Only really Bissouma, Tchoumeni and Caicedo are true CDM that can hold the line by playing by themselves. I'd say Rice is easily better than all 3.
Players like Camavinga, Tonali & Bruno Guimeres all play in a CM midfield 3 that shift all the work across their midfield.
For example,
Camavinga played alongside Kroos & Valdevre, Bruno Guimeres played with Longstaff & Anderson when Tonali got banned because Tonali plays as a deep lying playmaker - not a CDM that provides the defensive ability of someone likes Rice.
We couldn't play
Tonali - Mainoo
Bruno
@UTD
Or
Tonali - Mainoo
Bellingham
@England
There's no defensive stability. To provide that you either have to use players like Valdevre or Connor Gallagher or someone like Fred to provide that defensive engine type of player that goes straight in to tackling the opponents legs rather than a player who sits deep to provide defensive cover.
Thats why
Rice & Gallagher doesn't work for England because both players are too defensive in two different ways to help transition the ball from deep that is possible with players like Kroos, Mainoo, Modric, Camavinga or Tonali. However they need defensive support - either with a player with a high work rate like Gallagher, Longstaff, Valvedre etc or someone like Rice or Casemiro that provides central defensive blockage all by themselves.
For england:
Mainoo- Rice
Bellingham
Creativity comes from Mainoo's short passes & dribbles dictating play or
Bellingham - Rice
Foden
Where the main creativity comes from Foden playing centrally.
England haven't played either during a full 90 mins & basically have no creativity in their midfield.
That's not Rice's fault and it's just poor management.
@giorno
Is Tchouameni looking like a player that Madrid might sell if we were interested this summer? Or will you be happy giving him more time to develop?