Hmm. The thing is with constant pressuring and hassling your opponent to rush passess and moves, etc, is that there is no negative consequence of doing so. In real life, constant pressure on the ball would result in fatigue and tiredness right and players out of posistion, On FIFA it allows you to just pressure your opponent without it effecting your players badly or losing their position.
This leads to ping pong passing which is basically just pressing X as soon as you receive the ball which almost gurantees a perfect pass. Likewise with the pressure, making the game unrealistic and down to whoever hits the buttons the fastest which is not what a football simulation game should be about.
The reason I say manual is better, is because it eliminates this side of the game. On manual, you have to direct your passes and just pressing X quickly does not gurantee a perfect pass or the touch of triange does not equate to a perfect threaded through ball unless you time it right.
I wouldn't say it's viewed as wrong by the FIFA community, whoever they are
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Tongue :p :p"
, but imo it takes away realism from the game due to no negative effect or constant pressure, we can only hope it'll be fixed in FIFA11.