Far from it, he's not even the best CB at our club. On paper is not how you judge a player or team.
Shaw is not anywhere near the best left back in the league, he's pretty much been about 50/50 in his United tenure, for every good period there is an equally dreadful period to balance things out, which strangely could be said for the vast majority of our squad. He seems quite mentally soft as well, not exclusive to him by any means, again the vast majority of our lot completely crumble under the slightest bit of pressure both physically and mentally.
Fred I do hold out hope for, I reckon he could do well for ETH.
The squad is atrocious by an large tbh. I'd honestly only keep about 5-6 players, the rest is made up of deadwood and untested youth players (some obviously could make it, but some won't).