Edward Woodward

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't see anything to actually have an opinion on.

All that has happened is that the CEO has come back from the tour to attend to some business. From that small snippet of information the media and our own resident muppets have gone full retard. There is speculation about speculation, largely driven by twitter as well as the mainstream media. To believe what you read in the papers and then call what you come up with 'educated' is just nonsense.

Nobody outside of probably 3 or 4 people know why Eddy has come back.

But why does it bother you? What harm does it do if people speculate?
 
It's been a disappointing day so far, considering what has happened over the past few days United related

I'd rather its like this than the constant leaks.
Silence doesn't mean nothing is happening.
 
But why does it bother you? What harm does it do if people speculate?


I don't recall saying it did.

Why does me calling it all nonsense bother you? What harm does it do to point out the futility of this entire thread?
 
So do you have any opinions of your own or are you here purely to rubbish other people?

To go from not being in for Bale, to Woodward rushing back even though he was due back in 5 days anyway, simply to put a bid in for Bale, doesn't seem likely to me when we could have gotten someone here to put a bid in by fax/email etc. For him to rush back suggests to me that it's not simply a bid, which if the papers are to be believed is all we're about to do for Bale. To rush back seems like something a bit more final needs to be sorted.

That's not a wild guess, it's a guess which has tried to weigh up the situation as i see it. But feel free to tell everyone what you think of the situation.
What facts are you aware of that make your guess that it's about Fellaini/Baines/Garay, an eductaed guess, moreso than any other player/s?
 
I don't recall saying it did.

Why does me calling it all nonsense bother you? What harm does it do to point out the futility of this entire thread?

I just don't understand. Ultimately every single thread on a football forum is futile. Discussing tactics is futile as we have no input; discussing potential transfers, incoming or outgoing, is pointless as we don't have a clue; it's unnecessary to rate players after games as they won't give a shit. Why talk about anything then?
 
I'm cheerful. It was a joke. Maybe you couldn't take it. Cheer up.

Nobody realises that you're the most ironic poster and actually the biggest bundle of joy going, you give off this impression that you're not to balance out all the muppets and hysteria.

I admire you for it.
 
I just don't understand. Ultimately every single thread on a football forum is futile. Discussing tactics is futile as we have no input; discussing potential transfers, incoming or outgoing, is pointless as we don't have a clue; it's unnecessary to rate players after games as they won't give a shit. Why talk about anything then?


The exchange I was involved with centred around me taking issue with the idea that what the guy was saying was 'an educated guess', when it clearly wasn't. I followed up with pointing out that his basing his theory on what he had read in the paper was flawed logic, seeing as the papers don't know dick about why Woodward has returned from tour.

In this specific instance (the topic of this thread) nobody knows what the hell is going on, and claiming otherwise is nonsense. This is my only point, which I thought I had made quite clear in my initial post. The concept of a forum is one I'm quite familiar with, and I don't believe I have told anyone that they shouldn't discuss things, I have simply offered up my opinion on the futility of this particular discussion.

Thanks for your concern, though.
 
Nobody realises that you're the most ironic poster and actually the biggest bundle of joy going, you give off this impression that you're not to balance out all the muppets and hysteria.

I admire you for it.
nah, he is a cnut and an orangeman
 
The exchange I was involved with centred around me taking issue with the idea that what the guy was saying was 'an educated guess', when it clearly wasn't. I followed up with pointing out that his basing his theory on what he had read in the paper was flawed logic, seeing as the papers don't know dick about why Woodward has returned from tour.

In this specific instance (the topic of this thread) nobody knows what the hell is going on, and claiming otherwise is nonsense. This is my only point, which I thought I had made quite clear in my initial post. The concept of a forum is one I'm quite familiar with, and I don't believe I have told anyone that they shouldn't discuss things, I have simply offered up my opinion on the futility of this particular discussion.

Thanks for your concern, though.
I said 'educated guess' because i tried to have a go at why i think he's come back. That is an educated guess based on the information (or lack of) that we have at hand whether that be the press or whatever.

