top target (and dedicating so much time on this) then this has pushed Ronaldo to lose his s**t and cry that he wants out. It does seem we have put all our energy into chasing this transfer and now it is clear de Jong's preference is not to join us then we are somewhat lost on the plans for the coming season. The trouble is this mess of a transfer window has now had the knock on effect of creating further division amongst those already on the books and from going from nothing but Ronaldo upfront we now have nothing but forcing a unwilling Ronaldo to continue.

Why is it we are just so poor and transfer recruitment and everything we do seems to take so much time to try to resolve whilst others (City and Liverpool especially) are just so much more professional and proactive?
 
barca reports that Dembele is staying after accepting a 40% pay cut. So FDJ looking at 40%+?
 
For all your negative scenarios to happened, it hinges on the situation where de Jong has to accept salary reduction.

I've just explained it above, Laporta has had to be publicly blunt with him and tell FDJ that he takes the pay cut or sods off. The fact its dragging out 2 months now suggests FDJ is quite happy to stay put either forcing Barca's hand into payment (make cuts elsewhere) or considering actually taking a huge pay cut.

Malacia jumped at the chance of signing with us, done and dusted in 3-4 days, Martinez telling Ajax to listen to our offer and consider lowering their asking price.
 
Wouldn't be the first manager to do this would he? You're attempting to portray it as exclusive to ETH. It's not.

Moyes chased Cesc all summer, hell Pep has countless instances chasing players... he chased Maguire and didn't get him.

It's just a bad, bad feckin move.

If folks took a step back, looked at the bigger picture and just said OK, I'll put blind tribalism aside and do my best to be honest here and judge the transfer saga fairly and weigh up the statements being put out for consumption to the supporters, it's a bad move.



Mate, Barca's president is at a point this weekend where he is telling the player to make his feckin mind up. He's been blunt and told FDJ to accept the pay cut or sod off. If anything it actually seems like he is attempting to force Barca's had to pay him so he can stay or.. possibly considering taking the pay cut!

Does that sound like a player chomping at the bit to join our club?

Look how quickly we can do a deal with Malacia and we've Martinez telling Ajax to lower their price as he wants to consider offers from Arsenal and ourselves.

Meanwhile I'm mocked for suggesting a player will never tell his current club he wants out... give your heads a wobble lads.




This is all you personally caught up in the emotion of the transfer, you want it to happen so freaking badly and buy into a new world of ETH and rebuilds etc that you aren't thinking clearly. That's my honest opinion.
No pal, this is me having seen so many of these transfers to know that what you hear in the media isn't always whats being told behind the scenes.

Yes Laporta is saying take a paycut or sod off, and yes they will offer him a paycut, but it's widely reported that Barca want him out and they'll likely offer him a proposal that they know he won't take. They're going to force him out one way or another as they have players in his position that they feel are better suited to their plans. The simple fact is, you nor I, have any idea whats going on behind the scenes. We don't know what de Jong has told Ten Hag. We don't know what Barca have told de Jong. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn't, it doesn't. Simple. I'm just under no illusions that what we hear in the media is the absolute truth, because it's clearly not
 
No pal, this is me having seen so many of these transfers to know that what you hear in the media isn't always whats being told behind the scenes.

Yes Laporta is saying take a paycut or sod off, and yes they will offer him a paycut, but it's widely reported that Barca want him out and they'll likely offer him a proposal that they know he won't take. They're going to force him out one way or another as they have players in his position that they feel are better suited to their plans. The simple fact is, you nor I, have any idea whats going on behind the scenes. We don't know what de Jong has told Ten Hag. We don't know what Barca have told de Jong. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn't, it doesn't. Simple. I'm just under no illusions that what we hear in the media is the absolute truth, because it's clearly not

Keep on keeping on so.

We'll agree to disagree and that's perfectly fine.
 
As opposed to staying at a team that is facing financial ruin and need to take absolute drastic action soon to sort stuff out... but still seem to want to cut everyones wages so they can sign other players on huge contracts?

Or he’d be more open to moving to a team like Bayern, City, Liverpool or even Chelsea if that option becomes viable.

I don’t care how fecked Barcelona are they will still make the CL, still be relevant in a league title challenge and still be one of the biggest clubs on the planet (like us). Leaving one shit show for another might not be high on his list of things to do.

So I could fully understand if he explores every possible chance of staying at Barca, a club and City he loves, however slim they may be.
 
barca reports that Dembele is staying after accepting a 40% pay cut. So FDJ looking at 40%+?
Apparently the max they can cut his wages, according to what i've read on here (with sources from the posters) is 50%, and apparently even that wouldn't be enough so he'd have to forego some of his deferred payments too.
As i say, Barca know he won't accept that, so it's their way of forcing him out in my opinion
 
Barca emotionally blackmailing their players into accepting a significant pay cut says everything about them as a club. Pathetic.
At least they can make a pay cut and still keep their players, imagine us giving our best players a pay cut, they would be gone in a flash. we had to give Bruno a pay rise even though he was shit.
 
Imagine a team with Jong, Shane Long, Chong, Alex Song :drool:
Don't forget....
Dong Fangzhuo. He was our first East Asian player and only got 1 game. He is 37 now. Maybe we should bring him back. He retired at 29 so I'm sure he feels fresh!
 
They don't want you, Frenkie.

imagine taking a 40-50% pay cut because your employer has a gambling debt and they are trying to whore you out to the largest bidder. Pride alone should be enough to take your talent elsewhere
 
We really haven’t learned any lessons have we. We should’ve walked away from this weeks ago and gone after someone who actually wants to come.
 
Or he’d be more open to moving to a team like Bayern, City, Liverpool or even Chelsea if that option becomes viable.

I don’t care how fecked Barcelona are they will still make the CL, still be relevant in a league title challenge and still be one of the biggest clubs on the planet (like us). Leaving one shit show for another might not be high on his list of things to do.

So I could fully understand if he explores every possible chance of staying at Barca, a club and City he loves, however slim they may be.
Which, by all acounts, won't happen as none of them clubs are interested.
Again, if we're going by reports no other club aside from United are in negotiations with Barca. Chelsea have rumoured to be interested, but that could easily be something said by Barca to speed up Uniteds negotiations. I don't know as i've not really read much into it or where the rumour started
 
imagine taking a 40-50% pay cut because your employer has a gambling debt and they are trying to whore you out to the largest bidder. Pride alone should be enough to take your talent elsewhere

Most these lads are still earning 10-12m even with 40-50% cut.

Hardly on the breadline.

Reality is they've just been astronomically overpaid in recent years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.