criticalanalysis
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2015
- Messages
- 7,363
Wirtz a player.
Fixed.
Wirtz a player.
I think the most remarkable thing about him is that he somehow looks even better after the injury. I guess “lucky” for it to have happened at such a young age in his career, but how often do you see that?Was voted player of the month for the third time this season (Harry Kane still at 0 ). Bundesliga.de provided some interesting stats for February on that occasion as well:
- fourth youngest player to have 100 Bundesliga appearances despite his ACL
- ran 12.3 km (7.6 miles) and made 36 sprints oer 90 minutes
- most duels (105) of his team despite being an attacking midfielder
That is because they are all far betterHis battle with Xavi Simons in Germany's next match will be interesting. Both insanely talented players but Xavi has sort of gone under the radar in the BL due to Wirtz and Musiala's performances.
I think the most remarkable thing about him is that he somehow looks even better after the injury. I guess “lucky” for it to have happened at such a young age in his career, but how often do you see that?
they never learn, do they?But can he play with Bellingham?
Yeah the last time he kicked a ball before Alonso he was also kinda like 18 years old. Shocking that he was not a complete footballer yet.I think ACLs have lost a bit of their "notoriety" since they can be treated quite well these days. Suffering one 20 years ago is probably now the equivalent to suffering two today. But yes, he came back incredibly well - but Alonso also managed his minutes excellently, giving him rests even when Wirtz seemed to disagree a bit. Alonso is probably instrumental in the improvement you mentioned as well. Before him, Wirtz was kind of a "dribbling Bruno" player who always went for the final ball and lost it many times. Now he's regularly racking up 90% passing accuracy and 80 touches per game and has even more chance creating plays in terms of through balls, dribbles and shots.
I'm very happy that he now receives more attention on the big stage thanks to our outstanding season and his presence for Germany. IMO, many haven't really realized how good he is.
Yeah the last time he kicked a ball before Alonso he was also kinda like 18 years old. Shocking that he was not a complete footballer yet.
Not that I disagree that Alonso has been instrumental in the development of many Leverkusen players. You still need to have the talent and desire.
You really think Pep is going back to Bayern?Will be nice to see him spend some of his development years under Pep
I think ACLs have lost a bit of their "notoriety" since they can be treated quite well these days. Suffering one 20 years ago is probably now the equivalent to suffering two today. But yes, he came back incredibly well - but Alonso also managed his minutes excellently, giving him rests even when Wirtz seemed to disagree a bit. Alonso is probably instrumental in the improvement you mentioned as well. Before him, Wirtz was kind of a "dribbling Bruno" player who always went for the final ball and lost it many times. Now he's regularly racking up 90% passing accuracy and 80 touches per game and has even more chance creating plays in terms of through balls, dribbles and shots.
I'm very happy that he now receives more attention on the big stage thanks to our outstanding season and his presence for Germany. IMO, many haven't really realized how good he is.
That is because they are all far better
I have my eye test and the other two especially Musiala are better.That's not true, Xavi has been great this season himself. Look at any ratings and he, Musiala and Wirtz are all very close.
Let me guess you watched him for 90 minutes against West Ham´s bus and were disappointed he didn´t play some neat through balls against a low nine man block.Great intelligent player but I'm unsure if he's an elite 10. Seems to lack passing range of Bergkamp, Fabregas, Silva etc.
Let me guess you watched him for 90 minutes against West Ham´s bus and were disappointed he didn´t play some neat through balls against a low nine man block.
I've watched him a few times actually; not often, so could be wrong. He seems to me, a secondary playmaker profile but lacks incisive passing. Foden is similar; great dribbler, at closer control and shooter without the elite passing.
What is it with you butchering player names?Naigelsman will be all over the German national squad for his new club gig, wherever that will be. I love F Wirtz and that’s coming from an English man, yes Muisaka is better and both are just a tad behind Bellingham and Foden, but Germany for me are the favourites for the Euros with England and France.
Naigelman 3421 system suits the players and now he’s got Kimmich to concentrate on playing RB and the master Kross back they will be seriously dangerous,
Ter Stegan or Neuer in Goal, Kimmich, Tah, Rudiger, Mittelstadt, T Kroos, A Pavlovic, J Muisala, F Wirtz, K Havertz
with D Raum, R Koch, I Gubdogan, P Gros,
L Goretzka , T Muhler, N Fullkrug, D Undav
There’s more than enough there if motivated to go far in their own Euros. Yes Rudiger, Kross, Gundogan and Muhler are aging but they’ve won big titles, underestimate them at your peril.
Yes, but both are used to (at least sometimes) play on the wing. However when they do, they usually do it relatively narrow as they tend to play centrally. But for example Wirtz usually plays in a 3421 system as part of the "double 10", so he naturally at times supports on the wing while the other 10 stays more centrally.While Wirtz and Musiala can presumably co-exist in the same team, are their best positions both as 10’s?
