Erik ten Hag | 2024/25 | Votes can now be changed
- Thread starter Cheimoon
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) are here to talk about United's dreadful home defeat at the hands of Big Ange's Tottenham Hotspur. Should this have been the end of Ten Hag? How long does he actually have left? And does Nik finally want ETH out?!
Took me a moment to register who is this Gary guy and why you having a go at him.
At least Gary knew he was shite and he had no problem stating it !
He will get sacked, 100%. You can not be making such dumb mistakes at this level. You are playing Rashford against Barnsley home, only to rest him v Palace away? Your probably most in form player.
You leave your worst performer on the pitch for two 90 minute games in a row, while the subs you bring have no impact on the game, even worse, they break the play and we play worse. I thought he had learned by now that Bruno does not work as RW. We got 3 clean sheets in a row, but Palace created many clear cut chances to score. Southampton missed a penalty.
People are seeing progress because we've created many big chances, and we don't concede as many shots on target per game. But after 2 full seasons with him, we should be expecting much more than marginal improvements. Hansi Flick managed to turn Barcelona around in less than 7 games. We haven't been able to "figure it out" after 2 years. We can't beat the likes of Twente, Palace etc.
Our pivotal player seems to be Eriksen, who doesn't have the legs for 90 minutes, week in, week out. He can not be making so many beginner mistakes at this level with rotation, substitutions, first eleven.
The excuses have run out. This is it.
You leave your worst performer on the pitch for two 90 minute games in a row, while the subs you bring have no impact on the game, even worse, they break the play and we play worse. I thought he had learned by now that Bruno does not work as RW. We got 3 clean sheets in a row, but Palace created many clear cut chances to score. Southampton missed a penalty.
People are seeing progress because we've created many big chances, and we don't concede as many shots on target per game. But after 2 full seasons with him, we should be expecting much more than marginal improvements. Hansi Flick managed to turn Barcelona around in less than 7 games. We haven't been able to "figure it out" after 2 years. We can't beat the likes of Twente, Palace etc.
Our pivotal player seems to be Eriksen, who doesn't have the legs for 90 minutes, week in, week out. He can not be making so many beginner mistakes at this level with rotation, substitutions, first eleven.
The excuses have run out. This is it.
We need to be far more direct at times. For the next 10-15 minutes hug the wings and put in crosses. We just knock the ball sideways time and time again
How many more signs do we need to sack this fecking idiot?!
This is so true. Thats why i didn't buy the 60 minutes BS against palace, because had we scored in the first half, there is very good chance that Palace changed tactics and pulls one back. It has happened way too many times under Ten hag.
I feel that with these players he should do better. I saw that he thought we were complacent today. It’s his job to get them up for these games. Some players will be complacent if you let them.
It all started with that cursed game vs. Sevilla. Not only we let a big lead slip, also lost Martinez to a long-term injury (and Varane too? cant remember) in the game. It was 2-2 by the way, not 3-3. All downhill from there.Copenhagen gave us hell for that 1-0 at OT as well
Quite sure they outshot us
Is that what he said?
There's some minor progress in performances from the disaster that was last season, but is there any real progress on the pitch from when he joined? Our squad is better and younger, but it should be after throwing that many hundreds of millions at it. And yet on the pitch I still don't see any substantive progress from 2022 to to now, in our general play or in our results.
The best manager make a team more than the sum of its parts. He does the opposite.
These quotes never end up going well
If SAF was the master of game management Ten Hag must be the extreme opposite of that. His original plan when it was on song was pretty enjoyable to watch but when opposition team made one or few changes he could hardly adapt. Hes Dutch's Arsene Wenger and just like Wenger's Arsenal we should be prepared for some big embarrasment losses.
That should have been all Ineos looked at when it was decision time.
There is a reason why INEOS extended his contract by only 1 year. That itself is a massive signal. They are giving themselves time and space to make a considered decision to hire/poach the best available manager before possibly firing.
I’m just disappointed in him.
Owen Hargreaves overheard the conversation between ETH and Garnacho before he came on.
Apparently Garnacho told ETH he wanted to attack them to secure the win, but ETH told him "No. Defend, defend, defend."
Here’s the issue
ETH - keeping him in charge is the same as doing the same thing continually and expecting a different result. Nothing will seem to change if the person responsible for performance doesn’t change, simple analogy but a correct assumption of where we are. That team of individuals should not work to a draw with an inferior club, no need to continue down the same path, make the decision now and get some benefit.
