ArmchairCritic
You got pets me too mines are dead
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2011
- Messages
- 16,430
Yeah, that was OTT. I don't know how much it was meant as it came across though. There was a grain of truth to what he was saying (and Cook's markedly improved since then) but he did his normal thing of relentlessly droning on about the same thing.
I guess he's probably better doing the third man stints. Partly because I don't think they create those packages on their own, but also because it gives you a condensed view into what he's thinking - which is probably reasonably perceptive - without having to hear him say the same thing in 31 different ways for the next half an hour.
Obviously as an Aussie he's going to want to stir it up a bit, but he overstepped his role as a commentator that series even if there was a kernel of truth to it and since then I haven't really heard him go back and say Cook's grown into the role or he's improved.
I definitely agree he's better doing the third man stints and his spin masterclass was riveting, I suppose now he's kind of set in his ways which is unfortunate really because there is great brain underneath all the bravado and 'banter'. What always sets the best commentators apart for me (Benaud especially) is they let the game do the talking and just offer brief insights along the way.