Musiala can easily play on the wing in an inverted role. I think they link up very well and desperately want Wirtz at Bayern.While Wirtz and Musiala can presumably co-exist in the same team, are their best positions both as 10’s?
I love F Wirtz and that’s coming from an English man, yes Muisaka is better and both are just a tad behind Bellingham and Foden
While Wirtz and Musiala can presumably co-exist in the same team, are their best positions both as 10’s?
Funnily enough, I'd rank them exactly the other way round Though I haven't seen much of Foden this season, he seems to be phenomenal judging by Pep's comments. But based solely on their Bundesliga performances, I'd say Wirtz > Musiala > Bellingham.
Yes. I'd say fitting both in one team is more about the right balance of playstyles. Wirtz and Musiala are both players who like to see a lot of the ball and dribble very often. So I think somebody like Gündogan who likes to play one touch football besides them works better than e. g. Leroy Sané who is also a player who engages in many one on ones and likes to carry the ball across the pitch.
Bellingham played deeper in Dortmund, but he's still the best player out of those 4 players IMO.
Agreed on Musiala > Foden though if that's what you mean
No, I meant Bellingham. For Dortmund, Bellingham hasn't gotten close to the level Musiala and especially Wirtz show this season. Bellingham has improved massively for Real Madrid and I really don't intend to belittle him but I still have Musiala and Wirtz ahead of him.
Usually, people see Wirtz as an Özil kind of player who "only" plays incisive passes and his, in my opinion, already world class dribbling ability is overlooked but this is the first time I see somebody not rating his incisive passing Thing is, Wirtz plays incredible through balls and crosses (most assists in Europe so far) but in contrast to somebody like de Bruyne or Bruno, he doesn't force them. So if a team parks the bus like West Ham yesterday with 9 men in their own box, he will retain possession and keep the ball moving most often.
If you want to see how good he is at incisive passing, watch this video from around 4:20 onwards. if you don't have much time, at least make sure to watch 5:45 and 6:15, that tells you enough already Can only recommend the full video, though. He's simply a joy to watch this season (and the last one as well to be honest).
Bellingham is the best number 10 in world football, he’s a beast he’ll just dominate the smaller man 9 times out of 10, you don’t go to Madrid dominate the league, he’s played 32 games domestic and CL and got 20 goals and 9 assists, perspective Jude is doing it in the CL, F Wirtz in the Europa League His stats are also exceptional played 40 - Goals 14 - Assists 18 but the Europa League is not the CL. He may have been better last year but this years version of Jude is best in the world.Funnily enough, I'd rank them exactly the other way round Though I haven't seen much of Foden this season, he seems to be phenomenal judging by Pep's comments. But based solely on their Bundesliga performances, I'd say Wirtz > Musiala > Bellingham.
Yes. I'd say fitting both in one team is more about the right balance of playstyles. Wirtz and Musiala are both players who like to see a lot of the ball and dribble very often. So I think somebody like Gündogan who likes to play one touch football besides them works better than e. g. Leroy Sané who is also a player who engages in many one on ones and likes to carry the ball across the pitch.
Bellingham is the best number 10 in world football, he’s a beast he’ll just dominate the smaller man 9 times out of 10, you don’t go to Madrid dominate the league, he’s played 32 games domestic and CL and got 20 goals and 9 assists, perspective Jude is doing it in the CL, F Wirtz in the Europa League His stats are also exceptional played 40 - Goals 14 - Assists 18 but the Europa League is not the CL. He may have been better last year but this years version of Jude is best in the world.
I know Still, Wirtz and Musiala are better, IMO. Both are far better dribblers and Wirtz has an incredible football IQ going for him as well. Bellingham is indeed more athletic but athleticism isn't a means in itself. Don't get me wrong, he is absolutely amazing as well but just I don't think he's every bit as good as the other two who are legitly the two biggest talents I've seen in the Bundesliga. Germany is incredibly lucky to have both coming through at the same time.
Better than De Bruyne?
I'd build a team around him. Fantastic player.I watched him vs West Ham yesterday.
I'd love a player like that at United.
What is this?Naigelsman will be all over the German national squad for his new club gig, wherever that will be. I love F Wirtz and that’s coming from an English man, yes Muisaka is better and both are just a tad behind Bellingham and Foden, but Germany for me are the favourites for the Euros with England and France.
Naigelman 3421 system suits the players and now he’s got Kimmich to concentrate on playing RB and the master Kross back they will be seriously dangerous,
Ter Stegan or Neuer in Goal, Kimmich, Tah, Rudiger, Mittelstadt, T Kroos, A Pavlovic, J Muisala, F Wirtz, K Havertz
with D Raum, R Koch, I Gubdogan, P Gros,
L Goretzka , T Muhler, N Fullkrug, D Undav
There’s more than enough there if motivated to go far in their own Euros. Yes Rudiger, Kross, Gundogan and Muhler are aging but they’ve won big titles, underestimate them at your peril.
D-day rerunWhat is this?