ETH - keeping him in charge is the same as doing the same thing continually and expecting a different result. Nothing will seem to change if the person responsible for performance doesn’t change, simple analogy but a correct assumption of where we are. That team of individuals should not work to a draw with an inferior club, no need to continue down the same path, make the decision now and get some benefit.
Agreed. Business wise it makes a lot of sense so I don't fault them for the decision they made. Just sucks it comes with a seemingly even longer wait til things improve on the pitch.
Absolutely. Barring the odd collapse season like last season, Ole’s last year etc where teams starting taking us to the cleaners, our biggest issue, by far, has been the quality of our general / possession play and more specifically, the inefficiency and inadequacy particularly with which we move the ball about in congested central areas. We are fine in low pressure wide areas but once the ball comes inside we crumble and panic. Of course to be fair having better attackers would lead to more chances too but aside from recruitment my biggest drive has been how we don’t value the ball, and are so incredibly loose and erratic with it. Heart on sleeve over composure and precision.
Yesterday was a great example actually. The intent was there but the way we went about it was so poor. Everyone looking desperately for the furthest man, whacking every pass as if that makes scoring goals more likely - it was just a silly way to go about trying to dominate games and emblematic of our football this past decade. We supposedly want to dominate but also decide to skip the difficult parts (midfield control and dominating the ball) to get to the end goal asap
I still see him as an interim manager.
Spot on. You’ve watched the games, analysed the tactics, the team, the transfers, the subs - for two years now - and there is absolutely nothing to suggest this man can’t be the next Alex Ferguson. Other people just don’t have the mental capacity to see the grand scheme only you can see.
Jesus wept.
Only way but up?
Should have been sacked several months ago
What ajax level manager producing ajax level performance in europe?? Shocker.
I looked at Liverpool's performance against West Ham yesterday and I genuinely belive 3/4 of that squad would be shit here for us.
I really don't blame the players here and I believe we still just haven't got a good enough manager here.
I knew hardly anything about Slot & he's already looking bloody brilliant playing his own style of football.
Whether a club is title challenging team is a different story where much like Arsenal we will have to build a squad to challenge a squad directly at City's level -
But for far too long we just haven't looked like a top club & as many have said, clubs like Spurs, Aston Villa & Newcastle look like bigger clubs than us.
Liverpool getting Klopp & Slot alongside their good history of recent players has been because of their owners Fenway Sports Group.
INEOS has shown promise this year with many calling it a 10/10 transfer window.
Now it's time to stop f*cking around and scout and find a bloody good manager just like we would a player & not go for managers like Moyes, Van Gaal, Ole, Mourinho & Ten Hag because they are our versions of Antony or Wan Bissaka.
I'm one of the few fans who doesn't blame Rashford for sulking on the pitch & showing sh*t work ethic - because I know I would be exactly the same if I had to play under such a bang average manager aswell.
I really don't blame the players here and I believe we still just haven't got a good enough manager here.
I knew hardly anything about Slot & he's already looking bloody brilliant playing his own style of football.
Whether a club is title challenging team is a different story where much like Arsenal we will have to build a squad to challenge a squad directly at City's level -
But for far too long we just haven't looked like a top club & as many have said, clubs like Spurs, Aston Villa & Newcastle look like bigger clubs than us.
Liverpool getting Klopp & Slot alongside their good history of recent players has been because of their owners Fenway Sports Group.
INEOS has shown promise this year with many calling it a 10/10 transfer window.
Now it's time to stop f*cking around and scout and find a bloody good manager just like we would a player & not go for managers like Moyes, Van Gaal, Ole, Mourinho & Ten Hag because they are our versions of Antony or Wan Bissaka.
I'm one of the few fans who doesn't blame Rashford for sulking on the pitch & showing sh*t work ethic - because I know I would be exactly the same if I had to play under such a bang average manager aswell.
Last edited:
One of the more frustrating points I've tried to nail in to people's heads around here is that you don't just magically score more goals "by bringing in better goalscorers". Especially in 2024 when chance creation is so systemic for many teams. Just because you stick Haaland up top instead of Zirkzee wouldn't mean we are magically contending for the league. Sure it would help but he certainly wouldn't hit his City numbers here and the attack would still be disjointed because we simply don't create any "easy" chances that are repeatable. Most of our creation comes from one of Bruno's 50 tries, or pure individual quality from a winger. But you rarely see the type of goal scored by Garnacho against Soton from our side.
