Really liking this!
I played one single player game and 6 Pro Clubs games last night and thought it played much, much better than FIFA 16 - loved it and looking forward to playing more games.
- the control feels more natural - it's hard to describe, but your player feels more grounded - you push the stick and it feels as though your player begins to move in that direction, rather than simply starting a sequence of animations...
- it feels less scripted - with the previous FIFA sometimes you felt like the game had already decided that the ball was going to go a certain way out of a tackle - this feels more real and unpredictable, which is very good
- the crossing seems to have been improved - less aimless crosses for the goal keeper to simply catch and more going to areas that can be attacked by the forwards
- the graphics look excellent
- AI seems smarter - was cutting in on the wing and about to play a ball across the box, then saw Ibra drop off his marker so cut the ball back to him and he scored. I felt as though in previous games he would have just continued his run straight into the box.
- stamina seems much better in Pro Clubs - your player isn't a knackered wreck at the end of the game
- passing and shooting feels crisper
- the match ratings seem fairer - I got a couple of man of the match awards despite someone else scoring more than I did - assists seem to be more rewarded EDIT - in one game on the RW I made one assist and my match rating was 9.3 - pretty sure that would not have been possible in #16
With regard to Pro Clubs, I just tried the drop in mode - so haven't created or joined a club yet so not sure what is different on that front. Will give that a go over the weekend. I had to create a pro to use - and not spent too much time on that part so far, but looks pretty similar to #16. Making my player 5'8" was still the optimum height to make him as fast as possible unfortunately. I did see more progression in my ratings after each game - last game felt a bit random - you would improve your passing suddenly after hitting 50 crosses, for example.