If i said 'well he's come back urgently because he's got a cat that needs feeding and some dry cleaning to pick up' then that's totally different.

If i'd said 'a guess based on the stuff we know from the papers which may or may not be true' it would have been the exact same thing. I know i said 'educated' but if you take issue with the fact that i used a certain phrase then you're far too pedantic.

I thought football forums were supposed to be places to discuss bullshit? Far too many people on here picking holes in things, whether to make themselves look clever, start an argument or whatever.

Don't take a stab at what's going on because we don't know anything because the papers sometimes lie?

Some people on here need to lighten the feck up.

Or maybe just not go into threads where they think the discussion is pointless rather than going in purely to tell people how stupid their discussion is?
 
Looks like no one took any notice of anything said before this whole episode started, be patient.

Take your own advice and be patient; people might start being patient with time, you just have to be patient until then. Patient.
 
nah, he is a cnut and an orangeman
I'm not in the Orange Order. I didn't kick the Pope on the 12th, I don't even go.

I even capitalized Pope to give him his proper title.

Having disproven your argument about being an Orangeman, I'll leave the cnut accusation to speak for itself.
 
I said 'educated guess' because i tried to have a go at why i think he's come back. That is an educated guess based on the information (or lack of) that we have at hand whether that be the press or whatever.

If i said 'well he's come back urgently because he's got a cat that needs feeding and some dry cleaning to pick up' then that's totally different.

If i'd said 'a guess based on the stuff we know from the papers which may or may not be true' it would have been the exact same thing. I know i said 'educated' but if you take issue with the fact that i used a certain phrase then you're far too pedantic.

I thought football forums were supposed to be places to discuss bullshit? Far too many people on here picking holes in things, whether to make themselves look clever, start an argument or whatever.

Don't take a stab at what's going on because we don't know anything because the papers sometimes lie?

Some people on here need to lighten the feck up.

Or maybe just not go into threads where they think the discussion is pointless rather than going in purely to tell people how stupid their discussion is?
If you say it's most likely Fellaini/Baines/Garay because of what the press are reporting, then it's as likely to be Fabregas or Bale, because the press are reporting them too. In fact, if that's your basis for it being an educated guess then it's more likely to be Fabregas than Fellaini, since the press have reported we've put in a bid for one and not for the other.
 
If you say it's most likely Fellaini/Baines/Garay because of what the press are reporting, then it's as likely to be Fabregas or Bale, because the press are reporting them too. In fact, if that's your basis for it being an educated guess then it's more likely to be Fabregas than Fellaini, since the press have reported we've put in a bid for one and not for the other.
Yes but there's been talk that Fellaini and Baines might come together as one huge bid and Garay has been reportedly close for a while.

I think if he's rushed back it's something that cannot be done over the phone, which could be something to do with terms or final offers or whatever.

Bale is apparently still at the pre-bid stage and the Fabregas thing apparently needs a bigger bid. I don't see why he'd fly back purely to put in bids, unless it's to sit down face to face with some chairman to thrash it out, but we're led to believe those deals aren't that far along yet.
 
And in either case my original point was that i couldn't see how it would be for Bale. The other players mentioned were more an afterthought.
 
I'm so pessimistic about it all now.

I hope i'm wrong and he's come back and then BOOM! Fabregas, Ronaldo, Mata, Bale!

Carrick Fabregas
Ronaldo Mata Bale
RVP

Will try and get that side together via cheat option in next Football Manager and see how she goes. Its looks terrifying.
 
Who knows? That would be baseless speculation.

....but yeh he musta done by now. He left just after midday yesterday, if he was flying to England you'd think he'd have been back in the country for at least a few hours.

Its a door to door +- 30 hour trip from Australia.
 
Hello! it's been impossible to stay away what with all this summers shenanigans.

What can I say, i'm a muppet at heart!


Hah! Wasn't asking what pulled you back but where the feck have you been? Its becoming harder to find familiar faces in the threads nowadays
 
All this waiting in anticipation has made me start doubting that we'll get a player :lol:
After the names we've been linked with, it's inevitable that it'll end in disappointment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.