It's also why I've constantly pushed back on the notion that Bruno is required for us to ever score/create as a team when people cite his huge creation metrics. There are hardly any other teams in the world that rely on a singular creator, much less a flawed one, yet a team like Arsenal scores plenty of goals because their team and system result in numerous opportunites and aren't just reliant on a few moments where if the player on the end of a random cross/pass doesn't ruthlessly finish it we lose and people lament our forwards.
I recall Hargreaves saying he overheard Ten Hag telling him to defend, but I don’t recall anything about Garnacho telling Ten Hag he wanted to attack to secure the win.Owen Hargreaves overheard the conversation between ETH and Garnacho before he came on.
Apparently Garnacho told ETH he wanted to attack them to secure the win, but ETH told him "No. Defend, defend, defend."
Did you just make that up to spice up your post?
Maybe £600+million million just doesn't stretch very much nowadays? Maybe ETH needs another 500million quid to get us to play the ETHball we so crave.
Last edited:
Some of our players have been in the team for over 3 seasons now, and yet, every game is like a new season. Team work is a joke, so why do we need all these multi-million coaches? Just pick 11 names and play, like school team, let them figure out how to score.
he's finished.
No way he survive next fixtures
No way he survive next fixtures
Same here. Displayed some cowardice today, second half was dull af but yet he waited for the FC Twente manager to make changes before making any himself.
It was obvious the game needed a spark and he sat back and let the opposing manager be the one to change things first. Reactionary and weak.
Can't even say I'm surprised by the result. This is the level he's dragged us down to.
Sum of parts:
Either we play less than the sum of our parts, or the opposition play greater than the sum of their parts. Given the massive discrepancy of the squads, and against the opponents we've faced to date for all but one game this season thus far, it's enough to tell you this manager is out of his depth. You don't need to delve into the archives; this is a problem from the ground up of this so-called fresh start.
You can actually say this fresh start exacerbates all of the flaws Ten Hag has. There's no fallback excuses; this is just bad management and coaching. We are also seeing his substitutions and in-game management constantly doing more harm than good. Objectively, he has worked himself out of a job. This next run will be the end of him.
Either we play less than the sum of our parts, or the opposition play greater than the sum of their parts. Given the massive discrepancy of the squads, and against the opponents we've faced to date for all but one game this season thus far, it's enough to tell you this manager is out of his depth. You don't need to delve into the archives; this is a problem from the ground up of this so-called fresh start.
You can actually say this fresh start exacerbates all of the flaws Ten Hag has. There's no fallback excuses; this is just bad management and coaching. We are also seeing his substitutions and in-game management constantly doing more harm than good. Objectively, he has worked himself out of a job. This next run will be the end of him.
FC Twente - Squad Value - 20 million.
Where are we going wrong? Why are we not able to convincingly win against such minnows at home? If we need world class players in every spot, then what’s the use of a manager? Isn’t it the primary job of the manager to make “sum” play better than the parts?
Or is this his level, he is a basically a midtable manager, who was lucky to be handed the keys to the “biggest” club in the world. Whatever it is, but for the sake our club, he needs to be let go or one more season goes away in drain.
Where are we going wrong? Why are we not able to convincingly win against such minnows at home? If we need world class players in every spot, then what’s the use of a manager? Isn’t it the primary job of the manager to make “sum” play better than the parts?
Or is this his level, he is a basically a midtable manager, who was lucky to be handed the keys to the “biggest” club in the world. Whatever it is, but for the sake our club, he needs to be let go or one more season goes away in drain.
And you are not a real fan if you weren’t subjugated by 2 wins against abysmal teams and a draw to Palace.
This team has had a goal scoring problem ever since Ten Hag became manager. This is the third season now and it’s not going to change no matter who’s playing. This is a managerial limitation.
He'll survive. He'll get a decent result against Spurs and the agony will be extended.
Absolutely. It was just partly papered over by an insane Rashford streak in the first year, but there really is no consistent way of getting goals under ETH.
Yes, all other concerns should be temporarily case aside, significant short term pain inflicted, in pursuit of improving consensus in our online fanbase. A thing that definitely matters a great deal.